A squad to win back the Ashes

By Brian Zhang / Roar Rookie

The Ashes is less than four months away and England are red hot favourites to retain the famous urn while Australia are rank outsiders.

There have also been talks of back-to-back Ashes humiliations for Australia in both away and home series.

And Australia’s latest Border-Gavaskar humiliation at the hands of India probably back this theory up.

But if most things go Australia’s way and if the selectors make smart choices, something they haven’t done for a while, then Australia may just have a sniff.

England haven’t had it all their way either. They have performed very ordinarily in their current series against New Zealand.

Personally I don’t think Australia will win the series in England but it may be closer than some suspect.

1. David Warner

He’s made a reasonable start to his Test career with 1263 runs at just under 40 including three centuries and seven half centuries.

Over the last year and a half, Warner has matured slowly but surely into a Test cricketer.

Innings like the 123* off 170 deliveries against New Zealand in Hobart late 2011 shows that he has the patience to build an innings in tough conditions.

However innings like the 180 off 159 balls against India last year in Perth shows that he can still be aggressive and dominate bowling attacks when he wants to.

His aggressive out-and-out attacking style could be very effective in nullifying the English attack.

But it is also a huge risk.

Many of Warner’s dismissals so far in his career have been because of careless wafts outside off stump with no footwork.

Warner had a fairly ordinary series in India but England is almost the opposite conditions.

He has been a part of the Australian side in all forms of the game for over four years now. He needs a big series this series to confirm himself as a genuine Test batsman.

2. Shane Watson

I have Watson in the side but he goes back to his successful position in opening.

Unlike Cowan, Watson scores runs at a much quicker rate and he and Warner can easily get Australia off to fast starts and quickly silence the English crowd.

Watson’s success in every form of the game has come as an opener. Ever since he has been demoted down the order he has averaged less than 25. He still continues to open to ODIs and T20s and still is scoring runs heavily.

But Watson’s position will come with one condition, he must play as an allrounder, whether he bowls 15 overs or 25 overs.

He has had success in England with the ball before and if he either chooses not to bowl or is not fit to bowl then he should not be considered. This could a big breakthrough series for Watson that could see him return to his 2009/10 form. But it could also be a series where his position goes on the line.

He is too talented to not be converting 50s into 100s and needs to start doing so and stand up.

3. Usman Khawaja

I have Khawaja over Hughes for the start of the series simply because he has a much more sounder, fluent and steadier technique than Hughes. Khawaja was extremely unlucky not to get a Test match against India and also not to get a Test against Sri Lanka earlier in the summer.

Despite his ordinary record in first-class cricket this season, he is the more fluent batsman and his technique means he can play swing bowling better. This is also a big series for Khawaja as he can easily establish his position in the Australian Test team.

4. Michael Clarke

The all important captain Clarke bats at no.4. I initially wanted to keep Clarke at five simply because all his success has come at number five. But because Australia’s top order is not strong at all, he bats one higher.

It is predictable that Clarke has yet another heavy series with runs but his captaincy on the field will also be a huge factor. If Clarke performs well in both aspects, Australia will have a chance.

5. Ed Cowan

Many of you will think this is an extremely bizarre move considering I don’t have Cowan opening.

But because the selectors will never drop him, I’ve kept him at no.5.

Cowan’s numbers in terms of runs may not back it up, but he has the ability to stay at the crease for long periods.

Because he doesn’t score at a reasonable rate, he is not suited opening but in the middle order. In case Australia lose three quick wickets, Cowan can come and steady it for Australia by getting through the new ball.

If he comes in when Australia are 3/250, then Cowan will have more freedom and less pressure on him to score runs. But if Cowan does not perform in the first two Tests, then he should be axed indefinitely.

6. Moises Henriques

Henriques plays as the batting allrounder at no. 6. His average was strong with the bat in the Shield season and had a extremely good debut match. Despite scores of 5, 0, 0 and 2 in his next four innings, I would still retain Henriques as the main or back-up allrounder to Watson.

7. Brad Haddin

Brad Haddin starts as the keeper for the start of the series as has he been in sensational batting form this season. His keeping form is good too.

Also his last Ashes series in England yielded 278 runs at 46 (4 Tests) which is more than acceptable for a keeper-batsman. His experience will be vital to the side considering Watson, Clarke, Hughes and himself are the only batsmen to have played in the ’09 series.

If he under performs then Wade comes right back in.

8. Mitchell Johnson

I have Johnson ahead of Starc because I don’t think rushing Starc into the side straight after surgery is the right thing to do for such a young talented player.

And also having Johnson isn’t a big loss as both players are very similar.

Johnson’s experience is also vital to Australia’s chances as he will know the conditions better now having already been a part of the ’09 series.

His batting form over this season has been solid but not great, but it may come in handy at times. I thought he was unlucky not to have played more Tests in the India series but this will be a big chance for Johnson.

9. Peter Siddle

For the last two years he has been Australia’s most consistent bowler. At 28 with 41 Tests, he is now one of the more experienced players in the Australian side. The last Ashes series in England, Siddle proved his qualities with 20 wickets including 5/21 in the fourth Test.

He had a mediocre series in India but the swinging and seaming conditions of England suits Siddle’s style of bowling.

10. James Pattinson

He was probably Australia’s best bowler in the India series despite his stats not showing it.

He gave it his absolute all on pitches that were never going to assist fast bowlers. The England conditions like Siddle will suit Pattinson nicely and if he gets his rhythm going, he can easily rattle the English batting line-up.

11. Nathan Lyon

His nine-wicket haul in the last Test against India proves that he is still the best off-spinner in Australia at the moment.

The conditions will not be the best for an off spinner especially for a touring side but given Graeme Swann has had success, Lyon will have an impact. If he bowls like he did in that first innings against India, and around the wicket more often, then he will take wickets.

Reserves

12. Mitchell Starc

Given he proves his fitness, Starc will replace either of the three starting fast bowlers if an injury or poor performance occurs.

His height and ability to swing the ball both ways makes his Australia’s Chris Tremlett.

Throughout the Australian summer, Starc was also able to bowl up to and around 145km/h. He will be another bowler that can threaten the English batting line-up.

13. Pat Cummins

He has faded away slightly since his Test debut against South Africa due to injuries. But he is certainly not forgotten. I wouldn’t rush Cummins straight into the side, given he has barely played a first-class game in the last 18 months but if he should be selected in the tour matches and certainly considered later in the series.

14. Stephen O’Keefe

He was very unlucky to not be selected in the India series but he should be given a chance at the baggy green this series. He is the leading wicket taker for all spinners in the Shield this season and he also is a very good back-up for Nathan Lyon.

Not only that but he is a very capable with the bat and can play as the spin-bowling all-rounder. At 28 he is no rookie and his experience as captain of the NSW team will come in handy.

15. Alex Doolan

I haven’t seen much of this guy bat but his stats this year are nothing to scoff at. Doolan has scored 715 runs at 42 this season including one century and four half-centuries. The conversion rate and the average may be a minor issue but he definitely deserves a chance this series given the amount of talent he possesses.

16. Phil Hughes

I wouldn’t write this guy off just yet. Hughes had a torrid time in India but England is a totally different story. Hughes has been tormented by the English bowlers in the five Tests he has played against them.

But Hughes has enormous talent within him. His record right now is almost identical to Ricky Ponting’s when he was the same age and not many 24 year olds have scored 21 first-class hundreds.

He will be seriously tested by the English bowlers but this time he will know what to expect and be much better prepared for it.

17. James Faulkner

Many of you will be extremely surprised by this selection of mine. But Faulkner this season has impressed domestically and internationally.

This season he has taken 38 wickets at just over 20, strike rate of 42, best of 5/23.

With those stats you can’t walk passed this guy without considering him. Faulkner also has the ability to swing the ball back into the right handers and bowls extremely well bowling at that angle.

He can also swing it away from the left-handers. He is inexperienced but could make a huge impact.

Well Roarers, I’d like to hear your comments and thoughts, if you agree or disagree with me.

The Crowd Says:

2013-04-09T11:25:21+00:00

John Edgar

Guest


+2, well said Bearfax

2013-04-09T00:42:59+00:00

Amith

Guest


Agree 100% Bearfax, kid is ready to fire

2013-04-02T22:37:52+00:00

Jeremy

Guest


Haddin is back. Play no one who has poor technique - the swing in UK will undo them. Force the T20 players to improve techniqwue to get into the Test team. Lift the standards and demand more. Watson must perform in UK or he is gone. Play Khawaja. find a spinner that can spin their stock ball and win a game Encourage immigration of top international talent

2013-03-31T22:32:13+00:00

johnverdal

Guest


jordan silk, ashton agar, joe burns, pat cummins, m.marsh, gurinder sandhu, chadd sayers, and sam whiteman will be pushing for selection in one years time.

2013-03-31T22:29:15+00:00

johnverdal

Guest


my ashes squad will be: 1.warner 2.hughes 3.khawaja 4.clarke 5.burns 6.watson 7.paine 8.agar 9.siddle 10.pattinson 11.harris 12.bird 13.starc 14.lyon 15.haddin 16.doolan 17.faulkner 18.cowan

2013-03-31T22:26:28+00:00

johnverdal

Guest


ryan harris, jackson bird, tim paine and joe burns deserve to be in ashes squad of mitchell johnson, henrqiques, cowan and cummins.

2013-03-31T22:04:20+00:00

Davo

Guest


Anyone watch the recent sports show where Tubby announced his team? Haddin was in there as well as Warner.Lawson not only supports Haddin but has him in a leadership role. The reason is, and if you ever played the game you would understand, it is about experience and ability. There needs to be this mix with youth and talent. I still think we could entice Warne back for one last gig - so what if we don't win, his will to succeed, competitiveness and freakish ability will rub off. I have put my team up for discussion before but I have had an individual comment that was a little out of line. Funny no one else but that one individual saw a need to make such comments. Perhaps the recent comments by Tubby, Lawson etc....have put some clear perspective on this. No more underarms thanks. Imagine a team with Clarke, Warner, Haddin, Warne, D Hussey, Pattinson, Cummins, Starc, and build the rest around that. I am not suggesting that Wade be left out as Haddin could fill a middle order batting role. Darren Lehmann coaching and Clarke removed from the selectors role. Richie was right in his comments about selectors, a captain is handed his team to represent their country and he had no right in interfering with that process. Having said all that Brian's views are really respected - very good article Brian! Toss up some more it was a good read.

2013-03-31T14:43:49+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Thanks Micky. But we already know how you feel about him. By the way hows Joburg

2013-03-31T09:07:19+00:00

Nick

Guest


Usman khawaja shouldn't even be in the top10 best batsmen in Australia Matthew wade is a better batsmen than him

2013-03-31T09:04:42+00:00

Nick

Guest


I think that the starting xi should be Warner Cowan Hughes Clarke Bailey Wade Starc Sidle Bird Lyon 12th man Steve smith

2013-03-30T18:06:21+00:00

Bertie

Guest


Bearfax I'm encouraged by the young batsmen; Nic Maddinson, Marcus Harris, Travis Head, Jordan Silk, Kurtis Patterson, Cam Bancroft, Will Bosisto and Sam Hain (in the unlikely even that Hain chooses to play for Australia instead of England). I've added a few names to those you put there. But Ian Chappell, whose talent spotting of technically strong young batsmen I admire immensely, thinks Australia still has massive problems with the technique of young batsmen and he wasn't at all encouraged by the U19 World Cup in 2012. So I'm still rather concerned about all this.

2013-03-29T10:18:45+00:00

Davo

Guest


Dear Red Kev, Bowl another underarm Kevvy. You are a master of cheap shots. Brian's team is thoughtful and reflects the talent we have on display at the moment. If we all don't agree with your 'dream side' then it is probably because our views differ from yours, not our knowledge of cricket. I think you need to pull your head in Kevvy.

2013-03-28T13:05:08+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Not seriously suggesting Sandhu should go on tour for the Ashes, but get a load of the fact that after two Shield matches and four one dayers, he was declared the Steve Waugh NSW Cricketer of the Year. He also won the NSW Ryobi Cup Player of the Year Award. He apparently pipped Haddin for the big one. Very early days but this younger generation of Sandu, Agar, Ahmed, Silk, Maddison and with Zampa and Bosisto to come, coming through the ranks and already showing up the best we have, I think Australia may have a very strong national side in a couple of years if they continue to develop as well as they are now aged 19-21 (I think Ahmed's older). They definitely need a serious guiding hand and it seems we need some people and structures of quality established quickly to ensure these kids get the appropriate training they need. No 1. Get Lehmann in as coach. I'm looking forward to next years Sheffield Shield comp because I think the standard is about to improve markedly and a number of young new stars are going to strut their stuff and entertain us all big time..

2013-03-28T12:34:03+00:00

Nick Richardson

Roar Guru


Odi's talk about ways to get him injured.

2013-03-28T12:26:47+00:00

Nick Richardson

Roar Guru


Brian you lost all credibility by putting Watson opening, but then it got worse Cowan 5 Henriques 6 Haddin 7. Mate your fried. Johnson over Harris and Bird. There would be half a dozen more capable bowlers than Johnson. Not to add the fact he will get abused in England.

2013-03-28T05:48:10+00:00

iambunney

Guest


I hereby whip myself for a great oversight - Ryan Harris. He dragged Qld back into the Shield final with 4 wickets in 5 overs on a dead pitch - Let's hope he stays fit. I stand by my selection of Watson as third seamer, so Harris will have to fight it out with Siddle, Pattinson and Bird. Tough call. If only 6 bowlers and 4 batsman was a good balanced team - we might just be alright! :)

2013-03-28T04:33:19+00:00

Lachlan

Guest


Interesting selections...I'm not sure about opening with Warner and Watson though. While Ed Cowan hasn't been spectacular, he complements Warner nicely with his solid-grind-out-the-runs method. Watson seems to have ruled out doing any bowling, so he doesn't get a run in my starting eleven as his batting hasn't been up to scratch (the excuse of not batting in his favoured position anymore doesn't cut it for me). I wouldn't have Moises Henriques batting in the top 6, although there aren't many batsmen putting their hands up. Brad Haddin wins over Matthew Wade, who in my opinion should be 3rd in line behind Haddin and Harley. In fact I'd be tempted to pick Hartley, although Haddin is a good choice given his experience. Funny that you mention Faulkner being a surprising pick, in my opinion he should be really pushing for a run in the side. Great bowler who scroe runs when needed, even under big pressure in the Shield final. Very thought provoking article, my two cents.

2013-03-28T04:10:11+00:00

iambunney

Guest


Well said Red Kev - what I don't understand about the plethora of "this is what the Aus team should look like" articles, is that the authors all use drastic language in describing the problem, and then shuffle the deck chairs when presenting their "solution". I think that, at the very least, in the short term the following players should be waved bye-bye - Henriques, Smith (despite his decent showing in last two tests), Wade (a keeper who can't catch is untenable) Hughes, Cowan, Maxwell, & Doherty. The Sheffield Shield this season has produced very few standout batsmen, but good bowling figures, so the cupboard is essentially bare on that front. So what to do? Blood some really young players who have potential. Here's some suggestions. 1. Warner - he has the skills, but perhaps not the temperament. Should be instructed he's going to be dropped if he knicks having windy woofs! 2. Chris Rogers - If you're looking for experience, and a quality avg over a long period - the unlucky Rogers should have a change of fortune. 3rd highest Shield scorer this season at avg of 49. If Ricky & Hussey weren't too old, neither is Rogers 3. Khawaja - Hughes has had his third chance, and failed to impress. Time to give Khawaja another crack. Neither have banged down the door with sheer weight of runs, but few options 4. Clarke - nuff said 5. & 6.Joe Burns / Nic Maddinson / Alex Doolan - Burns and Maddinson look the best of the new bunch, even though their numbers may not look that way and should be thrown in so they will get the experience. Is a long road ahead. I include the not so young Doolan as a back-up - the best two of the three in tour games should get initial nod. 7. Hartley - best catcher in the country. Not an awful batsman either. Tim Paine to tour as back-up 8. Watson - that's right Watson. His batting has stunk for too long, but his bowling is still excellent, esp in swinging conditions such as England. Pick him as 3rd seamer and then he's in no doubt. You don't bowl, you're not picked. 9. Siddle - under pressure from Bird for mine, but he gets 1st crack. 10. Pattinson - our best and brightest young fast prospect 11. Lyon - proved he was number one after returning from dud dropping in 2nd test. O'Keefe to tour as back up To the NSP - I offer comparitively cheap rates for my consultancy!

2013-03-28T02:52:47+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


I still think if CA conducted a web survey and got fans to submit a 17 man squad then simply took the 17 players with the most votes we'd end up with a better squad than the NSP would select.

2013-03-28T02:47:59+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Hmmm. Close Red, close. I wouldnt drop Wade but bringing Paine in seems sensible. I like your Rogers, Burns thoughts. I'd have Harris in the mix I think. But overall I'm comfortable with your selections Mr Red Inverarity.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar