The Roar
The Roar

Advertisement

Greatest ever Origin team: NSW forward pack and bench

22nd June, 2014
Advertisement
Steve Menzies has been denied his rightful career stats. (Eden Park Photo: Andrew) Cornaga/www.Photosport.co.nz
Expert
22nd June, 2014
72
1886 Reads

After going over the best ever back seven for the NSW Blues on Sunday we now move onto the forwards and the interchange bench. Remember the interchange bench will be based on who was most unlucky to miss out throughout all the other positions.

So who makes the forward pack and bench for the Blues?

Front rowers
The candidates are: Craig Young (St George Dragons), Steve Roach (Balmain Tigers), Glen Lazarus (Canberra Raiders, Brisbane Broncos and Melbourne Storm), Paul Harragon (Newcastle Knights), Luke Bailey (St George Illawarra Dragons and Gold Coast Titans), Robbie Kearns (Cronulla Sutherland Sharks, Western Reds and Melbourne Storm), Mark O’Meley (North Sydney Bears, Canterbury Bankstown Bulldogs and Sydney Roosters), Ian Roberts (South Sydney Rabbitos, Manly Warringah Sea Eagles and North Queensland Cowboys).

Craig Young played in the front row in the first ever State of Origin match after playing a couple of matches for the Blues before 1980. He ended up playing 10 Origin matches and always stood up in defence.

We have all heard about the legend of Steve “Blocker” Roach. The big front rower played 17 games for the Blues and has been described as one of the best. He was one of the first picked and hardly missed a game. He also played for Australia 19 times.

The next two on the candidates list, Glen Lazarus and Paul Harragon, often lined up next to each other in the front row and proceeded to terrorise Queensland with their hard running and hard tackling. They were an unmissable feature in the Blues team for a number of years in the 1990s.

Lazarus played for the Blues on 19 occasions and Harragon on 20, showing just how parallel their careers ran. They also represented Australia together on a number of occasions, with Lazarus on 21 and Harragon on 20.

Luke Bailey is one of those players that just never gave up. Whether it be Origin or club he would fight until the end. He represented the Blues in just his third season in the NRL and made an immediate impact going onto play 15 games for the Blues and managing to make the Australian set up four times.

Advertisement

Robbie Kearns and Mark O’Meley, also known at the Ogre, are the final two candidates. They both represented the Blues a number of times and gave it everything. Both were good players. Kearns represented the Blues on nine occasions while O’Meley played 10. Kearns also represented Australia a staggering 29 times.

Ian Roberts played his footy at many different clubs and was always up there during his time as one of the best props in the game. He was big, tough and solid in both attack and defence. He represented the Blues nine times and Australia 13 times.

The Verdict: It comes down to Paul Harragon, Glen Lazarus, Steve Roach and Ian Roberts. Because Harragon and Lazarus played so many games together and the fact that they both played more games than Roach and Roberts means they are the two front rowers that get selected.

Hooker
The candidates are: Royce Simmons (Penrith Panthers), Ben Elias (Balmain Tigers) and Danny Buderus (Newcastle Knights).

Royce Simmons represented both the Blues and Australia on 10 occasions. He was a fantastic ball player and tough in defence. He received a man of the match in only his fourth Origin match and was involved in a number of successes with the Blues.

Ben Elias played around the same time as Simmons and in his early State of Origin career. Eventually he nailed down the spot as age caught up with Simmons. He was tough as nails in defence as well. He played for the Blues on 22 occasions and had the honour of captaining the Blues six times. He also played for Australia six times and was considered the best hooker in the game during his era.

Before last Wednesday night Danny Buderus will be remembered as the last captain of a Blues winning State of Origin series before Queensland started their unbelievable run of eight straight. Buderus was probably the best hooker in the game before Cameron Smith came along and age started catching up with him. Buderus played 21 Origins, captaining 15 of them over a five-year period, and not missing a game after his debut. He also played for Australia on 24 occasions.

Advertisement

The Verdict: All three of these hookers were awesome in their own way. Royce Simmons is the first out as clearly he is below the other two. Buderus ends up making the team over Elias, because he had a bit more talent and was the captain 15 times and played 21 Origins in a row.

Second Row
The Candidates are: Noel Cleal (Eastern Suburbs, Manly Warringah Sea Eagles), David Gillespie (Canterbury Bankstown Bulldogs, Western Suburbs Magpies and Manly Warringah Sea Eagles), Paul Sironen (Balmain Tigers) Steve Menzies (Manly Warringah Sea Eagles and Northern Eagles), Ben Kennedy (Canberra Raiders, Newcastle Knights and Manly Warringah Sea Eagles), Nathan Hindmarsh (Parramatta Eels), Craig Fitzgibbon (Illawarra Steelers, St George Illawarra Dragons and Sydney Roosters) and Greg Bird (Cronulla Sutherland Sharks and Gold Coast Titans).

Noel “Crusher” Cleal was one of several brilliant second rowers who have played for New South Wales. He has been named in the greatest 25 players to ever play for the Blues and represented them 12 times. He also played for Australia 10 times.

David Gillespie was not someone you wanted to run at or have running at you. He was big and strong in both attack and defence and he represented the Blues on 15 occasions, as well as playing for the Kangaroos 16 times and scoring three tries.

Paul Sironen was another of the brilliant second rowers that have played for the Blues over the years. He was big, strong and had a never-say-die attitude, and it was these couple of things that got him so far in the brutal world of rugby league. He played for the Blues 14 times and for Australia 21 times.

Steve Menzies and Ben Kennedy are two names you associate with a lot of tackling. The beaver and the bold – two of the greats that have ever represented NSW or Australia. They had careers that were fairly similarly timed and never failed to disappoint at any level.

Menzies played for the Blues 20 times and Australia 13, while Kennedy played for the Blues 13 times and Australia 16. Both were always up to the task of taming the Queensland forwards and were a big part of the Blues’ three-year winning streak before Queensland decided to go on an eight-year one.

Advertisement

Nathan Hindmarsh and Craig Fitzgibbon also had fairly parallel careers, until the latter went off to play Super League in England. These two often battled for the second row spots with Kennedy and Menzies during the middle of their careers.

Fitzgibbon also happened to be one of the greatest goal kickers in Australia. Hindmarsh played 17 games for the Blues and 23 games for Australia while Fitzgibbon played 11 games for the Blues and 19 games for Australia, kicking 20 goals for the Blues and 50 for the Kangaroos.

Greg Bird is one of the hardest and meanest characters to ever walk into the Origin arena. He never backs down from anything, is happy to tackle blokes double his size and run at them too. He is also creative and has a never-say-die attitude. Bird has represented the Blues 15 times and Australia 12 times.

The Verdict: This is not an easy position to pick just two. Fitzgibbon is the first one out, he struggled to hold down a spot and even though he was a brilliant goal kicker it doesn’t push him into the team. Bird doesn’t make the team at this point in his career. Paul Sironen and Steve Menzies are the two best although it’s nearly impossible to split them, so they get the nod.

Lock
The candidates are: Ray Price (Parramatta Eels), Wayne Pearce (Balmain Tigers), Bradley Clyde (Canberra Raiders), Paul Gallen (Cronulla Sutherland Sharks).

Ray Price was a brilliant lock. He made 15 appearances for the Blues, although some of these were before the first official Origin game in 1980. After that he played lock for the Blues without exception until Wayne Pearce came along. Price also represented Australia 22 times.

Pearce was without doubt one of the best forwards of the 1980s. He was tough and liked to outmuscle his opponents. He captained the Blues for a number of his 16 appearances and he also went onto play for the Kangaroos 19 times.

Advertisement

Both Pearce and Price have been named in the list of the game’s 100 greatest players.

Bradley Clyde was tall, big, strong and agile and took a lot to bring down. He is still the only player in the game to win the Clive Churchill Medal twice and was named in the top 25 players to ever play for the Blues. He made 12 Origin appearances and played for Australia 19 times managing to score six tries.

Paul Gallen is the current Blues captain and will triumphantly lift the State of Origin shield above his head this year. He has done some amazing things for the Blues throughout his career and will keep pushing to get what he wants. He has currently represented the Blues 18 times, 10 as captain, and has also played for the Kangaroos 31 times.

The Verdict: While Price and Clyde were great in their own right they can’t keep up with the other two. Because Gallen has mainly played in a losing team I am giving the spot of lock to Wayne Pearce.

Interchange:
After all this we arrive at the interchange bench. All the stars that have missed selection have to be narrowed down to a four-man bench and an 18th man. How? It’s nearly impossible.

So who were the most unlucky to miss out on the 13?

Here are the contenders: Jarryd Hayne, Steve Rogers, Mick Cronin, Laurie Daley, Brett Kenny, Peter Sterling, Steve Mortimer, Steve Roach, Ian Roberts, Ben Elias, Nathan Hindmarsh, Ben Kennedy, David Gillespie, Ray Price, Bradley Clyde and Paul Gallen.

Advertisement

Jarryd Hayne and Laurie Daley are the best of the backs so they go onto the bench. Then Steve Roach edges out Ian Roberts and Nathan Hindmarsh edges out the rest.

18th man comes down to a battle between Ben Kennedy, Peter Sterling and Paul Gallen. Gallen is out because of his losing record, unlucky but that’s the way the cookie crumbles.

So Kennedy or Sterling? A back or a forward. If Sterling didn’t have his Origin career at the same time as Terry Lamb he would have played a lot more games, although the same could be argued for Kennedy. I’m going to pick Sterling but it’s certainly up for argument.

The greatest ever Blues team
1. Tim Brasher
2. Andrew Ettingshausen
3. Ryan Girdler (gk)
4. Matt Cooper
5. Rod Wishart
6. Brad Fittler
7. Andrew Johns
8. Paul Harragon
9. Danny Buderus (c)
10. Glen Lazarus
11. Paul Sironen
12. Steve Menzies
13. Wayne Pearce
14. Jarryd Hayne
15. Laurie Daley
16. Steve Roach
17. Nathan Hindmarsh

18th man: Peter Sterling
19th man: Ben Kennedy

Captain
There are plenty of applicants for the captaincy position in this team. Both the halves, Brad Fittler and Andrew Johns, were great captains, as was the hooker Danny Buderus.

Wayne Pearce at lock captained the Blues a number of times, as did Laurie Daley, who is on the bench. At the end though I think the most successful applicant is Danny Buderus. He managed to lead the Blues to three series in a row so for that he gets the nod as captain.

Advertisement

Goal kicker
The goal-kicking duties come down to a battle between Andrew Johns and Ryan Girdler. Johns and Girdler were both great goal kickers, but at the end of the day I think Ryan Girdler gets the nod. He still holds the record for the most goals kicked in a single Origin match and was one of the best to ever play.

Well that’s NSW’s greatest ever Origin team. Over the next two days I will announce the Queensland team so be sure to check back then. In the mean time be sure to leave your thoughts in the comments section.

close