Live scores
Live Commentary
Melbourne Victory
Adelaide United
| 38'

The Roar’s A-League expert tips and predictions: Round 23

Daniel Jeffrey Editor

By Daniel Jeffrey, Daniel Jeffrey is a Roar Editor

 , ,

5 Have your say

    Sydney FC have continued their march towards the minor premiership, and Melbourne Victory seem to have a monopoly on second, but there’s still plenty of finals spots up for grabs. As always, we’ll break down who’s going to edge closer and who’s falling back in our A-League expert tips and predictions.

    Last week was a decent one on the tipping front for everyone. Everyone except me, that is. Vas has once again surged up to regain a share of the lead with me on 56 points, while The Crowd and Matt are both edging back – albeit ever so slightly – now on 49.

    Mike (48) is a further point back, and Janek (44) remains in last spot.

    As a split round, the upcoming series of matches is going to be shared over the next two weekends, but we’re still going to tackle all five games in the one go.

    As always, be sure to lend your voice to The Crowd in the form below to help every Roarer out-tip the experts. Voting closes at 4pm (AEDT) on Friday, so make sure you check back after then to see the final results.

    On to the tips!


    Mike Tuckerman

    Sydney FC, Melbourne Victory, Melbourne City, Brisbane Roar, Wellington Phoenix

    Sydney FC vs Central Coast Mariners
    Sydney FC. The Sky Blues are romping home to the Premiers’ Plate and they’ll take another step to sealing the trophy in front of their home fans. The only question is: how many fans will be there to witness it?

    Melbourne Victory vs Perth Glory
    Victory. Last weekend’s loss to Sydney FC will have been tough to take for Kevin Muscat’s men. They’ll look to bounce back against an unpredictable Perth Glory in what should be a tight contest at AAMI Park.

    Melbourne City vs Newcastle Jets
    City. Melbourne City have flattered to deceive all season, and they’ll head into the home stretch of the season looking over their shoulders. They should have too much firepower for the Jets, but you never know with City.

    Adelaide United vs Brisbane Roar
    Roar. John Aloisi is furious at having been linked with Adelaide United, and his side could go into this clash with an added dose of motivation. The Roar have been in patchy form of late, but they’re likely to claim all three points in Adelaide.

    John Aloisi Brisbane Roar

    Western Sydney Wanderers vs Wellington Phoenix
    Phoenix. It’s been a season to forget for both teams, but despite that, they’re still fighting for a place in the top six. Spotless Stadium hasn’t proved a happy hunting ground for the home team, and they could come unstuck against an inconsistent Phoenix.

    Matt Connellan

    Sydney FC, Draw, Melbourne City, Brisbane Roar, Wellington Phoenix

    Sydney FC vs Central Coast Mariners
    Sydney. The Sky Blues are just relentless and although the Mariners are spirited and have come a long way since the start of the season, they won’t be able to match it against their former coach and a couple of their former players.

    Melbourne Victory vs Perth Glory
    Draw. Victory are still my alternate favourites (is that a thing?) to Sydney FC, although Perth aren’t far behind. The boys from the west are certainly hitting their stride at the right time, but I can’t split them.

    Melbourne City vs Newcastle Jets
    Melbourne. City should be too good for Newcastle here, although there’s still much to like about the Jets’ spirit and determination. But City just have too much firepower across the park.

    Adelaide United vs Brisbane Roar
    Brisbane. The Roar are another team that could well be in the mix on the final day and when Jamie Maclaren is scoring goals they are as dangerous as anyone in the competition. They’ll get up here, I reckon.

    Western Sydney Wanderers vs Wellington Phoenix
    Wellington. I just can’t tip Western Sydney at home. So… Wellington it is, but without a lot of confidence.


    Janek Speight

    Sydney FC, Melbourne Victory, Melbourne City, Brisbane Roar, Draw

    Vas Venkatramani

    Sydney FC, Melbourne Victory, Melbourne City, Brisbane Roar, Draw

    Sydney FC vs Central Coast Mariners
    Sydney FC. A win for the home side will all but secure the minor premiership. The Mariners made a fine comeback against Melbourne City last week, but couldn’t hold on to prevent a home loss, which has severely dented their finals hopes. On form, the Sky Blues are a safe option.

    Melbourne Victory vs Perth Glory
    Melbourne Victory. The Victory’s minor premiership hopes all but evaporated last week after losing to Sydney FC. With nine points separating them from their crosstown rivals, the Victory should be sufficiently clear to not have any late season nerves. The Glory will be more motivated for a result, given both Brisbane and City are a point ahead, yet away from home, Perth’s struggles are notable.

    Melbourne City vs Newcastle Jets
    Melbourne City. With a two-week break in the offing, both sides should be refreshed heading into what is shaping as a crucial fixture. City need a win to keep the chasing pack at bay, while the Jets’ slim finals hopes will likely dissipate without three points. At home, and having won a tumultuous fixture last week in Gosford, City should be too good.

    Adelaide United vs Brisbane Roar
    Brisbane Roar. The Reds were obdurate in holding out the Wanderers last week on their travels, yet it’s been at home where Adelaide have largely disappointed. The Roar can climb to third if they can win here, and that should almost secure a top six finish.

    Western Sydney Wanderers vs Wellington Phoenix
    Draw. The match of the (split) round – the Wanderers have two points on their opponents, and will be at home against the Phoenix that are notorious strugglers on their travels. It may largely fall to one side breaking the mental hoodoo, yet with the pressure on, it possibly paving the way for either a feisty or lamentably poor occasion. Yet with not many games left, both sides will be disinclined to risk, making a draw a decent option.


    Daniel Jeffrey

    Sydney FC< Melbourne Victory, Melbourne City, Brisbane Roar, Western Sydney Wanderers

    Sydney FC vs Central Coast Mariners
    Sydney. This one didn’t take too much mulling over at all. Sydney have been dominant this year while the Mariners, well, haven’t. At all.

    Melbourne Victory vs Perth Glory
    Melbourne. A tough one to tip, but the Victory have been the second-best team in the comp all year, while the Glory have been brilliant at times, but overall inconsistent. At home, I’ll back Melbourne.

    Melbourne City vs Newcastle Jets
    City. They’ve lost Fernando Brandan for the year, but City still have too much quality on the pitch, particularly up front, to not make a serious finals push. After last week’s win, they’ll keep the momentum rolling at home against the Jets.

    Adelaide United vs Brisbane Roar
    Brisbane. Adelaide have become less and less terrible the longer the season has gone on, but they’ve still been a long way from what anyone could describe as ‘good.’ I’ll take Brisbane on the Roar.

    Western Sydney Wanderers vs Wellington Phoenix
    Western Sydney. The Wanderers have been dreadful at Spotless Stadium this year, but they’ve shown some signs of decent form in recent weeks. Given Wellington’s inconsistency, I’ll take Western Sydney.

    Round 23 Mike Matt Janek Vas Daniel The Crowd
    Last week 2 3 2 2 1 3
    Total 48 49 44 56 56 49

    Daniel Jeffrey
    Daniel Jeffrey

    Daniel is Editor of The Roar. You can catch him on Twitter @_d_jeffrey.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (5)

    • March 10th 2017 @ 10:09am
      mattq said | March 10th 2017 @ 10:09am | ! Report

      anyone know why it is split?

    • March 10th 2017 @ 11:48am
      Chopper said | March 10th 2017 @ 11:48am | ! Report

      I was told it is to give the ACL competing teams some space to recuperate in between ACL fixtures. As a Brisbane Roar supporter I reckon it has come two or three weeks too late.

    • Roar Guru

      March 10th 2017 @ 1:41pm
      Kaks said | March 10th 2017 @ 1:41pm | ! Report

      Nix (forever WSW bogey team)

    • March 10th 2017 @ 1:51pm
      Nemesis said | March 10th 2017 @ 1:51pm | ! Report

      Always interesting to see pundits & posters predict Melbourne Victory will Draw every week.

      Victory has only Drawn 3 matches out of 22. Least likely team to draw.

      By contrast, WSW & Brisbane are leading the League for Drawn matches.

      • March 10th 2017 @ 10:57pm
        Daniel T said | March 10th 2017 @ 10:57pm | ! Report

        As you rightly point out, I think this has to be one of the hardest games to predict in the round.

        Glory have had the wood on Victory in recent encounters, but you can never write Melbourne off with the players Muscat has at his disposal.

        Since their last game, Glory have had a much more consistent line up and this has shown in their performances. Fewer goals conceded, better passages of play and considerably more possession. Earlier in the season Perth were limited to playing (and frequently scoring) on the counter, but were always on the back foot and thus conceded a lot of goals. This has changed in recent games and they are now dominating possession for considerable periods.

        Even as a Glory fan, I’ve tipped a draw but I am far from confident in my tip. The game could go either way and as you say, Melbourne have very few draws to their name. It will really depend on each side on the day as both teams have the capacity to win this one without it being considered lucky. Perth arguably have more to play for given that Melbourne has almost wrapped up second spot whilst Perth are still battling it out with Brisbane and WSW for third. From my own perspective, I hope this is enough to get them over the line. I just hope the ref doesnt ruin the game and dominate the post match headlines as has occured in so many previous encounters.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , ,