Why it has been a positive few months for Wests Tigers

By A View From the Top / Roar Pro

On the surface sitting in 15th position, your marquee player asking for a release and 1/3 of your financial backers withdrawing from the club doesn’t appear all that positive for the Wests Tigers football club.

But far from the disaster it appears, A View From the Top believes that Tigers fans will eventually look back on 2013 fondly in much the same way South Sydney fans have come to view the 2006 season in which they only won three games.

It’s no secret that A View From the Top has had the Concord Tigers club in its sight over the past 12-18 months.

But far from being personal the barbs have been well directed and warranted as the club has lurched from one disaster to the next after starting last season as heavy premiership favourites.

The club’s recruitment policy led largely by previous coach Tim Sheens has been nothing short of diabolical failing to address the three weaknesses of an otherwise very strong roster; the front row, halfback and fullback.

While there are no signs that the clubs recruitment is getting any better, Braith Anasta anyone, the club has had some entirely positive news fortuitously forced upon them by a footballer with delusions of grandeur.

Benji Marshall announcing he is leaving the Wests Tigers and rugby league to chase his All Blacks dream would be like me up and moving to Canada to propose to Kristin Kreuk.

In fact I’m backing my smouldering good looks and charm to woo before Smallville’s Lana Lang before Benji makes even a preliminary All Blacks squad.

It has been said that Benji makes Quade Cooper look like Trevor Gilmeister which is perhaps a little harsh.

Nonetheless it is not his defence that will be an issue in changing sports but his once fabled attacking arsenal which has been reduced by an injury prone body, diminishing reflexes and the absence of a willingness to commit the defensive line and take a hit while ball playing.

Can you imagine how bad he is going to be with the defence in his face all day? I feel sorry for whoever the inside centre is that will be forced to run outside him.

For the money that Wests reportedly offered Benji over the next two seasons, the simple fact is he isn’t even close to being worth it with Wests roster.

Much like Chris Sandow at Parramatta, offering such ludicrous money to a front foot half without the forward pack to lay an adequate platform is just plain stupid.

On the other hand the new reality for Wests Tigers will be easing some of the games most talented halves into first grade over the next few seasons.

Luke Brooks and Mitchell Moses will be Wests next long term halves partners and Benji’s release has already paid dividends in the shape of long term extensions for the two 19 year olds.

Brooks is perhaps ready for an introduction to NRL football against the Eels this weekend while Moses with a rangier frame and some injuries this season will probably be in a similar spot around this time next season.

Next season I see Brooks starting and finishing the season at halfback with Braith Anasta his scrumbase partner and Curtis Sironen moving into the backrow spending time on the edge and ball playing around the ruck.

Mitchell Moses will eventually force his way onto the interchange bench and spend the first 12-18 months of his career floating from position to position filling gaps in the outside backs before eventually settling as a fullback or five eighth once Anasta is finished at the club.

While I don’t have a huge opinion of Anasta in 2013 he is a player capable of taking the pressure off Brooks and playing a simple percentage style of football while Brooks settles.

Continuing to play Sironen in the halves alongside Brooks would leave Wests short in direction, composure and consistency which are qualities that the experienced Anasta should at least be able to provide to compliment Farah and Brooks.

Throwing Brooks and Moses to the wolves early on would be equally as counter-productive.

To continue with a Sironen/Anasta halves combination would be a continuation of the Tim Sheens pursuit of an all backrow NRL side that has proved so damaging for the club in recent times.

If their fans allow themselves to look forward to 2015 the Tigers could put a side on the field that includes Tedesco, Moses, Brooks and Farah in the key spine positions.

With the Toyota Cup winning side of 2012 still coming through the ranks and solid first graders such as Curtis Sironen, Aaron Woods, Keith Galloway, Liam Fulton and Chris Lawrence alongside 2013’s breakout players Tim Simona, Marika Koriobete and David Nofoaluma it is not quite as bad for Tigers fans as it is their fellow cellar dwellers the Eels.

Politically the withdrawal of financial backing from Wests Campbelltown Leagues Club in the three way merger is a positive for Wests Tigers if not rugby league in the Macarthur region.

While it is incomprehensible that Wests continue to base themselves in Concord instead of Campbelltown that is a debate for another day.

The funding hole created by Campbelltown’s withdrawal will be covered by the uber-rich Wests Ashfield club who will also seize Campbelltown’s relinquished seat on the board.

Campbelltown have bizarrely voted in line with the Balmain bloc on the joint venture board and it is hoped this structural change at board level will bring parity and an improved sense of togetherness from the two foundation clubs.

While there’s nothing great about being second last and getting lapped most weeks, Wests Tigers fans can take heart from the off field circumstances which have them in a good position for an improved 2014 if not 2015 and beyond.

Much like Russell Crowe and Peter Holmes a Court at South Sydney in 2006, the recent off field changes at the TigPies give reason for their fans to be optimistic of brighter times ahead.

All that’s left now is to get their recruitment right and go out and sign their own ‘2006 Roy Asotasi’ to lead the march up the table.

The Crowd Says:

2013-08-07T10:50:34+00:00

Chris

Guest


We live in hope but if Anasta is to be 5/8 there is no hope. I agree 2 young halves together is big ask and Moses clearly not ready, but we have to find another solution then Anasta.

2013-08-07T05:17:43+00:00

Dogs Of War

Roar Guru


I think the problem was that the Tigers really didn't have any forward leaders for Fifta to model his game off. Thus the lazy attitude with which he played. Moving to the Sharks with lots of competition for time really helped him focus on his game, plus seeing how the rest of the forwards work meant he had to raise his game to another level. I think the Tigers would be best served trying to get some old forwards in who have a good work ethic to teach all those promising youngsters they have coming through how hard they need to train etc.

AUTHOR

2013-08-07T05:06:45+00:00

A View From the Top

Roar Pro


I will admit that I never had a huge opinion of Fifita at NRL level. Saw him as a big bodied bully at NYC level and didn't see it translating to first grade. I and they were pretty wrong there weren't we? Matt Groat on the other hand has never looked up to it and I still think never will be. If you could have your time over eh...

AUTHOR

2013-08-07T05:02:50+00:00

A View From the Top

Roar Pro


Are you thinking of his Toyota Cup halves partner Harry Seijka? Blake's future is in the backrow much like Curtis Sironen so not sure Wests needed to go that way with their young squad. There's a reason Penrith don't want him anymore although as you say with the expected outlay and his age there is a definite upside

2013-08-07T04:47:10+00:00

Rich

Guest


Agreed. Good chance Brooks would have played this weekend had Luani not been picked for Injured Farah

2013-08-07T04:47:06+00:00

maximillian

Guest


Shocking! I'm just glad CEO Dave Smith understands the need to review the salary cap because it's horrible that a local junior is denied the opportunity to play 1st grade due to some archaic 2nd tier salary cap laws. I remember Matt Moylan having similar issues at the Panthers so the sooner this is fixed the better.

2013-08-07T04:32:35+00:00

eagleJack

Guest


max - due to injuries the Tigers exhausted their 2nd tier salary cap months ago. They wanted to blood Brooks but the NRL blocked the move

2013-08-07T04:21:11+00:00

maximillian

Guest


Why not bring Brooks in off the bench for the remaining games & give him 20 odd minutes? I thought the Raiders did a good job by introducing Milford to 1st grade in this way. He will be better for the experience next year & they've got nothing left to play for so start preparing for 2014.

2013-08-07T03:43:00+00:00

Mark Young

Roar Guru


Nice stuff AVFTT As much as I would love Brooks and moses to waltz in and start carving up, I do hope they get some space, and not crushing expectations. Interesting how the Clubs longstanding testy relationship with Newslimited has continuously backfired. Benji could drive all night to attend a fundraiser for a dieing child, and 'Buzz' would complain about how much petrol he wasted.

2013-08-07T03:10:52+00:00

Will Sinclair

Guest


I think Austin is an interesting signing... Only two years ago the Panthers made him the highest paid rookie in NRL history, and he has since been plagued with injury. Still only 22yo, and you'd imagine he's not on a lot of cash. Plenty of upside there, potentially?

2013-08-07T03:09:06+00:00

Will Sinclair

Guest


I remember Stephen Humphries talking about losing Fifita back when it happened. At the time the Club could only afford to keep two of Fifita, Woods and Groat, and it was felt that Fifita's discipline issues were holding him back. I bet the Club wishes it had THAT decision again! (Although, the benefit of hindsight is wonderful...)

AUTHOR

2013-08-07T01:23:51+00:00

A View From the Top

Roar Pro


Blake Austin - another backrower trying to play in the halves and Cory Patterson are quite underwhelming signings though

AUTHOR

2013-08-07T01:19:01+00:00

A View From the Top

Roar Pro


Should never have been signed in the first place but he is there now. Can play a composed hand alongside Brooks and with Farah there too will be able to play to his (limited) strengths - his running game.

AUTHOR

2013-08-07T01:17:17+00:00

A View From the Top

Roar Pro


Thanks Will. Imagine if you could add Fifita and a hard nosed Gibbs to that rotation right now, I'm guessing you wouldn't be 15th. Big wraps on recently re-signed young prop Nathan Brown as well and a shame the club has lost former Australian schoolboy lock and captain Brendan Santi

AUTHOR

2013-08-07T01:14:10+00:00

A View From the Top

Roar Pro


Playing like every other footy side in history with nothing to play for. Avoiding the tough stuff - dont want to split a lip and not be able to drink that night.

AUTHOR

2013-08-07T01:11:43+00:00

A View From the Top

Roar Pro


Foran and DCE are definitely the exception to the rule. Two signings to be announced today will really show where the club is heading. As you say old hard heads would be great

2013-08-06T23:00:36+00:00

The eye

Guest


First and foremost the clubs got to bring in a witch doctor to lift the injury curse that's been put on it,even Robbie F. is going down.So excuse me for being worried about the future health of the 2 young halves both recovering from fairly lengthy injury spells...after watching the Titans game,save for a couple of players,no one wanted to get dirty enough to win,which smells of division and raises doubt about their relationship with Potter..Robbies had his run in has that really been patched up ?

2013-08-06T22:44:25+00:00

james

Guest


only thing I disagree with is that Anasta shouldn't be in first grade next year. he has been just as bad as marshall this past month.

2013-08-06T22:33:50+00:00

Will Sinclair

Guest


Great piece AVFTT - hard to disagree with anything you've said. As a Tigers fan, I am hugely optimistic about the future. Possibly one thing you haven't touched on is the Club's policy of buying talented, young front-rowers. Jack Buchanan has already showed he will be a good first grader in a few seasons, while James Gavet is making hos way back from injury (together with Matt Groat) and young Martin Taupau has been signed from the Dogs. At the same time, big Keith galloway has been retained. Hopefully, in a couple of years, these blokes (and Aaron Woods) will form a good front-row rotation.

2013-08-06T20:56:35+00:00

Milksteak

Guest


Yep, agreed. Everyone justifies blooding young promising halves by using the foran/ cherry evans example. However, manly have had arguably the toughest, strongest and most competitive forward pack for the last 5 years. They protected the young halves and made life much easier for them. I think Potter has identified the weaknesses in the current roster and is looking to add some old hard heads to toughen up the pack and show the young guns how to play.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar