Magpies hold off Bulldogs for AFL win

4 Have your say

    Collingwood survived a fierce challenge from the Western Bulldogs to win an absorbing AFL match by 21 points at Etihad Stadium.

    The Magpies took full toll of several Bulldogs turnovers in the last term to win 15.8 (98) to 11.11 (77) on Friday night.

    Midfielders Dayne Beams starred for the ‘Pies with 33 disposals, while defender Alan Toovey was superb with his work on in-form Bulldogs small forward Luke Dahlhaus.

    Collingwood midfielder Scott Pendlebury was also prolific and was awarded best afield.

    Bulldogs onballer Ryan Griffen led his team with 33 possessions and eight clearances.

    Collingwood fans were furious with the umpires after a free-kick count that went the Bulldogs’ way 21-10, including 9-0 at the start of the match.

    The ‘Dogs were trailing by eight points midway through the final term when two mistakes from Shaun Higgins – one with a kick to goal and the second at the other end shortly after – meant Harry O’Brien kicked a vital goal for the Magpies.

    Sharrod Wellingham kicked the sealer soon after after a turnover from Bulldogs defender Dylan Addison.

    But the Bulldogs were outstanding with their intensity and they set up well against Collingwood.

    Their biggest problem – again – was the lack of a big-marked key forward.

    When Collingwood kicked the opening goal of the third term, they had an ominous nine-point lead.

    But Daniel Giansiracusa then kicked two straight to give his side the lead again.

    The game continued to see-saw through the third quarter, with four lead changes.

    Bulldogs defender Ryan Hargrave marked and goalled to reduce the margin to one point at three quarter-time.

    In a major blow to the ‘Dogs, defender Easton Wood hobbled off with a hamstring injury in the third term after he had been one of their best.

    Earlier, Collingwood had withstood a strong challenge from the Western Bulldogs to kick the last three goals of the second term and lead by three points at the main break.

    Star Collingwood midfielder Dane Swan, who had an absorbing battle all night with Bulldogs tagger Liam Picken, ran through a stoppage brilliantly to kick a goal late in the second quarter.

    Collingwood utility Ben Johnson left the field with a shoulder injury in the second term and did not reappear.

    The game appeared to be going the Bulldogs’ way when Giansiracusa soccered through a goal at 17 minutes in the second term after a series of 50-50 balls that went their way.

    But it proved their last score of the half as Collingwood kicked three goals and regained the lead.

    Collingwood’s Darren Jolly was a late withdrawal with a groin injury and Cameron Wood, who took his place, rucked for nearly the whole game.

    Buckley said there was still plenty of room for improvement in his team, but he was pleased with how they responded to the Bulldogs’ challenge.

    “The Bulldogs were true to their form in the last couple of weeks, they love to outnumber at the contest, they work very hard for each other,” Buckley said.

    “It took a while for us to adjust and eventually it was a good performance to do and grind the win out.”

    Bulldogs coach Brendan McCartney was encouraged by his team’s endeavour and said he had no problem with the last-quarter turnovers, given the players were trying so hard to set up scoring chances.

    But ultimately, he said the ‘Dogs had not kept the Magpies on the back foot for long enough.

    “It wasn’t a frustrating night, it was disappointing for our club to lose a game we’d done a lot right in,” he said.

    “It was a combination of things, we made some errors but every team makes them.

    “We felt we just didn’t smash in aggressively enough for long enough and the contested ball count got out of control in the last quarter.

    “We’ve got to become a club and will become a club that is physical and fights to the death.”

    © AAP 2018

    This video is trending right now! Submit your videos for the chance to win a share of $10,000!

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (4)

    • Roar Guru

      May 5th 2012 @ 11:00am
      The Cattery said | May 5th 2012 @ 11:00am | ! Report

      A surprisingly good game last night, which ebbed and flowed with the contested possessions count. Ultimately, it was the dogs’ problem which they have had all season that counted most against them: low conversion of inside 50s, relying on Gia as a spearhead, he did well, but they were always up against it. In fact, the dogs dobbed 3 or 4 running goals from outside 50m, to sort of underscore how dysfunctional things are inside 50.

      At the other end, at crucial times, Dawes and Cloke pulled down big marks in the goal square.

      In the last quarter, 3 dogs’ turnovers in the defensive 50 resulted in 3 pies goals – and that was the ball game.

      Good performance by the dogs, but they are in real trouble up front.

    • May 5th 2012 @ 11:26am
      GrantS said | May 5th 2012 @ 11:26am | ! Report

      Your article is spot on Roger.

      The game last night was winnable by the Bulldogs if they possessed a power forward which they obviously do not.

      It’s hard to say which player is playing in what position nowadays but according to the doggies team sheets Liam Jones is center half forward and Jordan Roughead is full forward (changing in the ruck).
      In the six games this year Jones has kicked 6.6 and Roughead 2.0 . Eight goals six behinds from a total of sixty five goals fifty two behinds scored by the team. So the two main forwards are only responsible for 12% of the total goals. Not a very good result is it?

      Last year Barry Hall kicked 55 goals 17 behinds and only played 15 games. This was 18% of all the goals kicked by the Bulldogs for the season.

      This being the case it is quite clear to all that it is impossible for the Western Bulldogs to make the finals, let alone feature in the Grand Final ,until they recruit some personnel capable of filling (and performing) in the required positions.

      I think Mick Malthouse once said that the best coach can’t take the worst team to the Grand Final or something along those lines.

    • May 5th 2012 @ 1:49pm
      Swampy said | May 5th 2012 @ 1:49pm | ! Report

      Where does this result paint collingwood? It seems to me they are struggling to kick a winning score. With the rest of the top sides all largely attacking juggernauts it’s hard to see how the Pies will feature in a GF this year. I’d say their run is probably over as the salary cap will get them next year.

      Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.

      • May 5th 2012 @ 2:24pm
        GrantS said | May 5th 2012 @ 2:24pm | ! Report

        Collingwood aren’t playing anywhere near as well as last year but they still have players out with injury and I think it is a bit early to write them off.

        I don’t think they will make the Grand Final either but with so long to go they could easily prove us wrong.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , ,