SMITHY: Upsets set up an intriguing round

By Brian Smith / Expert

I can’t wait for Round 20 to unfold. After a crazy round last weekend, the response of some teams intrigues me enormously.

Tonight the Knights get a chance for a big scalp at home to the Roosters in what has been a disastrous season for them.

It’s hard to believe how poor Newcastle were on such an important occasion.

Emotion abounded but the Titans handled it well, while a team full of experience and tough nuts fell apart. They will surely come meet the defending premiers with pride at stake. Those veterans and that physical hard edge across the board are needed to confront the top dogs of smash-mouth footy.

To read more Brian Smith, outside The Roar, check out his website SmithySpeaks.

The Roosters used their bye to reconfigure their focus. The Panthers were not in the race when met with such power and speed. Can the premiers do it again if the Knights at last find top gear? I think so.

Can the Panthers bounce back after being outclassed, despite their lofty ladder position? They’re playing the Sharks, so probably.

The really big match this weekend is the Warriors at home to Manly. As regular readers here would know, I love watching the Eagles do their thing. As tough and physical as they are every week, it’s their ability to play footy that thrills me. The way they can keep the physical components going nearly all the time but still work out strategically how to undo their opponents proves they are a classy outfit.

On the other hand, the Warriors’ bubble popped after leading at Brisbane last weekend. Midway through the first half it looked like the form of the Kiwi team was strong, beating the Broncos to everything early on. But when the chips were down and Brisbane got a sniff, they appeared lost as to how to steady the ship.

More importantly, when they really needed points to kick clear, they didn’t seem to know how to go about it. Without physical dominance what could they do?

Manly know how to keep scoring or start scoring without physical dominance or even majority of possession or field position. It will be great to see this match-up, particularly to see what lessons the Warriors learnt in that loss. Will they be prepared for Manly’s plan for this game or will they do what they do best, knowing that Manly will have done their homework on that too?

We all know what the Dogs will do this weekend after that embarrassing and highly surprising second half collapse to the Tigers. They are a proud team and we see a revamped and refocused group who can really change it up with variety in how they approach from one week to the next.

The Dragons’ little form bubble popped on Monday night too. While the scoreboard was pretty close for much of the game, Manly dominated most aspects.

Coach Paul McGregor looks to have changed the feel in the team by unleashing some more flexible and enterprising attack. Unfortunately when the opposition is up for it and smart about what they do, as Manly most certainly are, the Dragons looked lost.

Instead of that sparkling early attack, ‘Mary’ needs to have addressed the smorgasbord right-side defence his side currently offer.

Jason Nightingale stands 20 metres behind the rest of them all the time, Benji Marshall remains without resolve or apparently any awareness of his role in this system, and Josh Dugan plays like a wounded soldier 20 minutes into the game. Fixing that is some task.

Then again their opponents, the Tigers, may do what they do best and ignore the opportunity the Eagles feasted on.

The Crowd Says:

2014-07-26T04:01:02+00:00

MAX

Guest


I have/ had the utmost respect for Western Suburbs. The standard of refereeing is at the lowest I have witnessed in my 77years. It is not a question of bias,it is the method in which they apply their authority. Inconsistency week after week. Balmain may be ready to go again. I wish them well. I had doubts about Canterbury's recovery and was not surprised at the result. The Cowboy's game has me real edgy. Sorry for delayed reply.

2014-07-25T09:21:19+00:00

curaeus

Guest


Max, I hate to be picky but Balmain merged with Wests to form Wests Tigers some 15 years ago. It was Wests Tigers who won the game, not Balmain. Moreover and despite your implication that the Dogs lost due to biased refereeing, they won simply because they outplayed the Bulldogs who, in the 2nd half at least, were dreadful!

2014-07-25T07:08:09+00:00

MAX

Guest


Thanks Muzz, Please add tomorrow .

2014-07-25T07:05:02+00:00

Muzz

Guest


MAX - Your team is playing tomorrow night.

2014-07-25T06:59:33+00:00

MAX

Guest


Hi Alex , I do not begrudge Balmain their victory. I had anticipated the worst. The match was a prime example of how the attention by referees against one side early can crucify their chances . . This method of establishing 'control ' over the game has been used for decades. It is detrimental to all teams and to the code. Together with the soft penalty it is a major factor in our poor assessment of refereeing standards. We see how penalty counts are evened up. Enough said Tonight,my main concern is that the Cowboy's bad away record has to turn. I pray it is not tonight.

2014-07-25T04:34:52+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


I think the main difference is missed tackles in their own half. Bulldogs spent most of the game defending their line (and had done so the week before too) and were pretty obviously out of juice by the second half due to the big defensive efforts they had to make -- those ball drops from Mitch Brown and the penalty count (some of which was justified and some of which wasn't) basically killed any chance of it being a competitive game.

2014-07-25T04:14:25+00:00

mushi

Guest


I read that as they would stick to their game plan and not focus on the right hand side?

2014-07-25T04:01:12+00:00

Alex deLarge

Guest


The Bulldogs missed 26 tackles against the Tigers, which was fewer than winning teams last weekend like the Roosters (33), Broncos (28) and Titans (50). The young, enterprising Tigers used nous and speed to run around the bigger Bulldogs, rather than try to trample over the top and through them, or so it seems.

2014-07-25T01:28:24+00:00

FrozenNorth

Guest


Crazy? I picked 7 from 8 and the one I missed out on I forgot to change my pick on Thursday!

2014-07-25T00:48:30+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


Out of the five teams that he criticized you're upset that the tigers were included? They havn't exactly been the most consistant team this season... Or have you just been waiting for a Brian Smith article to vent?

2014-07-24T23:50:20+00:00

Western Fuglie

Guest


And one more cheap shot to the tigers .... Did you actually Finnish that coaching review or was it like the majority of your coaching carrer Abrasive inconclusive and incomplete?

Read more at The Roar