College football Down Under is a great idea if done properly

By Ed Wyatt / Expert

The famous USC marching band holding a pep rally in Federation Square? Sparky the Sun Devil riding a tram? Ralphy the Buffalo leading his team out onto the turf?

Those scenes could be reality if reports from ESPN’s Brett McMurphy about the Pacific 12 Conference wanting a bowl game in Melbourne are true.

Maybe a real-life bison charging out of the tunnel is unrealistic (there’s that pesky quarantine thing), but everything else about McMurphy’s story – in which he quotes unnamed sources – makes perfect sense.

Apparently the Pac 12, one of the NCAA’s power conferences, had been considering a post-season football bowl game in Melbourne for 2015, but is now “targeting the 2016 season”.

It’s unclear whether this was an idea concocted by the Pac 12 alone or if Victorian Major Events and/or a for-profit concern had approached the conference.

No matter, the idea appears to be on the table and, as we’ve seen with Liverpool, State of Origin and the upcoming International Champions Cup, there seems to be no stopping the influx of sporting events to the Victorian capital.

Will it work? College football isn’t the English Premier League and Pac 12 schools – even USC, UCLA and Oregon – aren’t Liverpool or Real Madrid. But there are plenty of positives, including the fact that this would be a legitimate, competitive game, not an exhibition.

Bowl games count on teams’ records, they are prestigious and used as recruiting tools, and most importantly, they are lucrative. Last year the Sun Bowl in El Paso, Texas, which hosts the Pac 12’s fifth-placed finisher, paid each team more than two million dollars.

ESPN’s live coverage into Australia and the fact that Aussies like Jesse Williams, Scott Harding, Adam Gotsis and Tom Hackett have starred at the collegiate level make an event like this much more than a case of the circus coming to town.

However, while there is truth in the old wives’ tale about Australians paying to see a race between two cockroaches, I’m not sure how much they’d pay to see Washington State play Nevada.

One of the attractions of bringing a big sporting event to Australia is that fans get to see a team or individuals they may never get the chance to see live again.

Liverpool: Steven Gerrard. Real Madrid: Cristiano Ronaldo. These are iconic clubs and iconic names. It’s easy to see why 100,000 would pack the MCG to watch them play.

A December bowl game is different. To begin with, the odds of seeing one of the Pac 12’s football big boys – Oregon or USC – are minimal. They will more than likely be playing in one of the more prestigious games like the Rose Bowl or even the national championship game.

But with some flexibility and creative thinking, the Pac 12 could help ensure that the Melbourne match-up is an attractive one.

Last year, Stanford finished with a 7-5 record and beat Maryland 45-21 in the Fight Hunger Bowl in San Francisco. Stanford is one of the USA’s best universities and has a wealthy alumni and fan-base that could easily afford the costs of travelling to Australia.

The school also has a reasonably high football profile thanks to NFL stars like Andrew Luck and Richard Sherman, and would be a good choice as a Pac 12 representative.

The opponent is just as important. Ironically, Maryland, with its Under Armour connection, would have made marketing sense, but in all likelihood it will be another West Coast school for travel reasons.

Obviously you’d love to land someone like Boise State, but the Broncos are also more than likely to be bound for a bigger bowl. That said, with some monetary inducements, a trip to Australia is a once-in-a-lifetime chance for many of these players, coaches and fans.

The other beauty of a bowl game is that teams arrive a week ahead of time and cultural outings are a big part of the buildup. With ESPN more than likely to telecast the game, you’d expect to see nightly highlights of the respective teams in various locales around Melbourne.

One of those locales would probably be the Melbourne Cricket Ground, but the players would certainly be there only as visitors. Cricket has the MCG tied up over the summer and to be honest, the ground is too big for a bowl game.

Etihad Stadium or AAMI Park would make more sense, and a crowd close to 30,000 would be a victory from a PR standpoint.

I would definitely like to see grassroots football organisations like gridiron Victoria involved. There is a passionate and knowledgeable fan-base out there and to see them neglected or priced out of attending would be a massive mistake.

December in Australia used to be a sleepy time, with cricket and a few other events like Sydney to Hobart dominating the news. Now you’ve got the Big Bash phenomenon and the growth of the A-League, with the NBL and ABL struggling for a piece of the pie too.

If scheduled and organised properly, a college football bowl game could be a yearly event. It might even be worth a call to Phil Knight to see if he’ll underwrite the ‘Nike Bowl’, with occasional visits from his Oregon Ducks.

Ok, now I’m getting carried away.

The Crowd Says:

2018-03-19T21:40:01+00:00

Mo

Guest


Hi Ed, Good to find you here. I will be in Australia temporary. Please bring back Almost Live.

2015-04-15T03:29:47+00:00

Timber Tim

Guest


not that this would happen but the one college game I would like to see out here if you could is Alabama v Auburn My late girlfriend was from Arkansas and the Arkansas/LSU games can get heated too and she really dislike LSU with a passion. College Football i do find more passionate than NFL football in the stands but how they work out the rankings of teams can get quite complicated. would love to see teams come here but would fans no the chants of the certain schools.

2015-04-10T02:21:36+00:00

piru

Guest


The situation is weird, but the sport isn't. It's not hard to understand American football, it's basically Rugby league with a forward pass

2015-04-10T02:19:50+00:00

piru

Guest


pish, we play American football through the Perth heat every year. If fat buggers like us can manage in 40c+, elite athletes should be able to handle Melbourne's mild clime

2015-04-09T03:22:06+00:00

Joe

Guest


Boise ended the season ranked somewhere in the mid teens,I think ranked 15th in the nation in the final AP poll. So they're still a solid program & have been for the last decade. Im not sure where you're coming up with the idea BoiseSt isn't any good nowadays? They consistently have guys selected in the 1st & 2nd rounds of the draft as well. Obviously they aren't the football powerhouse of SEC teams like Bama,LSU,Georgia,etc,but Boise is still a darn good program year after year.

2015-04-09T02:28:04+00:00

Andrew Kitchener

Roar Guru


Boise State were good before Kellen Moore - remember Jared Zabransky and Ian Johnson? And they were pretty good last year, winning, you know, the Fiesta Bowl over a good Arizona squad. Time to update your knowledge a little.

2015-04-09T00:58:04+00:00

hooter

Guest


The only teams from the PAC 12 with any punch of making an impact in Australia are Oregon, Stanford , UCLA and USC. One of thise four would have to be one of the teams. The US college sports are popular on tv here, but it would be a waste if we got 2 very average teams. And by the way Boise St are not very good , they were ok when Kellan Moore was QB , but they are in a weak division and are just not good enough to be in the top 30 or so schools anymore!

AUTHOR

2015-04-08T08:33:17+00:00

Ed Wyatt

Expert


I think you MAY see a Super Bowl in London but it's a long, long way off.

2015-04-08T02:49:45+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Ed I'm gonna take this article a step further. Super Bowl out side of America. Im talking Mexico City,Toronto,Berlin,London as options.

AUTHOR

2015-04-07T21:28:08+00:00

Ed Wyatt

Expert


Great knowledge. I was talking to someone about that the other day. Wyoming and UTEP. Wow. Interesting on Brisbane. I supposed Victorian Major Events has been so aggressive that you just natural expect them to come up with more events!

2015-04-07T13:54:47+00:00

Brendon

Guest


Agreed. People can easily understand the NFL and the super bowl (even if they don't like american football) but American college sports are just weird to Australians, actually, to the rest of the world.

2015-04-07T11:34:58+00:00

GWS

Guest


It would not be the first US College football game to be played in Australia. That distinction belongs to The Australia Bowl played at VFL Park Waverley on December 06 1985. 19 107 fans turned up to see Wyoming defeat UTEP, 24 to 21. Who remembers that? I would suggest playing a future game in Brisbane at Lang Park. The stadium only has a minimal use over summer; college football owes its existence to rugby so that is a stronger connection locally than in the AFL dominated southern states; and last, Brisbane does not get as many "events" as Melbourne and Sydney so the opportunities for publicity and marketing to generate an interest are likely greater.

AUTHOR

2015-04-07T11:24:16+00:00

Ed Wyatt

Expert


I liked the John Oliver bit. Plenty of truth in there for sure.

AUTHOR

2015-04-07T11:23:08+00:00

Ed Wyatt

Expert


Johnno. I was the Communications Manager for the South Dragons. We won the title and then folded. I have done a little bit of NBL on internet radio, but that's about it. Thanks for asking.

2015-04-07T09:21:37+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Ed you being an American living down under, have you ever done any NBL work. You with your background, I'm surprised no network has ever asked you, as you know your hoops.

2015-04-07T06:47:01+00:00

Gyfox

Guest


I lived in California for 8 years & enjoyed going to College Football games with friends who had a connection with one of the UC's. But it is a different sports scenario & has no relevance outside the U.S. In fact, Australian college/Uni sport is very different, not least with cash & scholarships. Perhaps a game would have curiosity value. But it doesn't translate to our sporting traditions - even if Adelaide Uni has the oldest football grandstand in the country.

2015-04-07T02:30:55+00:00

Tigranes

Guest


I can't imagine the NFL ever staging a preseason or regular season game considering the amount of players that have got prior criminal convictions.

2015-04-07T02:17:37+00:00

Smell the fear

Guest


College sports don't make sense to most Australians, athletes earning millions for sponsors and schools and getting an "education" in return only happens in America. See John Oliver's rant from the other day and you'll agree

2015-04-07T01:41:01+00:00

aubgraham

Roar Rookie


And what about the heat? Football is a winter sport for a reason. This story is a week late I think.

2015-04-07T01:22:28+00:00

Ned Balme

Roar Guru


Two issues I see occurring are; Despite also getting a lower tiered collegiate program, many players experiencing injuries are more likely to shelve themselves knowing that an international bowl game won't stand to help raise their draft stock or profile within American. Many college athletes, and Americans in general, don't possess adequate documentation for international travel and given the extensive procedure to acquire these documents this would not be an easy task for a student who's entire time is occupied by the football program itself. Not only that but a number (obviously not the majority) of college athletes have prior records, albeit often minor possession chargers, but enough to make them denied from entering a country.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar