Wallabies depth in 2017: The backs

By The Crowd / Roar Guru

Following on from my previous article on depth in the Wallabies forwards, I am going to explore backline depth in 2017.

Halfback is really the only sufficiently rigorous and specialised position to require the same three-player depth as the forward positions. From 10 to 15 player interchangeability between positions means that two international standard specialists plus a third generalist who can cover the position represents adequate depth.

I will start at 15 because that incorporates a key consideration of Israel Folau.

Fullback
Israel Folau is not an international standard fullback. The bloke can’t kick, he is always out of position in defence and he doesn’t play an organising role or a playmaking role. All he really offers from that position is kick returns which have become predictable, support play while out of position and the opportunity to defuse the high ball – but opposition teams just kick it away from him.

The Wallabies need a proper fullback and the hottest property in the competitive Aussie football market needs to be moved somewhere where he can do he loves, scoring tries, or rugby risks losing him when his contract expires.

Folau covets the 13 jersey but he has hot competition in Samu Kerevi and Tevita Kuridrani, so the wing is the obvious place where he could be moved to be given more attacking opportunities.

The mid-year tour this year provides a prime opportunity to put him there to develop a partnership with Kerevi at 13, a skilled and absolutely unselfish player who will get him the ball and space he needs to shine again.

As for other fullback options Kurtley Beale and Dane Haylett-Petty represent good depth while Luke Morahan represents a capped fall back option and Karmichael Hunt a potential left of field bolter.

Wings
Capped specialists on the wings are a bit thin on the ground with Sefanaia Naivalu and Henry Speight being the only two, but there are enough generalist names to consider such as Folau, Morahan, Haylett-Petty and Reece Hodge.

There are also uncapped options such as Marika Koriobete, Andrew Kellaway and Izaea Perese who may warrant a first cap in June if they do well in Super Rugby.

Most of all though I hope that a club finds a spot for James O’Connor to come back to Australia, Australia can’t afford to leave players of his talent out forever.

Outside centre
Australia is in a happy place in this position with plenty of Kerevi and Tevita Kuridrani representing world class options and Folau snapping at their heels. Other players who can cover 13 include Henry Speight and Sefania Naivalu so depth here is very good.

Inside centre
In contrast to 13, the loss of a swag of experienced 12s last year has left this position looking short on experienced options.

Reece Hodge did a good job there last year considering that he was thrust into the role and has tremendous athletic potential, but he is still raw and needs to work on his handling and decision making.

Kyle Godwin is another option who will keep the pressure on Hodge and Kerevi can cover 12 as well, providing another option to accommodate Folau at 13. I don’t rate Beale at 12, he is the best attacker from that position but he just can’t defend and for an international 12 that is in my opinion a non-negotiable.

As for potential bolters, it is early days at the Tahs for Irae Simone but based on what we saw from the trial game against the Highlanders, he is one to watch.

Fly half
Quade Cooper and Bernard Foley represent experienced specialist options in this role and Beale is an international standard backup option, therefore this position has good depth.

Halfback
This position is the greatest worry in the entire team. Thank goodness for Giteau’s Law because it makes Will Genia available, as he is the Wallabies only genuinely international-standard halfback at the moment.

However, while he plays in France is not available for the full international season and the backup options are poor or untested.

Nick Phipps is not an international standard halfback, after six years he still makes too many mistakes and costs the Wallabies games. Nick Frisby hasn’t had enough international experience to be confident that he can step up yet and other options such as Nick Stirzaker and Joe Powell are uncapped.

It is imperative that Cheika give players other than Phipps the starts mid-year this year, or the Wallabies are going to be stuck in the same cycle of poor halfback play when Genia is away.

Therefore aside from halfback which is a big worry and to a lesser extent inside centre, Wallabies backline depth is looking OK in 2017.

The Crowd Says:

2017-02-25T01:12:32+00:00

Rhys Bosley

Guest


No worries :-)

2017-02-24T02:09:36+00:00

Cassandra

Roar Rookie


The bloke can’t kick. Thank you. I've written dissertations and bored friends and family to death about what is wrong with Folau's kicking, but you've summed the problem up in four words. The logical extension of not being able to kick is that he cannot play fullback.

2017-02-23T14:33:02+00:00

Rhys Bosley

Guest


Agreed, but then so do all of them.

2017-02-23T13:55:24+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


I think he is a lot better than fourth string The problem is that he needs to stay fit to prove it

2017-02-23T13:53:37+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Let me clarify Kurtley should stay away for 2 seasons to make the move worthwhile for himseld financially You can't begrudge him making the cash If he does this then by the time he returns to Australia he'll be a yard slower and at the wrong end of his career. Hence DHP, even though he only a little younger is better positioned at FB over the next few years Just my opinion and I accept it is an arguable position

2017-02-23T11:00:55+00:00

Rhys Bosley

Guest


Lance did well against France last year, goal kicks well and tackles well. For a fourth stringer he is credible, we would use him for the lower profile games if we needed to preserve one of the others during an injury crisis. Besides which I don't know which young player has demonstrated enough form to justify a trial, I think those four and Leleifano when he comes back are the options for the next few years.

2017-02-23T10:54:40+00:00

Rhys Bosley

Guest


Disagree on Beale, he didn't lose the series by himself and it was nearly four years ago. He has played plenty of good footy since then. We should remember that he was the 10 in the 2012 and 2014 Bledisloe draws, both times the Wallabies were seriously under strength. I rate him better than Foley at 10 but behind Quade.

2017-02-23T09:46:42+00:00

Markus

Guest


Haylett-Petty is all of like 5 months younger than Beale.

2017-02-23T09:28:48+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Halfback - what to say , you nailed it. We are struggling here. I am a bit surprised at the level of confidence in the fly half position. I would have thought that this was one position that did warrant consideration of some new talent - Jono Lance for example (assuming he can stay on the paddock for a season). I also agree that Hodge is a bit raw but for my money he is definitely the future of the 12 position and should be the first pick in that role. All the other positions I agree with. W are actually quite strong in the back 3 and have good depth - we just have to pray that Cheks actually decides to pick his best 3 and not throw them around like he has been doing. I agree with the sentiment on JOC. Such a waste of talent but ultimately he needs to get his act together. If ARU tries to entice him home that will work against us. He needs to decide that he wants to come home for the right reasons. Kurtley can stay away. He was right to leave, it was a good decision for him. Hodge and DHP are better than adequate options and both have more rugby left in them than him at international level.

2017-02-23T08:13:46+00:00

Jimbo81

Guest


Totally agree with the article and GM. If Folau is selected FB we will never win the Bledisloe. They've completely got that figured out. Also: foley has 100% lost his mojo. With the new halfback we need a new Full Time 5/8. If Quade can run and recapture the step, he's our man. If he can only pass long or flick, we need to keep looking. Beale lost us the Lions series by slipping over. The final straw for me. Try Godwin at 10 or Harris.

2017-02-23T03:19:22+00:00

Rhys Bosley

Guest


I'm not because if he doesn't get it right he will be back to selling jeans by years end.

2017-02-23T02:36:29+00:00

Marto

Guest


I`m really afraid to see what backline chieka picks.... Genuinely afraid :(

Read more at The Roar