My Australian XI for the first Ashes Test

By Sean Mortell / Roar Guru

Considering that the next Ashes series is almost upon us, I have decided to attempt a likely Ashes squad for the first Test at the Gabba.

1. Chris Rogers
With the old timer’s selection being much talked about during the last Ashes series, Rogers proved why he should be in the Aussie line-up, scoring a blistering 84 off 114 on the first morning of the third Test in Manchester before knocking up a brilliant maiden century in the fourth.

With his experience of Australian pitches after so many years of Sheffield Shield cricket, Rogers is ready to hammer England again.

2. Phil Hughes
With a great start to the Ashes series during the winter, a vital 81* in the first innings of the first Test helping Australia nearly topple the English, Phil Hughes was dropped after failing twice in the next game.

His dropping may have been a little bit premature, and I believe that batsman bat their best in their natural positions.

Phil Hughes, he has always been an opener and I believe he can become a stable partner for Rogers, as long as they run well and don’t play wasteful shots early on in their innings.

Hughes just edges out youngster Nic Maddinson and seasoned veteran Michael Klinger due to his Test match experience.

3. Steve Smith
After two series in a row where the young beachy blonde New South Welshman has proved himself after looking all but gone in international cricket, Steve Smith is back and ready to go.

After a near century in India and some great knocks in England, Australia is desperate for a first drop and it is there for Smith’s taking.

Early in his career he was a flamboyant batsman who played some wacky shots, but now Smith has toned his game down to a perfect level.

If Australia is going to move forward, they need good young players in key positions, and Smith at first drop may be the first of many such players. After the series he may be a good consideration for vice-captain and possibly an eventual captain.

4. Michael Clarke
If Clarke’s back is healed by the time the first Test swings around, he is a shoe-in at number four.

The record breaking skipper of the Australian team didn’t necessarily have to carry the batting by himself for the whole Ashes series in the winter, but a couple of times the Aussies found themselves relying on their injury-plagued captain.

Clarke needs to do what he has done over the past two Australian summers, which is deliver on the big stage and help get the Aussies over the line.

5. Shane Watson
Even though he may be out of his usual top order position, if Shane Watson is going to bowl in the Ashes series (which he almost has to) then he will have to bat down the order to prevent injury.

He also has to continue on from his brilliant innings in the last Test at the Oval, which was made after the series had already been lost.

If he can bat like that when the Ashes are still up for grabs then maybe he can help pull the Aussies over the line. The only reason he isn’t batting at six is because of Usman Khawaja’s absence.

The big all-rounder simply has to make an impact if Australia are going to win.

6. George Bailey
After being a solid leader in the one-day team for a fair period of time, I believe that it is now Bailey’s time to shine.

He has a cool head on his shoulders after captaining the Australia one-day and Twenty20 team, and his game will suit the longer form.

He may be a key part of Australia’s resurgence in Test cricket, but hopefully he doesn’t go the way of Dave Hussey.

This man may play a surprisingly huge part in the Ashes.

7. Brad Haddin
The only reason this stalwart is still in the line-up is because of the back-to-back Ashes series. If the Ashes were at their usual times, with another year’s interval in between, then Tim Paine would be in the line-up for the first Ashes Test.

Fate has it that he won’t be, but after this series expect him to start taking over the wicket-keeping duties for Australia.

Even though Haddin nearly won the Aussies the first Test at Nottingham, the first chance the Aussie selectors get they will head for Paine as the new generation starts to come through.

8. Ben Cutting
The only reason that Faulkner, Johnson or Hazlewood aren’t in the number eight spot is because the first Test is at Cutting’s home; the Gabba.

If it was in Perth, then Johnson would be taking this spot, and at any other ground it would be Faulkner or Hazlewood, preferably Hazlewood.

But if Cutting can slide some balls through the Englishmen’s defences he may be a shoe-in for many years to come. Expect big things either from Cutting or Hazlewood, as both have bright futures.

9. Peter Siddle
Siddle is instrumental to Australia’s chances, as he is the work horse leading the attack along with Harris.

Don’t expect a birthday hat-trick like last series, but expect this inspirational, tough-as-teak leader to help skittle England right when we need it the most.

Siddle and Harris may be the perfect pair to help the youngster Cutting.

10. Ryan Harris
After many an injury Harris finally played a full series out, helping the Aussies to at least have a chance in the recent Ashes series.

If he can perform like he did in patches in 2010/11 and in the last series, then Australia may just be a chance.

Just like Siddle, Harris is a tough and reliable bowler who is consistent even in the face of loss. If he doesn’t get injured then he will be a key factor.

11. Nathan Lyon
In the last Ashes series, many people thought that Lyon was as good as gone after 19-year-old Ashton Agar entered the cricket sanctum.

But Agar was soon given the boot as his bowling proved rather less effective than his debut innings.

Lyon can be just the same, with the scrawny spinner under scrutiny last year when he pushed through 90 km/h darts at South Africans.

If Lyon wants to retain his spot, he needs to flight the ball and bait in the batsman, with Australia desperately needing an answer to England’s Graeme Swann.

12th man: Usman Khawaja
The stylish lefty narrowly misses out on playing because of Bailey’s record in one-day Internationals.

But young Usman still has big things ahead of him if he can sure down his technique and keep a good attitude. If he wants to enter the fold of Test cricket, Khawaja will have to accumulate many runs in the Sheffield Shield.

Special Mentions:

Jackson Bird: If the series is close at the end and Harris is injured, then Bird may be the word as the reliable young man who resembles McGrath may be asked to step up.

Will need to do better than in England though, but if he bowls like he did against Sri Lanka then he may swing the Ashes in the Aussies’ favour.

Ashton Agar: If Lyon gets smacked around in the first couple of Tests, then Agar could be called up to bowl and bat again by around the Third Test. He is a big x-factor when batting, but bowling he will need to lift if he wants to retain a spot in the team.

David Warner: This controversial batsman could re-enter the Aussie team in a desperate need for power hitting.

He has been drastically out of form of late, with the troublesome Warner having to be ready to carry the drinks for almost all of the summer.

The Crowd Says:

2013-11-03T23:27:07+00:00

Taylor

Guest


Chris Rogers David Warner Nic Maddinson Michael Clarke Steve Smith George Bailey Brad Haddin Mitchell Johnson James Faulker Ryan Harris Peter Siddle Nathan Lyon 12th man Faulker in side as a bowling allrounder cause watson injury in india No spinner in side cause smith can bowl part time leg spin Maddinson at 3 need someone who they can give a whole series there to build confidence Unlucky to miss out Usman Khawaja Matthew Wade Fahmed Ahmed Ben Cutting Doug Bollinger

2013-10-28T02:14:28+00:00

Kieran

Guest


Good team! I like it ... except maybe Warner in for Hughes, neither of who inspires confidence!

2013-10-18T11:23:09+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Hughes, Khawaja, Warner, Smith, Maddison, Burns, Cosgrove, Silk. All 'rookies' on the rise with better first class averages than Bailey and I suspect better batsmen. Maddison is one of the best rookies we've had since Clarke. What do you mean there are no top rookies? Our problem is that there is a big gap between these rookies still learning their craft and 30 something batsmen with 50+ averages (Rogers, Clarke, David Hiussey, Kattich). Our problem is that almost none of the generation which includes Bailey were up to standard and it was left to these kids to become champions overnight.

2013-10-18T07:21:05+00:00

Marcus Halberstram

Guest


Cameron White? thats a typo right?

2013-10-18T07:19:11+00:00

Marcus Halberstram

Guest


a great rookie would be great and would walk into the team...there just isn't one.

2013-10-18T07:17:16+00:00

Marcus Halberstram

Guest


He is just suited to the middle order role of one day cricket - working singles when it is very easy to do so. He has done nothing to earn a test spot but as that same goes for just about everyone these days he is an outside chance. I would rather recall an old guy who once put in the hard yards at shield level some like Klinger, Katich, even ask Hodge if he wants to have another go. We need to get back to the days where one day cricket is not the way to force your way into the team.

2013-10-18T07:10:51+00:00

Marcus Halberstram

Guest


I'd go with an aged team - and make it clear to the youth that we just are not picking you until you earn it: 1. Klinger 2. Rogers 3. Katich (looks like he is back with WA) 4. Smith 5. Clarke 6. Watson 7. Hartley 8. Siddle 9. Harris 10. Johnson 11. Lyon

2013-10-18T07:02:30+00:00

Marcus Halberstram

Guest


If I was a selector I would say to Maddinson that you need to dominate at shield level first. He is talented, but he has done nothing to provide he is test material. I would say to him no 6 is yours if you want it but if you want it you need to pile on the rules at shield level. I would even elevate less worthy options (Bailey), or previously relevant but now slightly past it options (Klinger) above him to make the point.

2013-10-16T23:45:00+00:00

Dan Ced

Guest


The spot I want Klinger to fit in to will probably go to Bailey. I just feel Klingers form is wasted not being in one of the AUS teams. Sayers will get his chance next year probably if he keeps up last years form, hasn't had an amazing star to Ryobi though.

2013-10-16T09:17:25+00:00

DT

Guest


Sayers, Paine and Klinger are no chance. Sayers is good but probably 5th in line behind (assuming Harris and Siddle are first picked) Bird, Faulkner, Hilf and Pattinson. he is then behind starc once he is fit.

2013-10-16T09:07:47+00:00

DT

Guest


Dan, that'll be the team save for Johnson's place. That will come down to whomever is fit out of Bird and Pattinson with Johnson and Hilf in reserve. Khawaja hopefully given a proper run this time!

2013-10-16T04:58:01+00:00

Dan Ced

Guest


Here's mine :D Rogers Klinger Watson Clarke Smith Khawaja Paine Johnson Sayers Harris Lyon Sayers for Siddle is probably a little silly at this point so I'd be open to keeping Siddle in, but Klinger would be great opening with Rogers. I was very disappointed with Haddin in the ashes, give Paine a go. Johnson looked good in the ODI, there is still time for him to turn to mush, I usually hate him but we need a speedy gonzales I think. The siddle position could also be filled by Cutting or Faulkner, who would add sting to the batting tail.

2013-10-16T03:54:11+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Watson was also the one saying the players should stay behind with Huss (after his last test) rather than go on the boat.

2013-10-15T11:53:31+00:00

Aakash bhat

Guest


Well is in awful form

2013-10-15T11:11:38+00:00

ChrisUK

Guest


Get rid of the player who scored 176 in his last Test? You must have lots and lots of world class batsmen to choose from.

2013-10-15T10:51:16+00:00

Rob Barrow

Guest


Good points Manoj, i would also have UTK in the side but lets wait on shield resuts.

2013-10-15T10:49:50+00:00

Rob Barrow

Guest


Well said Manoj, Khawaja looks good after the first few games. Can someone tell me why SOK is not playing for NSW in the Ryobi he is their best short form bowler.

2013-10-15T10:48:21+00:00

Mr Mac

Guest


Sorry - its all about culture Get rid of Watson!! Stop massaging egos & kick a few a.ses Get bowlers to bowl instead of standing pouting and pretending to growl at batters. All this attitude stuff is a cover for being inadequate

2013-10-15T10:26:05+00:00

rp

Guest


Doolan is a gud option

2013-10-15T10:05:03+00:00

Manoj

Guest


UTK has stared well in the Ryobi mate, top scored in the last 2 games and looks a class above and i am sure he will take this into shield as well. And keep in mind that Swann won't do as well in our conditions, in England the pitches were made for him.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar