My Test selection Christmas wish list

By Daniel Gray / Roar Guru

Dear Santa, or whoever Kitty Flanagan believes distributes presents globally in the event of your non-existence. Christmas is a time for giving. A time to stop and reflect on less fortunate people around us, like Greg Ritchie.

I don’t ask for much each year, Santa. Win, lose or draw, my main hope is that the Australian selectors won’t get sucked in to the hype around certain players, and will actually pick in-form players who can perform in the Test arena.

With this in mind, I humbly present my Test selection Christmas wish list.

A new number three
You already granted this wish before I had time to put my list in the mail, Santa. Joe Burns is an excellent choice. I’m glad to see you’ve been paying attention. I guess that means I need to come up with another wish.

The end of Shane Watson’s Test career
A few years ago, Watto was in his prime. Opening the batting seemed to suit his style, regular LBW dismissals aside. He was fairly injury-free, by his standards anyway, thanks to a new running style that resembled the trot of a constipated pony. Above all, he was an automatic selection at the time.

Fast-forward to 2014, and only the pony run remains. While the combination of Mitchell Marsh’s hamstring woes and Watto’s contributions with the ball will keep him safe for the remainder of the summer, after Sydney he should be marked ‘for ODI/T20 use only’.

Marsh has shown enough so far to indicate he is worth persisting with for the immediate future. If his injury battles rule him out of the next year’s Test series against the West Indies, Moisés Henriques, James Faulkner or even Sean Abbott would be a better option than Watson, should the selectors continue with their compulsive selection of all-rounders in the Test side.

For now, Watto’s 20s and 30s with the bat, along with a wicket or two in each innings, will be a sufficient return in his new home at number six.

A wicketkeeper who is in the side for more than leadership ability
“Brad Haddin has been a great servant of Australian cricket,” the press release could read.

“However, the national selection panel has decided that with the upcoming World Cup and Ashes series in England next year, now is the time to promote our next wicketkeeper.”

There are a few options for the name that can appear after the last sentence that I’d be happy with, as long they contain no words that rhyme with raid.

Peter Nevill? Sure. He’s been an outstanding performer for New South Wales for years, and would bring leadership and a level head to the role.

Sam Whiteman? His early season form hasn’t been great, but he’s an outstanding long-term prospect and would find his feet quickly.

Chris Hartley? The best gloveman in the country for several years would perform admirably on the big stage, and has at least four or five years of top level cricket left in him.

On recent form with bat and gloves, Tim Ludeman may even get a look-in.

The most important thing here is that despite my early season calls for Haddin to be retained for the summer, he hasn’t performed adequately to date. If Michael Clarke’s body had behaved itself, the keeping position would be up for more serious debate.

A few Test matches in front of home crowds before the World Cup and subsequent tours of the West Indies and England would provide our new gloveman with a great opportunity to settle into the side. However, the realist in me would also be happy to see Haddin get a tap on the shoulder after next year’s Ashes series in England.

A further injection of youth into the side
Rod Marsh and his selecting buddies have shown every intention of making this wish come true in recent weeks, with the additions of Josh Hazlewood and Burns to the Test side.

With the 2015 Ashes likely to be the end of the line for several veterans in the side, next summer will hopefully see a number of fresh faces sporting the venerable baggy green cap.

The selectors are certainly spoilt for choice, with strong batting, bowling and keeping candidates ready to step up and prove their worth in the Test arena.

For what it’s worth, here’s my side for the first Test in Brisbane next year: David Warner, Joe Burns, Usman Khawaja, Steve Smith, Michael Clarke (c), Mitch Marsh, Sam Whiteman, Mitchell Johnson, James Pattinson, Josh Hazlewood, Nathan Lyon.

That’s it for me, Santa. I know things have been rough for you in the past few years, with citizen journalists and social media making it tougher for you to do your job, but if you could find the time to re-jig the Test side for me, I’d be rather grateful.

Yours in anticipation,
Daniel

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2014-12-23T21:40:47+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Pretty sure the majority of people on here would prefer to see all players in the Australian side perform well, Don. I don't think criticising inconsistent, underperforming players is unique to fans from any particular country. Plenty of South African and Kiwi fans I know have been complaining about some of their players every time I speak to them. I appreciate class and performance, which I know both Watson and Shaun Marsh are capable of. This is one of the main reasons it's so frustrating to see them both floundering in recent Tests.

AUTHOR

2014-12-23T21:35:54+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


I think the point being made there, Don, is that Watson had one really strong season, which was followed by a AB medal victory. Aside from this, his international career to date has been marked with inconsistency, and his current place in the team appears to be based predominantly on performances from a few years ago. The hope that Watson somehow will regain form is no substitute for actual form.

AUTHOR

2014-12-23T21:33:15+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Correct, Don. My point was that Carters performed strongly for a whole season. Bancroft has started this season well, but we'll be able to conduct a more accurate comparison of the two players once this Shield season is over.

2014-12-23T13:20:38+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


That was the first season of 5 that Carters showed something.

2014-12-23T13:17:44+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Behrendorff, Hilfy and Hopes are better, more consistent swing bowlers than Sayers. When conditions diminish, so does Sayers' effectiveness. The others have secondary strings to their bows.

2014-12-23T13:12:57+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Some people just enjoy watching people fail and digging the boots in...then there are cricket fans who appreciate class and performance. The mocking of Watson and Marsh is an English and Indian thing. An Australian cricket fan doesn't do it.

2014-12-23T13:08:21+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


But if you take away anyone's success they will look like a failure. Was everyone wrong when he won the AB medal...or doesn't it suit you to acknowledge that he actually can play?

2014-12-23T04:07:22+00:00

SCC

Guest


7 runs nothing? That's 140 runs over a match if every wicket cost 7 more... All I am saying is that everyone seems to agree that form was a major reason of Burns' selection (which is great) but in terms of form players who can replace Clarke and his style of batting, no-one has shown better form this season than Marsh this year (ok, admittedly Voges but he has really improved his average since Marsh was selected). The other form players such as Cowan Bancroft and Burns have been playing as top order batsmen and were never in serious consideration to come in at 4 or 5. Also, I think you'll find that Marsh's average last year was impacted seriously by injury and international duties (ODIS v England, South Africa series) At the end of the day though, your comment that you have no idea how he got a recall is ridiculous. His form and undoubted talent always made him one of the frontrunners. One mediocre game doesn't change that fact, however much the benefit of hindsight might make you wish he wasn't

AUTHOR

2014-12-23T01:03:34+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


I like Faulkner in the shorter forms of the game, but not confident enough in his batting to have him at 6 in the Test side. He is certainly a super competitor, and very good in ODIs and T20s.

2014-12-23T00:50:37+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


I'd love to see Watson given a chance batting at 5 or 6 and if he fails, drop him permanently. Would also love to see Faulkiner picked ; he's just about the best ODI player in the world at the moment. I know his Shield stats aren't persuasive, but sometimes you just have to recognise a competitive beast. His left-arm pace would bring great options to our attack, once Harris returns to take Starc's place. Mitch Marsh has been impressive and should return to side once fit, to replace whichever player performs worst out of Watson and Faulkiner. I've said it before on here, but Smith is the most qualified batsman in Australia to be our Test #3. Next test: Warner, Rogers, Smith, Burns, Watson, Faulkiner, Haddington, Johnson, Harris, Hazlewood, Lyon. (P.S. I don't know much about our wicket-keepers around the country.)

AUTHOR

2014-12-22T22:13:51+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


I think Cummins needs a solid season of Shield cricket under his belt before he can be considered for Test cricket again. Certainly an exciting prospect, but he needs a bag of wickets in long-form cricket.

AUTHOR

2014-12-22T22:12:36+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Hi Doc, Pattinson has 51 wickets at 27 from 13 Tests to date, along with a batting average of 30. As a proven Test performer, he is rightly considered a certainty for selection when fit. On first class stats, he has 124 wickets from 30 matches at 24. Behrendorff has 77 wickets at 25 from 20 matches, which are also strong figures. Plenty of people are talking about him on here in general, although perhaps not at much in comments on this particular article. I think he's a certainty for T20 selection, and should definitely be considered for the World Cup squad as well. Was in devastating form last night for the Scorchers, and I think he is positioning himself nicely for Mitchell Johnson's role when he retires. Certainly ahead of Starc form-wise right now. Carters has had a longer run of form than Bancroft, who is showing a lot of promise so far this season. The 2013/14 season saw Carters score 861 runs at 53.8, which is why is in the conversation for the soon to be vacant opening berth. No blue glasses here. You may wish to consider taking off the Sandgroper suit :)

2014-12-22T12:33:59+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Guest


Hasn't anyone here heard of Nathan Rimmington or Jason Behrendorff , both of whom I'd pick before Pattinson or Sayers and who've taken wickets season on season, because they din't get injured. Bancroft is the best young opener in the Shield with 2 100s and a 99 and has faced 160 overs, that's temperament.Way ahead of Carters, if you want to blood new players for the Windies.Get those blue glasses off

2014-12-22T11:59:16+00:00

DT

Guest


I like that team for next year just with Pete Neville in for Whiteman. David Warner, Joe Burns, Usman Khawaja, Steve Smith, Michael Clarke (c), Mitch Marsh, Peter Neville, Mitchell Johnson, James Pattinson, Josh Hazlewood, Nathan Lyon Cummins back up quick and need a reserve batsman to put his hand up to repalce Clarke - someone out of Maddison, Carters and the like.

2014-12-22T11:40:43+00:00

Professor Rosseforp

Guest


The best off-stump letters I have seen were Ian Redpath and Alan Turner, so we are going back a long way!

2014-12-22T11:20:57+00:00

Watson has to go

Guest


Amen brothers! Watson has to go above all else. We can't seriously be thinking we should continue to pick some at #3 who can't bat because.......every 4th or 5th test they take one wicket.........? Are we really that dumb? Pick batsmen who can bat and bowlers who can bowl, it really isnt much more complicated then that.

2014-12-22T11:03:26+00:00

Ducko

Guest


AND SIDDLE GOOOOOOOOOOORNE

AUTHOR

2014-12-22T09:11:12+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Fair call, Matt. I usually feel that S Marsh would be better suited to a cricket-themed modelling shoot than actually playing cricket!

AUTHOR

2014-12-22T09:10:06+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Boyce has looked great in T20 games he's played for Australia and the Hurricanes. Zampa has likewise performed very well for the Strikers in the BBL. However, while Boyce has bowled some great deliveries in Shield cricket, as you mentioned, his economy rate and lack of wicket taking in the longer form of the game makes me nervous to consider him as a Test prospect right now. Unfortunately, the same goes for Zampa. I would love to see one of them take a 6 or 7 for in the 2nd innings of a Shield game and bowl their side to victory. Ahmed is a more consistent wicket taker in Shield cricket than either of his blonde counterparts right now.

AUTHOR

2014-12-22T09:07:32+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


I agree on Sayers. He's had a pretty average start to this Shield season, but would perfect in English conditions.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar