Would an Anzac Day fixture work for football?

By Mike Tuckerman / Expert

The Last Post sounded up and down the country yesterday as Australians remembered those soldiers who never returned from battle. The question is, should it have sounded at a football game?

Tuning into Channel Nine’s somewhat bombastic coverage of St George Illawarra’s battle with the resurgent Sydney Roosters, you could have been forgiven for thinking that Anzac Day was the most significant holiday on the Australian calendar.

A packed house at Allianz Stadium, a solemn military commemoration before the game and Gus Gould waxing lyrical on TV about the importance of the occasion suggests that for many it may well be – though that hasn’t always been the case.

By focusing some of their attention on the Roosters’ imposing Kiwi enforcer Jared Waerea-Hargreaves, the Nine network at least acknowledged the role played by New Zealand during that doomed campaign at Gallipoli.

Their presence is sometimes forgotten by those looking to turn Anzac Day into an increasingly one-sided day of Australian remembrance.

That’s not all that surprising given that the nationwide commemoration of the day is only a relatively recent phenomenon, as younger generations eager to cloak themselves in nationalistic rites of remembrance fuel the imaginations of a dwindling band of veterans prone to nostalgia.

Prior to the late 1980s or so, no one outside the Returned Services League much cared for Anzac Day, and as the grandson of a veteran myself, I can attest there wasn’t much enthusiasm for the glorification of war where I grew up.

That’s not necessarily to say there is today – though the gap between remembrance and the air-brushing of history is undoubtedly a complex and uneasy one.

For all the pomp and ceremony of yesterday’s showdown between the Dragons and Roosters, it’s easy to forget that this ‘annual’ clash has only been played since 2002 and by my count has only been televised by Channel Nine on three separate occasions.

Perhaps that’s why they played a bit loose with their history during the broadcast, as champion halfback turned laconic sideline commentator Andrew Johns almost choked on his words in his attempt to describe the larger-than-usual attendance.

Describing what was close to a ground record attendance, it seemed obvious that ‘Joey’ knew that the largest crowd to ever turn out at the venue was for the Socceroos’ legendary World Cup qualifier against Argentina in 1993 – but the former Newcastle Knights playmaker stopped just short of admitting it.

It seems old habits die hard in the land of rugby league, but the question at hand is whether football should jump on the Anzac Day bandwagon and play a fixture of its own?

There was at one stage furtive talk of an annual clash against Turkey, though that seemed more a political pipe dream than the type of fixture that could actually be coordinated on a regular basis.

Perhaps it would be easier to just schedule a match against New Zealand, though that would hardly seem to reflect the spirit of the day.

Or maybe football – global game that it is – simply doesn’t need to reflect on a senseless battle fought on behalf of an Empire so derelict in its duties, it sent thousands of its loyal subjects off to a gory death for want of some decent maps and a compass.

Dr Ian Syson, a senior lecturer at Victoria University, has written extensively on the nexus between football and Anzac Day and his painstaking research makes for an illuminating read.

On a personal level, I don’t feel that there’s any particular need for football to instigate some sort of annual ANZAC clash, be it in the club or international arena.

Is that the common consensus, though? Would an Anzac Day football fixture make sense, or is it something the round-ball game can do without?

The Crowd Says:

2013-04-30T05:00:50+00:00

Australian Rules

Guest


Where the hell did I say that?

2013-04-29T22:59:12+00:00

Sky Blue

Guest


So that means that no other sports contributed to the war effort and don't continue to do so today?

2013-04-29T04:32:51+00:00

micka

Guest


I don't get it.... Do you actually know what happened around the Gallipoli campaign?

2013-04-29T02:43:27+00:00

micka

Guest


Gee, what a larf Bob. At least we know the netballers won't dive. I don't think there would be anything wrong with a friendly on ANZAC day. I don't really understand what makes sport/recreation and rememberance mutually exclusive. Some of the most touching memorial/dedications I have ever seen have been at sporting events.

2013-04-29T00:19:48+00:00

Planet Football

Guest


Australians seem to think that we are the only country obsessed by sport. In my opinion, and from my experiences, this is not the case. Disrespectful? Why? I am happy to post two or three myths regarding, for example, Gallipoli and Anzacs, if you so desire.

2013-04-28T02:21:40+00:00

Australian Rules

Guest


Very true. When Mark Twain visited Victoria he wrote about the enormity of the Melbourne Cup and was staggered by the public fervour for a horse race.

2013-04-28T02:10:57+00:00

Matthew Skellett

Guest


How about a tri -nation round-robin for anzac day-week ? aus-nz-turkey ?

2013-04-27T15:18:53+00:00

Stevo

Guest


Jon Stevens needs to do some research on WW1

2013-04-27T11:13:35+00:00

clipper

Guest


AR - does this also include the St Kilda / Swans game? Is this also the case with the NRL? Is it just for the Victorian RSL or nation wide - there's a lot of RSLs closing, so any large donation would be welcomed.

2013-04-27T10:17:15+00:00

nordster

Guest


Well said! Statism/nationalism has a lot to answer for. Mindless patriotism via anzac day just makes it easier for dopey politicians to send the next batch of young people off to war. Although now they do have drones i guess...neater at our end of things, not so great if u live under their payloads...

2013-04-27T08:58:41+00:00

AL

Guest


Simon, it may be Andrew Johns who is the unintelligent one.

2013-04-27T05:25:55+00:00

Simon

Guest


Comparing record crowds is stupid, when a game sells out it sells out, you make yourself look unintelligent with that "Andrew Johns almost choked" crap. That kind of bias does not make for good journalism.

2013-04-27T05:17:07+00:00

Backheeler

Guest


I like the idea of a combined Aus and NZ team if FIFA allowed it

2013-04-27T04:29:13+00:00

Avon River

Guest


11 of the 11th is Rememberence day. Anzac day is a different beast. Is it a day for no more the sombre requim? Or what? The survivors of Gallipoli are long gone now as too the Anzac combined forces of WWI. Perhaps Anzac day is about remembering that sending the lads off to someone elses war is shere folly? To me the day can be twisted many ways. And I recall matches on Anzac day 30 years ago when yobbos would call out during the minutes silence.....not any more. Instead of belittling others - how about appreciate that across the AFLs Anzac round that ~330,000 Australians will stand in silence across all states with whatever 'take'...jingoistic or otherwise....showing more respect for the day than 30 odd years ago when it used to attract protestors to the marches.

2013-04-27T04:19:13+00:00

jack@hotmail.com

Guest


It would be perfect for an Soccerroos Vs New Zealand match for domestic players at end of HAL season. Could even apply to FIFA to make it a FIFA recoginized match (Class A match) and it would become a good oppourtunity for both teams to lock young players in who are about to go to Europe.

2013-04-27T04:14:29+00:00

Rookoz

Guest


David Gallop mentioned something about an FFA Cup Final on Australia Day...

2013-04-27T04:13:28+00:00

Avon River

Guest


They appreciate soccer too I've heard.

2013-04-27T04:11:39+00:00

Avon River

Guest


As with AR look at how Adam Scott's win at the US Masters was regarded....just another national sporting mountain scaled and conquered. There are tangible reasons why Australia developed a culture of esp community based sports almost unrivalled around the world and even by the 1870-80s neutral observors had commented on such.

2013-04-27T03:56:18+00:00

Titus

Guest


Nations sharing things in common is a good thing. Hopefully World Cups can replace World Wars.

2013-04-27T03:30:11+00:00

nufcmvfc

Guest


Only type of football I think might work on ANZAC day is an FFA Cup I'm not really too strung up about the concept though

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar