Melbourne Heart post-season A-League review

Patrick Hargreaves Roar Guru

By Patrick Hargreaves, Patrick Hargreaves is a Roar Guru

 , ,

5 Have your say

    Related coverage

    Melbourne Heart is the most unobtrusive sporting team Australia has seen since professionalism.

    This season has been poor. And now with hindsight I can whine and complain as if I’d have run the team better.

    From the outset, we were struggling to make the top six. And when you’re playing teams called Perth ‘Glory’ or Melbourne ‘Victory’, a top six finish should be a prerequisite.

    Our squad was inadequate compared to the at least eight other teams. Fred and Colosimo were too old to be ‘marquee’ or ‘starting’ players.

    The 24-27 year old bracket was lacking in talent and numbers. But of these players, David Williams, Josip Tadic and Andrew Redmayne were our best.

    They have experience and talent, and if you look at the Mariners, the Wanderers or the Victory, they had a similar amount of quality within this age bracket.

    Macallister was not a bad selection. His first derby goal justified his contract for me, but compared to the rest of the competition he just didn’t do enough to compete with the top four.

    He scored just as many goals as Kresinger, yet he didn’t have Ono or Mooy around him. He only scored one goal. Thanks, but goodbye.

    Fred is poor. His technique is good, but the A-League has moved on.

    Matt Thompson didn’t have a good season either, and while it’s sad to see a foundation player go, he wasn’t performing well enough either.

    The clean-out along will bring in a more positive and younger team.

    Meeuwis should be the yardstick for all international investments – mediocre European players do not guarantee good A-League footballers.

    From a coaching perspective I think our season showed a few things.

    When we look at the grand final teams, they have both been applauded as the most organised teams in the competition, and rightly so.

    But how were the heart not better organised?

    Tactically we were exposed too much and we were just too short sighted at times.

    It seemed if the team weren’t firing we just accepted the loss and moved on. So for next year, the Heart need another experienced assistant coach.

    Aloisi is safe, but needs help. If we can combine the pass and move Dutch inspired football with more structure and nous, we can win this league.

    As for next season, besides an assistant coach who else to we need?

    As well as a new assistant coach, we need a new CB, creative marquee player, CM with experience and technique to rival McGlinchey, Mooy and Milligan.

    Assistant coach

    A coach from the VPL – Chris Taylor anyone?

    Craig Foster has watched enough UCL and EPL to have an A-level coaching license. Jokes aside, he would be a wonderful addition to the club, and emphasises the football philosophy that Heart employ.

    However, he might be expensive.


    Ok, so we have a bit of money after clearing Colosimo, Bolton, Thompson and Fred.

    Let’s get a quality centre-back who can rival anyone in the A-League. Shane Cansdell-Sherriff has kicked around in the third and fourth divisions of England for long enough to break someone and start a play and therefore would be perfect for the A-League.

    He is solid, is a leader and is better than Colosimo. He would be good for a year or two more.

    He would be an interesting choice and would provide the experience and ability that we’ve lacked.

    Matt Jurman has been released from Brisbane. He wasn’t the best and was released for a reason but you never know, he’d be cheap.

    He’s only 23 and had to defend a league title – it wasn’t the easiest job.

    Otherwise perhaps Alosi could scout a better player from Europe? Suggestions anyone?

    Centre midfield

    Now that our centre-back has been discovered, we need to invest in an awesome footballer. A footballer that will make people watch our games and realise that there is another team in Melbourne.

    Frank Lampard? David Beckham?

    Really, if the FFA throw in 400-600K like they did with Kewell, Ono and Del Piero, we can get anyone. We just need to be bold, and not go for someone completely past it.

    We need very good technical centre-midfield who can boss the midfield. I like Luke Brattan, or someone from Europe, but please not a second division Dutch/Argentinean/Brazilian who is here for the money.

    Moving Garcia into this position could work as he is easily our best player.

    The Heart are three or four signings away from winning the league.

    When we’re on form we can thump teams, and as our young players become more experienced this will become more frequent.

    Possible starting 15 for Round 1:

    GK Redmayne

    LB Mitchinson CB Vrankovic,Jurman/OS player RB Walker

    CM Garcia, Mauk
    AM- Lampard/Becks.

    RW Dugandžić

    CF Mehbratu

    LW Williams

    Subs- Ramsay, Babalj, Garrucio, Germano.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (5)

    • April 24th 2013 @ 3:02pm
      Matthew Skellett said | April 24th 2013 @ 3:02pm | ! Report

      Mehbratu was impressive against the Wanderers I was hoping WSW would sign him up for next year 🙂

    • April 24th 2013 @ 4:24pm
      elgee4 said | April 24th 2013 @ 4:24pm | ! Report

      Just get a new coach. That’s the problem looking for all these excuses last season and missing the main problem.!! If you have a professional coach they will work it all out. Send Aaloisi around the world a million times it wont make any difference he is a player who doesn’t know how to lead.

    • Roar Guru

      April 25th 2013 @ 8:36am
      Patrick Hargreaves said | April 25th 2013 @ 8:36am | ! Report

      I think the HAL has com far enough to give a new coach 2 years/at least until January. The first derby he outclassed AP, don’t forget that. Heart’s season looks really poor compared WSW and people are calling for a move to Geelong or mergers etc and sack the coach, but the league is steady enough to have a bad year.

    • April 26th 2013 @ 1:00am
      kylesy sky blues fan said | April 26th 2013 @ 1:00am | ! Report

      Heart have a great stadium, a good strip, a solid foundation of support, 3 big games a year to get support, and a handful of top players and young talent. If the board and JA can’t build from there over a big off-season and be pulling 9k+ and in top 4 come December, there needs to be some serious attention given to the board and coaching staff. I like Heart, and really want you guys to succeed!

    • Roar Guru

      April 27th 2013 @ 2:42pm
      Patrick Hargreaves said | April 27th 2013 @ 2:42pm | ! Report

      According to the Courier Mail we’ve signed Murdocca/or about to. Which is awesome, a good pass more technique over physical abruptness.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , ,