There is no one person to blame for the cancellation of UFC 151. On Thursday morning, UFC President Dana White informed the media of the chain of events that led to the organisation having to pull the plug on next weekend’s event.
The short version of the things is that Dan Henderson got hurt, Lyoto Machida declined, Chael Sonnen stepped up, and Jon Jones opted not to fight “The Gangster from West Linn” on short notice.
In a twist of further craziness, Machida declined the opportunity to face Jones at UFC 152 – which White had announced as the end result of all the UFC 151 shuffling.
This led to Vitor Belfort stepping out of his fight with Alan Belcher at UFC 153 to challenge “Bones” for the light heavyweight title next month in Toronto at UFC 152.
For the record, Mauricio “Shogun” Rua turned down the bout as well.
When all this news came out, Twitter opinion went out of control. All kinds of people started pointing fingers; some were directed at Dana White (and ostensibly the UFC), others were turned towards Jones.
Personally, I think anyone trying to pin this on one person is simply choosing not to acknowledge that there are all kinds of sides to this situation.
The blame for this can’t be placed on any one person’s shoulders.
This is a confluence of problems coming together to create a historically bad day.
Taken on its own from a business standpoint, I understand Jones’ decision to decline a fight with Sonnen on extremely short notice.
He has very little to gain, a bunch to lose, and – even though I’m not a big fan of saying this – Sonnen in no way earned the opportunity to fight for the light heavyweight championship.
But I can’t look at this as a stand alone situation because there are other components to consider than just Jones’ career.
Fingering the UFC for spreading themselves too thin isn’t entirely fair; they had a fight on the table to keep things moving forward, and whether he should have taken it or not, Jones opted to pass.
According to White, the light heavyweight champion was made aware of the ramifications of such a decision, and still made the choice he made.
While it is his to make and he doesn’t owe it to anyone to take a high risk/low reward match-up on short notice, let’s not pretend there weren’t multiple ways to still keep UFC 151 alive in all this.
Secondly, as we’ve seen with both Machida and Rua choosing to pass on fighting Jones next month in Toronto as well, it’s not as easy as saying, “Well, if they had guys who could step up…” and calling it a night.
To the best of my knowledge, both Machida and Rua are physically capable of stepping up; they’re just not so inclined, and that’s not something you can blame on the UFC.
Even if they had a dozen light heavyweights kicking around this week, there is no guarantee that (1) any of them would have accepted this opening or (2) Jones would have agreed to fight them.
For the record, I think you could have offered Jones a bout with the a fresh out of retirement Matt Hamill at UFC 151 and he would have turned it down.
He was prepared to face Henderson, and when those plans changed, his participation in UFC 151 came to a screeching halt.
That being said, I think the UFC’s decision to cancel the show completely rather than press forward without a main event is the big acknowledgement that they know there is a need to get back to loading up pay-per-view cards to the best of their abilities.
We’ve all watched Dana White trying to sell a piece of glass as a precious gem in the past, but there was none of that here.
Once Jones was out, they knew they needed to cut their losses and start focusing on the next card.
By the way, those losses are going to be sizeable, and I believe that any argument in favour of Jones being faultless for making the decision that is best for him from a business standpoint absolves White of any criticism for lashing out at the light heavyweight champion (and his team) in the wake of this.
The UFC will lose a lot of money from the cancellation of this event.
If Jones gets a pass for doing what is best for him, you’re damn right I think Dana White can be pissed off about losing millions and millions of dollars.
While I don’t think we’re going to see a reduction in the number of events the UFC holds as a result of this situation, I do think more of those great fights that keep landing on free television are going to cost you money to watch in 2013.
The major FOX events will likely remain star-studded, but don’t be surprised if the events on the other outlets feature even fewer recognizable names in the future.
People can argue and debate who is more to blame all they want; I’m way too tired and in no way interested in engaging in that time-wasting activity.
The bottom line is that Thursday sucked, and there is plenty of blame to go around. Rather than point fingers, I say we just start moving on.
Who’s with me?
Follow E. Spencer Kyte on Twitter (@spencerkyte).
Steve
Guest
That's a good, sensible analysis: I'm just afraid the average fan will still take Jones as 'the villain'.
Grujgo
Guest
Through an unbelievable turn of events that I believe has outlasted the Silva vs. Sonnen Rivalry, as one of the biggest things to happen to the sport of MMA, at least the UFC, Jones has damaged his image unfortunately through a stupendous amount of ‘finger pointing’ and angst against Jon Jones. Furthermore, the majority of this uproar was lifted by the president of the UFC, Dana White, acting in a complete disrespectful manner towards Jones, for who he is and what he represents –something that Dana White will never understand. Jon Jones is on the verge of something great, incredible even. To amass something that no one has done before. Jones has begun to form his legacy from the beginning of his reign of the Light Heavyweight Title. Anderson Silva, as we know, would have been recognised as just beginning to cement his legacy with the win over Sonnen from the worldwide appraisal that that fight encountered. It’s just outright stupidity that a fighter such as Chael Sonnen can even challenge for a title, considering the circumstances he should not even have been referred to at all in this incident other than to refer to him as someone that Jones turned down. Adding to this, Jon Jones goes through a preparation method that a possible 80% of the fighters fighting in the UFC don’t go through. Jones spends an unmeasurable amount of time studying his opponent, stating that he had watched every single fight in Dan Henderson’s career prior to fighting him. This along with the non-countable hours spent in the gym putting the plan into action. I believe that there should be an incredible amount of more articles questioning the actions the UFC takes rather than subsiding with them to brighten up the hype and PPV numbers. There have been too many occasions where attacks like this have happened on a fighter. To name one easy one- Silva vs. Mia. This is not a place on the street where you always get a slugfest or a brawl. This is a sport. If fighters can dominate someone like that, find bigger opponents that can measure this power than wine about how disappointing a domination and highlight of skill is. Sometimes I wish someone else took the spot at the top of the business and not a bunch of subjective, overpowering lunatics, that which has brought a slow death to the legendary sport of boxing. And as much as dislike Mayweathers mindset at times and ways he goes about things I hope his plan can save the sport of boxing.
Steve
Guest
Well I'm with you, but going by the MMA message boards I've seen already, I think Jones may have damaged his brand more badly than he would have if he'd somehow managed to lose to Sonnen. MMA fans can be vociferous and less than philosophical, so the unstoppable new star dodging an aging underdog he should be able to beat, barring a major upset, isn't a good look. The rationale that Jones hadn't prepared specifically for Sonnen only makes it sound even worse- Sonnen should be even less prepared, but he's raring to go-fearless and opportunistic as ever. Giving Sonnen, of all people, an opportunity to get publicity and stir up trouble at your expense can't be good. I do feel a bit sorry for Jones in the sense that he was put in a difficult solution, but the way out would have been to fight Sonnen. It's not quite true Jones had nothing to gain from the fight- Dana White would have been indebted to him, the victory would add to his legend (he can beat anyone, anytime etc.) Sonnen is at least a name people will tune in to watch etc. A loss would be bad, but probably seen as an anomaly: I certainly don't think the ignominy and cat-calls would go on for as long as they are going over this. Of his limited options, I think Jones might have gone for the worst one, and while you are right we should all move on, I fear the ramifications of this might go on for a good while yet.