Weight for age ranks changing for better

By Travis Noonan / Roar Rookie

For years Australia turned out some freakishly gifted horses and we somewhat took them for granted.

We had the golden era of racing in the 90s, turning out champions like Super Impose, Better Loosen Up, Vo Rogue, Saintly, Octagonal, Let’s Elope, Might And Power, the list goes on.

Before those horses we had Kingston Town, Dulcify and Manikato.

Though the champions became household names, it was horses they beat that gave them the stature we hold them in today.

Remember how Saintly won the ’96 Cox Plate? It wasn’t the way he won the race it, was who ‘The horse from Heaven’ beat.

They were all great horses in their own right such as Filante, All Our Mob, Octagonal, Juggler, Anthems, Crying Game and Adventurous.

After Saintly won that race there was no doubting he would be remembered as a champion but you couldn’t say the same for weight for age horses in recent years.

Go back 18 months to the 2011 Cox Plate where Pinker Pinker won and beat Jimmy Choux, Rekindled Interest, Wall Street, Secret Admirer, Efiicient, Kings Rose, Helmet, Sincero, Glass Harmonium, Playing God, Shamrocker, Avienus and Lion Tamer.

The 2011 Cox Plate may well go down as one of the worst Cox Plates in the last 50 years, with only Glass Harmonium, Playing God and Sincero winning races since that day.

In the last couple of seasons, Australia has had no genuine weight for age stars, with the exception of So You Think, Black Caviar and Whobegotyou.

While our sprinters have still drawn good WFA races it’s the middle-distance WFA ranks that have been hit hard over the past couple of seasons.

A further example of this is to look at the horses who have topped the middle-distance WFA ranks over the past two years.

They are Shoot Out, a multiple Group 1 winner, Manighar, a European import who had raced in two Caulfield Cups before he won a Group 1, and More Joyous, who is the second best older horse in Australia to Black Caviar, though has failed in almost every Grand Slam she’s raced in.

All of the mentioned horse are great on their day but they all lack the killer punch that is required to become a champion.

Even though the lack of quality WFA horses has been prominent, I think it’ll change through the next batch of three year olds coming through, including Pierro, All Too Hard, It’s A Dundeel, Proisir, Rebel Dane, Dear Demi, Norzita, Fiveandahalfstar and Super Cool.

I think this will be the year where champions will emerge and 2013 will go down as one of the best for racing.

The Crowd Says:

2013-03-22T07:22:33+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Because of Lion Tamer? Because you backed Jimmy Choux? That's one of my favourite days in racing - a greyhound I part owned with my best mates won on debut by 5 lengths at Lithgow. A week later, on Derby Day 2011, she broke down. And then I was despondent....that's racing.

2013-03-22T07:19:37+00:00

Andrew Hawkins

Expert


Ah, that makes sense! Yeah, I'll never forget how despondent I was after the 2011 Cox Plate, just felt disappointed...

AUTHOR

2013-03-22T04:11:56+00:00

Travis Noonan

Roar Rookie


Peeko I think we shall see a great version of the Cox Plate this year and I dont think it'll be a full field maybe with only 11 in it.

AUTHOR

2013-03-22T04:10:49+00:00

Travis Noonan

Roar Rookie


It was a great ride by Craig Williams Alfred. Still a good day I might add just not a great race

AUTHOR

2013-03-22T03:54:20+00:00

Travis Noonan

Roar Rookie


Couldnt agree more Justin , The IFHA has hit the nail on the head that it wasnt very strong WFA wise plenty of Group 1 winners but no champions and a couple horses in it were already past their best.

2013-03-22T03:17:21+00:00

Alfred Chan

Expert


http://www.theroar.com.au/2011/10/22/cox-plate-preview-and-live-blog/ I had a bit on Pinker Pinker that day!

2013-03-22T03:13:47+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Should clarify - lowest rating of 150 races

2013-03-22T03:01:37+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Of all the winners of the world's top 50 ranked races in the last three years, Pinker Pinker has the lowest IFHA rating of 116 for her 2011 Cox Plate victory. That's an indication of both the weakness of Australia's great weight-for-age race that season and further reinforcement that our WFA ranks weren't overly strong that season.

2013-03-22T02:39:39+00:00

Peeeko

Guest


I agree the 2011 cox plate was very weak and 2012 was not much better, it looks like we may get a much better installment later this year

AUTHOR

2013-03-22T01:33:39+00:00

Travis Noonan

Roar Rookie


True Pinker Pinker could have been a star , Though Jimmy Choux was beaten convincingly in the Queen Elizabeth last year. Lion Tamer was a freakishly good horse , It was a real shame that he had depart when at his best could have been anything.

2013-03-22T01:17:19+00:00

Alfred Chan

Expert


Hey Travis, I pretty much agree with everything except for the 2011 Cox Plate being the weakest in 50 years. Of that field only King's Rose (2nd in the Toorak Handicap) and Avienus were not Group 1 winners. We also didn't get to see how great Pinker Pinker could have been due to her accident. Jimmy Choux was retired at 4yo and that race was the end of Lion Tamer who had been unbeatable in the lead up to the Cox Plate.

Read more at The Roar