My thoughts on the Rosberg-Hamilton incident

By Ryan Eckford / Roar Guru

It has been nearly a week since the infamous contact between Mercedes drivers Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg at the Belgian Grand Prix at Spa Francorchamps.

I have thought about the incident, watched the replays and looked at the comments from the drivers’ steward for the race, former F1 driver Emanuele Pirro.

James Allen on F1 reported that Pirro spoke with Italian sports newspaper, La Gazzetta dello Sport.

“We needed less than 10 seconds to decide that the contact was innocuous and not worth pursuing,” Pirro said.

“It was something venial that had unfortunate consequences, but the contact came in a few millimetres, in other words neither of the two cars had sudden movements.”

“There was no intention, perhaps Rosberg was a little cunning and clever to try it, but in the end the main problem was what happened within the team. The contact between Alonso and Vettel on the final lap, for example, was much clearer, but there again there was no investigation.”

However, I’d like to use footage of the incident to debate that. What I saw was a couple of sudden movements, not extravagant, but sudden none the less, by Rosberg with his steering wheel before contact with Hamilton, which consequently damaged Hamilton’s rear tyre, and Rosberg’s front wing.

I ask you, does this look familiar from Rosberg? Remember earlier this year in Monaco in qualifying?

Again, a couple of sudden movements with the steering wheel, designed to miss the corner/racing line, and cause trouble to his teammate.

You might say that the contours of the track caused this mistake from Rosberg, but Rosberg has raced and visited Monaco many times before, and knows that he can cause a yellow flag there and prevent his teammate from completing his flying lap. Rosberg’s reaction after getting pole position after this incident was absolutely disgraceful, and his reaction at Spa after the race was also disgraceful.

What is even more disgraceful was that it took the Fédération Internationale de l’Automobile (FIA) stewards at the race meeting, Emanuele Pirro, Gerd Ennser, Enzo Spano and Yves Bacquelaine, less than 10 seconds to make their minds up about the incident. Surely, considering the standing of these two drivers in the world championship, it deserved a much longer review than 10 seconds.

However, these four stewards had no habitus at that particular moment. For anyone who may not know the word habitus means, it is ‘a feel for the game’. It’s surprising considering the roles that the stewards were given by the FIA, they know the sport and the game inside-out. What I saw from the replays, however, gives significant doubt to Pirro’s explanation of the incident.

However, this is the second time in a relatively short period that Rosberg has made similar mistakes, which has given him a sizeable advantage over his teammate. I’m not sure what to think, but many people would think that his actions and conduct are as close to coward-like as you can get.

There would be good reason for him to be acting in this way, as his dad, 1982 Formula OneWorld Champion Keke Rosberg, criticised seven-time World Champion Michael Schumacher for his deliberate actions during qualifying at the 2006 Monaco Grand Prix, and (Nico) Rosberg may not want to reveal his actions to avoid feeling the wrath from his Rosberg senior.

However, the bigger question is, what are Mercedes going to do about this? I think they should drop him for one race for breaking team protocol, but that won’t happen as the bosses at Mercedes, Toto Wolff and Paddy Lowe, don’t have the guts. Both of them have shown no guts in their leadership, and everyone knows that for success to happen, you must have a ‘no guts, no glory’ approach.

As for Rosberg, if he is a coward, which I’m not saying that he is, well then he should be punished by the appropriate authority. And, as we all should know, cowards will always lose in the end.

The Crowd Says:

2014-09-01T02:36:22+00:00

Pete

Guest


Why even use the word "Coward" using it and then saying I am not saying he is is very much what you are calling him. You know better then 4 very experienced stewards ... Really!!! Please tell me which team would drop their number one contender for the Championships, saying Mercedes have no guts again is just stupid. No team racing would drop their leader without being forced to. All in all a very ordinary article making very little sense.

2014-08-30T22:29:37+00:00

Wrappaper

Guest


Isn't it weird how the commonwealth media has found a German villain once again. They blamed Vettel for Webber's mistakes, now they're blaming Rosberg for Hamilton's. How about letting people just race and stop the constant whining? How about that?

2014-08-30T11:52:25+00:00

Distant Knight

Guest


I don't really care which one of these 2 drama queens wins the title, if they don't take themselves out in the meantime. But I do know which one of them has a former F1 driver as his dad, who also just happened to race alongside many of the former drivers that have been in the stewards room so far this year. If I just watched this latest contact in isolation, I'd 100% say it was just a racing incident and get on with enjoying the great racing we are seeing this year. But when you consider the Monaco qualifying mishap, the lack of a safety car in Germany, and now this one in Spa, something is starting to smell a bit rotten from the Barbie side of the Merc garage.

AUTHOR

2014-08-30T00:49:12+00:00

Ryan Eckford

Roar Guru


READ THE ARTICLE! This is what I said, "As for Rosberg, if he is a coward, which I’m not saying that he is, well then he should be punished by the appropriate authority." The appropriate authority may not necessarily be the FIA. I wrote before this that, "However, the bigger question is, what are Mercedes going to do about this? I think they should drop him for one race for breaking team protocol, but that won’t happen as the bosses at Mercedes, Toto Wolff and Paddy Lowe, don’t have the guts. Both of them have shown no guts in their leadership, and everyone knows that for success to happen, you must have a ‘no guts, no glory’ approach." Not once did I say the FIA in that part of the article.

AUTHOR

2014-08-30T00:45:08+00:00

Ryan Eckford

Roar Guru


And, I am not a fan of any particular driver.

AUTHOR

2014-08-30T00:44:35+00:00

Ryan Eckford

Roar Guru


Have you watched the footage? Can you give us your analysis of the incident?

AUTHOR

2014-08-30T00:43:26+00:00

Ryan Eckford

Roar Guru


What rubbish do I write? Name an article that I have written other this one that you think is rubbish, and I will explain the article to you.

AUTHOR

2014-08-30T00:40:56+00:00

Ryan Eckford

Roar Guru


Read the article. This is what I said, "I’m not sure what to think, but many people would think that his actions and conduct are as close to coward-like as you can get." "There would be good reason for him to be acting in this way, as his dad, 1982 Formula One World Champion Keke Rosberg, criticised seven-time World Champion Michael Schumacher for his deliberate actions during qualifying at the 2006 Monaco Grand Prix, and (Nico) Rosberg may not want to reveal his actions to avoid feeling the wrath from his Rosberg senior." I later said that, "As for Rosberg, if he is a coward, which I’m not saying that he is, well then he should be punished by the appropriate authority. And, as we all should know, cowards will always lose in the end." I did not say that he was a coward as you seem to think I did, but the way that he has been thinking would make many people think that. I was just saying that. READ THE ARTICLE!

2014-08-30T00:19:12+00:00

Scuba

Guest


Sorry, think I'll probably side with Emanuele Pirro over another Hamilton fanboy

2014-08-29T23:51:17+00:00

GD66

Guest


Where in the FIA rulebook are there penalties outlined for cowardice ? This is what you've come up with after a week ? If Hamilton's left rear had taken Rosberg's wing endplate off, it would have been regarded as no more than an unfortunate brush. The subsequent puncture, and Hamilton's petulant response have made it more than it was. Move on...

2014-08-29T23:16:06+00:00

AJ

Guest


What rubbish you write.

2014-08-29T22:59:24+00:00

Simoc

Guest


Stupid cowardly article. Why did you write coward? Dumb stuff.

Read more at The Roar