Three Wallabies in BBC's Spring Tour Team

By Michael Essa / Roar Guru

With an array of talent to come back from injury next season, I believe there are only three Wallabies that have cemented their place in the line-up for season 2015.

These happen to be the same three players that were named by the BBC in a combined Rugby Championship Spring tour side.

The fact that this is a foreign entity gives much more credibility to the selection, especially when compared to what anyone on The Roar has said recently. There is no interstate bias at the BBC.

So who are the three wallabies? If you guessed they are all backs you’d be correct.

They are Israel Folau at fullback, Tevita Kuridrani at outside centre, and Bernard Foley at flyhalf.

So what was actually said about our boys?

Israel Folau
There’s a lot of competition for this shirt but the Wallaby full-back is an attacking force of nature. He’s an incredible athlete who always manages to slip the first tackle and he’s only been playing Test rugby for 18 months. The 25-year-old is wonderful under the high ball and a great talent who is a pleasure to watch.

(He) was the top metre maker this autumn (405m); also making the most carries (53) and most offloads (11).

Tevita Kuridrani
Centres these days are about the gainline but the 6ft 5in Wallaby is about more than just getting go-forward for his team. The 23-year-old makes clean breaks, scores tries and is a real handful – a very exciting attacking talent.

(He) completed 17 of the 18 tackles he had to make in his 205 minutes of game time.

Bernard Foley
You need a player to release this talented backline and Foley is the consummate 10. The 25-year-old has only played 18 Tests but he is a real general who knows when to kick, when to pass – and whether to go short or go wide- and is very reliable with the boot, keeping the score ticking over.

(He) was the top points scorer this autumn (spring), notching up 57 in 269 minutes of action, including two tries.

So there you have it.

Perhaps Folau had a quieter EOYT than what we expected, but it bodes well for him that even when he is quiet he still makes more metres than everyone else.

Now before Roarers all roar that he makes metres because he returns the ball from deep, think about the fact that for a lot of his carries he begins by taking up-and–unders, before almost always beating several defenders.

His ability to make 5-10 metres while being surrounded by tacklers is amazing and it is what sets him apart from every other fullback in world rugby.

In terms of Kuridrani, he has been brilliant since the Rugby Championship and I’m sure this will continue into next season.

He will have to continue to be as good to keep Ashley-Cooper on the wing. Ashley Cooper’s performance against England was superb and a timely reminder that he plays his best rugby also at 13.

I’ve said it before but Adam Ashley-Cooper made more run metres (159m) than the entire English backline put together last Saturday.

That is simply outstanding no matter how you want to spin it. On a side note, having watched the replay once more I saw no situation where Ashley-Cooper should’ve definitely passed the ball.

All that criticism about him not passing the ball is curious to say the least. Kuridrani, for example, is a player that has passed the ball less times than there have been world wars yet I have not heard one criticism of that part of his game. Curious.

In my opinion Kuridrani and Ashley-Cooper should continue to both be in the side somewhere.

But what about Foley? Many are calling for his sacking. For me he is just as safe to be a Wallaby starter at next year’s world cup as the other two mentioned by the BBC.

At the beginning of 2014 I wouldn’t have thought so but he is now the best flyhalf in the southern hemisphere. It helps that Dan Carter has been injured this year.

All the debate regarding Foley is a symptom of division among us. People want Quade Cooper in the side for suspicious reasons.

He hardly played the house down for the Reds this year and his game against the Barbarians was reflective of that.

This is my take on the Cooper v Foley argument. Cooper is in many ways the opposite of Foley.

Cooper is flashy and flamboyant, Foley is quiet and conservative.

Cooper plays deep and uses long passes to good effect where-as Foley plays extremely flat and relies on his short passing and off-loading while taking on the line.

Both have genuine claims to the no 10 shirt but one of these styles suits Michael Cheika and the other doesn’t.

The other point I would like to note is that Cooper doesn’t kick on average as many metres (Foley out-kicked everybody in terms of average metres in all four recent Tests) and Cooper isn’t as accurate at goal kicking. For me it’s a no brainer.

Foley has usurped Cooper and as long as he continues his form I believe he will be a stand-out Fly-half at the Rugby World Cup 2015, alongside the likes of Dan Carter and Johnny Sexton.

I believe many roarers have been clutching at straws to belittle the deeds of a player such as Foley.

Some are saying he doesn’t take on the line, which is inaccurate, and some are saying he can’t kick – when the evidence is to the contrary.

The fact is from a neutral’s point of view Foley is the best the entire southern hemisphere has to offer at the moment and we should be excited about that.

I for one am looking forward to 2015 with great anticipation.

The Crowd Says:

2014-12-13T22:14:08+00:00

neil

Guest


the team is a joke. I doubt foley would make the ABs ahead of any of the 4 #10s they took on tour.

2014-12-09T05:36:54+00:00

ScrumJunkie

Guest


'99, I think that's the point of his comment.

2014-12-09T00:24:25+00:00

Patrick D

Guest


For mine, Barret was very poor at first five against Wales. He showed when he made an impact from fullback that the ABs management have been using him wisely and how he is best suited. People are blinded by two tries. He lacked control, execution, vision and his defence is weaker than counterparts. Sexton is surely the player Foley should be compared to at the moment.

2014-12-08T03:51:41+00:00

bennalong

Guest


I don't like the term "butt-hurt". It sounds offensive (as I'm sure it was meant to sound) and American. I'm impressed Mr Essa is still responding. It is important to him that you get the idea he was proposing of an outsiders viewpoint. An outsiders viewpoint of a world team that includes his own nations players cannot be impartial.

2014-12-07T19:01:28+00:00

skirttheissue

Guest


....'teach a pig to sing' Abdul - gold ! :)) .....'Piggie, the pink-nosed Porker' would be a great one to start with.....being this time of year and all........

2014-12-07T18:21:22+00:00

Graeme

Guest


42 caps already. Bloody hell, he could make the 100 caps before he gets to puberty at this rate!

2014-12-07T13:05:36+00:00

Redbull

Guest


But your pick of the team is better than most!

2014-12-07T13:02:24+00:00

Redbull

Guest


See, that's where we differ. Me, I would say back to back Reds titles is close to wallabies winning World Cup and three in a row for reds I would take over wallaby World Cup any day

2014-12-07T12:43:33+00:00

Common Sense

Roar Rookie


Rob Kearney had a better year than Israel Folau.

2014-12-07T11:43:44+00:00

jack

Guest


I would add slipper, cooper and tomua to the automatic selection list. No one in oz can get a backline going like cooper and he has the tacticall nous. I would also like to see frisby given a invite to the rc along with genia and white; he had a blinder in the nrc but has always been understudy to genia. Unfortunately slipper is the only automatic selection in the forwards.

2014-12-07T06:32:35+00:00

44bottles

Roar Guru


Always look forward to some high-brow discussion with Alan Jones right Common Sense?

2014-12-07T06:31:55+00:00

44bottles

Roar Guru


For accuracy's sake, the line "she doth protest to much" was used in a completely different situation to how people quote it now. Gertrude was speaking about how the Player was showing her love for another too overtly. You may now continue.

2014-12-07T06:31:01+00:00

Common Sense

Roar Rookie


I love this. It's just like talk back radio!

2014-12-07T06:29:41+00:00

Common Sense

Roar Rookie


Me. That's my wet dream.

2014-12-07T03:31:14+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Barrett's two tries were from fullback after Slade subbed on.

2014-12-07T03:29:42+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Of course it's not true - the reality is that of the 80 times the Welsh have lost at home, the Welsh commentary team has given the MOTM to a Welsh player on 64 occasions.

2014-12-07T03:18:12+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Hi Michael, thanks for the post. Good to get Aussie representation in the list Taking off my Oz hat: - Controversial decision. - I would have thought BBC would pick a flyhalf who performed better over the year. eg Sexton Cruden Sanchez.Pumas - Folau I thought was bested by a few opposing 15s But well done, in any case QC and Foley are both good. I suspect they will be swapped next year. But we will see.

2014-12-07T02:27:26+00:00

Realist

Guest


Again you miss the point. At what times should have Kuridrani passed and didn't ? None that I can recall. However, we have at least 2 occasions against England that AAC stuffed by not passing. This has been a feature in his career.

2014-12-07T02:24:05+00:00

Realist

Guest


AAC made no impact at 13 in the rugby championship which is why he was dropped from the position. Kuridrani is a better 13 and can also set up his winger which AAC can't or won't do. Ironically it was Kuridrani who put AAC away against SA in SA.

2014-12-07T01:48:29+00:00

44bottles

Roar Guru


Reminds me of the theoretical exchanges I had with a few Blues/Hurricanes supporters. We'll give them one of our forwards like Romano or Bird for a nice big outside centre/winger like Moala, or Leuia. Maybe I should write a mock trade article. Everyone propose possible trades and we could have a nice big debate on it all, weighing up pros/cons and all.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar