What to make of the 12-all Bledisloe draw?

By Digby / Roar Guru

The All Blacks and Wallabies fought out a tense and thrilling 12-all draw at ANZ Stadium in Sydney on Saturday night in terrible conditions, highlighted by tremendous defence from both teams.

Such a contest makes the glass half full for any fan.

The All Blacks and Wallabies produced a lacklustre, error ridden game and both teams were unable to adapt to the horrible conditions or referee’s whistle, with poor execution and options throughout the match.

On that assessment the glass is now half empty.

The Wallabies’ tremendous attitude and defensive pressure earned the rub of the green from Jaco Peyper, forcing the All Blacks to make numerous errors and concede penalties to keep them in the contest. The Wallabies will look to Eden Park with a lot of confidence knowing they can compete with this All Blacks team and break the Eden Park hoodoo.

Back to glass half full.

The Wallabies put in a solid display on Saturday night but despite earning the favour of Jaco Peyper and up against an out-of-sorts All Black team they were still unable to secure victory. Poor skill execution and option taking let them down at crucial moments and their best chance to secure victory over New Zealand has disappeared. They now face mission impossible at Eden Park next week.

Glass half empty.

The All Blacks will be disappointed not to secure the 18th straight win but can be very happy with the commitment and desperation to hold out against a committed and desperate Wallabies team away from home. In terrible conditions, and on the back of a pedantic refereeing display by Jaco Peyper, they will be relatively happy with the result knowing they will be much improved next week.

Glass half full.

The All Blacks were bitterly disappointing on Saturday night. Ill-discipline and unforced errors were costly and only an equally inept showing from the Wallabies kept them in the match. They were very fortunate to escape Sydney with a draw to their names after being out-muscled and out-enthused by an inexperienced Wallabies team who will head to Auckland with all the momentum.

Glass half empty.

There are various points of view one can take from a match that I found to be an incredibly frustrating but enthralling contest.

The Wallabies will be ruing their slow start to the match but as time wore on combinations started to click and confidence grew as the All Blacks, through a number of unforced errors, were unable to capitalise on their dominance in the opening minutes.

The Wallabies will be very happy with their defence, which was aggressive and forced a number of poor options and errors from the All Blacks. That is a very good sign of the positive mindset and attitude within this current squad.

I would give serious thought to starting Bernard Foley and Nick Phipps next week in Auckland. Their combination and understanding of each other would have been invaluable on Saturday night. At the very least, Phipps should be the starting halfback next week over Nic White, who had a less than memorable match.

The All Blacks will be disappointed knowing they had the ascendency early but allowed the Wallabies to wrest the initiative away from them. They were unable to bring themselves back into the contest but after losing men to the sin bin they were still able to hold on and fight out a draw in the end, an effort that they should be very proud of.

The All Blacks will know they are in for a real contest at Eden Park. Their skill execution and physicality at the breakdown was lacking at times and this will need to be improved.

Dane Coles’ substitution was inexplicable to me. He was having a fantastic match and his work rate and set piece work was top notch. I cannot understand why he was substituted and I cannot help but feel that this was a preordained move by the coaches.

When you saw the effort made by Nathan Charles, who was outstanding playing the full 80 on his starting debut, I thought it was a poor decision to sub Coles, who was easily one of the All Blacks’ best along with Richie McCaw.

Looking forward to next week, I believe that both teams have plenty to work on and both will be greatly improved to set up an exciting return match.

I still believe, however, that the All Blacks will win for one reason. Conrad Smith should be available.

Now I may be accused of bias here, but the All Blacks missed Conrad’s composure and decision making under pressure. His ability to organise the defence and identify opportunities are second to none and dare I say it, would have made a huge difference to the team on Saturday.

It is of no coincidence that the All Blacks have won more than 90 per cent of the games played with him in the team, and I expect him to be the key point of difference next week.

In saying that, there is no question this Wallabies squad is vastly improved from their 2013 team, and they are a very real chance of not only walking away from Eden Park with a victory but also giving this Rugby Championship a very real shake.

Eden Park shapes up as a classic match between these two Bledisloe rivals and it is going to be a long week waiting for kick off.

The Crowd Says:

2014-08-20T03:10:11+00:00

Ralph

Guest


That is not true.

2014-08-19T01:54:53+00:00

Harry Jones

Guest


Yes, let's hope for sunny dry tracks and 20 tries (8 for SA).

2014-08-19T01:07:03+00:00

SteveP

Guest


2014-08-19T01:07:01+00:00

SteveP

Guest


Well Armand, they probably would say they would do better, but then they have a standing disability in this matter don't they?

2014-08-18T23:07:01+00:00

Jerry

Guest


If you're referring to the penalty against Beale, it's a pretty basic law of rugby. If you've got the ball on the ground, you can get up (if not held), pass or release. You can't crawl. Savea got pinged for the exact same thing just prior to Crockett's card.

2014-08-18T20:40:49+00:00

Riccardo

Guest


We'll see on Saturday ZG. I think Dave is right actually. The All blacks have bounced back to shellack the same opponent, including the Wallabies. I think we'll see a pretty decent spectacle at Eden Park and a much truer reflection of where these two very good teams are at. The Bledisloe will stay where it is for now...

AUTHOR

2014-08-18T20:31:20+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Hi Armand, Thanks. I am not happy that we didnt play well in those conditions. Its not like we dont get opportunity!

AUTHOR

2014-08-18T20:30:41+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Thanks Harry. I am not to sure this drawing thing will stick ;) I have to say I was please that SA didnt get a bonus point on the weekend. The weather certainly helped out in that case.

AUTHOR

2014-08-18T20:28:33+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Hi Stu.B, Yes, didnt quite provide the impact I assume he is there for. Do you continue with him though? Perhaps it would be more beneficial for him to play a season of NRC and then head North at the end of the year. He has been chucked in the deep end somewhat. Will be interested to see if he is on the bench this weekend, should provide an insight on Links thoughts.

AUTHOR

2014-08-18T20:25:59+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Who would be your choice CH? I guess as a young Captain he will make mistakes, trick will be has he learnt from them. Always take the points.

AUTHOR

2014-08-18T20:24:33+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Ahh, right.

2014-08-18T17:09:30+00:00

Armand van Zyl

Roar Guru


Sup Diggercane, great article man. I don't think any conclusion can be drawn by these first games. Neither team adapted well, we are the Southern Hemisphere of course. I think the Northern Hemisphere laughed themselves silly at these games. No doubt they would have done much better in these conditions.

2014-08-18T15:40:42+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


The odds for a WB win is 5/1. NZ 1.15 to one Good time to get some of the young ones get some time on the paddock, assuming the ABs performs as expected

2014-08-18T14:00:12+00:00

Harry Jones

Guest


Digger The best summation of B1 that I've read; w this caveat: Only saw highlights bc I'm in Canada and had to rely on you You seem like the most honest Kiwi So I'm going w this viewpoint Very nice situation for SA Can you ANZACers keep drawing? If we win-win-win-win in Perth/Cape Town (w/o bonus points) we'll have a nice little lead if you keep drawing

2014-08-18T13:51:11+00:00

Goose and Gander

Guest


Watch out BB, you aren't allowed to make an objective assessment of the referee's performance according to Pirates. Listening to him, JP had a perfect game and any questioning of his decisions if sour gapes.

2014-08-18T13:44:32+00:00

Goose and Gander

Guest


Why did the Aussie scrum get away scott free in the last 10 min? Aussies have no trouble complaining about the ref when it suits them and any objective assessment of the game will include the refs performance. To dismiss that as 'don't blame the ref, every decision he made was perfect and the problems are all of your own doing' is childish. Are you yet another from the the Phil Kearns school that views the Wallabies as perfect angels who never deserve to be penalised and any loss is due to cheating (Ritchie McCaw especially) by the opposition, the ref or both.

2014-08-18T12:54:31+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Guest


20 points in the first 20 mins?... WOW. The game I went to, I saw one clear chance by the AB's (to score a try that is. Early, about 5 - 6 mins in Aaron Smith passed to Dane Coles who was into a gap I think less than 20 metres from the line. Outside him were 2 other supporting All Blacks against one defender. Coles spilt the pass cold... opportunity lost. Held it and he would probably have scored himself. Would have changed the result?... who knows as it was so early on in the game when the AB's seemed to be all over the Wallabies. Other than that single clear opportunty the Wallabies held there line, a few half breaks shut down by resolute defence, simple errors punctuating a stop start game but I saw no other threatening opportunities created by the men in black. The Wallabies created the greater pressure and had a couple more threatening thrusts in the game I watched. With the numbers advantage for 20 minutes, no question in my mind that if just a mite more clinical and the Wallabies would have won and who could have denied them that?

2014-08-18T12:53:13+00:00

Engineer

Guest


As much as both teams scored, at the very least

2014-08-18T12:32:53+00:00

PiratesRugby

Guest


Why don't you watch the game before commenting?

2014-08-18T12:21:28+00:00

Zero Gain

Guest


Guru of fantasy...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar