Heady task awaits Saint Nick and his merry men

By Vince Rugari / Expert

It’s just as well that St Kilda’s new leadership group is the size of a small army. Newly re-appointed captain Nick Riewoldt is going to need all the help he can get this year as the Saints look to put a tumultuous 2011 behind them.

In the latest most ridiculous development in the wonderful world of AFL leadership groups, the 29-year-old is going to have six deputies.

Well, seven, technically.

Brendon Goddard, Nick Dal Santo, Leigh Montagna, Adam Schneider, Sam Fisher, James Gwilt and Ben McEvoy were all announced on Wednesday as part of the Saints’ pack of leaders.

Veteran Lenny Hayes, currently on his way back from major knee surgery last year, wasn’t named as a member – he has a separate role, as a ‘leadership mentor’. Whatever that means.

It’s madness. Next thing you know, they’ll be renaming their Best & Fairest award the First Annual Montgomery Burns Award for Outstanding Achievement in the Field of Excellence.

Nevermind Hayes’ job title – there are now eight officially recognized leaders at St Kilda.

Assuming they are all going to be fit for Round 1, then St Kilda’s leadership group will account for more than one third of their 22-man squad.

But the farcical intersection of bureaucracy and leadership in the AFL is a story for another week.

The St Kilda leadership troupe has an enormous task ahead of them in 2012, and much of the responsibility falls on the broad shoulders of their skipper.

Nick Riewoldt is the face of the Saints. After a 2011 they’d rather forget, his performance as captain will go a long way towards determining whether or not they’ll turn their fortunes around.

He needs to prove the value of his leadership by doing his bit this year, or else St Kilda are at the risk of further sliding down the ladder.

The burly superstar was plagued by injury last season, and while he was on the sidelines the Saints were badly missing his influence – both in the forward line and above the shoulders.

Less than two years ago, St Kilda were within inches of ending their 46-year premiership drought with their second-ever flag. But they tied the first Grand Final in 2010, and Collingwood put them away in the sequel.

From premiership contenders that season, they slumped to a seventh-placed finish in 2011. With 12 wins, nine losses and a draw, they were bundled out in the first week of September by Sydney.

With the Pies, Geelong, West Coast, Hawthorn, Carlton and the ever-consistent Swans all tipped to have a major say this year, their window of opportunity remains ajar – but only just.

A pack of clubs with young, developing lists – North Melbourne, Richmond, Fremantle and Melbourne – are expected to be on the improve, and they could well find the Saints in their rear-vision mirror.

Not only was last year a struggle on the park for St Kilda, it was a disaster off-field.

The Saints’ season from hell began with the Kim Duthie saga, and the troubled ‘schoolgirl’ – who is now apparently back on the straight and narrow – gave them headlines for all the wrong reasons.

We all know what happened and we don’t need to revisit it, but it was a terrible way to begin the year for the club. It is also important to note that Riewoldt was implicated in the scandal and it may have affected him whenever his troublesome knee problem allowed him to play.

The year ended with the shocking defection of Ross Lyon to Fremantle. One minute, he was busy planning for the Saints’ 2012 campaign. The next, the self-proclaimed ‘career coach’ blindsided the club’s boardroom by replacing Mark Harvey at the helm of the Dockers.

Speaking of the boardroom, things were just as bad there. The club posted a loss of $1.5 million in their financial report, and their president said they need to quickly find new ways to increase revenue.

There is also the prospect of Greater Western Sydney’s courtship of star on-baller Brendan Goddard becoming an unwanted distraction this year.

Just like we saw with Gary Ablett in 2010 and Tom Scully last year, as they were lured into joining the AFL expansion project by big bucks, every move Goddard makes will be scrutinised to a near-invasive extent by the media. Will he, won’t he? Those are two questions that will be repeated ad nauseam.

It would be unfortunate if St Kilda’s era of dominance in recent years went by without a flag. It would leave a massive hole on the CV of Riewoldt, an elite player who deserves to hold up the cup.

It’s up to him, his seven (or six) deputies and new coach Scott Watters to keep their premiership window open. Leadership was lacking in 2011 – it needs to improve right away.

Riewoldt said last week that he will be looking to offload the captaincy next year to a younger player, but that’s 12 months away – right now, he’s skipper, and his job is not over.

He knows that. His 2012 is going to be intriguing to watch.

The Crowd Says:

2012-02-15T13:14:20+00:00

Kel

Guest


You used the word ridiculous to describe the situation, so I figured you were questioning the merit behind it. I think Watters articulated well why there is so many, they will each have roles and responsibilities. It's new, it's different, let's see if it has any impact.

2012-02-15T06:51:45+00:00

NeeDeep

Roar Pro


The 2012 Collingwood Leadership Group: Heath Shaw, Dale Thomas, Harry O'Brien, Nick Maxwell (captain), Nathan Buckley (coach), Scott Pendlebury, Luke Ball and Travis Cloke - 7 players. Essendon Leadership Group for 2012: Michael Hurley and David Zaharakis become the newest additions to the group which also includes Watson, Mark McVeigh, Brent Stanton and Heath Hocking - 6 players, at least Geelong Leadership Group: midfielder Joel Selwood has been named Geelong's new captain, with 2007 Brownlow medallist Jimmy Bartel appointed the club's vice-captain. Harry Taylor, Corey Enright, Joel Corey, James Kelly and Steve Johnson are the other members of the Cats' leadership group - 7 players. I recall a number of other clubs announcing similar sized leadership groups, although finding the details is a bit of a choir. I do tend to agree with you to some extent Vince, that more than 3 or 4 is a bit of overkill, but who is behind the need for this bigger "leadership groups". The main thing you need to consider here, is that the situation is not unique to the St. Kilda Football Club and as such, the ridicule you include in your article is a little unwarranted. And as per my previous comment, what difference does it really make, anyway, how many "people" are in a so called "Leadership Group"?

AUTHOR

2012-02-14T12:05:31+00:00

Vince Rugari

Expert


And, I suppose, what's the point of having a leadership group when it's so big? Then you're just going to have different levels of leaders within the leadership group. Or maybe I'm a traditionalist.

AUTHOR

2012-02-14T12:04:03+00:00

Vince Rugari

Expert


No, it's just funny that Lenny Hayes has a different title.

2012-02-14T10:14:56+00:00

Kel

Guest


So your argument in regards to an extended leadership group is that because it hasn't been done, it's simply not a good idea?

2012-02-14T10:05:12+00:00

stam

Roar Rookie


Oh my beloved saints, its an eternal struggle defending your decisions, wasted talent and I'm yet to know what a premiership feels like. Too many ifs over the last five years to write up

2012-02-14T02:53:55+00:00

NeeDeep

Roar Pro


Firstly, I can't see a side winning 20 games and loosing 2, or going 19 & 3, or slotting into 3rd spot on the ladder with an 18 win, 4 loss record. This years minor premier will probably go 17 & 5, or maybe even 16 wins for the season. So, what we'll have is a more congested ladder and a win or loss, either way, may improve or cost your club 2 or 3 spots on the ladder. Having said that, the Saints should find themselves well & truly in the mix, but their season may be defined either way, by a win or a loss, in a game they should win, or weren't expected to win - if you get my drift. And I don't think they'll be the Lone Ranger, in that boat. Most clubs have a number of "leaders", on and off the field. By publicly announcing them as part of a "leadership group" changes what? Nothing as far as I can tell. Same blokes, doing the same job. All they've done is stick the hand up to say we're taking a little bit of ownership in the performance of the team. St. Kilda is a club renowned for "self-destructing", right on the brink of success. And don't the media love it. Kim Duthie had several scandalous incidents with other AFL clubs - Sydney, Carlton and even Collingwood, I believe. None of this really had any great media attention. Then we had the Lovett incident. The guy hadn't even played a proper scratch match for the Saints, yet he was in the press in a bad way, as a St. Kilda player. Then when he was acquitted, he becomes a former Bomber / Essendon player??? Anytime we get a little sniff that somethings amiss at Collingwood, it hits the press for a matter of a couple of days, is laughed off as trivial, or silly and then we never hear anymore about it. Put the spotlight on St. Kilda and it stays there for months. Having said that, the club needs to accept some responsability as well. If you do dumb things, then you're always a chance to be scrutinised. Ross Lyon - well, I reckon he's a bit of a down-hill skier. I really don't think he has what it takes to work with a development list and whilst the Saints don't have that yet, he may have felt that was where they needed to go, or were going to go. With Freo, I think he may have over estimated that clubs lists, potential. Time will tell if Ross has bitten off more than he can chew, with the Dockers. Personally, I think if I was on the Giants scouting comittee, I would be much more interested in Scott Pendlebury - but that's right, he plays for Collingwood, so we won't go there - let's focus on Brendon Goddard and St. Kilda - again!

2012-02-13T22:19:12+00:00

TomC

Guest


Can't see the Saints having a genuine tilt at the flag this season, but I do think there's plenty of quality left in the team to get them into the eight. Possibly even the four if a few teams underperform. There's a lot of experience in that team.

Read more at The Roar