Cutting Savea the right call, now it’s time to give Lowe a go

By Matt Porter / Roar Guru

Big ups to the All Blacks selectors for axing Julian Savea from the team to face Wales in the second Test.

The ‘Big Bus’ has been driven out of the entire matchday 23 in response to an insipid display in the first Test, following an anything-but-super season for the Hurricanes.

The All Black press release confirmed that Ben Smith has “replaced” Savea on the right wing, with Israel Dagg coming into fullback to revive his international career after being left out of the successful All Black World Cup defence last year.

It was obvious Savea was a world away from his blockbusting best last Saturday, not least the coach, who took the drastic action to hook him in the second minute of the second half.

The selectors have clearly lost patience with the big winger who, for the second year in a row, has shown up clearly out of shape and out of sorts from the All Blacks’ ‘off season’.

Last year he was so out of whack when reporting for the truncated Rugby Championship that he was dropped by Steve Hansen and not allowed back until completing an intensive boot camp.

He went on to play a starring role at the World Cup triumph, but that was then and this is now.

Last Saturday at Eden Park the strike weapon was a blunt instrument, able to beat just one defender and net only 22 metres in his five runs with the ball.

And you can put his try down to the pin-point accuracy of Aaron Cruden’s ‘kick pass’ that enabled him to claim the ball over the line largely uncontested.

But it was in defence that the All Black no.11 was utterly shown up, making just one tackle and missing three, mostly on his opposite George North, who had an barnstorming game with four clean breaks and six defenders beaten from his 121 metres carried.

It’s a real shame that the giant Welsh wing has been ruled out of the remainder of the tour with injury.

Savea has ruled himself out.

But despite his obvious lack of fitness and form, it still comes as something of a shock that Hansen and his selectors have dropped Savea.

They are a typically loyal bunch and a revert to type would have seen them work Savea into form from within camp.

It’s pleasing to see them making the tough and the right call.

Now ‘Shag’ needs to go one better and give James Lowe a go on the wing.

The 23-year-old has been brilliant all year for the Chiefs, including an eye-popping display in his team’s thumping of the Welsh on Tuesday night in the unfamiliar position of fullback.

Lowe did it all in the stunning win: burning up the FMG Stadium Waikato turf with some scintillating, trademark swervy busts upfield and clever offloads. Most notable was his big break in the first part of the second half, when his team were starved of possession, which led to him scoring the try that ultimately put the sword through the Welsh Dragon.

His raking left boot carved off big hunks of territory all night and his big-hearted defence saved at least one certain try.

He’s been doing this all year, despite his Super season being interrupted by a shoulder injury. Surely he’s loomed into the All Black frame.

When that tasty prospect was put to him after the game, Lowe said, “Hopefully one day, I’ve just got to keep plying my trade hopefully bigger honours will
come.”

Should the All Blacks win the second Test on Saturday, those higher honours should come in the third.

Dagg has been in compelling form and deserves a shot, but he can’t hold a candle to Smith at fullback – nobody can – and it irks that the world’s best custodian has to be shunted out of position all because the bloke that should be there doesn’t deserve to be there.

The All Blacks shouldn’t have to make do with non-specialists in makeshift arrangements, no matter how good or versatile they are.

The Crowd Says:

2016-06-18T04:05:17+00:00

lassitude

Guest


The Canterbury rugby mafia have given you 2 world cups. You're welcome.

2016-06-18T01:41:29+00:00

Apelu

Guest


Dream on, Mr Porter. Supper Rugby is not Test Rugby. The Bus is not fit, but when fit, he remains the best winger in the world; and Lowe can only dream.

2016-06-17T04:59:11+00:00

Jokerman

Guest


It could be subtle, Ben and a respect to his privacy. He's not in the right mental space and he does have a life outside rugby. Read between the lines.

2016-06-17T01:31:39+00:00

Jacko

Guest


To me it was a shame that he was taken off before his brother came on. I imagine it would be a special moment to play for your country with your brother, Apart from that I hope he is back to his best soon and back challenging for a starting position.

2016-06-17T01:02:09+00:00

taylorman

Guest


Liam Williams, classy player. My fave Welsh player to watch.

2016-06-17T00:48:28+00:00

Highlander

Guest


Savea has scored 16 more tries than that lot put together

2016-06-17T00:14:56+00:00

ken

Guest


It will be 2 nil Saturday night because Chiekas refuses to pick the best 23 ...None of those blokes I mentioned are test match quality..

2016-06-16T22:17:35+00:00

Scrumma

Guest


Last year savea had weight problems, this year he was part of the canes saga and now savea form last week was below par.

2016-06-16T20:49:35+00:00

pete and paul

Roar Rookie


all of a sudden you are a psychiatrist Council....lighten up mate - Hansen's strategy is to pull Savea so he regains the hunger just as he did with Dagg...when you work and turn up to the Office day after day you get stale...in the AB environment that is anathema to what they aspire to....let it go mate

2016-06-16T18:32:34+00:00

mania

Guest


world rugby championship...yeah agree its a naff name

2016-06-16T15:21:32+00:00

Not Bothered

Guest


World Rally Championship?

2016-06-16T15:20:36+00:00

Not Bothered

Guest


Rubbish. You are the biased one and quite ridiculous. You represent the worst aspect of Wallaby supporters culture. You hate your own team and players because of a pathetic and childish bias. Grow up.

2016-06-16T15:17:40+00:00

Not Bothered

Guest


Ahh Ken. Always hating your own teams players. Great work. Oh, they are not your team though QLDs your team, not Australia. Go QLD and booooo to those NSW players. Who needs enemies...

2016-06-16T15:14:23+00:00

Not Bothered

Guest


That was Lowe was it? Are you a different Ben to the one having a go at people for suggesting Savea had some issues outside the game because you are assuming a great deal yourself mate by asserting it was Lowe.

2016-06-16T15:08:08+00:00

Not Bothered

Guest


Tivita Li!!!!? Seriously? Id like to see him play well enough to nail down a Blues spot first. I dont think he is in the top 15 wings in NZ. Wing depth is not a problem in NZ. Savea, Naholo, Smith, Lowe, Ioane, Jane, Moala.

2016-06-16T15:02:49+00:00

Not Bothered

Guest


Piutau played both wings. Funny how you are determined to put Ben on the left but claim Naholo, whos played whole seasons on the left, is not a left wing and should not really play there.

2016-06-16T11:56:29+00:00

Council

Guest


I class mental issues and health as off field. Same as you would with depression.

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T11:19:45+00:00

Matt Porter

Roar Guru


Very valid point Nicholas. You don't see guys like McCaw when playing & Pocock, with lots of interests outside game go stale often.

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T11:17:19+00:00

Matt Porter

Roar Guru


Fair call, when is NMS due back?

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T11:14:17+00:00

Matt Porter

Roar Guru


Good point Jerry

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar