The greatest MMA fighters of all time

By Tane Mahuta / Roar Rookie

MMA or Mixed Martial Arts is a relatively young sport in terms of its present form.

Although the sport has been around in one form or another since the dawn of man, it has only been around for a very short while with the rules the way they are today.

The UFC, MMA’s most prestigious event, has only been around since the early 1990s.

Despite being such a young sport MMA is rapidly growing and shedding the image of “human cockfighting” that it portrayed early on, and is now hitting the mainstream.

Across the sport’s history, these are the fighters who have stood out above the rest and made the grade as the best MMA fighters to date.

10. Randy Couture
A true competitor, Randy Couture was the epitome of grit and determination.

Couture was a Greco-Roman wrestler who would often grind the will out of his opponent with ‘dirty boxing’ and takedowns. A handy boxer and a guy who thrived on a challenge, he was often the underdog but never counted out, even into his late fourties.

A UFC hall of famer and a champion in multiple weight classes on mutiple occasions, this tournament champion at heavyweight was one of the greatest championship fighters of all time.

If there is a will, there is a way and all too often Couture had the will and found a way against more fancied opponents.

Only his record stops him from being higher on the list, but anyone who is still fighting at the very top level heading towards his fifties in such a taxing sport deserves recognition.

In his last MMA bout he was KO’d by another great, Lyoto Machida. Not the best way for a legend to finish but as it was a karate ‘crane’ kick that caught him flush on the jaw he can be forgiven for bowing out in that way. As they say, it’s a move that “no can defend against”.

Record: 19 wins (seven by stoppage), 11 losses (10 by stoppage), zero draws

9. Chuck Liddell
One of the first fighters to show us how effective wrestling could be when used in reverse to keep the fight where he wanted, and where he wanted was on the feet where his unorthodox punches did the damage.

Liddell was not known for kicking or grappling but for looping, unorthodox punches that would come from unexpected angles and catch his opponents off guard. An outstanding takedown defence and ability to ‘wall walk’ or scramble back to his feet made Liddell a feared opponent.

A multiple UFC champion and one of the first ‘rockstar’ fighters in the USA, Liddell was a knockout machine and gave the spectators what they wanted – finishes.

Liddell fought on for a few too many years after he should have and finshed his career on a low, but at his peak he was the best light heavyweight in the world at a time when LHW was stacked full of great fighters.

Record: 21 wins (13 by stoppage), eight losses (six by stoppage), zero draws

8. BJ Penn
At a time when the best lightweights were thought to have been outside of the UFC, Penn put his career in jeopardy to pursue his rivals.

He dismantled them with ease and kept looking for greater challenges, fighting at heavyweight against Lyoto Machida and going the distance.

Penn was extremely well rounded in a time of specialists. Equally as comfortable on his feet or on the ground, Penn could do it all.

It was often suggested that Penn relied on his gifts and never pushed himself enough leading into fights – his lack of conditioning in the later rounds supported this theory.

But that just makes us wonder about how good he could have been if he spent more time training and less time on the beach in his native Hawaii.

A multiple UFC champion in two different weight classes and one of the few lightweights to test himself against great fighters much bigger than himself, Penn is a worthy owner of the No.8 spot on this list.

Record: 16 wins (13 by stoppage), nine losses (two by stoppage), two draws

7. Dan Henderson
Another veteran with a long career, Dan Henderson is a hard as nails Greco-Roman wrestler who has had multiple titles in more than one division.

Although he has great wrestling, like his former training partner Couture, he also posesses a thunderous right hand that has put fighters like Bisping and Wanderlei Silva to sleep.

“Hendo” has been a UFC tournement champion aswell as a title holder at middleweight (UFC LHW) and welterweight (UFC MW) in Pride FC, fighting a who’s who in MMA and beating most of them.

Record: 29 wins (15 by stoppage), 11 losses (four by stoppage), zero draws

6. Jose Aldo
If you like leg kicks and Muay Thai, Jose Aldo is the fighter for you.

With lightning-fast strikes featuring near-perfect technique, Aldo has fast become recognised as one of the best pound-for-pound fighters in the world.

Although this UFC champion is a black belt in Brazilian jiu-jitsu (BJJ) he gets most of his wins via his deadly and precise strikes. Aldo inflicts massive damage with his leg kicks and can pick an opponent apart with relative ease.

Jose Aldo may not be a household name like the Liddells and Hendersons due to the smaller profile of his featherweight division, but don’t let this fool you – he is a hall of fame fighter of the future.

Record: 24 wins (16 stoppages), one loss (one stoppage)

5. Matt Hughes
Starting primarily as a wrestler, Hughes evolved quickly to become an accomplised submission artist, often out-grappling highly ranked BJJ practitioners with a combination of power and technique.

Although a specialist ground fighter, Hughes was a powerful finisher, having finished his opponent in 35 of his 45 victories.

During his prime it was thought that the hall of fame inductee was unbeatable, having defended the UFC welterweight belt six times before defeat to his great friend and rival, BJ Penn.

Record: 45 wins (35 by stoppage), nine losses (nine by stoppage)

4. George St Pierre
“Rush” is the UFC welterweight champion and has defended the UFC WW title a total of nine times. He’s without a doubt the greatest WW fighter of all time and one of the greatest fighters of all time – some may say the greatest.

St Pierre is one of the most well-rounded fighters to have ever entered the ring. He is equally at home on the feet or the ground and is often the one deciding where the fight takes place due to his outstanding MMA wrestling, which is the best the sport has ever seen.

St Pierre is never one to trash talk, choosing to do his talking inside the ring. He is known as a true gentleman in a sport often asscoiated with a less desirable personality type.

Record: 25 wins (13 by stoppage), two losses (two by stoppage)

3. Fedor Emelianenko
In an age where MMA was divided, Fedor Emelianenko was considered the best fighter in the world although he never set foot in the UFC.

Having only suffered one loss in his first 32 bouts (due to a dubious disqualification), “the Last Emperor” had seldom looked in trouble in any of his bouts.

A well-rounded fighter with explosive speed and power, Emelianenko could take an opponent’s strength and use it against them, often turning the tables when it appeared he was out of his comfort zone.

Beating striking specialists on the feet and grappling specialist on the ground, Emelianenko was destroying all that were put in front of him despite being a small heavyweight.

A very religous and humble man, Fedor never seemed to show any emotion before, during or after fights. He often opted to respect his rival because “it is not personal”, and always looked at the ground when facing off with his opponent.

The former European Judo and Sambo champion was the greatest fighter on the planet for the best part of a decade.

Record: 35 wins (27 by stoppage), four losses (four by stoppage), zero draws, one no contest

2. Jon Jones
The UFC light heavyweight champion is the top pound-for-pound fighter on the planet today.

Jonny “Bones” Jones uses push kicks, spinning elbows, catch wrestling and a dominant top game to finish and outscore his opponents, mixing unorthodox striking with excellent wrestling.

On many occasions, Jones has completely destroyed opponents who were thought of as serious challengers, throwing wrestlers around like rag dolls and dominating strikers on the feet.

The story of Jon Jones has just begun and already he is considered as one of the finest MMA fighters of all time. I for one think he will become the greatest fighter ever before he has finished.

Record: 19 wins (15 by stoppage), one loss, zero draws

1. Anderson Silva
Where does one start?

This is a guy who was bored with his competition. A guy who dances around the ring because his opponent is too afraid to attack him. A guy who dares his opponent to try to hit him.

I have never seen a fighter toy with a title challenger like Anderson Silva has, and genuine frustration with the lack of a challenge presented by the No.1 ranked contender can be easily confused with arrogance.

Arguably the best Muay Thai striker MMA has ever seen, the freak of nature known as “The Spider” has unnatural accuracy mixed with evasive skills only ever seen before in The Matrix movies. It’s as if he sees everything a little slower than the rest of us.

An incredible striker and submission artist of the highest order, Anderson Silva doesnt care where you want to fight because he will be better than you there anyway.

Anderson Silva is the best MMA fighter to have ever entered the ring, and in my opinion the best combat sports fighter of all time.

Record: 33 wins (26 by stoppage), five losses (three by stoppage), zero draws

This is only my opinion of the greatest MMA practitioners of all time.

What do you think?

The Crowd Says:

2016-01-08T12:55:50+00:00

Jay K.

Guest


Not to mention, that he's essentially a LHW as far as height and ("natural") weight goes, and yet he fights at HW which makes his career even more impressive IMHO. Just imagine how dominant he'd be/have been had he spent his whole career at LHW instead (we'd all be saying "Jon Who?!?!?" I mean he's been fat or at least "chunky" his whole career and STILL kicking elite fighters asses.

2014-07-31T07:15:30+00:00

MMA Fan

Guest


Fedor is the best ever followed by Silva, in his prime Fedor was untouchable. He lost his last three fights after he passed his prime, and that does not erase his accomplishments, and so did Anderson Silva lose his last 2 fights being clearly that he is also in his way to pass his prime too. Anyhow although I don't agree with the writer of the topic placing Silva above Fedor, but I can to some extent accept why he did so, because the choice between the two can be a bit confusing, But placing Jone Jones above Fedor is an absolute mistake.

2014-04-08T13:41:17+00:00

Ben Gibbon

Roar Guru


A very shallow assessment of MMA fighters lacking in nuance or depth of knowledge. How is popular at the moment, oh yeah, they will be in my Top10... terribly written.

2014-01-11T14:42:28+00:00

Slicer

Guest


I could understand no Wanderlei but no Shogun? Shogun is the most decorated LHW ever, Shogun tops both Chuck and Randy, UFC was dirt in competition when Chuck was winning, when the only Pride guy comes over he gets KTFO. Shogun winning the Pride Prix at such a young age and the UFC LHW Belt. This list looses a lot of credibility

2014-01-01T09:24:19+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


I'd agree with you if the list was written any time before 2010, Fedor was a beast at his peak but since 2010 the likes of Silva and FTP have kicked it up to another level. That said while The UFC would like to forget Fedora ever existed his achievements cannot be discounted.

2014-01-01T06:44:00+00:00

Johnny Football

Guest


Any list without Fedor at number 1 is not a list at all.

2013-12-18T01:06:52+00:00

ohtani's jacket

Guest


I was always more interested in Japanese MMA than US MMA and haven't watched much since PRIDE folded, but Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira was my all-time favourite fighter. I also liked Takanori Gomi, Rumina Sato, Caol Uno and Tatsuya Kawajiri a lot among the lightweights.

2013-12-17T14:12:46+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


Oh I rate him and appreciate others may rate him as the best ever but for me he isnt. For me finishing is a big part of how I rate a fighter. If you cant finish or dont finish I dont rate you as high. Imo GSP can finish but plays it safe. I just cant bring myself to rate GSP above somebody who has a killer instinct and who stops his opponents rather than a fighter who figures out a way to outpoint them like GSP does. To put it another way, is it more impressive to sub or KO a top fighter after a dominant performance like Jon Jones vs Shogun or is it more impressive to outpoint a fighter over 5 rds by avoiding risk and imo thats what GSP does, he avoids. Are you better if you have to avoid and cant finish or if you dont have to and you finish? For me its the guy capable of putting himself in danger and finishing a fighter on a consistent basis. To me it says that hes capable of taking you on and taking you out. Outpointing time after time says that maybe hes not capable of doing that or at least is too afraid to.

2013-12-17T12:29:41+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


You forget that going into the Shields fight he had something like a 35 round win streak, he didn't just beat his opponents, he dominated them at every single point of every fight. While it isn't knocking your opponent out it is a different kind of perfection that I would argue is probably harder to achieve. From memory that streak is a UFC record and I don't think anyone else has come close, especially in mostly championship fights.

2013-12-17T11:55:19+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


Sorry, should read "...won 3 rds to 2 (according to 2 of the judges)"

2013-12-17T11:49:26+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


Oh I was supposed to mention that he didnt dominate all of his recent fights. He won a split decision against Hendricks, won 2 rds to 3 against Shields (according to 2 of the 3 judges) and he hasnt fought Fitch in almost 5 years. In that 5 years he has finished 2 from 10 fights.

2013-12-17T10:39:17+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


So if you are a good MW then you should fight LHW? Silva beat a former LHW champion easily when he ventured up to LHW and destroyed Forrest. He also humiliated Bonnar He finished the Pride LHW and MW champion Hendo and KOed former LHW and HW champion Belfort. He beat Sonnen twice and Sonnen beat Shogun at LHW. As I said I think Bones will be the best ever and is the best in the world now. I also said some may consider GSP the best but after his team greased him up and other fighters had complained about his body being "slick" I find it hard to back him for the top spot. He is also a "safe" fighter that seldom finishes these days. I just couldnt put him first. Anderson has fought his fair share of sub par fighters but all fighters have. Anderson has also completely dismantled Pride champions, former UFC champions and a UFC champion. Newton, Franklin, Sonnen, Marquardt, Hendo, Okami, Griffin, Belfort. Those are very good fighters. He finished all of them.

2013-12-17T04:44:33+00:00

Carrollj

Guest


I am not going to offer a ranked list but some points to consider UFC middle weight division is really weak and if full of guys who would be fighting as light heavy weights if they were any good, Anderson Silva included. Jon Jones beat more top line oponents in his first year as champion than Anderson's Silva's entire undefeated streak. GSP has none of Silva's flamboyance but had consistently beaten worthy oponents including Hughes twice, Penn twice (both on your ten greatest list) and his recent openents Shields, Fitch, Diaz, Condit were al completly dominated albeit in boring fights. Granted the Hendricks fight was close but, Jones was equally shakey against Gustafson and Silva was knocked out in his last outing.

2013-12-16T14:04:12+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


There were many fighters worthy of the list. Fighters such as Wanderlei, Big Nog, Severn, Sakuraba, Valasquez, Royce Gracie, Ortiz, Rickson Gracie, F.Shamrock and many others but I just picked those I those I thought that deserved it the most imo. I also wanted to create more of a conversation about MMA on the Roar. P.S. Thankyou to the Roar editors for correcting my spelling etc.

2013-12-16T12:39:05+00:00

nickoldschool

Roar Guru


Agree Sam. Wanderlei over BJ Penn any day for me. Dunno why but I have never been a fan of BJ (maybe am being influenced by his guy-next door body shape, dunno). So not in the top ten of all times for me.

2013-12-16T11:09:04+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


Sorry for the multi-posts but I just remembered Wanderlei Silva and how he just dominated PRIDE and just destroyed all comers. Have to put him up around that 10 mark with Liddell, Tito and the Shamrocks. Once again, he probably went on for a few too many fights but at his prime he was one of the most feared men in the MMA world.

2013-12-16T09:59:21+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


For the record I'd have: 10. Tito Ortiz 9. B.J. Penn 8. Matt Hughes 7. Randy Coulture 6. Dan Henderson 5. Jon Jones 4. Royce Gracie 3. Fedor Emilienanko 2. George St Pierre 1. Anderson Silva That was harder than I thought and I'm torn on the positioning of Penn, Hughes, Hendo and Coulture, in my mind they are all so close. As I said above I feel Liddell, Ortiz and the Shamrocks are all on a similar level but I ended up going with Ortiz because of his title defense streak. While he fought on a few fights too long and his dodging of Liddell looks pretty bad, it cannot be ignored that he was able to defend the belt that long in probably the most historically competitive division in the UFC.

2013-12-16T09:46:40+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


Nice round up, pretty hard to argue with most of it. I've written before that Silva is the greatest of all time at the moment but if Jones continues as he has he will surpass The Spider, especially if he makes a successful transition up to heavyweight as he said he would like to. I also love that you have Hendo up so highly, he held the PRIDE middle and light-heavyweight belts at the same time which is a simply amazing feat. My main gripe with it is not having Royce Gracie in it, he should be a lock in and could arguably be placed as highly as second. He may have benefited from other fighters inexperience against BJJ however he still managed to tame some much larger, stronger and powerful wrestlers like Ken Shamrock and Dan Severn. Aldo at 6 is probably a touch high at this stage, however on the other side of his career he could be right up with the greatest of all time. I also think Tito Ortiz and Ken and Frank Shamrock are worth a look at, while Liddell did far more outside the cage for MMA, inside the cage their records are all right up there, especially Ortiz, who's light-heavyweight championship streak only just got broken by Jones. Liddell's reputation gets a much better run in the UFC because of his friendliness backstage whereas Tito gets much more mixed coverage and the Shamrocks, especially Frank, are more or less written off by the UFC.

2013-12-16T01:56:27+00:00

nickoldschool

Roar Guru


That's a pretty good list Tane and all your fighters deserve their spot. Having said that, the Gracie family has to be mentioned somewhere imo. Then you have the guys who made MMA what it is now, the Rich Franklin, Forrest Griffin, Vitor Belfort etc. Rampage Jackson and Wanderlei Silva were also monsters during their Pride years in Japan and I think they aren't far either. (Wanderlei is probably the guy who hooked me on mma a decade ago.) The biggest flop has to be Kimbo Slice. Toughest fights to watch/stand were Akebono's, with his kids/wife in the audience waiting for the moment he would be dropped, fear in the eyes. that was sick.

2013-12-15T23:57:58+00:00

bryan

Guest


Royce Gracie?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar