Who is Australia’s greatest ever Socceroo?

John Davidson Roar Guru

By John Davidson, John Davidson is a Roar Guru


34 Have your say

Popular article! 7,361 reads

    Australian football fans have the tough choice of helping to decide our greatest ever footballer.

    At a time when the Australian football family is under-siege with A-League dramas, finally some good, positive debate.

    The poll is being run by the Johnny Warren Football Foundation and members of the public can have their say for who should be honoured. Public voting will be combined with the decisions of a judging panel on a 50/50 basis to determine the winners, with voting close on June 22.

    The judging panel includes the likes of Les Murray, Andy Harper, Craig Foster, Anthony LaPaglia, George Negus, Moya Dodd, Jack Reilly and Michael Cockerill.

    There’s no easy answers among choosing the best Socceroo team ever. It’s very difficult to decide on players when you have never seen them player before, like Marston and Date, and to compare eras. But here’s my two cents, and the reasons for them:

    Mark Schwarzer – Bosnich may have been more talented, and Ron Corry and Jim Fraser have had great careers as both players and coaches, but for me it has to be Mark Schwarzer. His longevity, his remarkably consistent career in the top flight in both England and Germany, and his fantastic Australian debut against Canada in the ’94 World Cup cannot be forgotten. And nor can his penalty saves against Uruguay in 2005.

    Joe Marston – A pioneer for Australians playing in England, a long-serving career with the Socceroos and ex-NSW State League and national team coach. Joe has done it all, and he is also a true gentleman and legend of our sport.

    Alex Tobin – 87 games for the Socceroos, many as captain, says it all. So does his haul of 522 senior games in Australia, three NSL championships with Adelaide City and the high esteem he is held in, evident of the PFA Medal being named after him.

    Peter Wilson – An enigma, Wilson was born in England but moved to Australia at 22. He had a long and prolific career in the NSL and with the Socceroos, with the highlight for the dominant sweeper coming as captain for Australia at the 1974 World Cup.

    Lucas Neill – A tough choice between Lucas and Craig Moore, but Lucas just gets the nod. What a captain, a phenomenon at the 2006 World Cup and a proud leader.

    Johnny Warren – Has anyone ever given more to the beautiful game as a player, coach, ambassador, media pundit or spokesperson in Australia? I don’t think so.

    Tim Cahill – This man has carried the Socceroos in recent years. He scores goals for Australia for fun, and has conquered the brutal English Premier League. Such an inspirational figure.

    Ned Zelic – Deciding between the immensely talented but injury-prone Paul Okon and the freakish but more temperamental Ned Zelic is near impossible, but Zelic just edges it. What a player, a legend in the Bundesliga and a fantastic Socceroo (though primarily in defence). His goal against Holland in 1991 will live long in the memory.

    Mark Viduka – You just can’t go past the V-Bomber. A freakish teenager, he wowed crowds in Australia, Croatia, Scotland and England. His goal-scoring record for the Socceroos may not have matched his club feats, but this ignores the fact that often he was a lone soul up front for Australia. Such skill and impressive technique for a big man who could virtually do it all.

    Harry Kewell – Another boy wonder turned English Premier League star. ‘H’ cops a lot of criticism but he has delivered for Australia time and time again – against Iran in 1997, against Croatia in 2006 etc etc. He’s still doing the business for the Socceroos (see the recent Saudi Arabia friendly) and had a good debut A-League season with the Victory.

    Reg Date – Some might be saying, Reg who? To those I would say, do your research. Date was a goal-scoring machine, a fearsome striker with a ridiculously powerful shot. My recent deceased grandfather told me a story about once seeing Date play, and with one of his goals the goalkeeper ended up in the back of the net with the ball.

    Date has been termed as the ‘Bradman of Australian Soccer’ by some, and to his contemporary Joe Marston he the best Australian player he ever played with or against: ”Great player. Great bloke. But boy he could drink. The selectors, they never liked Reggie. He was too much of a larrikin. They couldn’t handle him.”

    Date just makes it front of fellow Novocastrian Ray Baartz, perhaps our most skilful Socceroo ever, whose career was tragically cut short in his prime.

    Notable mentions go to players like Baartz, Moore, Okon and Frank Farina for missing the cut. Also somewhat surprising that Craig Johnston was left off the nominees list. I will do my picks on the greatest ever coach, Matilda and overall player another time.

    More importantly, who would you choose?

    There are 72 nominees to choose from, and they have been chosen from a set criteria. For the greatest ever team, it is between

    Ron Lord
    Ron Corry
    Jim Fraser
    Mark Bosnich
    Mark Scwharzer

    George Keith
    Doug Utjesenovic
    Alan Davidson
    Tony Vidmar
    Luke Wilkshire
    Paul Okon
    Joe Marston
    Manfred Schaeffer
    John Watkiss
    Peter Wilson
    Charlie Yankos
    Milan Ivanovic
    Alex Tobin
    Ned Zelic
    Craig Moore
    Lucas Neill
    Col Curran
    Harry Williams
    Jim Tansey
    Stan Lazaridis
    Scott Chipperfield

    Jimmy Rooney
    Johnny Warren
    Murray Barnes
    Paul Wade
    Brett Emerton
    Jimmy McKay
    Paul Okon
    Vince Grella
    Josip Skoko
    Jason Culina
    Ned Zelic
    Tim Cahill
    Les Scheinflug
    Ray Richards
    Oscar Crino
    Robbie Slater
    Mark Bresciano

    Atti Abonyi
    Frank Farina
    Aurelio Vidmar
    Tim Cahill
    Adrian Alston
    Ray Baartz
    John Kosmina
    Graham Arnold
    Mark Viduka
    Branko Buljevic
    David Mitchell
    Eddie Krncevic
    Harry Kewell
    John Aloisi
    Reg Date
    John Watkiss

    For the greatest ever coach, it is between:

    Joe Vlasits
    Rale Rasic
    Frank Arok
    Eddie Thomson
    Terry Venables
    Frank Farina
    Guus Hiddink
    Pim Verbeek

    For the greatest ever female player, it is between:

    Julie Dolan
    Julie Murray
    Cheryl Salisbury
    Jo Peters
    Joanne Millman
    Collette McCallum
    Alison Foreman
    Heather Garriock
    Lisa De Vanna
    Melissa Barbieri

    Who do you choose, Roarers?

    Twitter: @johnnydavidson

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (34)

    • April 13th 2012 @ 1:05pm
      Johnno said | April 13th 2012 @ 1:05pm | ! Report

      H K Kewell. Nothing more needs to be said and no more names, end of story non negotiable.

    • April 13th 2012 @ 1:30pm
      sheek said | April 13th 2012 @ 1:30pm | ! Report


      I’m not a football expert as such, but based on what I do know of the history of the Socceroos, i like your team.

      Schwarzer vs Bosnich is the old Stones vs Beatles argument, isn’t it? In this case the Stones (Schwarzer) wins.

      From what iIve read, Ray Baartz was pretty special. He could play attacking midfielder or striker, which means is he directly opposed to Viduka? Or Date, who I don’t really know much about but I’ve read he was pretty good.

      I’ve got Johnny Warren’s best XI somewhere at home. It will be interesting to compare it with yours.

      Anyway, assuming we leave your XI (well selected I think) untouched, here are my 4 reserves.

      goalkeeper; Mark Bosnich

      defender: Craig Moore

      midfield: Paul Okon

      forward: Ray Baartz

      Captain is a toss-up between defenders Wilson & Neill, don’t know, maybe Wilson. Rale Rasic is my suggestion for coach, despite Aussie Guus’ achievements. Guus was a shooting comet, passing far too quickly to leave a long-term legacy.

      Really good team, I like it a lot…..

    • April 13th 2012 @ 1:30pm
      apaway said | April 13th 2012 @ 1:30pm | ! Report

      There is a glaring omission in the list and that is the name of Ian Gray. Yes, it is well-known probably to Roar readers that he was a friend of mine but he was a magnificent midfielder or defender, a natural leader, fierce, skilful, tough and one of the game’s great thinkers.

    • April 13th 2012 @ 1:49pm
      Johnno said | April 13th 2012 @ 1:49pm | ! Report

      Ned Zelic has to be in the starting 11 what a player he was. Goal vs Holland got the Olyroos into the Olympics.
      For me sadly Terry Venables, cost us vs Iran , not peter Hoare “Peter pest”
      Not palying Milan Ivanovic was ridiculous. EL Tel played our old friend Foz.
      Ivanovic was the rock of the soccer’s defence should of played vs Iran.

    • April 13th 2012 @ 1:50pm
      super G said | April 13th 2012 @ 1:50pm | ! Report

      Have to go with players I saw first hand although I’m sure our past greats would have a say or two.
      Bosnich – T. Vidmar – Neill – Ivanovic – Chipperfield ; Bresciano – Zelic – Cahill ; A. Vidmar – Viduka – Kewell. Coach: Hiddink

      • April 13th 2012 @ 3:02pm
        striker said | April 13th 2012 @ 3:02pm | ! Report

        Super G thats spot on for me only id put Emerton in there for for Vidmar.

    • April 13th 2012 @ 2:06pm
      apaway said | April 13th 2012 @ 2:06pm | ! Report

      Mark Schwarzer

      Scott Chipperfield
      Alex Tobin
      Lucas Neil
      Stan Lazaridis

      Mark Bresciano
      Ian Gray
      Johnny Warren

      Harry Kewell
      Mark Viduka
      Tim Cahill

      Coach: Frank Arok