Good old Collingwood too much for West Coast

Andrew Sutherland Roar Guru

By Andrew Sutherland, Andrew Sutherland is a Roar Guru

 , , ,

6 Have your say

    The Magpies played the football they're capable of in an emotional win over West Coast. (AFL media/Slattery Images)

    Related coverage

    Whether it was the dreaded prospect of being only the second team in the history of the current finals system to be bundled out after two straight defeats, or the tragic loss of a former teammmate, the Collingwood of old returned last night.

    There was the wizardry of Scott Pendlebury and a perfect sprinkling of Dale Thomas magic, but for the most part it did what it had to do to stay alive and that was play ugly.

    The last thing Nathan Buckley wanted to hear on the eve of a game whose result could have ended his season and cast doubts upon his future, was news that his champion playmaker Pendlebury has coaching aspirations of his own.

    A meticulous note taker and dossier keeper, Pendlebury commented: “I always think in my head what I would do and see if Bucks thought the same things”.

    As I suspected he would, Buckley encouraged the game Malthouse devised for his midfield-laden team. Collingwood began to play the style that brought them a premiership during the last quarter of the Hawthorn game: applying fierce pressure and chipping the ball around the midfield.

    At times, they resembled the side that decimated Geelong in the 2010 Premliminary Final, swarming over and around the opposition. The pressure applied to the Eagles’ midfielders led to poor delivery into the forward line. Darling kicked two goals but Collingwood defenders Reid, Shaw, and Tarrant dominated their taller opponents.

    In a masterstroke Buckley started with Alan Didak who is a superb exponent of the short stab pass. He dominated when Collingwood were getting back into the contest after West Coast’s brilliant opening salvo when they booted four straight goals.

    The Pies were fearless in their movements, with defenders often entering the forward line. While O’Brien kicked a goal, Shaw and Tarrant were also seen delivering the ball deep into the foward zone. Cloke who didn’t need to kick a goal did some useful work up the ground.

    The contests were brutal and the execution of skills was often poor. Collingwood had more tackles, possessions and clearances (despite the ruck dominance of Naitanui) but were unable to convert this advantage into dominance on the scoreboard.

    The Eagles, who are used to doing more with less of the ball,  were equally ferocious and
    courageous but appeared to tire earlier than Collingwood. Danel Kerr and Jacob Brennan were forced to play on pain killing injections after sustaining injuries.

    West Coast didn’t deserve to win, but the six day turn around must have had some effect, as it clearly did on Fremantle on Friday night. It’s time that all finalists are granted the same period of time between matches.

    It was an emotional game for many reasons for the Pies, of course. Andrew Krakouer’s amazing survival during a difficult journey that has included prison, personal issues and a knee reconstruction was fiercely celebrated after he kicked his team’s first goal (disallowed after a video referral).

    The passing of John McCarthy clearly affected some of the players. Despite the exuberance following each goal – hard earned and rare- the mood in the changerooms was sombre.

    History was with the Pies last night.

    With the exception of West Coast five years ago, the qualifying final losers have always recovered  to win the following week. Unfortunately they usually don’t make it past the preliminary final.

    Next Friday we’ll find out if last night was their grand final.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (6)

    • September 16th 2012 @ 5:05pm
      Mango Jack said | September 16th 2012 @ 5:05pm | ! Report

      Poor Swans. Their reward for winning last week is to play a team on a ground where they haven’t won for 9 years or more. Maybe they should request to move it to Melbourne?

      • September 17th 2012 @ 9:50am
        amazonfan said | September 17th 2012 @ 9:50am | ! Report

        Never count Sydney out. If any team can overcome that record, it’s them.

    • September 16th 2012 @ 6:52pm
      JBodzter said | September 16th 2012 @ 6:52pm | ! Report

      Actually Andrew, ‘Straight sets’ losses in finals already happened to Port in 2001. Surprised everyone seems to have forgotten that.

    • September 17th 2012 @ 6:14am
      Ironmonger said | September 17th 2012 @ 6:14am | ! Report

      Going into the match the only area I felt Collingwood had an advantage was in the midfield…but what resulted was that this midfield dominance lead to the WC talls being nullified and the Collingwood forwards enjoying quicker, more precise delivery. The Collingwood small fowards were excellent overhead too. I felt WC were still in it and even had momentum on their side UNTIL Emberly came streaming out of the back fifty and completely muffed his kick straight to the Pies who kick a goal and from there any chance of resurgence was dead.
      I know Swans haven’t won against Pies at Homebush so maybe they are due…

    • September 17th 2012 @ 7:56am
      Andrew A said | September 17th 2012 @ 7:56am | ! Report

      With the unavailability of both ANZ Stadium and the SCG this Saturday night, perhaps the Sydney v Collingwood match should’ve been moved to the MCG. Whilst the Swans are entitled to a home preliminary final, surely an available ground on the date the match should be played should be a criteria. Now we have Collingwood travelling interstate on a 6 day break, Adelaide travelling on an 8 day break, and the top side Hawthorn having one less day preparation for the Grand Final than lower ranked opponents, should they win through.

    • September 18th 2012 @ 9:38am
      Wood said | September 18th 2012 @ 9:38am | ! Report

      I know sour grapes a bit but Embley kick T/O cost WC game. plus 3 goals given to Thomas as direct opponent in 3rd. I guarantee WC will win flag next year. Don’t fuck around go straight up guts to Lecras Kennedy and Darling and we will not be stopped. If WC $6.00 + put your house on it !!!!!

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , , ,