Will the Roosters break the Brian Smith hoodoo?

By Junior / Roar Guru

It is grand final week and like every grand final week our thoughts turn to one man: Brian Smith.

The great man has spent the last 12 months blogging and tweeting his unique insights on rugby league to anyone with a smartphone and time on their hands. His rugby league coaching days, at least at the NRL level, are seemingly behind him.

His record at the top was solid rather than stellar. On the numbers alone, he had a remarkably similar coaching record to one of his contemporaries, Tim Sheens. Both started coaching in 1984 and both coached 600-plus first grade games. Sheens had an overall 50.8% win percentage versus Smith’s 50.7%.

The main difference? Another number.

Four. As in four premierships.

Smith coached five clubs in Australia over almost 30 years.

Two of those five clubs no longer exist. He got his team to last game of the season five times, but discovered that efficient junior pathways, left-field analysis and random texts to key players late at night did not win trophies.

Smith is all too aware of these facts, while astute rugby league people only think one thing when they hear the words “Brian Smith”.

Most, however, may be less aware of the record of these five clubs after ties were severed. Let’s call it the Smith legacy. Okay, hoodoo.

Here are the facts: Smith left the Illawarra Steelers in 1987 and the club disappeared 11 trophy-less seasons later. Smith left the St George Dragons in 1995 and the club vaporised after three lean seasons.

The post-Smith era at Paramatta began seven years ago, while Newcastle have been Smith-free and glory-free now for four years.

That is an aggregate of 25 post-Smith seasons.

All without Smith. All without a premiership.

Call it a legacy, call it a hoodoo, call it a curse. How ever you cut it, thirty barren seasons as coach plus 25 subsequent seasons of inertia and stagnation is not good.

So to 2013, the Roosters inaugural post-Smith season.

On the back of a rampant season from Sonny, the Roosters can sniff the Provan-Summons. Finally, the hoodoo will be snapped.

Or will it?

Eagles by 20.

The Crowd Says:

2013-10-04T07:56:52+00:00

SuperEel22

Roar Guru


The Tigers have underperformed every season since that premiership

2013-10-04T01:41:34+00:00

Mr snrub

Guest


The Brian smith hoodoo is quite unfortunate. He was a smart coach who got to the big dance a few times but just couldn't finish the job. Brian smith is great for building teams. If he only won one of those grandfinals this article would be very different. I think this article is a bit of a low blow for Brian smith but I am sure he is wearing a pair of torpedoes to soften the impact

2013-10-04T00:46:35+00:00

League_coach101

Roar Pro


How is the Sheens hoodoo just as bad when Sheens won a Premiereship with the Tigers in 2005?

2013-10-04T00:25:54+00:00

Arthur fonzarelli

Guest


What a garbage article .

2013-10-04T00:02:11+00:00

Mals

Guest


Junior - good read! A man known as "The Sea Eagle" coined a name for this Brian Smith hoodoo. DFI - Dark Force Influenza.

2013-10-03T22:52:39+00:00

Mushi

Guest


A bit of a disingenuous article this one. Isn't the sheens hoodoo as bad? Also sheens got to kick off with a stacked team built by Bennett and cheated the cap smith got the expansion steelers in the non salary cap era. Robinson deserves a lot of credit for melding this team as a defensive unit but the team is one built by smith.

2013-10-03T22:17:15+00:00

Zip Zip

Guest


Parra fans would take Smithy back in a heart beat.

Read more at The Roar