Sydney are flat track bullies. The Bulldogs are the real deal.
Three weeks ago Sydney failed to get one of their renowned fast starts. They panicked and then disintegrated under the pressure Western Sydney applied.
A similar performance was put up by the Swans earlier this season against the Giants, and also against Hawthorn and anyone else the Swans weren’t able to put away early.
The two top four winners of the first week, Geelong and GWS, were scratchy and rusty in the opening 25 minutes of their preliminary finals. While Sydney capitalised with seven goals, the Bulldogs let GWS off the hook – going forward a remarkable 16 times in that time period but managing only two goals, and missed two excruciatingly easy shots in the first quarter.
Both GWS and Geelong matched their opponents from quarter time on. The difference was the Cats were a mile behind. Turns out playing one game in four weeks isn’t ideal preparation for a preliminary final, but we can thank the cynicism of the Fremantle Dockers and North Melbourne in seasons past for this particular innovation that no one asked for, nor wanted.
A quick word on the vanquished.
Greater Western Sydney are a strong chance for next season’s flag. Make no mistake, they can play.
There is no missing piece in the GWS puzzle and their younger players will only get better. This defeat will put a hitherto unknown hunger into the team that will not rest until a silver cup resides in a pristine minimalist Scandinavian cabinet at Spotless Stadium.
Geelong aren’t done. Jimmy Bartel and even Corey Enright may go, but Nakia Cockatoo, Darcy Lang, Jed Bews and Tom Ruggles are pounding on the door to come in. Cory Gregson and Jackson Thurlow will return. Scott Selwood will play a full season.
Sam Menegola will improve. Patrick Dangerfield already plays like a man possessed – and his demons will grow in power after this disappointment. He will be like Joachim Murat’s cavalry charge at Eylau – a tidal wave that will shake the earth under the feet of his enemies.
Back to the main event…
The upside of the bye was the Bulldogs were able to bring back some stars and freshen up, with their extraordinary win against West Coast at Subiaco the result. That outcome – against a team that seemed to have hit devastating form – gave the Dogs the self-belief to roll Hawthorn and then march into western Sydney like Caesar at Bibracte.
Lin Jong’s 29 touches in Footscray’s VFL Premiership victory recommend him highly for a return to the main stage, and he could do a Steven King, with a VFL and AFL premiership medal in the same season.
The Swans are a good team, a very, very good team, but not as good as their easy wins against Adelaide and Geelong suggest. Sydney’s win against Adelaide was similar to its win against Geelong. The Crows, like the Cats, played far below their best – especially early. And like the Cats they were wasteful when they did enjoy belated periods of dominance.
As the song says, Bulldogs fight. This season the Dogs had to overcome a shocking injury run, and then in the finals faced huge tests – West Coast in Perth, the reigning triple premiers coming off a stinging loss, and the Giants at their toy stadium.
Every time they have stood up and overcome the odds. This is a club that understands struggle, that understands suffering. This is a club that understands community, and gladly belongs – heart and soul – to its supporters. This is a club that remembers ’89.
There will be no easy start for Sydney on Saturday. From the first second there will be no quarter given by the Dogs, who play like they are prepared to die in a ditch for Luke Beveridge.
The Bulldogs are blessed with speed, intensity, marking power, exquisite skills – and hearts like 22 Phar Laps. Not one of that 22 will play a millimetre below his best.
This is it, 62 years in the making – here come the Dogs.
Giovanni Torre
Guest
As Hamlet said... "Cock will crow, and dog will have his day". Seems applicable here.
Giovanni Torre
Guest
My prediction regarding Geelong and the Hawks was a little audacious, but since the Dogs beat West Coast I backed them to beat the Hawks, GWS and Sydney. You were quite right about the Dogs' need for greater efficiency.
Giovanni Torre
Guest
Sydney finished on top of the ladder, with the same amount of wins as Geelong and Hawthorn, just one win clear of GWS, Adelaide and West Coast, and just two wins clear of a Bulldogs side that suffered a horrendous run with injury. I am not a Bulldogs supporter, I was just very, very confident the Dogs would win for the reasons I laid out above.
Giovanni Torre
Guest
A "flat track bully" is a cricket term that suggests a particular team looks great in placid conditions or against weak opponents, rather than being an actual bully. Sydney are a pretty clean side. They are also a good side, but not as good as the easy wins against Adelaide and Geelong suggested. This is why I was confident in predicting a Dogs win.
Giovanni Torre
Guest
“Not one of that 22 will play a millimetre below his best.” - this is written in future tense. It was a prediction that on Grand Final day not one of the 22 Dogs would play a millimetre below his best. I did not write "not one of the 22 Dogs ever play below their best". That would have been silly. I watched them lose to Geelong by 54 points. My prediction was fairly accurate, as it turned out.
Giovanni Torre
Guest
I'm not a Bulldogs supporter.
david graham
Guest
Well written Olivia. THe public has a short memory. THey forget the years of struggle we endured and the sense of the door being slammed shut on us. THe Swans still seems to be a club with lots of soul to me ; a club which is close to it's supporters - old South and Sydney.
Bruce
Guest
Meh....a 50m given on a technicality? Oh he got 8m from Scully instead of staying 10m away. Who cares...the whistle rightly gets put away and they only pay the really obvious ones. Please...would have been disgraceful to pay that in the final minute of a tight prelim.
andyl12
Guest
So you are admitting that a Bulldogs flag would be devalued by the fact that the game will be played at the MCG. Good to hear.
Birdman
Guest
Making excuses in advance? That's novel.
Birdman
Guest
I'm sure they are after 4 consecutive grannies and will be better for the extra month's pre-season. Thanks for caring.
Mark
Guest
Your boys enjoying Bali? #tosser
rusty
Roar Rookie
I think Sydney will win fairly easily but I am praying that I'm wrong.
mattyb
Guest
Andy,I've told you twice today already,the Swans should have a home GF,stop twisting things. Of coarse I'd rather win the GF with fairer rules.l,who wouldn't. If you can't support you're own argument without nonsense go away,seriously.
Bruce
Guest
Exactly
andyl12
Guest
Mattyb, I'm just asking fir consistency. You've said in the past that the GF needs to be moved, yet now you've gone quiet on that opinion because, in your own words, it would devalue any success the Bulldogs happen to have this Saturday. You're only about pursuing the agendas that suit you, it's quite obvious.
Jim
Guest
Your vitriol knows no end.....
Pumping Dougie
Guest
Bring on Saturday! I secured tickets today and can't wait!!!
Pumping Dougie
Guest
Jong is unlucky but I still don't think he's in our best 22. McLean's decision-making and class are way higher. Very impressive effort by Jong though to play two weeks after a broken collar bone and surgery - mad.
Pumping Dougie
Guest
One change only I reckon - Suckling for Roberts.