International rugby in review: Week 2

By Rugby Fixation / Roar Guru

The second week of the Spring Tour is over and boy what a week it was!

In the course of just a few hours, the majority of the 20 teams competing for the coveted Webb Ellis Cup in 2015 battled it out in a weekend of highly entertaining and well-contested matches.

In fact it’s taken this long to find time to watch and review each match, but not one of the games was I disappointed with the spectacle on show.

All teams in the Rugby Championship will be succinctly analysed, but I’ll do my best to provide news on all games.

England 21 – New Zealand 24
As the highest-ranked match of the weekend, spectators and viewers alike were sure for a show when two of the top contenders for Rugby World Cup 2015 locked horns.

New Zealand have never embraced, nor deserved, underdog status and they showed why with a fantastic second half performance. Despite playing at Twickenham, a fortress in its own right, New Zealand found strength under pressure.

With New Zealand trailing 14-11 at half time, courtesy of a nifty Jonny May try mixed with Owen Farrell’s boot, the Kiwis turned to Richie McCaw for the turnaround, his 45th minute try bringing the visitors back in front.

It was also McCaw’s leadership that bound his team together when hooker Dane Coles was sent off 10 minutes later. During this time New Zealand outscored England 3-0, applying even more pressure than they had previously despite being down a man. A deserved try by Charlie Faumuina extended the gap before a penalty try to England in the dying stages of the match added credibility to the scoreboard after a poor second half.

Sonny Bill Williams continued to show why his automatic Test recall was deserved while the battle for the coveted 10 jersey wasn’t resolved after Aaron Cruden and Beauden Barrett played great, controlling matches.

England were without a lot of their regular starting players and still put on a great display, especially their first half. They also have a lot of options at 10, but neither Owen Farrell nor George Ford did anything to warrant automatic selection.

It was the result most expected. No matter where you play, there is no such thing as an easy match against the world’s number one outfit.

As for this coming weekend, New Zealand will take great confidence heading to Murrayfield to verse Scotland, and will take the opportunity to test other improving All Blacks. England will have a far harder assignment against South Africa, but will take a lot of anger from their loss and put it into a sterling performance against another Southern Hemisphere powerhouse.

Australia 33 – Wales 28
Another improved performance from the men in gold and suddenly things are looking up. Slightly.

The performance was still far from perfect, but Michael Cheika will be happy with his two from two record and the fact that Australia managed to close out a game against an impressive Welsh team.

The Wallabies finally found the necessary means of involving Israel Folau with purpose, and the result was two tries to the Waratahs fullback in the first half. Coupled with a rampaging run from the human wrecking ball, Tevita Kuridrani, the Wallabies did enough to make up for some poor defence to go into the second half at 21 all.

The second half was a story of the forward pack though, with all try-scoring momentum halted, save for a Welsh penalty try courtesy of their reserve front-row out-muscling us close to our line.

Cue Bernard Foley. The Wallabies 10 calmly slotted two penalties prior to the Welsh penalty try, but it was his unplanned drop goal to regain the lead that proved his class and showed he’s a Test-level flyhalf. Another penalty goal soon after helped extend the Aussies to the final score, but it didn’t come without its fair share of fright, as for the third match in a row the Wallabies kicked away possession in the final seconds.

The best performances on the field go to Welsh hooker Richard Hibbard, a standout in general play, Dan Lydiate, and Leigh Halfpenny (before his concussion led to an early exit). For the Wallabies it was the previously mentioned Waratahs pair Foley and Folau, as well as a dynamic Michael Hooper, whose quick-thinking and Energizer Bunny legs set up one of Folau’s tries and gained the forwards plenty of metres tight around the rucks’ edges.

Wales can expect a much easier game against Fiji, though it won’t be a pushover. I expect more game time for Mike Phillips and a recall to the 23 for winger Liam Williams (coming back from injury) and James Hook following the injury of Dan Biggar and Halfpenny, two positions Hook has plenty of experience covering.

Australia will square up against France, a team they’ve already beaten three times this year. The challenge is intensified given the home ground advantage has shifted favours, but the result will remain the same.

Points of interest will be whether the 6-2 reserve ratio will keep given the different challenge that Les Bleus present. Sean McMahon had a great game for his first international Test debut, but if Scott Higginbotham recovers in time it will be interesting to see what happens with the backrow. Quade Cooper won’t oust Foley after that game, but a spot on the bench could be up for grabs. As for his Reds partner Will Genia, he provided a great bit of spark and quick ball upon entering the field, but his rival Nick Phipps was no slouch and should retain the starting spot for now.

Ireland 29 – South Africa 15
Well, didn’t this cause a a stir in the rugby community? Fresh from an impressive win against world champions New Zealand, South Africa were completely outgunned and outclassed in nearly every aspect of this thriller.

Even as a diehard Wallabies supporter, I happily state that the Irish team provided the performance of the week. Resolute in defence, quick on the ball and masters at the turnover – the forwards didn’t step a foot wrong. Combine that with the dominating lock pairing of captain Paul O’Connell and one of the world’s tallest rugby players, Devin Toner, the lineout was impressive even up against the ageing might of Victor Matfield.

The front-row was industrious at the set-piece and provided the opportunities for sharpshooter Jonathan Sexton to nail five from five penalty attempts. The perforamce was helped tenfold by Sexton’s immaculate tactical kicking, an area that South Africa just couldn’t master.

As for the standouts in this match, the tight five of Ireland as well as Sexton and Rob Kearney were all fantastic. Conor Murray also stamped his claim as one of the world’s best scrumhalves. For South Africa, it was hard to fault Beast Mtawarira and Eben Etzebeth, but Bismarck du Plessis and Duane Vermuleun didn’t have the same impact they usually do. This led to very few rucks in which the Springboks felt confident. As a result, Francois Hougaard played a very forgettable match and so his outside backs were presented limited opportunity to shine.

Ireland’s next game against Georgia won’t pose any problems, even if they field a largely experimental team, and as mentioned earlier, the Springboks have the hardest match of their tour against World Cup hosts England. My tip is South Africa by 4, but there won’t be much in it.

Both sides have a lot to prove if they are to stake their claims for next year’s tournament, but South Africa have a dangerous tendency of shining against the best opposition. This might be their shot at redemption.

Scotland 41 – Argentina 31
This was always sure to be a great encounter between two fairly evenly matched teams. The perennial underachievers in the Rugby Championship were fired up after a first ever win in the tournament, whereas Scotland are improving game-by-game under New Zealand-born coach Vern Cotter.

Unfortunately for South American fans, the scoreboard doesn’t really do justice to how much the Scots outclassed Los Pumas. Despite an early runaway try for the Argentinians, Scotland dominated the rest of the game to lead 34-10 up until the last 10 minutes of the match.

The lock combination of the Gray brothers proved to be too much for the Argentinian defence to cover, as both brothers crossed for tries inside the opening 25 minutes. Young flyhalf Finn Russell and the cool, calm and collected captain Grieg Laidlaw were also vital to the success of the Scottish, and their absence towards the end of the match showed as they let in a series of preventable tries.

It was hard to pinpoint standouts for the Argentinians as they had so few opportunities, especially in the second half, but replacement scrumhalf Tomas Cubelli was excellent when he came on the pitch and the centre pairing of Juan Martin Hernandez and Marcelo Bosch found some great form in patches.

Argentina will fancy their chances a lot more against Italy when they face each other on the weekend, whereas Scotland face an uphill battle against New Zealand. They have the team to test the All Blacks, but I think most would agree a win would be a massive stretch.

Elsewhere on the weekend, Pacific Island nations Fiji (40-15) and Samoa (24-13) lost to France and Italy respectively. Unlike Fiji, Samoa were in the game for a long part of the match, but the Azzurri fought back and claimed an impressive win against a team they’ve struggled against in the past.

Fiji’s job won’t get easier as they face a hungry Welsh outfit, but with Nemani Nadolo set to make a comeback to the starting team, their chances are improved greatly.

The only other successful Southern Hemisphere nation were Tonga, who overcame a slow first half to beat Georgia 23-9 with a strong showing from the impressive half Taniela Moa.

USA showed what they’d learnt against their massive loss to New Zealand last week to overpower Romania 27-17, while their neighbours Canada held off an ever-improving Namibia in a tight and low-scoring encounter, which ended at 17-13.

The Crowd Says:

2014-11-16T00:13:12+00:00

atlas

Guest


correction to Italy-Arg score it ended 18-20, my mistake didn't realise IRB score was updating as game went on the internationals, results so far Italy 18 - 20 Argentina Canada 13 - 23 Samoa French Barb 35 - 14 Namibia England 28 - 31 South Africa Wales 17 - 13 Fiji Romania 13 - 18 Japan Tonga 40 - 12 USA Scotland 16 - 24 New Zealand Hong Kong 27 - 39 Russia France 29 - 26 Australia to play: 16 Nov2014 Ireland v Georgia Big win for Tonga, and Russia wrap up their two test series v Hong Kong with their second win A three-try burst in six minutes raced Tonga away from the United States in a 40-12 rugby win at Kingsholm, Gloucester, UK, today. Until they beat Georgia 23-9 in Tbilisi last week, the Tongans had not win their previous six tests. Tonga 40 (Fetu'u Vainikolo, Viliami Ma'afu, Vunga Lilo, David Halaifonua, Nili Latu tries; Kurt Morath conversion, 3 penalties, Latiume Fosita conversion), United States 12 (Tim Stanfill, John Quill tries; Folau Niua conversion). HT: 14-12

2014-11-15T00:16:51+00:00

atlas

Guest


Samoa beat Canada overnight: A slow start and a string of mistakes cost Canada in a 23-13 loss to Samoa in a rugby test match Friday. Mike Stanley, in his first start for Samoa, kicked 13 points and the Pacific Islanders never trailed on a wet pitch at Stade de la Rabine. The 17th-ranked Canadians, who had a much better second half, closed the gap to 16-13 with less than 10 minutes remaining but gifted the Samoans a try on the ensuing restart and never recovered. Canada wrap up their tour Nov. 22 in Bucharest against No. 18 Romania. Samoa heads to London next for its date with No. 4 England at Twickenham.

2014-11-14T18:41:55+00:00

atlas

Guest


some more internationals this weekend . . . all important to those involved Played: Italy 15 v 17 Argentina Stadio Luigi Ferraris and Canada v Samoa Stade de la Rabine French Barb v Namibia Stade Felix Mayol England v South Africa Twickenham Wales v Fiji Millennium Stadium Romania v Japan Stadionul National Arcul de Triumf Tonga v USA Kingsholm Scotland v New Zealand Murrayfield Hong Kong v Russia Hong Kong Football Club Ground France v Australia Stade de France Ireland v Georgia Aviva Stadium Russia beat Hong Kong 31-10 last week, it's the 2nd of their two-test series today; and not an international, but the NZ Heartland XV (players from NZ's 14 3rd/4th div Heartland provinces) play their second match in Rarotonga, Cook Islands, today against the Cook Islands Residents XV, having won the first match on Thursday.

2014-11-14T14:53:45+00:00

Homer Gain

Guest


It is difficult to see how Stuart Lancaster can be "proved wrong". He didn't say Twickenham was a fortress, only that he wanted it to become one. When we are constantly told that Ellis Park and Eden Park are intimidating citadels of their respective rugby powers, why wouldn't an England coach want to gain the same psychological edge?

2014-11-14T13:38:03+00:00

Aidan Loveridge

Roar Pro


To be fair if those injured Scottish players were as good as Leguizamon Lobbe and Creevy you'd be right to think Scotland had no advantage but they did. At the same time this is rugby and people get injured so i agree it should not be used as an excuse because if your playing rugby for your country your the best that was available and should you lose well that's too bad they are currently better than you at rugby

2014-11-14T13:32:46+00:00

Aidan Loveridge

Roar Pro


Apart from set piece the Saffas were completely outplayed offensively and defensively i wanted South Africa to win but i have to admit they got owned.

2014-11-14T13:27:21+00:00

Aidan Loveridge

Roar Pro


Only in the World Cup otherwise its Oz or England

2014-11-12T15:07:58+00:00

Nobrain

Guest


Stats, stats, they do not mean much. You can make 200 tackles in a game but if you miss a key one you lose the game. I mean, at the end of the game the coaching staff of SA will be reading the stats and will not understand how the lost the game. They would say attitude , but a team that makes so many tackles, win so many line out, scrums, ect... it will be difficult to say the attitude was not there. I think they lost because they played a very talent but to young fly/half that was not able to control the game , in the other hand you have Sexton, a very talented and experienced fly/half that had control and managed to use the few balls he had in a magnificent way.

2014-11-12T14:55:10+00:00

Nobrain

Guest


The difference is those players are profesional, the 19 year argentines are college students that play rugby in their spare time. We can start an argument if it is ok that for Argentina to show up with so many amateur leaving many pro outside the team (Albacete, Carizza, Guinazu, ect..) but it seems that the coach have ulterior objectives to this window. Hourcaude on his own words has said that he wants to develop depth, I am still confuse about some of the old gard still play under the national shirt (Hernadez), and not developing players at key positions as scrum/half( only have Cubelli and Landajo) , Fly half (only Sanchez, you cannot count Iglesias as a fair replacement ), number 8, and Hooker. IMO there a key positions to any team that wants to compete at this level, Hooker,8, scrum/half, fly/half, and fullback.Is not that the other positions aren't important, but these are the ones that the ball touches the most thus have a strong influence on the functioning of any team.

2014-11-12T09:28:42+00:00

balotelli

Guest


@Rower..I dont agree with you there..... I wonder even for a team like the All Blacks if we ask them to remove their 5 leading backrowers if they will still be the All blacks... Add to that their 2nd and 3rd and 4th lock, plus early injury of their Captain and arguably the best hooker in the RC.....Even for well resourced teams like the Boks and the All Black they wont be the same.... Players like Baez,Guilleman,Ponce,Facunda Isa,Ortega Desio all have less that 5 tests with tier 1 opposition and Guilleman,Ponce and Isa were all debutants so i still mantain they beat a weakened Puma side...

AUTHOR

2014-11-12T07:01:02+00:00

Rugby Fixation

Roar Guru


Yeah, that's a fair call - especially in the first half. Hougaard had a shocker; with better delivery the backs would have had a better chance at finishing off try-scoring opportunities early on in the match.

2014-11-12T06:08:29+00:00

Common Sense

Guest


What I was trying to say is that South Africa were the dominant team but still lost.

AUTHOR

2014-11-12T05:12:29+00:00

Rugby Fixation

Roar Guru


I think what you've described his the impressive part about how they won. Their defence and ability in the rucks was fantastic, especially when you compare it to South Africa who are traditionally strong in those areas. Stats are useful in some matches, perhaps if you didn't watch the match, but this game has to be viewed in order to understand the dominance Ireland had.

2014-11-12T04:39:53+00:00

Rower who wishes he could play rugby.

Roar Pro


Well if you looked at the Scottish team and saw how many new, young players were playing. Not to mention new combos and a new coach. This makes any excuses about injuries irrelevant.

2014-11-12T04:21:30+00:00

Common Sense

Guest


I don't agree with your take on the Ireland v South Africa game. South Africa had all the stats from the game. Dominated the set piece, scrums, lineouts, mauls, territory, possession, offloads (Ireland had zero) and still found a way to lose by 14 points - almost 19 points. That's the most impressive part about Ireland's game and why stats are irrelevant, they don't tell you who won the game by stats alone. Ireland's defence, tactical nous, resilience and their ability to convert their very few opportunities won them the game. Contrast that with Welsh game when they didn't know how to create nor capitalise on their opportunities.

2014-11-12T04:14:30+00:00

Common Sense

Guest


France's worst enemy is France. New Zealand's worst enemy is France

2014-11-12T03:41:53+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


.

2014-11-12T03:41:05+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Good one Harry. Its going to be a belter for sure! Thanks to ABs and their fans for getting WBs back the 3rd spot. Now the same result from the Boks please :D As long as the WBs can lift their game against the French at home Very keen to see what scrums the WBs coach and his players deliver

2014-11-11T23:43:02+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Guest


I understand what you are saying and I agree, it is really a slap of the head for Stuart Lancaster who made such statements and yes it is it give some sort of motivation if you like to 'prove him wrong'. They also suggest that these matches have no relevance on the RWC... I disagree with that. It is my opinion, right or wrong, is a team (and this can be any team), is constantly (or at least frequently) being put to the sword by the same opponent, the mental aspects of the game come into play. When exhausted and I mean really exhausted and a team is chasing a team with a much more superior recent record, I cannot believe that the 'inspiration' to keep asking for more yet achieving a similar result (a loss) could be anything but demoralising. I maybe wrong but sometimes with all the best intentions in the world, beating one's head against a brick wall might seem futile, while they may not openly admit to it, I cannot help thinking that the mental advantages can be significant.

2014-11-11T23:11:43+00:00

JimmyB

Guest


RT the whole "fortress" thing is all a bit silly really. It doesn't really mean anything of value and is instead just another a stick for our SANZAR cousins to beat us with. The fact is that England play all of their home matches at Twickenham, unlike the rotations that occur down south and whilst it is a fantastic stadium it holds little fear or trepidation for visiting players seeing as most of them have played there on multiple occasions. On top of that the "Twickers" crowd are hardly the most vociferous supporters in world rugby, so it's never been or never is it likely to be an intimidating place to visit. This all adds up to Twickenham never likely being any kind of fortress, but instead just the place that England play their rugby.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar