Spring Carnival review: Foreign raiders continue to dominate

By Brent Ford / Roar Guru

It started with a flurry of Group 1s and ended with Éclair Big Bang sneaking home to win the last race of the spring racing carnival.

But again it was another year that the international horses dominated our big races.

The Caulfield Cup, Cox Plate and Melbourne Cup were all won by overseas horses, which again highlights the Australian racing industry’s recent difficulty in producing world-class stayers.

For mine it’s down to the lack of true 3000m races and connections wanting a quick return on investment, where there are plenty of staying races in both Europe and Asia which is why we see so many true stayers from those countries.

As we have seen with some staying horses of late they take time to mature. Red Cadeaux is the prime example – the English stayer produced some stunning results, including a second placing in this year’s Melbourne Cup as a nine-year-old. Precedence could be held in the same regard after a good showing this year as a nine-year-old with plans to bring him back next year as a ten-year-old.

While I would love to see Australian horses win these races, it’s special when the world’s best stayers make their way to our country for the spring carnival, especially when there is an Australian on-board.

My defining moment of the carnival was the late Admire Rakti’s barnstorming performance in the Caulfield Cup to deliver Zac Purton his first Group 1 victory.

Kiwi James McDonald had given Rising Romance the perfect run along the rails and with 200m to go he looked the certain winner, only for Admire Rakti to motor through the middle of the track late and head Rising Romance in the closing stages.

The iconic vision of Purton on top of the Japanese stayer with his fists pumping is something that will stay with me for years to come.

Ryan Moore also proved he’s world class, steering home Irish horse Adelaide in the Cox Plate. It was a perfectly timed run with Adelaide holding off a number of runners late to give Aidan O’Brien another Group 1 in his stellar training career.

Moore was again involved in history when he led German horse Protectionist to this year’s Melbourne Cup. Protectionist became the first German-bred horse to win the Melbourne Cup in 154 starts.

The good news out of all of this is that we will see Protectionist in the autumn racing carnival in Sydney after he joined the stable of Kris Lees.

The Cup was marred with the sad passing of Admire Rakti from Sudden Death Syndrome, and Araldo who sadly was spooked on his way back to the stalls before shattering his cannon bone.

These are tragic circumstances but are rare occurrences, and both deaths sent the racing industry into sadness.

Once again the sprint races gave us some epic finishes and Terravista stamped his mark as a world-class sprinter in the final Group 1 of the spring carnival.

All the tips were with Team Hawkes Chautauqua to take out the Darley Classic, but Joe Pride’s Terravista was able to back up his tweet from earlier in the carnival where he declared his runner the best sprinter in the world.

It was a stunning finish, with Terravista slicing through the field late before holding off Chautauqua with the well-respected Lankan Rupee finishing third.

While Lankan Rupee’s spring this year wasn’t as stunning as last year, he provided us with a brilliant highlight in the Group 1 Manikato Stakes.

There was five horses split across the Moonee Valley track but it was Craig Newitt on Lankan Rupee who got the chocolates. Angelic Light was a gallant second and Famous Seamus was an eye-catching third.

The result was still unknown after a marathon protest but eventually the protest was dismissed and Lankan Rupee was declared the deserving winner.

It was his return to form in that race that silenced his critics, especially after Queenslander Buffering was able to get the job done in the Group 1 AJ Moir a few weeks earlier.

Damien Oliver was again brilliant in the carnival, gaining six wins during the Melbourne Cup week, and Dwayne Dunn again showed why he is one of the best.

I did feel for Tommy Berry however after both his rides in the Melbourne Cup were scratched and both he and Craig Williams missed out on the biggest race in Australia.

I did say before the spring carnival that we would see an apprentice have a breakout spring and Winona Costin was excellent in Sydney. She’s come a long way since May where she rode her first Saturday winner, and a few weeks ago was in stellar form booting home winners at will early on the card at Canterbury.

Again like most apprentice jockeys it will be whether she will be able to ride consistently without a claim, but she has undeniable talent and will go on to bigger and better things.

Horses we saw dominate the Championships on bog tracks struggled to hold their form in the spring carnival this year. The wet tracks of Sydney provided us with a false Melbourne Cup favourite in The Offer, which was eventually scratched.

Bring Me The Maid was the early favourite in the Caulfield Guineas, but without the rain the horse was unable to mount a charge, as Shooting to Win was able to beat the highly favoured Rich Enuff.

It was a carnival with plenty of surprises and memories, and getting to experience the last day of the carnival at Flemington on Saturday is something that I won’t be forgetting in a hurry.

No doubt I will be suffering withdrawals until the next Group 1 race in February.

The Crowd Says:

2014-11-14T06:08:48+00:00

BrisburghPhil

Roar Guru


Thing is Brent these aren't the worlds best stayers coming here from overseas. They are generally B Graders whilst the best go for the Arc in France or the big meetings in the U.S. & Japan. That makes it even more embarrassing for us.

2014-11-12T07:43:14+00:00

Michael shumack

Guest


Focus on the real stars of the spring, the three year olds. Remember the deeds of Hallowed Crown early spring, and the storming win by Shooting to win in the guineas and of course the best win of the carnival,in my opinion, Brazen Beau . The Sydney autumn and the following spring may well be unmatched.

AUTHOR

2014-11-11T00:34:49+00:00

Brent Ford

Roar Guru


Thanks KV! If I'm honest I hadn't heard of Slade Power til early last week. I don't take too much interest into runners until they enter 'our backyard' per say :) Yeah I just felt like Lankan Rupee just wasn't as good, he still came away with the Group 1 but it's a shame that he has been gelded because his progeny could've been stars. I love the comparisons between forms. On the weekend I thought Terravista on a straight track would measure up well. Chautauqua is world class but 58.5kg was too much for my liking for a horse who had been carrying 56.5 and 54 in previous outings. Yeah true as well if Lord Gordon Byron was in the Darley he would've been in the same position. I can't believe when I saw the margins how far back Slade Power actually was.

2014-11-11T00:28:31+00:00

kv joef

Roar Guru


Actually Brent, i think you mentioned that LR was a length or so under his spring form. just looking at the my numbers now and he looks to be returning 120/121 down 2 pts from 123 ... well done. I know you are probably on top of the following but for those who find international form hard to read ... i took a different line with Slade Power. thought both his Timeform and OTR rating was too high. This year in Europe his OTR jumped to 120 for his last 2 runs from a steady mark 115 he had for the previous 18 months. When dissecting SPower's form it was soon realised, everytime he met a quality sprinter ... he wasn't so flash. From our point of view he had met Lord Gordon Byron twice - he was defeated last year and beat him at Ascot this year when he LGB started FU ... also, LGB had beaten Topics by the same margin as Slade power. What chance LGB in the Darley? We know from last years TJSmith that LR served it up to LGB in no uncertain terms beating him 4L. there are other things but significant was that SPower was found wanting everytime the speed got close to an equivalent 69s. It seemed to me that the only chance he had was if Buffering was left alone and slowed the pace by a second to a 70s, that would bring him into the race. Highly unlikely in that field. Interesting that LR beat SPower home by 4.5L which married up to the LGB autumn formline. he went as good as he could at that speed :) .

AUTHOR

2014-11-10T23:42:19+00:00

Brent Ford

Roar Guru


Not the funniest thing I've heard but. Someone at Flemington on Saturday said they should try and turn Lankan Rupee into a stayer as he doesn't seem to be quite as quick anymore. I nearly sprayed my beer all over him. It's an interesting point of them struggling with sprints, as I thought Slade Power would've done alright had he been loaded in last. Obviously something was wrong with him though. We all must remember Black Caviar was nearly beaten in England but that perhaps wasn't the best of travels for her. I don't think we would've heard the end of it from the English had she been beaten!

2014-11-10T23:02:37+00:00

kv joef

Roar Guru


Ah you were funn'in ... i reckon we could solve the OS winning invasion on our races by making 1400m the longest distance we run over. see if they can beat us then :) ...

AUTHOR

2014-11-10T22:50:48+00:00

Brent Ford

Roar Guru


Haha not too sure what happened there but it's been fixed :)

2014-11-10T21:36:08+00:00

kv joef

Roar Guru


" ... Terravista stamped his mark as a world-class stayer ..." who's a cheeky boy then :)

Read more at The Roar