Slater's out, so who is the Kangaroos next fullback?

By Ben Lott / Roar Pro

Injury has ruled Billy Slater out of the Four Nations, leaving the door open for either Jarryd Hayne or Greg Inglis to take the custodian’s role.

Billy may have played his last Test in green and gold, but surely the battle for his spot isn’t a two-horse race?

Form suggests there are other challengers for the No.1 jersey. Let’s look at the Kangaroos’ options.

Greg Inglis
The favourite, because he wears maroon in Origin, and you Blues all love a Queensland conspiracy. I joke, I joke.

Let’s look at his 2014 stats. GI played 22 games this year, scored 10 tries, had 14 try assists, averaged 14 runs per game for 157 metres, busted 4.5 tackles per game, had 0.7 line breaks, with 0.5 offloads. That’s not bad for a ball-hogging back-rower, really.

His 3 penalties and 15 errors are good stats, and we all know he’ll get try of the year, and give Brisbane players and fans nightmares forever.

Jarryd Hayne
The Hayne Plane fell out of the sky after Origin, and the train derailed not long after, but he seems to still be the media’s darling. Granted, he appears to be a nice guy, and players, fans and coaches speak highly of him, but let’s check out his numbers.

The NRL’s leading try-scorer at season’s end, he had 20 under his belt before Parra’s atrocious for-and-against saw them miss the eight, and rightly so. Hayne played 22 games, had 14 assists, averaged 12 passes a game, 15 runs for an average of 180 metres, 6.2 tackle busts, 1 line-break and 0.8 offloads. Hayne gave away 13 penalties, and made 29 errors.

He might be good at scoring points, but he makes mistakes, and is a bit of a turnstile in defence.

Brett Stewart
It’ll never happen, but the Manly fans would have my neck in a noose if his name wasn’t included here.

Brett played 23 games this year, 1 better than Hayne and Inglis, for 10 tries, with 22 assists. He averaged 17 passes, 10 runs and 87 metres. His 2.7 tackle busts, 0.5 line breaks and 0.6 offloads are about average, giving away only 1 penalty all year, however, he made a huge 25 errors.

Matt Moylan
A bolter for sure, but many have talked up his chances this year, not just Gus Gould.

Moylan missed only 1 regular season game, had 8 tries and 17 assists. He made an average 29 passes, 13 runs for 116 metres, with 2.7 tackle busts, 0.5 line breaks and 1 offload per game.

Moylan gave away only 8 penalties, but is the worst so far, with 31 errors. Not bad, considering it’s his second year in the NRL.

Anthony Milford
Another with a huge question mark, Brisbane-bound Milford has played all bar 2 games this year, with 12 tries, and 14 assists. He average 16 passes per game, 12 runs for 105 metres and 4.6 tackle busts. His 0.7 line breaks and 1.1 offloads per game are good stats, too.

Milford gave away a lowly 6 penalties in a terrible Canberra side, but made a whopping 32 errors, the worst in this list.

I don’t really see him in with much of a chance, but he is in the running, so fair is fair.

Darius Boyd
Okay, we are getting a bit ridiculous here, but Darius is a fullback. He played a lowly 15 games, but his battle with depression is a fair excuse for that.

Darius didn’t have a good year, scoring only 3 tries, with only 5 assists. His 16 passes, 11 runs and 111 metres aren’t bad, but 3.5 tackle busts, 0.3 line breaks and 0.1 offloads are a bit average.

He only gave away 2 penalties, and made 10 errors, not surprising, given the lack of game-time.

Anthony Minichiello
Okay, he obviously won’t be considered by selectors, but he should be, and here’s why.

Mini played 26 games this year, had 15 tries and 1 assist. We’ve known for years he is a ball hog on par with Justin Hodges, so it’s not a surprising stat. His 10 pass-per-game average backs up his ball-hog stats, with 12 runs and 109 metres to go with it all.

The Count averaged 2.2 tackle busts per game, 0.5 line breaks, and 0.3 offloads, again, reliable, but unsurprising. He gave away 6 penalties, which, in a Roosters side whose coach acknowledged strategic use of penalties as a tactic, is rather decent. His 41 errors, however, isn’t.

There are three realistic options, but two contenders.

Moylan has the chops, the skills and the tactics to fill the role, and probably do better than Slater, but not the experience. Inglis and Hayne stand out in the crowd, but it’s the Hayne plane about to take off in the No.1 role. Granted, 2014 and 2009 were good years for him, but he was mediocre at best aside from that.

Inglis deserves it, he is safer in the role, makes less mistakes and is a much better defender, but Hayne will get it, because the ‘Roos need points.

The Crowd Says:

2014-09-24T00:57:32+00:00

Brett the Manly Fan

Guest


http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/league-news/brett-stewarts-charms-can8217t-save-manly-sea-eagles-20140919-10jlat.html Brett is a better fullback then Inglis and Hayne combined

2014-09-23T23:35:38+00:00

Scrubbit

Guest


That's not true. Hayne played centre for Parra early in his career

2014-09-23T11:43:13+00:00

Matthew Edwards

Roar Pro


I think healthy GI is better than Hayne… He clearly isn't healthy though and I imagine he will pull out anyway… There is a difference between saying you would put him centre and saying you think he isn't good. In saying that. I have as much chance of playing for the Kangaroos at fullback as Moylan.

2014-09-23T11:13:29+00:00

Matthew Edwards

Roar Pro


I think you are selling GI short, Give him an offseason to pile that weight back on (if he decided to be a prop) and I could say he could play 1-13. If he felt so inclined inglis would be a great back rower as well. the guy is a fantastic athlete, so is Hayne, Hayne might even be a better RL player. But Inglis is a special athlete on a level Hayne is not.

2014-09-23T11:03:02+00:00

Kevin dustby

Guest


Better relationship? He's never played fullback with that spine

2014-09-23T06:52:45+00:00

Parrafan

Guest


The difference though Josh is that Tedesco is made of glass. You can have all the talent and potential but if you're constantly injured it's a case of coulda, shoulda, woulda.

2014-09-23T06:51:36+00:00

Roarsome

Guest


Do you think Inglis even deserves a centre spot then?

2014-09-23T05:55:00+00:00

JB

Guest


Early days to compare to one of the greats but I have to agree I've thought the same about Moylan too and it's clear he has the temperament and skills to have a 6 on his back

2014-09-23T05:43:41+00:00

Parrafan

Guest


Lol, as Clark said it's an opinion site. Ben doesn't think Hayne is a good fullback. Everyone has pointed to stats that show he has been one of the most consistent this year in an ordinary club team. I for one think if Clark can back Hayne for number one anyone else could.

2014-09-23T04:34:47+00:00

jamesb

Guest


I love the way Moylan plays. There are some elements to his game that reminds me of a young Lockyer.(I'm not saying he will be as good as Locky) At the end of the day, it probably comes down to either GI or Hayne. International rugby league is very important. PNG hunters are in the Q Cup. Soon you see PNG players playing in the NRL.Fiji will also field a side in the NSW cup from 2016. We should never squash international rugby league. In fact, let's try and improve on it.

2014-09-23T04:32:33+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


Inglis looks like he is playing a bit hurt. If the Roosters lose it will be due to a Mini error again or mistackle.

2014-09-23T04:16:05+00:00

Clark

Guest


Come on, it is a sports OPINION site after all.

2014-09-23T04:04:58+00:00

mattray

Guest


And yes let's crucify hayne because he can't beat 17 players by himself...Ben Lott you are a disgrace. I will never read your biased written vomit again

2014-09-23T04:02:15+00:00

mattray

Guest


Can you tell me what game hayne played for the kangaroos in 2014?? He was injured in the Anzac test. What happened ben? Does your gf have a crush on hayne or something? He saved the series in game 2 stopping thaiday? So much for a turnstile

2014-09-23T03:58:36+00:00

mattray

Guest


Are you forgetting hayne stopping thaiday from scoring in game 2?? If thaiday scores qld win the series. His play was just as important as hodkinson try...Typical hayne hater

2014-09-23T03:43:24+00:00

Parrafan

Guest


I smell a heavy bias here Ben. The stats don't lie, but your analysis surely does.

2014-09-23T03:36:33+00:00

The Barry

Guest


Fair enough. Game 1 he absolutely dominated the game like very few have.

2014-09-23T03:36:31+00:00

Clark

Guest


For me it isn't a matter of who is the better fullback, it is who is the better centre, someone who can partner with a potentially inexperienced counterpart. So in that case I would take Hayne at FB

2014-09-23T03:34:49+00:00

Clark

Guest


Don't think anyone will stop JT mainly because his form push the Cowboys to a finals place, something Hayne couldn't do. The only thing I think will stop Thurston getting the Dally M is another conspiracy plot twist

2014-09-23T03:20:40+00:00

Chook

Guest


Inglis has been missing in action for 75 percent of this year - I am not saying it wasnt for a reason but whatever the reason he will have to stand aside for Hayne come the 4 nations if there is any justice

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar