2016 mock draft – final edition

By Tom Baulch / Roar Guru

The final edition of my full mock draft is here.

Ahead of one of the biggest days on the football calendar, every 18-year-old around the country is looking for his shot at the biggest game in Australia.

I have completed this mock draft with the academy bidding system and each team’s needs in mind.

The academy system and the rules of the draft are complex, so I have written down a few tips that will help you understand this mock draft.

Any club can bid on any academy player.

The club that the academy player is with then has a choice to match the bid or leave it to the club that has bid on that player. If the academy club chooses to ‘match’ the bid, then they will need to use a certain amount of ‘points’ to match the clubs bid. The club that bid then gets the next pick in the draft. Simple right?

When an academy club matches an offer, they are obliged to use their next pick, and if required, their next available pick after that. For instance, they cannot use their first and fourth round picks to match an offer.

There is a 20 per cent discount on academy kids and father-son picks in the first round. After that, there is a 197 point subtraction on points.

Clubs usually won’t take their own academy or father-son selections because of the 20 per cent discount on points. However, they will take their own father-sons or academy kids if they have fewer points left, to avoid being in deficit.

Teams with mid-range picks will bid on academy kids to move their own mid-range picks up the order.

All clubs must pick at least three players.

In this draft, a lot of picks look out of place. This is because if a club has left over points while matching a bid on a player then their amount of leftover points will slot into where it should belong in the draft.

Once again I must note that this is done on what each team needs, not randomly.

Below are the academy picks. Enjoy.

Academy and father-son bids
Pick 3 – Brisbane Lions bid on Jack Bowes – matched with pick 4
Pick 11 – North Melbourne bid on Will Setterfield – matched with pick 13
Pick 14 – Adelaide bid on Harry Perryman – matched with picks 37, 38, 45
Pick 25 – Geelong bid on Zachary Sproule – matched with picks 53, 56, 58
Pick 28 – Western Bulldogs bid on Harrison Macreadie bid – not matched by GWS
Pick 29 – Richmond bid on Kobe Mutch – not matched by GWS
Pick 31 – Essendon bid on Callum Brown – matched with picks 44, 51
Pick 41 – Fremantle bid on Brad Scheer – matched with pick 52
Pick 63 – Essendon bid on Lachlan Tizani – not matched by GWS
Pick 67 – Geelong bid on Ryan Garthwaite – not matched by GWS

Round one
1. ESS – Hugh McCluggage
2. GWS – Andrew McGrath
3. GCFC – Jack Bowes
4. BL – Ben Ainsworth
5. CARL – Sam Petrevski Seton
6. GCFC – Will Brodie
7. FREM – Griffin Logue
8. GCFC – Tim Taranto
9. SYD – Jarrod Berry
10. GCFC – Tim English
11. GWS – Will Setterfield
12. NMFC – Jack Scrimshaw
13. WC – Jy Simpkin
14. GWS – Harry Perryman
15. ADEL – Will Hayward
16. PORT – Josh Battle
17. BL – Oliver Florent
18. PORT – Alex Witherden
19. WB – Todd Marshall
20. SYD – Cedric Cox

Round two
21. ESS – Sam Powell Pepper
22. BL – Daniel Venables
23. BL – Brennan Cox
24. STK – Shai Bolton
25. GWS – Zachary Sproule
26. GEEL – Jordan Ridley
27. CARL – Patrick Kerr
28. WB – Harrison Macreadie (GWS don’t match bid)
29. RICH – Kobe Mutch (GWS don’t match bid)
30. COLL – Jordan Gallucci
31. COLL – Callum Brown
32. ESS – Jonty Scharenberg
33. PORT – Sam Walker
34. PORT – Jack Maibum
35. NMFC – Dylan Clarke
36. NMFC – Luke Ryan
37. WC – Jake Waterman
38. FREM – Ben Long
39. STK – Isaac Cumming
40. GEEL – Sam Walker
41. GCFC – Brad Scheer
42. FREM – Zac Fisher

Round three
43. ESS – Brandon Parfitt
44. GEEL – Jack Graham
45. ADEL- Jamie Hampton
46. SYD – Kym LeBois
47. MELB – Willem Drew
48. GWS – Isaac Cumming
49. CARL – Taylin Duman
50. SYD – Joe Atley
51. WB – Tony Olango
54. ADEL – Ben Jarman
55. WC – Josh Rotham
56. RICH – Hamish Brayshaw

Round four
57. COLL – Josh Daicos
58. STK – Josh Begley
59. COLL – Max Lynch
60. CARL – Sam McLarty
61. GEEL – Myles Poholke
62. ADEL – Ben Ronke
63. ESS – Lachlan Tizani (GWS don’t match bid)
64. MELB – Patrick Lipinski
65. FREM – Matt Guelfi
66. GEEL – Tom Williamson
67. GEEL – Ryan Garthwaite (GWS don’t match bid)
68. BL – Jacob Allison

Round five
69. RICH – Brodie Romensky
70. CARL – Josh Williams
71. MELB – Jake Pitman
72. CARL – Connor Noonan
73. STK – Judah Dundon
74. HAW – Esava Ratugolea

Round six
75. ADEL – Arie Sarkenson
76. HAW – Mitchell Hinge
77. GEEL – Elliot Himmelberg
78. NMFC – Oliver Hanrahan
79. RICH – Jeremy Goddard
80. MELB – Reece Piper
81. STK – Harrison Burt

Round seven
82. WC – Tyson Stengle
83. HAW – Corey Lyons

Any thoughts, questions or queries? Be sure to leave them below!

The Crowd Says:

2016-11-22T09:56:32+00:00

Macca

Guest


I checked that about 3 times and still missed it

2016-11-22T06:31:33+00:00

Slane

Guest


They have pick 26.

2016-11-22T06:19:47+00:00

Macca

Guest


Yarran and the Tigers have just parted ways - the TIges might be wishing they had a pick before 56.

2016-11-22T02:20:18+00:00

Aransan

Guest


Thanks Katfish. Macca, perhaps in the long run a national competition could be set up for the 19 year olds with two teams based on universities from Vic, SA, WA and one team each from Tas, Canberra, NSW and Qld. The existing competitions could act as feeders for the national teams. There could be enough interest for this to be televised, especially as it will give viewers a lead in to the draft.

2016-11-22T00:00:28+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


I think that raising the minimum draft age by two months each year is an outstanding way to go about it. I'd be happy with a minimum age of 19, just because my biggest concern for the current draft age is players having to balance football with their study. It would also mean that some of the talented 20yo's who didnt get picked the year before will have another chance with the overage rule. But I can certainly see why you'd be keen for the minimum age to be 20

2016-11-21T23:57:07+00:00

Macca

Guest


Aransan - I have no issue with lifting the draft age as such but where would these kids play in the meantime? Do we go back to an under 19 comp? On the education front I am aware of one player who got drafted in the top 10 whose agent told him not to bother with his year 12 exams despite him attending school all year - it has worked out well for him so far but it doesn't for everyone.

2016-11-21T23:49:08+00:00

Aransan

Guest


I would lift the draft age to 20 over a maximum of 12 years, lift the age by 2 months per year. I guarantee that at some stage the AFL will want to speed it up. This will give players the opportunity to make significant progress in a trade or a tertiary education before they embark on a footy career. It will also mean that they will be better able to cope with a move interstate if required to do so. The clubs can adjust to this change, we have seen many players delisted this year because of age who are still capable of good football. More of them will be retained and clubs will be forced to look at the secondary competitions. On another note, I think Macca has turned the tables on Don. Surely it wouldn't have been hard to find the origin of that quote.

2016-11-21T23:41:35+00:00

Slane

Guest


That is a classic Macca/Don exchange if I've ever seen one.

2016-11-21T23:34:13+00:00

Macca

Guest


Who said it - only philosopher, logician, mathematician, historian, writer, social critic, political activist and Nobel laureate Bertrand Russell - but who is he compared to the wisdom of Don Freo! "It’s certainly no aphorism." I love the irony that the certainty of the denial proves the quote to in fact be an aphorism.

2016-11-21T22:41:30+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Why is that in quotations? Who said it? It's certainly no aphorism.

2016-11-21T22:34:40+00:00

Macca

Guest


“The whole problem with the world is that fo0ls and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wise people so full of doubts.”

2016-11-21T22:34:11+00:00

Macca

Guest


“The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wise people so full of doubts.”

2016-11-21T22:24:16+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


There's a lot you are "not sure" about.

2016-11-21T22:18:45+00:00

Macca

Guest


"O’Meara and Hogan were ready at 17" I am not sure these are the 2 best examples - O'meara has missed 2 years with a Patella tendon and Hogan missed 12 months with a stress related back injury.

2016-11-21T21:14:06+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


I di rate Himmelberg quite highly and i'm pretty sure that he will be gone before the Crows second pick. Definitely agree that Adelaide's ability to develop players is just about best in the League. Had it not been for stars leaving the club, we would have had an outstanding team built from just the draft

2016-11-21T11:22:18+00:00

Macca

Guest


Yep Don they are one of the teams that "now occupy the bottom of the ladder" so as I said if Mattybs isn't talking about them who is he talking about -your Dockers? The Lions? Neither of which had bad drafts last year.

2016-11-21T10:54:30+00:00

Aransan

Guest


Katfish, you have made some excellent points in your various posts. At some stage they will have to increase the draft age and the longer they delay doing so, the harder it will be.

2016-11-21T10:33:09+00:00

Crowbot

Guest


You don't rate Himmelberg? I just feel that Adelaide have a lot of spots to fill and there seems to be a lot of utility types that could be good things available late in the draft, so grabbing a KPD a bit earlier maybe a smart move. I'd currently rate Adelaide's ability to develop players as 1st class.

2016-11-21T10:27:08+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Oh...good grief!!! Essendon's seconds was a bottom side.

2016-11-21T10:21:51+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


It would be an unfair restraint of trade for 18yo that are well and truly ready. O'Meara and Hogan were ready at 17. (O'Meara's injury could have happened at any age.)

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar