AFL Round 4: Anzac round review and results

By Brent Ford / Roar Guru

Round 4 of the AFL was another cracking round and if you look at the games in great detail the picture of how the season might play out gets a little fuzzier.

You never want to liken football to war, but in the Anzac round there was a number of times where those Anzac qualities of mateship and courage were on display.

The Demons weren’t given a hope in the world of beating the Tigers on Friday night. But they played a brand of football that was exciting, and they slammed the door on a dark chapter in the club’s history.

One player in particular signifies a new beginning of second chances at the Melbourne Football Club. Aaron Vandenberg. ‘Flanders’, as he was known at Ainslie laid a round-high 12 tackles and his work rate was unbelievable.

There was one moment when Vandenberg had the ball in the middle of the ground and he scrapped the kick forward, moments later down forward the ball fell to Vandenberg who snapped a crucial goal.

In just his fourth game he looks at home, he also wears the number 37 which was the same number Jim Stynes wore in his first year at Melbourne.

Saturday was a football feast, Carlton got on the board and the Saints continued to slide down the table. Patrick Cripps for mine looks a star of the future, he took grabs, laid tackles and used the ball effectively and will only get better with games.

Enter Paul Seedsman. The unheralded hero of Collingwood’s win over Essendon, the young Pie continues to build. He had 31 disposals on Saturday and he kicked a goal, the former housemate of Heath Shaw received a text from the former Anzac Medallist on Saturday morning that simply read “join the club”, and he certainly did.

We knew the Giants would make their charge at some stage, but against a fellow expansion club they made an emphatic statement. It was the biggest win in the club’s history and their young midfield looks like it could match it with the best.

Adding Ryan Griffen and Joel Patfull has given some much needed experience to the younger players, and has given players like Dylan Shiel and Lachie Whitfield plenty of time on the outside to deliver to their key forwards.

Speaking of key forwards, Jeremy Cameron and Cam McCarthy are fast becoming the most exciting duo in the league. If you don’t believe me just look at Jeremy Cameron’s attempted bicycle goal, young and exciting.

They’ve taken that next step up now bring on the big guns.

Saturday night was reserved for the ‘big 4′ games. Both games looked disappointing early, with both Fremantle and Port Adelaide blowing their highly fancied opponents out of the water before half time.

But both games were completely turned on their head. In the Fremantle versus Sydney game John Longmire managed to get the best out of Sam Reid, who was until then having a quiet game.

In a coaching master stroke he moved his big man onto the wing, and Reid proved an important dog in the Sydney comeback and showed he still has a valuable place in the team.

Isaac Heeney had his colours lowered against an impressive opponent, while Michael Barlow was quiet and Lachie Neale did his best attempt of a disappearing act. He had just nine touches after having a game-high 42 in the derby.

Nathan Fyfe is unbelievable. His stats read 27 disposals, but the manner in which he gets them, his second and third efforts at the contest and an ability to make something out of nothing. He is the modern day prototype and it’s scary to think how good he just might get.

If Hawthorn was to beat Port Adelaide it probably would’ve been unfair. Travis Boak is now in the elite class and surely Jordan Lewis has to be right up there in the early rounds of the Brownlow.

Sunday threw up a few surprises. One that wasn’t a surprise is that Josh Kennedy is a flat track bully and he dominated the Lions. Three goals doesn’t do his game justice, he kicked five behinds and had eight marks, it could have been much bigger.

Brownlow medalist Mathew Priddis was again busy with a ton of handballs and again laying a ton of tackles. Stefan Martin continues to carry the Lions’ ruck stocks, but in a look to the future Tom Cutler was super impressive on debut with 32 touches.

The battle of the Scott brothers was another cracking contest with Brad getting the better of Chris. I believe Sam Wright is terribly underrated. He had 32 disposals and is rarely talked of outside of Kangaroo supporters; he is one I really like.

Todd Goldstein is the premier ruckman in the competition. He can do it all; he dominates the hit outs, gets back in defence to take marks and he can snap goals with the movement of a small forward, it’s only early but he is a massive favourite for All Australian honours.

The moment of the round, in my opinion, was when Tom Hawkins kicked his first goal of the match. Hawkins’ mother passed away earlier in the week and in an emotional moment Hawkins signed a heart to the sky and kissed his black armband while team mates swarmed to their much-loved team mate.

Then, with a bang in the final game of the round. the Bulldogs showed why they are one of the most exciting teams in the competition this year. The big money forward line is firing but it’s from a guy you wouldn’t expect.

Jake Stringer has always struck me as a player who could explode, powerful, quick and smart he has all the traits you need to be successful and on a day when many were expecting a Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Tex Walker had his colours lowered for the first time this year.

It’s captivating the way the Bulldogs play when they are up and about, it’s a style that’s continually evolved over time, their press suffocates their opponents into errors and the Crows for the first time this year were put under pressure and looked ordinary.

You could still see the Bulldogs in their zone despite being 11 goals up late in the last quarter, a club that lost it’s captain, coach, a former Brownlow medalist wasn’t supposed to be this good, but when has the AFL ever gone according to the script?

It’s a new era at the kennel and it’s exciting.

At the end of four rounds Fremantle remains the only team undefeated, but I ask you Roarers what has surprised you the most in the opening four rounds of the season?

The Crowd Says:

2015-04-28T03:03:37+00:00

Macca

Guest


I agree with Malthouses treatment of Buckley (although Buckley said this week how thankful he is to Mick for giving him a chance as a rebounding defender so maybe there is more to the story than we see) but hopefully with Yarran out for the next couple of weeks he cements his spot. If I was a selector when Yarran comes back I would play him forward (even as a defensive forward) and allow Buckley to stay on a flank - that would make us more dangerous up forward and still have some good run off half back and probably better defensively.

2015-04-28T01:26:06+00:00

Col of Brissie

Guest


Troy Menzel round 16 last year.

2015-04-28T00:45:51+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


I think we might be seeing one of the shortest coaching tenures in history. Scott Burns would suit them but I say, bring back Bluey...and O'Meara and Ablett. The Suns must be cringing at Rocket's public statements.

2015-04-28T00:02:19+00:00

Macca

Guest


Don - I agree that the Suns should get more than a few finals appearances in their first decade but they should be closer than they are by now and what is par? For all they were given what would be a pass mark in 10 years? GWS declared they would win a premiership within 5 years - while I think that is ambitious they look closer than the Suns despite being a year behind.

2015-04-27T23:57:12+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Yep...should have won the Anzac Medal. McCarthy is an absolute gun. Who are the other two? I know one is Buckley and it seems Malthouse is doing everything he can to drive him to another club. Why doesn't Carlton play more good kids?

2015-04-27T23:55:00+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


The Suns will do that many times in their first decade. Let them have a decade first.

2015-04-27T23:53:39+00:00

Macca

Guest


No Don - Cripps got the rising star nod - well deserved too after 33 touches, 23 contested possession 9 tackles and a goal - 3rd blue to get the rising star in just over 12 months.

2015-04-27T23:00:21+00:00

Macca

Guest


Murray - This isn't just about Carlton - all the mid tier clubs have suffered the same fate - their is a reason the likes of North, Essendon, Richmond, Adelaide etc still look as far off the top 4 as they did 5 years ago. And you say the Suns have been well below par this year when were they above par? The blues at least have a few finals appearances and a couple of fials wins in the last decade.

2015-04-27T16:46:48+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Duggan's tackling is amazing. Give him full games, Simmo. My tip for 2015 Rising Star.

2015-04-27T16:43:08+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


The reasons are pretty obvious. The better sides beat WC. You can't kick goals if the ball in not in your forward line. Why would you need that explained to you?

2015-04-27T13:35:59+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


We at Freo last year were saying that we'd be happy to have McCarthy if GWS kept Boyd. Gotta be Rising Star this week.

2015-04-27T13:33:31+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Bootsma is doing really well in the WAFL, showing excellent leadership at Peel. Kids make mistakes. Carlton could learn a great deal about how to support and nurture players so they can become the sound citizens that kids like Bootsma can become. (Michael Johnson, Sunny Walters...) Wouldn't Carlton love a tight, fast, skilled defensive tall? Bootsma is proving to be all that. A very realistic candidate for a re-draft.

2015-04-27T13:15:48+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Bootsma is doing very well in the WAFL, providing excellent leadership at Peel. Kids do grow up. Pity Carlton know nothing about nurturing talent...just cutting them loose. How they'd love a fast, tight tall defender.

2015-04-27T12:38:20+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Guest


Pejoratives tend to mask poor analysis What would you suggest that Kennedy do? Not kick goals? Franklin kicked a motza against weak teams last season Oh, but he's a downhill skier Put Darling back in the side and see how the Eagles kick their goals

2015-04-27T08:43:04+00:00

Shaw

Roar Rookie


Break out the violin Macca, the blues are an established powerhouse club and have 150 years tradition. Goldcoast are in their infancy. Do you really want to draw direct comparison with a newbie expansion club in nrl territory and claim you're hard done by? Suns have been well below par this year, blues have been for a decade.

2015-04-27T05:56:22+00:00

jax

Guest


If Kennedy played for eg Hawks or Freo you would not be saying the things that you do. Players in stronger teams generally look better because they are in a strong and very even teams. Furthermore, if Darling or LeCras also played for the Hawks the Melb press would be calling them out and out superstars of the competition. Kennedy relies heavily on the speed and precise delivery of the ball into the forward line. Against stronger Top 4-8 teams WC's midfield doesn't have the ascendency it does against weaker teams and that's why Kennedy does better against some teams than others. You need to re-access how you evaluate players and take a wider view. Kennedy is a star, period!

2015-04-27T05:49:42+00:00

jax

Guest


I'm with you Don, poor form Brent. How about something positive like McGovern's game/season or Duggan's 11 4th quarter possessions after coming on as a sub? Or McInnes solid debut? Butlers 26 possessions and 2 goals from defence or the spread of goal kickers? Singling out one of the very best tall forwards in the game for not kicking straight when he is normally one of the most reliable kicks in the game is weak as Don said. WC have 8 of their best 22 injured which is more than 1/3 of the team. They got belted by Freo the week before and lost by 30 points then Freo did the same to Sydney the following week, winning by 16 points. There were so many other angles to write about but it looks like you spent 5 minutes coming up with your WC spiel.

2015-04-27T04:28:24+00:00

Macca

Guest


"That has proved the be the 2nd most accurate tip of the year." That says it all really

2015-04-27T04:23:39+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


I did make the observation that the only worry for Gold Coast might be Rocket Eade. That has proved the be the 2nd most accurate tip of the year. The most accurate tip is that Freo would finish 2 to 3 games clear on top, although I should have added, 'at least'.

2015-04-27T04:17:31+00:00

Macca

Guest


Hmmm - combine that with this years results and it does seem to be pointing to the "flat track bully" label being supported - but I am sure Don will have some evidence to the contrary greater than just his opinion.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar