What would happen if Pocock was hit by a bus?

By Brett McKay / Expert

You’d rightly be concerned for the bus’s well-being, initially. But looking beyond the literal, just how good is the depth of Australian No. 7s behind the premier openside in the country?

The public bus test is something that I like to apply from time to time because it forces immediate contemplation of something that you otherwise wouldn’t want to consider.

I most recently applied it to the spin-bowling ranks within Australian cricket, and the answer there – worryingly – is still no clearer.

Nevertheless, in New Zealand during the Rugby World Cup late last year, Pocock was hit by the metaphorical bus. The Wallabies, and more specifically the selection and planning of coach Robbie Deans, were left to look a little foolish as a result.

Happily, Pocock is again fit and firing, and seems to have taken to the Western Force captaincy like a duck to water. And with another Super Rugby competition under way, and with the international season nearing, are Australia’s openside stocks any better?

Happily, I think they are. Paul Cully did too, about a month ago, but I think things have improved even since then.

Looking around the five Australian teams, I think it’s now safe to conclude that there is considerably more depth behind Pocock than there was, and even more than when the Rugby World Cupn squad was selected. Ben McCalman shouldn’t have to worry about resuming his unsuccessful understudy role any time soon.

While the Reds have essentially kept their championship forward pack together, it’s interesting to note what is either the promotion of young Liam Gill, or the drop off of Beau Robinson.

Robinson is probably still in front of the apprentice for the moment, but there isn’t a lot of difference between the two at the breakdown. If Robinson is still in front, it can’t be by much now. Gill has really come along after gaining experience off the bench last year, though is still prone to the odd brain explosion infringement that youth creates.

That said, Robinson has been off the mark so far this year, perhaps a barometer for how the Reds are going in general. If he has any designs on adding to his sole Wallaby appearance, he has to reclaim both the No. 7 jersey and his 2011 form within the next month.

Apart from once-warm pies, the Canberra Stadium media box is perched directly above the commentary and coaches boxes, and it was from this perfectly elevated vantage point that I paid close attention to young Brumby Michael Hooper last weekend.

Hooper won all the plaudits and platitudes for his demolition job on the Highlanders a few weeks back, and there’s no question his star is rising rapidly.

What was noticeable about Hooper was the way he operates within the middle thirty or so metres of the field, and particularly how well he picks his times to attack the breakdown. It’s probably not that much different to how Pocock operates, though I don’t recall Pocock having the same patience at the same age.

That’s not to say that Hooper is destined to better Pocock, just that he clearly has a wise head on young shoulders. 2012 might be a bit soon for higher honours, but I’m quite certain Hooper will play for Australia sooner rather than later.

Pat McCutcheon started the season as the Waratahs’ preferred openside, but his horrible ankle break in Dunedin has opened the door for Chris Alcock to continue where he left off in 2011.

Alcock plays with a different level of physicality to McCutcheon, and it was for this reason that many a Roarer suggested he should’ve been wearing the New South Wales No. 7 from the outset in 2012. You could say that Alcock has the size to play the game that Phil Waugh always tried to.

Down in Melbourne, it was interesting to see young Tom Chamberlain had been keeping England international Michael Lipman on the bench up until this week, especially when the Rebel’s own profiles list Chamberlain as a blindside.

And it’s obvious that he is a blindsider, because he doesn’t play that natural ‘fetcher’ role even as well as Jarrod Saffy does. This in itself is interesting, too, because I do wonder if the thought has been given to playing Saffy at openside.

Though Saffy and Chamberlain’s dimensions are essentially the same, Saffy looks to be the more natural openside build. Chamberlain’s impressive tackling stats wouldn’t be lost at blindside either way. If someone from the Army could arrange that for me, that’d be grouse, as you guys put it.

This brings me back to Perth, where I’ve had similar thoughts about Pocock and Matt Hodgson. Like the two Rebels, Hodgson and Pocock share similar height and weight proportions, though to see them in the flesh you would swear Hodgson was the smaller, openside build. There’s no other way of saying it, Pocock’s bloody enormous now.

I think the Force have got it right this season, though, playing Hodgson at No. 8 in McCalman’s absence, because it’s essentially allowed Hodgson to play as a second opensider, with Richard Brown and Angus Cottrell both playing well so far on the blind.

It shouldn’t really make much difference from playing at blindside, but Hodgson seems to be relishing the extra freedom to roam at the breakdown and in attack from No. 8, and indeed, scored one of the tries of the year last weekend against the Reds.

The depth behind Pocock might be a bit stronger now, and I’ll be keeping an eye on how Hooper and Gill progress over the rest of the Super Rugby season, but Hodgson still looks to be heading the queue behind his Western Force skipper at the moment.

We still don’t need Pocock to go near public buses, of course, but at least if the worst-case scenario returns, we’re a lot better equipped than we were not too long ago.

The Crowd Says:

2012-04-10T09:02:15+00:00

Jagman

Guest


By the way what happened to Hugh Perrett, Eastwood captain. Played well for waratahs last year now where is he. If the rebels need an openside there's one staring in the face.

2012-04-09T02:17:03+00:00

faitala.lima

Roar Rookie


Graham the u20s have no effect on the eligibility of players at top level to clarify your question. so hes still eligible for either team i guess. all blacks or wallabies. or even manu samoa seeing as he is samoan but i think he only has one goal in mind and thats the black jersey.

2012-04-07T05:01:23+00:00

Graham Krebbs

Guest


I know you're just exploring the Australian franchises here but I saw someone mention the Hurricanes Jack Lam as back-up for the All Blacks. Well firstly, I'm not 100% on this but as Lam played for Australia U/20s I was under the impression he was only eligible to play for the Wallabies? Secondly if this is the case then I would hope that he would be brought over to an Australian franchise for a stint so he can play for the wallabies ASAP. He is a total weapon across the park with great feet and power in attack and absolutely massive defense bigger than any of the current Wallabies forward pack without a doubt. He's no Pocock or Hooper at the breakdown but I'd love to see him brought back across the ditch

2012-04-06T00:29:29+00:00

Blue Blood

Guest


The stats are true. Hodgson just slouches and has since he was a kid. His stats in the gym are also par with Pocock. I feel that Hodgson has far from had his chance with the Wallabies. He has had one start against Samoa where the entire squad sucked. The rest of the time he has been off the bench and looked good. Often his tackle stats have been better than Higgers or Rocky when he has had only 20minutes and they've had 60-80. In mid week Wallaby games he has shone (MOM) many times in squads full of estaished Wallabies. The games where Pocock doesn't play the Wallabies look like crap. They are used to having the breakdown attended too and the ball pilfered. Take out Pocock and the others still don't play on the ball enough to win the ball. Too many guys like rocky, Higgers. Samo who won't consistantly do the .... They need a 7 who loves the breakdown and the best solution for years has been Hodgson. I propose that Pocock looks amazing at super rugby because of the support of Hodgson. Them moving him to 8 over 2 Wallaby 8s illustrate my point. At the Wallabies Pocock could play even better if he had support like Hodgson. Even bus free, Hodgson as a backrow bench specialist is the logical option. He might not be your first choice for 7, but he is a great 2nd and a capable cover for 6,7 and 8

2012-04-05T10:30:01+00:00

sportym

Guest


Yup! Retired from turning Wallabies into Road Kill!

AUTHOR

2012-04-05T09:17:45+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Good on you BB - and I reckon you've nailed the optical illusion that is Pocock and Hodgson. I saw the two of them at close quarters at the start of the season, and I'd have guessed the difference between them was closer to 5cm and 10kg! And I certainly agree with your thoughts on Hodgson playing his best rugby this year, that's my perception too. He's been very, very good in 2012..

2012-04-05T08:02:32+00:00

Blue Blood

Guest


I agree with the conclusion of this article. Hodgson has played well for the last 3 years but I think he is actually playing his best rugby now. I actually think that on a number of times this year Hodgson has shone brighter than Pocock and Pocock is far from having a bad year. The difference between Pocock and Hodgson is 1cm and 1kg, but Pocock is a visual freak and Hodgson slouches on the field and in person. Perhaps it is a strategy so the opposition underestimate him at their peril. I have been watching the back row a lot this year and in particular the Australian derbies. Hodgson has been clearly dominating and looks to be enjoying his rugby. The Reds in particular looked shabby in comparison. Let's keep Pocock away from buses but keep Hodgson close...giving Pocock breaks from the work load. Hodgson should be a frequent bench favourite this year. Aptly covering the backrow in a super team full of Wallabies. Great article mate

2012-04-05T07:36:07+00:00

jameswm

Guest


If Hodgson's 1kg less than Pocock, then I'm Arnold Schwarzenegger.

2012-04-05T07:35:24+00:00

jameswm

Guest


I'd keep Kimlin ahead of Power

2012-04-05T06:29:34+00:00

jeznez

Guest


I think we are on pretty much the same page. Certainly Fardy is the top of my list to keep from that group, probably follwed by Carter. Kimlin/Power I'm fairly lineball on.

2012-04-05T06:14:01+00:00

King of the Gorgonites

Roar Guru


very true.

AUTHOR

2012-04-05T05:59:30+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


See my comment about Kimlin above - in your scenario there, I'm not sure it wouldn't be Kimlin that misses out, on current form. I know very little about Auelua either, other than what I've read about what he did for Toulon. But in the flesh, he is a massive human, and I can only imagine what he'd do with some speed up..

AUTHOR

2012-04-05T05:56:58+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


James, I'm not making the dimensions claim up, this is from the Western Force's site: Pocock: 184cm / 104kg Hodgson: 185cm / 103kg

AUTHOR

2012-04-05T05:54:29+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


See James, for me, Kimlin just isn't having the same impact at lock or at 6. When Fardy plays or comes on at 6 for Kimlin, the difference is massive and you can see the Brumbies lift. And when Kimlin goes to lock for Carter or Power, the lineout doesn't seem anywhere near as stable. Carter is also much more physical at the breakdown than Kimlin. I do agree that Mowen at 6, and Vaea at 8 could/should/would work, but I'd be leaving the locks as they are..

2012-04-05T05:02:36+00:00

jeznez

Guest


The Brumbies pack is coming together nicely, first choice front row is back together. When Fainga'a returns I assume that one of Kimlin, Power, Carter and Fardy misses a place. Vaea can return to 6/8 where the focus needs to be on his superb running. I'm not familiar with Auelua (apart from reading his profile on the Brumbies website) I take it from your comment that he is another power runner for the back row?

2012-04-05T04:16:37+00:00

faitala.lima

Roar Rookie


i think Cane something from the chiefs would be a bit of a threat to all of the above ..

2012-04-05T04:13:35+00:00

faitala.lima

Roar Rookie


now brad thorn woulda definitely hospitalized the bus ...

2012-04-05T04:12:30+00:00

faitala.lima

Roar Rookie


pocock simply outstaged george smith towards the end of smiths super rugby career. i dont think he wouldve been able to keep up wit super rugby at 31. he stands out in the northern hemisphere because the standard up there isnt quite as high as the southern hemisphere..

AUTHOR

2012-04-05T04:10:00+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Jez, he's certainly a known element, an it really is just a case of him not haing played this year that I haven't mentioned Colby Fainga'a. In fact it'll be interesting to see how White uses all his backrowers once they're fit again (I mentioned Auelua above). I expect we'll see more rotation both on and off the bench..

2012-04-05T03:23:10+00:00

Justin

Guest


Yes the Tahs backs are very very ordinary. The only ones I rate are Kingston and AAC has had somewhat of a return to form (but he still refuses to pass). Foley has the potential also.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar