Manly's glass still half full despite a disjointed season opening

By Jason Hosken / Roar Guru

Not many fans let alone coaches would brag about a 3-4 start to the season, especially a rebuilt Manly line-up touted by many as top four certainties.

But despite a dreadful opening fortnight, Trent Barrett should be slapping his men on the back following their spirited rebound amid a condensed schedule.

Thursday night’s loss to the revitalised Eels in a brutal contest perfectly summed up Manly’s strengths and weaknesses from the opening seven rounds and although they sit outside the eight, I’ve seen enough to conclude the glass is half full.

Results aside, Barrett has the essential ingredients – the ears and minds of his troops. They proved this to a man by greeting Parramatta’s ferocity head on. Without it, sprinklings of fineness as Jason Taylor described remain unsustainable and lead to rumours of divide as Michael MacGuire is finding out.

Since being bashed by the Bulldogs in the opening round, the Sea Eagles’ pack has more than held their own in subsequent contests.

Nate Myles, although unspectacular, regularly leads the pack with a century of metres up the front and Martin Taupau’s destructive charges have returned following a quiet Test series in England before Christmas.

Young Jake Trbojevic’s committed early showings show no sign of faltering while former perennial lower grader Siosia Vave’s power and minutes upfront have surprised many.

Throw in solid contributions from Darcy Lussick, Brenton Lawrence and the creativity of Tom Symonds in addition to Matt Parcell’s slick service and Manly’s struggles stem from an inability regularly navigate a path across the stripe from point blank range.

Losses to both Parramatta and South Sydney weren’t through lack of effort or lack of desperation on their own line, but rather repeated attacking raids more awkward in appearance than a stumbling baby giraffe. In each contest, punishment was delivered by opponents superior execution in the clutch moments.

Barrett’s revamped roster was always going to battle the hourglass to cover Kieran Foran’s direct forays.

Dylan Walker’s selection at pivot remains a hot topic and while the addition of Apisai Koroisau has showcased glimpses of brilliance its been more the individual greasy pig variety than rehearsed plays.

Daly Cherry-Evans absence hasn’t helped but even worse is the month lost working with the former Rabbitoh centre.

It’s a work in progress that will probably roll into next season but the signs are there.

Walker’s expertly weighted banana kick in the opening exchanges against the Eels was a throwback to the Matty Orford days and would have unveiled Brett Stewart’s next assistant had the fullback been able to round off the act like he’s done countless times in the past.

Two uncharacteristic fumbles at each end of the park overshadowed some of Stewart’s best efforts of the season. After several tentative showings following tight hamstrings the try-scoring ace was again backing his pace around the ruck, especially in tandem with Walker.

Tom Trbojevic brings his own unique scoring options and despite a tough night against Semi Radradra the teenager’s transfer to fullback is clearly underway often swapping with Stewart to maximise kick return metres.

As it stands Manly’s squad is laced with strike power and options aplenty but the rewards will only flow if Barrett cracks the code before time has the final say.

In reality, Manly need to rebuild Fortress Brookvale before the committed government funds roll in.

With only one win from four, the Sea Eagles finals quest could come down to securing at least five wins from the six remaining games at their Pittwater Road home base. A touch and go scenario with games against the Cowboys, Panthers, Dragons, Knights, Storm and Raiders.

But striking at less than fifty per cent, the Sea Eagles epitomise the one week at a time cliche and this week’s Anzac clash in Newcastle is one they’ll be ready for given last year’s grand finalists follow in consecutive weeks.

The Crowd Says:

2016-04-18T10:35:19+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


Thanks Bearfax. Yeah, i guess he was destined to follow Gifty, well it looked like the plan. Shame his progress has been hampered by injury. Poor fella just cant string enough games to show his best. We need his best to take the pressure of the 5/8. It'll be interesting how Baz fits him in the mix.

2016-04-18T10:14:52+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


G'day Jason. I have a lot of respect for Buhrer. He's like an Australian Rules rover, who is best if he has a roving commission and moves about the field cleaning up or finding gaps. He's best at lock which means playing wide which I think utilises his evasiveness and solid defense. Glen Stewart was a good example. Like a second 5/8

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T06:09:26+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Gday Bearfax. Where do think Buhrer's best position is in a line-up that I'm guessing will include Tommy T and Brown from the bench. Those guys all have similar games and I think Buhrer is at his best playing on the edges within a big pack. I'm not so sure they can all fit into the 17. I'd be sending Brown to join Mateo before Tom.

2016-04-18T06:02:01+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


They helped but then DCE was a kid then. He's earned his stripes. Just needs forwards that actually go forward. May have it this year.

2016-04-18T05:59:40+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


So that's what's been happening has it Parrafan. On to you I am.

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T05:13:04+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


apaway, Manly definitely ran empty before Parra, blokes cramping all over the park in the last 10 minutes. In the coach's defence there were two late changes in the lead up (Lawro, Parcell outs) which I'm guessing complicated his rotation. Leary was caught short out of position at hooker with a few lost balls in the clutch - who chips from their own 40 with nothing doing?? And Brown's impact was nullified playing dummy half. On the flip-side, it looks like they've found a gooden in Fonua-Blake.

2016-04-18T03:38:06+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


The key all along was Lyon and Stewart next to Cherry-Evans... made DCE look like a rep quality halfback.

2016-04-18T02:33:21+00:00

S T Ruggling

Roar Pro


Would have loved to keep Foran, but the realistically he was never going to stay, regardless of what manly offered him, Brad Arthur was the main reason he went to Parra. Were even clauses in contract that if Arthur wasn't coach he could get out of contract, though not sure it got approved by Salary Cap Auditors.

2016-04-18T02:14:37+00:00

apaway

Roar Guru


I'd like to be as optimistic, I really would. But I have seen nothing to convince me that Trent Barrett is a competent NRL coach. The loss to Parramatta was hard to swallow because 3 of the Eels 4 tries came directly from Manly fumbles near their own try line. But the damning statistic was that Manly conceded 3 times in the last 10 minutes, at which time Barrett had used up all his interchanges. I'm also starting to think the Eagles threw the cash at the wrong half. And I LIKE DCE...

2016-04-18T01:51:18+00:00

Parrafan

Guest


Or if they keep paying him with hot pies and cans of coke.

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T01:30:57+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Thanks Nev Nev, have you been taking tips from Pauli Pauli?

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T01:29:18+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Angle of the dangle, a speedsters nightmare. Agree Mals, but gee, Semi exploded out of the ground.

2016-04-18T01:19:14+00:00

S T Ruggling

Roar Pro


the brothers are oozing potential, Tom just needs to sort out positional play on defense and ball security, will be a superstar in a few years

2016-04-18T01:19:09+00:00

Neville Neville

Guest


Well done Jason. You used the word foray within two words of typing Foran. Peter Peters & Neville Neville applaud your efforts

2016-04-18T01:17:36+00:00

Mals

Guest


Scott only caught Tom because Semi had forced him to the left side of the field and Scott was tracking back across from the left on the angle. Tom only saw him at the last second... disappointing that he lost the ball in contact.

2016-04-18T01:11:31+00:00

Mals

Guest


Nope Manly would lose games when DCE was out and Foran played but rarely the other way.

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T01:09:31+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


How good is it too see T Turbo in the open field. I was surprised Beau tracked him down the other night but I was equally surprised how quick Semi gained ground after offering a massive start. One of my season highlights was seeing Tom bust Souths and go one on one with GI - eventually man handled but must have been a thrill for the youngster. Along with Jake, the best is yet to come.

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T01:04:29+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Zorba doesn't put up with rabbles for too long, back him to be there when the worm turns.

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T01:03:01+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Taufua a massive loss. At times he looks a throw back to the T-Rex days on the wing ie: sound asleep. But he certainly ignites at the line and always propels Manly from the danger zone - can finish too. I fear the Wiliame curse in his absence. Mateo a strange one, I think we discussed his absence earlier in the year. Sometimes I reckon he'd be the best 5/8 option, he has covered the position well in the past - runs straight and can ball play. Can be error prone and struggles to string games together, certainly a strong bench candidate.

AUTHOR

2016-04-18T00:55:22+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Cheers EJ. Good point you make about Broncs and NQ being the only stand outs. We always hear the comp has never been closer every year but at present those two are miles in front. Parra, Bulldogs, Storm and Sharks are next on the list but the gap to Manly is well within reach. Tough month coming up, the Eagles have to find away to stay 50:50 before hopefully stringing a run at the back end.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar