Rep selection snubs and uncanny horseplay

By Jason Hosken / Roar Guru

Is Luke Lewis the only Blues fan not blowing up over the omission of Luke Lewis from Origin 1?

Perhaps his indifference to rejection was conditioned by Gus and Ivan – the heavy handed rustlers who hustled the local junior from his Panther homebase after 12 years’ service.

In any event, an 18th Origin jumper jammed inside a cabinet housing rep gear accumulated since 2003 is hardly a crown jewel. So in the selection snubbing stakes, Luke’s scratching barely forms a ripple on the Ocean of Rebuff.

Certainly nothing in comparison to the tidal wave of emotion Mitch Aubusson must be riding. Despite playing in excess of 170 matches, the reliable Aubusson’s utility value has counted for nothing at the selection table.

He hasn’t even got a City v Country bench spot.

But who’d be a selector anyway? A thankless task where the upset outnumber the selected and distraught mums seek solace. That said, certain selection snubs emanate from hearts colder than a Warrington winter.

Look no further than Brian Bevan. The Australian Team of the Century winger owned the frozen goal-lines of Wilderspool for 17 years until 1962, compiling an astonishing 740 tries.

Even though the Roos visited four times, the try merchant’s balding scalp never once felt the warmth of an Aussie Test cap.

Oddly enough though, fans often grudge a snub longer than the player in question.

Roosters fans for instance with three or more decades under the tri-colour comb proclaim Kevin ‘Horrie’ Hastings the best never in green-and-gold and with reflex-fast pecks challenge anyone opposed to the former playmaker’s credentials as Origin’s best one-game-wonder.

Meanwhile, back at the coal face the competition is littered with journeyman drifting between clubs toiling for limited weekend gigs outside the rep committee’s gaze.

A good mate of mine reckons the term ‘journeyman’ is overstated. Back in the days of more transient Rabbitohs rosters, he specified his own criteria of at least four NRL clubs including Souths as currency for official status.

The likes of Julian O’Neill and Phil Blake – elite ‘journeyman’ in their own right – had no such trouble reaching the next level. Modern day versions like Glenn Hall – now at his fifth NRL club – edge towards 200 games oblivious to emblems portraying Kangaroos, Cockroaches, City, All Stars, PMs, Presidents or any other fancy-titled individual’s favourite XIII.

The good news for stalwarts like Hall is the likelihood of a rep call up increases with every NRL outing to the point where only two of 85 in the 250-plus game category have not attained rep honours.

Craig ‘Tugger’ Coleman was a top-notch halfback and the Usain Bolt of rapid fire linguistics but even the yappy Rabbit couldn’t convince selectors – his 268 top grade appearances still the most without a congratulatory phone call.

Todd Payten, the other to miss out must choke at the flipside knowing Phil Duke’s only Origin – the infamous Phil ‘Whatsapacketa’ Sigsworth in-goal gaff – came five years before his first-grade debut. He must feel sullen knowing that Cootamundra product Paul Field is the Blues’ only player to hang up the boots without ever playing first grade.

But further research uncovers more rep snubs from the bizarre to the downright weird.

Like Aiden Toleman, the made-for-Origin workaholic Bulldog who like fellow Kempsey product Greg Inglis debuted for the Melbourne Storm but is still to suit-up…in Maroon!

Or the trail of selection oddities linked to the Scone Thoroughbreds, one of the Newcastle Knights’ famous breeding grounds.

Of the 39 players to kick-off 2015 with over 200 appearances, only Scone juniors Dane Tilse and Todd Lowrie hadn’t played rep footy.

Standing at 200 centimetres – the tallest in the NRL – it’s a wonder Tilse never attracted the eye of the clipboard brigade, but it’s definitely no surprise he’s now in Hull hoping for a resurrection of the Exiles format.

Lowrie’s plight should debunk myths of nepotism at HQ, with father Robert – Operations Manager of the NSW Country Rugby League – obviously not bearing gifts on selection day.

The there’s Ruben Wiki, the most capped Kiwi and one of only two from 22 in the exclusive 300 club not to play Origin. The other, John Morris, and yep you guessed it – Scone Thoroughbred.

Go back further to 1999 prior to Darren Albert’s New South Wales debut and the source of this uncanny horseplay becomes abundantly clear. If anyone was going to tumble from their mount in a pre-match bonding exercise, it was always going to happen in the presence of a Thoroughbred.

And sure enough, Brad Clyde and Robbie Kearns cursed their misfortune from the sidelines as Queensland cantered home in a contest that also doubled as the Scone junior’s last.

So what does this all mean for Luke Lewis and Game 2?

He’ll be there! It’s as logical as young Knight and former Thoroughbred, the aptly named Adam Clydesdale, dreaming of a Broncos saddle to further his own rep aspirations.

The Crowd Says:

2015-06-07T05:28:00+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


Jim was rookie of the year. Was still in pretty good form at the end of his career but finished up before he was 30. If you can shed light why he or even Brett Dallas didnt get Northern Eagles contracts I'd be keen to hear. Billy Moore another.

2015-06-06T12:38:13+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


He certainly has been good, but he's also been down in back play struggling a couple of times, for me that's enough to say not in good enough condition for the physicality of rep football.

2015-06-05T11:57:09+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


Klemmer showed glimpses of his power, will be a mainstay for years all going well. I wouldnt mind seeing him have another run.

2015-06-05T11:53:39+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


Ok, happy to stand on my pat malone. Coleman-Blake combo ran hot in the late 80s, touted for Origin. Tugger unlucky not to get a rep of some description. Anyway, makes for a good story.

AUTHOR

2015-06-05T06:52:03+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


No worries - I'm just a big fan of pointless facts :)

2015-06-05T06:39:53+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


Ah, my mistake

AUTHOR

2015-06-05T06:33:01+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


That's the point, only bloke eligible missed out - from Scone - coincidence?

2015-06-05T06:12:11+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


Why would Rubin Wiki play origin exactly?

2015-06-05T05:55:30+00:00

Alex

Guest


no no no not ennis.

2015-06-05T05:54:08+00:00

Alex

Guest


Hoffman had an uncharacteristicly poor game and merrin was under played. Probably Gallen will come in for Jackson and hopefully hopefully Lewis in for Klemmer who was very disappointing.

AUTHOR

2015-06-05T04:42:47+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


that's a ripping Roar topic - do you mind if i draft something up????

2015-06-05T04:30:28+00:00

maximillian

Guest


Kurt Gidley captaining from the bench has to be 1 of the dumbest moves in Origin history!

2015-06-05T04:20:13+00:00

Neville Neville

Guest


Back to Craig Field, or at least his ilk. Jim Serdaris: Souths, Dogs, Magpies, Manly. Pretty sure he was rookie of the year, maybe 1989. Assume your mate pointed at his addition to the nest as further reason to snub Brookie?

AUTHOR

2015-06-05T04:04:20+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


I wasn't aware of that, Alex. He's been in strong form over the last month. I reckon he's worth a shot regardless. He's just a great footballer. Has an engine for 80, great hands and feet with still enough pace to fracture front lines.

AUTHOR

2015-06-05T04:01:40+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


good one! Not the type of surname to entice rep selectors..and... it didn't. Full credit to the broadcasters - I never heard his name pronounced 'deth', always 'deeth'. Handy player though.

2015-06-05T03:56:36+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


Initially I was against leaving Lewis out, but given he's still having trouble getting his meds right and it's causing him breathing problems, I can understand it.

2015-06-05T03:54:36+00:00

Neville Neville

Guest


I've got another for your list. Jason Death. 202 games for Raiders, Cowboys, Warriors and Souths. Born in Young NSW, which may explain the zero hit outs for the Clydesdales.

2015-06-05T02:45:38+00:00

Chop

Roar Guru


Blake Ferguson? He hasn't even played a game back from injury yet. The backs weren't the problem, it was the plodding forwards that got pumped in the second half. NSW need to pick some back rowers who can bend/break the defensive line.

AUTHOR

2015-06-05T01:50:29+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Ennis to replace Farrah as skipper too.

2015-06-05T01:30:22+00:00

Albo

Guest


Yep ! I am with you there. Lewis has been a great player over the years, but seriously, he has played very little football at all since he went to Cronulla due to injury and medical issues. I can remember one good match he played a year or two back up in Newcastle where he single handedly won a match for the Sharks, but that's about it. You can't really expect selectors to get too excited about risking him at Origin again at this stage of his stuttering career.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar