Germano's yellow too selfish for A-League

By Philip Coates / Roar Guru

There are any number of incidents in a game that might cause a manager to grimace and groan at the performance of their team or individual players.

The thing that must surely rankle the most with managers, and many spectators, is when players pick up meaningless and unnecessary yellow cards for pointless indiscretions.

There have been several clear examples on the weekend, two in the Melbourne Heart match.

Firstly, Germano. You have to ask yourself what fool packs a Santa hat in his shorts in the hope of having the opportunity to use it during a match?

This wasn’t a spur-of-the-moment celebration. It was a preconceived yellow card offence by an otherwise talented player.

I’m sure van’t Schip wouldn’t let a player on the park if he knew the player deliberately intended to pick up a yellow card.

Rutger Worm deserves equal condemnation for nonchalantly slotting the ball into the net well after the referee had whistled for offside. It wasn’t a continuous action of shooting as the referee blew.

It was an unnecessary action well after the play had been pulled up and the referee had no option but to book him for kicking the ball away and time-wasting.

That neither of these players picked up a second yellow, and thus a send-off, was fortunate for the team.

What is forgotten in the moment is that the accumulation of sufficient yellow cards could result in an automatic one match suspension later in the season.

Will Germano be thinking of his Santa hat, or Worm thinking of a pointless shot on goal, if they happen to earn a ”legitimate” yellow later in the season that takes them over the accumulated limit and earns them a suspension?

And then there’s Pavlovic for Wellington Phoenix. Coming on in the 76th minute, he managed to get sent off with a straight red for a needless chop from behind on Steve Pantelidis in the 94th minute.

It wasn’t a tackle. It was a pointless ankle tap from behind, with no hope of taking the ball which was meters away from the point of contact.

That the foul occurred deep in Perth’s defence when there was no threat on the Wellington goal just adds to the stupidity of Pavlovic’s action.

Ricky Herbert has seen more than his share of foolhardy yellow and red cards this season and I’m sure he’ll be livid with Pavlovic for his indiscretion.

Haliti from the Jets is another serial offender of the senseless yellow as he strips his shirt off for every goal scored. What is that about?

There are plenty of ways to celebrate a goal without picking up a yellow card and it’s time he learnt one or two.

His teammates must pray that he doesn’t score again in the same match and automatically whip off his shirt to earn a second yellow.

Of course there are occasions when yellow cards occur during a match for a foul in normal play, be it for a mistimed tackle or a ‘professional’ foul.

The likes of Jacob Burns from Perth or Leigh Broxham from Victory always extract a price for the yellow cards they receive as they deliver a bruised shin or sore ankle and put the opposition players on notice that they are around.

A professional foul is also a deliberate transgression of the rules which will earn a yellow but it is usually executed to save the team from conceding a goal.

Nothing can excuse a player who takes the field knowing he will receive a yellow card for carrying a prop, or one who wastes time when the game is not in the balance and there is no advantage to be gained, or one who twirls a shirt overhead in senseless celebration knowing a yellow will follow.

On these occasions, as the referee reaches into his pocket, the manager and many spectators are left to shake their heads in wonder at the behaviour of those players who are not playing for the team.

The Crowd Says:

2011-12-14T12:16:14+00:00

tracey

Guest


The players should try and remember they scored for the team and not to look good in the potential news pic in tomorrows paper - it's a bit of fun, sure - but putting self before the team is not a way to get the fans on side - and should definitely have the manager at your back, and you on the bench asap. And besides, theres plenty of pretty of fun and/or attention seeking ways to celebrate without getting yourself half way to a sending off.

2011-12-14T05:39:50+00:00

Shane

Guest


True when they are already celebrating like idiots knowing they will pick up a yellow card, which would come with a fine attached too (although football players do seem to live on a different planet to most of us anyway). The games won after the final whistle blows celebrate as much as you like with a stupid hat on then instead of attention seeking and wasting time in the game.

AUTHOR

2011-12-13T05:52:51+00:00

Philip Coates

Roar Guru


My main point is that with the rules as they are, players are foolish and selfish to deliberately pick up yellow card. But if you think making rules regarding celebrations is stupid and pointless just imagine how stupid and pointless the celebrations would become it the players had free reign to do whatever they liked.

2011-12-12T22:56:45+00:00

Ando23

Guest


For me, I think making rules telling players how they can and cant celebrate is stupid and pointless. They're just having a bit of fun, Its not hurting anybody so why do they need to be punished?

2011-12-12T03:11:54+00:00

Philip

Guest


Funny in a way ... and imagine if it had taken a few more games before he had chance to use it ... phew! But undisciplined all the same and Heart don't have a wealth of players such that they can afford to risk losing a good one to a pointless suspension later in the season.

2011-12-12T03:07:32+00:00

Philip

Guest


There are clothing rules for taking the field of play, "Rule 4: All items of clothing or equipment other than the basic equipment must be inspected by the referee ..." I doubt Germano showed the ref his hat before taking the field. And Rule 12 "A player must be cautioned if: .... • he removes his shirt or covers his head with his shirt • he covers his head or face with a mask or other similar item" A Santa hat would qualify as covering your head. (And removing your shirt has got nothing to do with having a number on your back)

2011-12-11T23:08:47+00:00

TomC

Guest


Good article, Phil. It hadn't occurred to me that there was something of a pattern over the last few weeks, but you make some good points. The comparison with the yellows picked up by players like Broxham and Burns is also well made. It's just as well for Perth Glory that Shane Smeltz doesn't go in for elaborate celebrations, as he picks up quite a few cards for his awful tackling. Although far less than he deserves, if you ask me.

2011-12-11T22:57:32+00:00

Tom

Guest


Germano shouldn't have gotten a yellow card for that, as it didn't cover his face. Yellow card for excessive celebration, covering your face, or removing your jersey (as long as the number is still on your back it's OK). Neither of those things happened, so no yellow card should have been given.

2011-12-11T21:26:30+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


Both the Germano and Worm yellows could be classified as undisciplined, althogh the Santa hat was quite funny, especially the thought that he has it packed in his undies for 90 minutes in the hope of using it - hopefully he is not intending to pass it on to anyone else.

Read more at The Roar