The mini revolution: Hawthorn’s forward line is football’s future

By Jay Croucher / Expert

In vogue, buzz terms like ‘congestion’ and ‘the rolling maul’ that have come to define the AFL have never applied to Hawthorn.

The Hawks are the league’s decongestant – a Sudafed of incisive left-foot kicking and pristine ball movement.

A perfectly oiled machine, the brown and gold are a breathtaking masterpiece of cohesion. They move in total unison, with an unparalleled ability to create empty freeway lanes for themselves in the middle of traffic jams.

They’ve become preternaturally aware of their teammates’ tendencies by this stage, developing into Australia’s answer to FC Barcelona and the Golden State Warriors.

The Hawks mimic Barca’s elaborate passing game of triangles and they rain efficient destruction like Steph Curry and Klay Thompson in Oakland.

Hawthorn have become the counter-argument to the suddenly popular contention that ‘the game must change’. Do the current rules of the game promote congestion and unattractive football? Not when Hawthorn are playing.

The old school might lament the dearth of ‘great’ centre-half forwards – Australia’s answer to the quarterback, the glam position of sport – who kick 100 goals in a season, but the Hawks have proven that such nostalgia is, as nostalgia tends to be, totally archaic.

You can have Jason Dunstall, I’ll take Cyril Rioli.

Different iterations of the Alastair Clarkson Hawks have been defined by different players. For a while it was the two-headed monster of Lance Franklin and Jarryd Roughead. Then it was the hardened silk of Sam Mitchell, Luke Hodge, Shaun Burgoyne and Jordan Lewis – unsociable warriors who combine brutal toughness with extraordinary skill and composure. Hodge is perhaps the best enduring symbol of this team, with his ferocity at the contest and his liquid whip of a left leg.

The 2015 Hawks have been defined by a new trio though. The mosquito army of Rioli, Luke Breust and Jack Gunston have in many ways come to personify Hawthorn. While teams like Collingwood and Essendon search despairingly to find tall foils for Travis Cloke and Joe Daniher, the Hawks have said goodbye to that way of thinking. They’re scaling new heights with small-ball, embodying a new trend in world sport.

The Golden State Warriors won the NBA title when they did away with classic positional paradigms and decided to go smaller than anyone in history during the Finals. Barcelona have done the same, abandoning the notion of a tall front man, long ago sending away Zlatan Ibrahimovich to the island of his own narcissism, and adding the fleet-footed bite of Luis Suarez and Neymar to complement Lionel Messi instead.

The Hawks have followed suit. They still have Roughead and the likes of David Hale and Ben McEvoy who can go forward and clunk contested marks the traditional way, but that possibility speaks to the team’s versatility and not its identity. The Hawks have five players who have kicked 25 or more goals this season, and four of them weigh 84 kilograms or less.

Cyril Rioli, all 177 centimetres and 80 kilograms of him, was Hawthorn’s goal-square focal point last Saturday evening, and he duly responded with six sublime goals. Compared to watching Tom Hawkins and Brian Lake grapple and brawl at the other end like two anachronistic gargoyles, seeing Rioli’s nous in the air, explosion at ground level, and dynamic skill with ball in hand was like witnessing the future overcome the past.

Hawkins, while imposing, is manageable. With modern defensive zoning, the ability to isolate a key forward one-on-one inside 50 is becoming less and less feasible. As is the case with Cloke, Daniher, Kurt Tippett, Nick Riewoldt, Jay Schulz and other traditional power forwards, if you can just ‘not lose’ the aerial contest with Hawkins, when the ball comes to ground, as it generally does, the advantage shifts to the defence.

That shift never occurs with Rioli, nor with Breust, Chad Wingard, Eddie Betts, Jamie Elliott, Michael Walters or Mark LeCras. These players have the savvy to be dangerous in the air and in one-on-one marking contests, and if the ball hits the deck they become even more of a nightmare. Even if they don’t win the contest, their speed and agility informs their team’s forward-half defensive pressuring.

The Hawks lost the game’s best tall forward since Wayne Carey and somehow got better as a result. Without Franklin, Hawthorn was forced to adjust their forward structure on the fly and in the process they found the future of modern football.

A power forward is a blessing and a curse. The ability to have a bailout marking option when nothing seems available should be a significant asset, but often it just bails a team out of creativity. The high, long bomb to the tip of the goal-square is football’s Hail Mary, but whereas the Yanks reserve it for only the direst of situations, in our code we use it almost as a first resort.

Patience is a sporting virtue, and the Hawks’ meticulous short passing and ability to pinpoint a target, any target, inside 50 is revolutionising the game.

Unfortunately for the rest of the league, you need a pioneer to start a revolution. Steph Curry, Lionel Messi and Cyril Rioli don’t grow on trees. But natural selection will place a premium on those who flaunt desirable speed and elite kicking ability, and the league will see an influx of these gifted types.

The tall forward will not die, but he will evolve, and may end up looking more like Jeremy Cameron, Jake Stringer and Jack Gunston over time – 190cm-plus players defined by their nimbleness. There will always be outliers, and it will be fascinating to see if recent number one picks Jonathon Patton, Tom Boyd and Paddy McCartin can succeed in spite of the paradigm that seems to be shifting against them.

Justin Leppitsch might despair that his Brisbane Lions can’t take the next step without a key forward, but such longing may soon become antiquated.

While a big man who can take a mark and kick straight will always be valuable (just look at what Josh Kennedy and Jack Darling did in the first quarter against Fremantle last weekend), their significance has diminished in the modern game.

As space becomes tighter and tighter, it only makes sense that those most adept to slip through the cracks will be the ones who thrive.

The Crowd Says:

2015-08-22T12:48:42+00:00

Paul

Guest


I thought they were rappers. Do the stanly leg!

2015-08-22T12:32:31+00:00

Pope Paul vii

Guest


moving on

2015-08-22T08:55:32+00:00

bryan

Guest


Yes,Port Adelaide "led at every change",& turned out winners by 22 points. I guess it was just an "off day" for Hawthorn! They have quite a few,these days! :)

2015-08-22T01:33:57+00:00

Pope Paul vii

Guest


They are a curious lot Ryan, often seeming to get to around the 17-19 goal mark with relative ease only to switch off and not go onto an old fashioned 20 goal plus goalfest. Which really annoys me because I am nothing if not old fashioned. Actually I think North have 5 players with 20 plus - Petrie, Big Brownie, Enigmatic Waitey, Thomas and Higgins - sounds a bit ordinary compared to the big goal kickers of days of yore but I'll take it.

2015-08-22T00:45:04+00:00

Pope Paul vii

Guest


And then they can lose

2015-08-21T16:31:13+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Eastern staters know so little about WA footballers, they probably think Ballas, Mayne and Sunny are talls.

2015-08-21T16:04:43+00:00

Freo As

Guest


Hahahahaha. Maybe you've gotten a little overly enthused here...pretty words, but Ballantyne, Walters & Mayne are too small to be effective at the business end.? Yet Hawthorn are trendsetters? Please. Hahahahaha.

2015-08-21T10:12:43+00:00

Kavvy

Guest


Great call. Throw in Buckenara too. Imagine how much happier Richo would've been if he just played with one bloke that could kick like the players you've mentioned!

2015-08-21T08:49:10+00:00

Gecko

Guest


Maybe the contradiction is the choice of Kane Mitchell for the photo. Think of Cyril Rioli, Luke Breust, Eddie Betts .... and Kane Mitchell.

2015-08-21T08:42:09+00:00

Gecko

Guest


Jay this is a thought-provoking article but while small forwards like Rioli "have the savy to be dangerous in the air and in one-on-one marking contests", they still need to be alongside a tall. Otherwise every long bomb into the forward line would be marked by Harry Taylor (and many other tall defenders who can take a grab). Walters and Rioli are great to watch but, despite Pav and Roughie being less spectacular this year, they're still negating the Harry Taylor-types and bringing the long bombs to ground. Maybe there's a future for drawing tall defenders further up the ground so small forwards (like Rioli) can get one-on-one with their opponents in the goal square. Then we'd see a goalfest.

2015-08-21T07:58:49+00:00

Frank R

Roar Rookie


I don't want to take anything away Dunstall's brilliance however he did of some of the most skillful kickers of his era in his team. They delivered the ball to him lace out. Especially Darren Jarman but there where more: Ben Allan, Darrin Pritchard, Rat Platten etc. But if Dunstall was playing today the hawks agian and 5 or more players that good kick equally as good and deliver the ball to him on a strong lead.

2015-08-21T07:44:52+00:00

Axle an the Guru

Guest


Pavlich still gets the best backman the opposition have, he is still Fremantles focal point up forward and still capable of winning a game off his own boot. The small forwards still rove off him and I would want him to play on next year.

2015-08-21T07:38:29+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


Don, The small trend is a thing. I see this as a result of the rarity of genuine power forwards and how under performing key forwards (e.g. Grant, Butcher and even Vickery at times) are such liabilities at their clubs. If you could have access to 3 elite talls (see the Eagles and Roos forward lines) you'd go for it over a smaller set up because they will be just as effective with quick ball movement as the smalls but far more effective when the play slows up. For the Hawks - even roughead is not your traditional tall and certainly not a power forward. We've seen this year how easily he can be shut down in the air, recording less than 5 or less marks in a game 11 times this year. I imagine that he would struggle quite a bit if he were playing for Melbourne, Carlton or another poor kicking side where he would not receive the same delivery he does at the hawks.

2015-08-21T07:17:25+00:00

Mwm

Guest


Didn't this same team lose to the giants... Who lost to the swans... Who intern were hammered by the hawks? Any team in the top 8 or close to it can beat any team on any given day. They just need to put into practice what they train hours and hours for. It's not exactly technically brilliant what the hawks do when they trounce someone. When they are on song they simply have precision kicking and run off their man to create a target... Combined with winning the ball it's footy 101

2015-08-21T06:54:51+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


I just mentioned him (Alex Pearce). Pav's "declining effectiveness" has him 16th in goal assists in the AFL. "Score assists (total): Matthew Pavlich (26) AFL rank (equal 16th): Pavlich's ranking could be even higher if his ability to bring the ball to ground when outnumbered in aerial contests went on the stats sheet"...afl.com yesterday. Good try Nev. Try watching some footy.

2015-08-21T06:50:49+00:00

Nev

Guest


If Fremantle could find a tall forward who is any good, they’d grab him. Walters and his support crew are fine but Pav is already declining in effectiveness without a second tall. That small forward line suits WC defence to a tee.

2015-08-21T06:40:31+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


If Hawthorn could find a tall forward who is any good, they'd grab him. Poppy and his support crew are fine but Roughie is already declining in effectiveness without a second tall. That small forward line suits WC defence to a tee. Freo also have the little guys covered but Roughie and the ruckmen are toast against Freo's defensive talls. No club will be in a hurry to follow the small trend (mainly because it is not a trend). Freo and the Bullies have had a smaller forward line than most but the Bullies have brought back Boyd and want nothing more than his success. Freo is far better with Alex Pearce's skills up forward.

2015-08-21T05:20:49+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


North Melbourne's is a very, very under-rated forward unit. If Hawthorn ever get sucked back to the pack, I'd feel comfortable forecasting that the Roos will end up as the best scoring side in the competition.

2015-08-21T04:51:15+00:00

Marty

Guest


Thank God Dunstall didn't come from this era. If he did, he would have been taught set shots all wrong, gone through all sorts of crises of confidence as is the modern forward's wont and would have singlehandedly blown a Grand Final with crappy misses from 25 metres out along the lines of Mooney, Milne and Co.

2015-08-21T04:24:11+00:00

GazzaW

Guest


Has so much time passed already that people have forgotten how good a forward Dunstall was? He would have kicked goals in any era. Rioli as a forward has never done over time what Dunstall did week in week out. Rioli is a freak of the game but put him at full forward every week and you won't get what dunstall did.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar