Lebanon leave-out for Socceroos hopefuls

By John Davidson / Roar Guru

Despite the media and fans clamouring for the Socceroos side to be rejuvenated, Holger Osieck has largely resisted calls for new blood in his 22-man selection for the next two matches.

Tim Cahill, long Australia’s talisman, is back, along with Matt McKay, Jade North and Matt Spiranovic.

Osieck will hope to have placated those wanting more youth by picking Nikita Rukavystya again, along with FC Utrecht’s Adam Sarota.

He has also given the nod to former Newcastle Jets midfielder James Holland.

Getting very little game time when he was at AZ Alkmaar, Holland made the move to Austria in January and has finally seen regular game-time again.

The 23-year old, who plays for FK Austria Wien, will be out to add to his five Socceroo appearances.

Jason Davidson and Ryan McGowan, who made their debuts in the disastrous last friendly against Scotland, have been retained.

Scott McDonald misses out after his recall against the Scots and his Boro teammate, the luck-less Rhys Williams, is down with injury.

For me, this is a bit of a mixed bag.

Osieck has copped plenty for not bringing along the new generation in his two years in charge of the national team.

This is not completely his fault – not many youngsters have been knocking on the door loudly enough for selection.

He has also introduced some new, albiet older players, such as McKay and Ognenovski, in his time who have largely done well.

But he has not gambled enough, especially in friendly matches which were inconsaquential.

There have been too few of the younger breed, who will actually be members of the team post Brazil 2014, getting experience now.

Harry Kewell has been left out, which is the right call considering he has had no game-time of late.

But Osieck’s persistance with David Carney and Archie Thompson, and probably North as well, is sure to cop flak.

However, partially in the German’s defence, I think he is at least finally attempting to try and blood some new, young talent.

The retainment of Davidson and McGowan, along with the picks of Rukavystya, Sarota and Holland, point to that. It may of course be too little too late.

The next move would be to give these players significant match-time, at least against Lebanon.

It is a friendly after all, and we need to see what they can do in the green and gold.

Holger’s critics will point to the non-selection of James Troisi, Matthew Leckie, Massimo Luongo and Luke DeVere and say he has not gone far enough.

They will say that he has been safe with his selections, not brave.

Unfortunately, as I understand it, both DeVere and Leckie are injuried, which is a huge shame.

Both are playing well for their clubs in Korea and Germany, and would surely add to the Socceroos squad.

Troisi has just been signed by Juventus, shouldn’t he be good enough for Australia?

Unless he has asked to miss these two matches, or Osieck wasn’t impressed with his recent Socceroo efforts, you would think so.

Luongo is 19, on the books at Spurs, and has just gone on loan to Ipswich.

He is playing there, and scoring, so it’s disappointing to not see him included in a wider squad. It would be a good experience for him.

Then there is the contentious issue of Aston Villa’s Chris Herd. He has been left out, after being called up previously three times and pulling out each time with injury.

It seems like Osieck’s patience is wearing thin.

Considering Scotland is hovering around to cap him, we need to sort this out, and fast.

This situation is becoming a farce and Australia can hardly have our 23-year-olds Premier League players representing other countries.

We just don’t have enough talent that we can afford to lose players of this calibre.

There is a lot in the 22-man squad for the Lebanon and Jordan matches for Socceroo fans to argue and debate over.

My XI for the Lebanon game (not the Jordan one) would be:

GK: Schwarzer
LB: Davidson, CB: Neill, CB: Spiranovic, RB: McGowan, LM: McKay, CM: Bresciano, CM: Sarota, RM: Holman, CF: Cahill, CF: Rukavystya

Give the kids a run at some stage in the match, and pick the team for the all-important Jordan game judged on this performance and what they have done in camp.

Holger is dammed if it does, dammed if it doesn’t at this point in time. Qualification for Brazil remains paramount.

But it will be a tough story to sell if the Socceroos remain the oldest playing squad in 2014, just like they were in South Africa 2010.

Follow Johnny on Twitter: johnnyddavidson

The Crowd Says:

2012-09-05T02:35:51+00:00

cliffclavin

Guest


whilst young players in the team is great - i would much prefer to qualify. We need to keep the faith that moving beyond first rounds in world cups is achievable, but also be realistic about where we are at. Whilst we have few players in top leagues at the moment - like in the past - we have much greater depth in the squad. It is not too long ago that after our top stars - admittedly in the epl serie a - we had second tier players coming from places like Romania - think Burns and Thwaite. Now we have players coming through Holland again (like early nineties) not to mention the Bundesliga. I see a better future down the track for the national team but 2014 and perhaps even 2018 are WCs where we are soldifying ourselves as competant - but not awesome - football countries.

Holland was in and out at Austria Wien last season under the previous coach Ivica Vastic. He's gone now and the new coach Peter Stoeger really seeems to have a lot of faith in him. I haven't seen him play first hand but I get in-depth match reports and 2 weeks ago he was man of the match. Not that often that the defensive mid gets a MOTM. I think he's doing really well and has rescued his career in Austria.

2012-08-31T05:38:45+00:00

eric1

Guest


A lot of discussion lately about NT selections.Everyone has a different opinion about who should be in/out of the squad.I think this is because we only have one or two decent, international standard players.The rest are mediocre at best of which we have plenty.This is evident by the big deal made of Chris Herd.

2012-08-30T13:32:23+00:00

Peter Wilson

Roar Guru


Nice article, mixed feelings too. Some puzzling decisions but hopefully they'll get through. But its going to be tough to get through from here if they lose a couple more..

2012-08-30T04:38:36+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


FFA announced yesterday they will take part in the East Asia Cup ... they have not done so before but the other teams Japan Korea China often use this cup as a way of looking at new players...

2012-08-30T03:31:05+00:00

Melange

Guest


David Carney cops a lot of flak and I will not argue that he should be our number 1 left back. But I will say till now there haven't been too many stand out alternatives, there have been alternatives but not necessarily standouts. People shouldn't be screaming for a Carney axing, he has done his best in a position he probably doesn't want to play. As it stands I think he has now dropped down the list in the LB pecking order and while he shouldn't be a 1st team starter, he is a very valuable aquad member. His lack of game time is a worry though. Overall I would have preferred different players in the squad but only minimal changes to the starting 11. Wholesale changes won't help the team and won't help the individuals who may not be as comfortable in the tactical structure and, in some cases, may have great potential but a lot of learning still to do at this level.

2012-08-30T02:00:38+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Troisi out Archie in .... Troisi currently playing , Archie in the off season... does make you look to the sky and shake your head... Holland is an interesting pick ... he could the DM we have been looking for since Viney .... I think the message to Herd is commit now or go.... is this the correct call me thinks ya ....

2012-08-30T01:24:16+00:00

whiskeymac

Guest


Definitely. He is getting game time in Serie A already. With Luongo and a few others there and thereabouts in first teams the team for the next few years will still have some good to solid players, if not great ones.

2012-08-30T01:14:08+00:00

Damiano

Guest


Troisi is on a co-ownership deal with Juve & Atalanta, with the registration rights with Atalanta, he should see some game time with them and continue to develop. I'd think he is good enough for inclusion now.

2012-08-29T22:29:18+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Not a good squad by Holger, he just doesn't seem to understand football, and how to pick the best squad.

Read more at The Roar