STEVE TURNER: 'Mr Reliable' McManus a great pick for battling Blues

By Steve Turner / Expert

The NSW selectors have gone the right way in picking Newcastle winger James McManus for the State of Origin decider on July 17.

McManus rarely gets the wraps he deserves for his work at the end of the Knights’ backline but it’s fantastic that his ultra-consistent form over the past two seasons has been recognised.

He is a brilliant finisher with 16 tries already in the NRL this year, he’s safe in the air defensively, and you have to hunt far and wide to find someone as deadly as this guy. Few, if any, wingers have got the better of him in one-on-one confrontations in 2013.

The Blues will miss the spontaneity that Jarryd Hayne would have brought, but they’ll certainly enjoy having James on board. He is a very tough customer and a ferocious competitor.

Stats show he has made 50 tackle busts this year for the Knights and many of those have been making the hard metres usually expected of the forwards.

I warmly applaud his selection. Newcastle’s ‘Mr Reliable’ certainly won’t let anyone down.

Having said that, I feel for Nathan Merritt who was given his chance in Origin 2 but had one of those games when he probably wished he had stayed in bed.

There was lots of action out on his wing, and for a number of reasons he was found wanting.

When I played for NSW, I was also faced with the proposition of stopping a runaway Greg Inglis. I couldn’t, and I’m still feeling the bruises to this day!

At least Nathan has a blue jumper, that he has so richly deserved with his performances over the years. No one can take that away from him, and the way things are shaping up, he might even collect a premiership ring at the end of the season.

The Blues team contains no real surprises, and that’s the way it should be going into the decider locked at one-all.

I notice that Mitchell Pearce says this will be a do-or-die game for him, and I have to agree.

He has had many chances to pilot NSW to a series win and this shapes as his best one in front of a sell-out crowd on home soil.

The decider will ultimately come down to how the halves perform for both teams.

Pearce and Maloney versus Cronk and Thurston. It’s very much a case of challengers versus the champs.

I’m tipping that the forwards battle will finish even and that it will all come down to the creativity and combination of the halves.

The Queensland duo has been there and done it on so many occasions, but I have faith in our men who have been doing plenty of great things in the NRL for the Roosters.

They will need to go even better than that, and I reckon they can.

The Crowd Says:

2013-07-16T03:24:36+00:00

Nico

Guest


Go Jimmy! Go NSW!!

2013-07-16T03:23:26+00:00

Nico

Guest


Concur!!

2013-07-16T03:20:24+00:00

Nico

Guest


Please people...get over it!

2013-07-10T12:48:43+00:00

Knight Vision

Guest


I would be interested to see how many errors Tafua has made vs McMannus, J Mac has been there done that Tafua has not and to put him in his first SOO in a decider would be foolish.

2013-07-10T01:54:44+00:00

Jayden

Guest


Should we call Queensland QueeNsouthwales?

2013-07-09T19:09:48+00:00

NSWelshman

Guest


One of those few wingers that is more 'deadly' & that has got the better of him is Jorge Tafua. Perhaps not as many trys but Tafua has better statistics to his name........McMannus in brackets. Trys 12 (16) Line Breaks 23 (17) Avg Mtrs 143 (111) Hit Ups 192 (193) I think your Newcastle bias is shining thru mate. He is good winger yes, he is rugged yes, he deserves a NSW jersey yes...........but to say he is the best option NO!

2013-07-09T08:56:56+00:00

Knight Vision

Guest


did you even watch the first SOO McManus played in ? Blew it ? how ? He was injured and missed the next 2 games that year. If you choose to have an opinion please make it an informed one

2013-07-09T07:48:25+00:00

Raugeee

Guest


So should we call the Blues the New South Scotsmen?

2013-07-09T05:26:47+00:00

DubbleBubble

Guest


If anything it was Merrit who blew his chance.

2013-07-08T23:12:37+00:00

Monners

Guest


Minni was ineligible because he already made his delegation to play for Italy. He did this prematurely, I expect because Italy has a friendly against England prior to the WC. As a Knights fan I am very pleased that James has been picked. He knows how to find the line and is great under the high ball both in attack and defense. He makes great reads in defense and is a true competitor. Merritt was under instructions to jam in but I also think he got a bit star struck in defense with Inglis being so close while he was on debut. McManus though is a true competitor and will relish the chance to mark his teammate Boyd.

2013-07-08T22:56:34+00:00

Steve

Guest


Couldn't agree more. And David, had his chance and blew it? He played game one in 2009 and had a season ending injury the following week.

2013-07-08T22:05:37+00:00

Alvin Purple

Guest


I am surprised he is eligible given Scotland are in this year RLWC. Minni cant play for NSW as he elected to play for Italy.

2013-07-08T17:25:43+00:00

David

Guest


Stevie Turner loved as a player but James McManus the right choice please, had his chance and blew it there are better chocies such as Nathan Merrit and Jorge Taufua just to name a couple.

Read more at The Roar