Will Mitch replace Mitch, or is there another leftie waiting to swoop?

By Sean Mortell / Roar Guru

The Australian pace attack has evolved this summer, with New South Welshman Josh Hazlewood zooming past veteran Peter Siddle, and it poses the question of who is going to take on the role of our most important paceman?

Mitchell Johnson is now 33 years old, and he is lucky to still be going around with all of the injuries that normally strike down express pace bowlers.

Brett Lee’s last Test match was when he was aged 32, Jason Gillespie was 31 and Craig McDermott was 30. The only exception is Glenn McGrath, who was 36. But that’s McGrath.

Comparing Mitch’s age to the other great fast bowlers that we have had, his time must surely be coming to a close soon. That means that a left-arm pace bowler has to be in the wings waiting.

Who is the ideal replacement for the huge moustached intimidator? I’ll look at a few youngsters vying for the role.

Mitchell Starc
Why: Starc has surely got to be the obvious choice; he has played 14 Test matches and is a lock in for limited-overs teams when fit. His damaging yorkers and ability to reverse swing the ball make him a challenge to face. He has the jump on the other candidates because of his Test match experience, and he has removed some of the best batsmen in Test cricket, as his five-wicket haul against Sri Lanka in 2012 shows.

Why not: He is about to be dropped for the tenth time, for Ryan Harris in the upcoming Boxing Day Test. In Brisbane, he was extremely erratic, with his dangerous and brilliant balls being intermitted with loose, horrible ones. He is injury prone and doesn’t have the presence that most good pace bowlers have.

Jason Behrendorff
Why: His great pace and swing can be extremely hostile, especially when his height creates steepling bounce. His outings in the Big Bash League show just how brilliant he is, with spectacular short-form bowling. Behrendorff never stops pushing the ball across right handers and making it awkward for them. He is economical and a wicket taker.

Why not: Hasn’t proven himself in first-class level. He hasn’t played for Australia in any format (although that may change soon) and he hasn’t dominated with the red ball. He has played majority of his cricket at the WACA, where the pace and bounce can be friendly for tall pace bowlers.

Joel Paris
Why: Paris is another great Western Australian pace bowler. He is the youngest of the candidates (22 years of age) and has played some Sheffield Shield cricket. He is just like Behrendorff in the way that he constantly pushes the ball across the right handers, and his bounce and swing are quality for a youngster.

Why not: Paris has not played much cricket this year due to injury. He has played a lot of limited overs cricket, but hasn’t completely established himself in the WA line-up. He is young and inexperienced, and he also has the problem of playing most of his cricket at the WACA – he hasn’t constantly had to endure batsman-friendly pitches.

My prediction
Starc looks the most likely once he finds consistency, but if Behrendorff can bowl with the red ball like he does with the white, then he will be the more consistent wicket-taker of the three.

The Crowd Says:

2014-12-25T17:18:54+00:00

blanco

Guest


Behrendorff is already better than Starc. He is certainly one to look out for.I still maintain though that Hazlewood, Cummins and Pattinson will be the bowling line up.Behrendroff, Bird, Starc will be in contention.Love the look of Paris.

2014-12-24T14:07:06+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Guest


Check where Berhendorff has taken his wickets before you run off at the mouth about "fringe" WA bowler.,Remember his 40 wickets last season - and 14 at the halfway mark this season,sharing them with Mackin and Rimmington who Troy hasn't heard of either. How many wickets have Pattinson and Cummins taken in red ball cricket so far this year? The WA bowlers might be bowling on a more pace-friendly pitch at home but Mackin.Hogan, Behrendorff and Rimmington are only there half the time and bowling plenty of overs without breaking down

2014-12-24T12:22:23+00:00

Troy

Guest


It should be who Is going to replace Mitch Johnson not Is It going to be Mitch Starc or another leftie. Quite a few right handers are in front of a bunch of fringe Western Australians. Cummins and Pattinson are good chances to come In to the side.

2014-12-24T11:21:41+00:00

Gav

Guest


I would agree......but I think Behrendorff should be moved up in the pecking order into that group. He really looks the goods, seriously. I'm a fan of Starcs, but Behrendorf is actually coming on better in my books. Is it my imagination or is Bird bowling from wider on the crease than he used to?

AUTHOR

2014-12-24T04:27:33+00:00

Sean Mortell

Roar Guru


It is a way to analyse the left armers waiting in the wings, as the topic makes it relevant.

2014-12-24T03:30:21+00:00

Rob JM

Guest


Beherendorff Looks the goods, has pace, bounce, swing and control. He also looks more durable than patto or cummins. If he continues with this form he will soon be streets ahead of Stark. Faulkner is another lefty option. Great first class stats and could bat 7 if we fine a good batsman keeper. Then we could play both Cummins and Patto.

2014-12-24T02:35:53+00:00

Craig Watson

Guest


Can I ask a silly question Sean? Why must a leftie be replaced by a leftie? You imply that when Johnson retires he must automatically be replaced by another left armer. Yes a left armer provides balance to an attack but it is certainly not a prerequisite to have a leftie in our test side. I think CA resurrected Johnno' s career because he has that X factor... speed. If we were looking to bring in a similar bowler I would opt for Jason Beherendorff. The tall West Australian has been putting his name up for two seasons now. His time is near. Just the other day selector Marc Waugh said the same thing, and on air. Sean, you also seem impressed by 'Dorff' , going on your glowing resume of him.

2014-12-24T01:31:07+00:00

jameswm

Guest


Eggzactly. Pattinson, Cummins and Bird would be ahead of any of them.

2014-12-23T22:51:28+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Peter George! lol.

2014-12-23T22:02:04+00:00

Chui

Guest


Why does it have to be a lefty? Including someone just because they are left handed can be problematic.

Read more at The Roar