The Chopping Block – Monthly Review

Ron Swanson Roar Guru

By Ron Swanson, Ron Swanson is a Roar Guru

 , , , ,

21 Have your say

    What a month of NRL action. We’ve had a resurgent Dragons outfit challenging for top spot until injury saw them slip a little. While pre-season favourites Penrith, and to a lesser degree Canberra, has struggled with consistency.

    Manly are proving to be a tipster’s nightmare and our good mates in The Bunker are continuing their outstanding performances. The rumour mill is in overdrive, suggesting The Bunker will replace the Brisbane Bronco’s current No.1 sponsor NRMA Insurance in 2018.

    Ray advised me YouI will be the Storm’s new main sponsor in 2018, after being impressed after signing Cam Smith as an ambassador and mentor of the current crop of officials in 2017.

    Meanwhile, over the ditch the New Zealand Warriors are about to part ways with Vodafone and link up with GEP (Global Energy Products Inc.), suppliers of choke products. While the Raiders are close to inking a deal with Jenny Craig to replace the struggling smartphone Huawei.

    With so much turmoil off the field we now turn our attention to the on-field action of the past month. Here are the Chopping Block’s standout performers.

    Joey ‘BJ’ Leilua
    From NSW State of Origin centre to potential ISP Cup Mounties centre, that is the predicament at the alarming drop in form of the damaging Raider.

    Leilua’s performances have been a reminder of his days with the Knights where inconsistency, poor missed tackles and handling errors where part of his weekly highlights reel.

    Whatever has happened needs to be addressed and fast as the Raiders’ season is slowly slipping away from them after an inept performance to the Knights, a side who recorded only their second win in 26 games last Sunday.

    Maybe a stint in NSW Cup might do Leilua the world of good as it appears to have worked for Sydney Roosters youngster Latrell Mitchell.

    BJ’s drop in form has also had a major effect on the scoreboard as most of the Raiders’ points are now coming from the usually less prolific opposite side of attack via Jarrod Croker and young Neville Cotric.

    The halves are not helping the cause, it must be said, with a very low assist rate between them. For the Raiders’ season to fully catch fire, they need their big physical centre to find his mojo and fast.

    Ray reckons BJ might be destined for the forwards if he can’t sort out his defence and rediscover his form. I disagree, as the Raiders already possess too many 35-minute forwards in their pack!

    Shaun Johnson
    The Warriors’ highest paid player of all time has failed to suit up in the second half over the last month. Taking away slotting a penalty goal in the gritty win over the Roosters, Johnson has looked tired, down on confidence and more prone to making poor options after the interval and when his side is under the pump.

    Is it coach Stephen Kearney taking a conservative approach tactically or the cardio levels of his forward pack letting him down? Who knows, but one thing’s for sure, Johnson has been average and inconsistent in defence and lacks game management or patience in the clutch periods.

    Take his defence in the Anzac Test, which was one of his highlights in a sub-par attacking performance, and then compare it with the lack of purpose displayed at Pepper Stadium on Saturday. It’s clear he is still inconsistent, much like his side.

    Excuses can’t be accepted given the amount of years and experience he has under his belt. Johnson’s desire to be the club captain and leader will never be realised until he addresses the major flaws in his performances. The difference between his best and worst is still miles apart in all aspects of his game.

    What will happen now over the Origin period will be the usual false dawn that has all long-suffering Warrior fans salivating and media types labelling them dark horses. Only for the current form to fade into the sunset during the last four or five rounds.

    The No.7 holds the key to destroy this annual phenomenon, but he needs to start showing consistency every week in defence and attack under pressure. Maybe then he can justify his price tag and realise the importance and influence he has on his team’s fortunes.


    Bryce Cartwright
    Sounds like we have an agenda on dynamic attacking players in this edition, maybe other sides have finally worked on gameplans to mute their influence on performances. However, a common theme has surfaced on Cartwright’s game, and that is missed tackles.

    Last year a large majority wanted him on the bench for the NSW Blues and were gobsmacked he was overlooked. Defence was often a response. Well, it’s clear to see it was and is still a major issue.

    It’s hard to fathom he is the nephew of the great Hoss Cartwright, who barely if ever missed ironing out an opponent in his time with the liquorice allsorts.

    Penrith’s coach has shifted him into the No.6 role, a role that the skipper and fullback should be claiming, and the opposition attack is still targeting him frequently and successfully in the defensive line. For all his attacking ability, hopefully he turns it around sooner rather than later.

    It would be a tragedy if he is added to the long list of overhyped youngsters we’ve seen all too briefly over the years.

    Here are just a few: Dave Taylor, Barney Haslett, Matt Gafa, Tulsen Tollett, Chris Sandow, Owen Craigie, Paul Hauff, Siuatonga Likiliki, Royston Lightning, Tom Learoyd-Lahrs, Harry Siejka, Billy Noke, Jason Martin, Jack ‘Barry’ Elsegood, Billy Weepu, Jamie Olejnik, Mark McLinden, Lenny Beckett, Jermaine Ale, Tim Smith, Steve Michaels, Daniel Mortimer, Ryan Stig and plenty more.

    Talkin’ Sport
    I usually enjoy the banter and views of the crew on Talkin’ Sport – Peter Tunks, Gavin Robertson, Brett Papworth and rugby league’s version of Richard Wilkins, Graeme Hughes. But of late they are showing their age and not getting any facts or advice before voicing an agenda.

    A few weeks ago they hammered the Warriors Under-20s’ drop in performances over the last few years and questioned the club’s recruitment. A quick check on the club’s website will point out some clear facts why, starting with the age of the squad.

    Most of their current NYC squad are aged between 16-18 and several members of their current ISP Cup and NRL squads are still eligible for NYC in 2017. At least two seasons ago the Warriors announced they would make a pathway for their elite youngsters via the harder and more physical ISP Cup.

    With the NRL scrapping the Under-20s from 2018, the Warriors made the right move to develop the likes of Ata Hingano, Nathaniel Roache, Bunty Afoa, Erin Clarke, Isaiah Papalii, Toa Sipley and co. against seasoned ex-first graders.

    From memory the last time the club won the Under-20s title, they finished eighth and stacked the team in Week 1 of the finals with members who had played NSW Cup or first grade and qualified to play in the NYC finals.

    They defeated the Broncos in the decider, a team boasting Ashley Taylor, the Nikorima brothers, Jayden and Codi, and Tom Opacic. The Warriors included Brad Abbey, Roache, Solomone Kata, Tui Lolohea, Sam Lisone, Ken Maumalo, Afoa and Hingano in their squad.

    Ashley Taylor
    Now for the focus to shift on the star performers over the past six weeks starting with Titans young gun Ash Taylor.

    This young kid will not only be the future halfback for Queensland but most likely the long term No.7 for the Kangaroos. He already shows poise and skill under pressure, toughness, a real competitive streak not unlike the current Maroons No.7 and has developed more than any other half around the same age bracket in 2017.

    Without him the Titans would be hanging out with the Knights on the NRL ladder. Sometimes a footballer comes along and you just know they are going to be an elite player. Hopefully he stays with the Titans and doesn’t return to the Broncos.

    Long-term contracts these days have about as much credibility as a Today Tonight reporter. I don’t want to sound all Gus Gould but the kid was born a footballer and has the DNA that other talents such as the above trio on the Chopping Block missed out on – calmness under pressure and belief in his own ability.

    Gold Coast Titans player Ashley Taylor

    Jack De Belin
    The young Saints forward has grown another leg this year and become a key component in the NRL’s best balanced back-row combination including Tyson Frizell and Joel Thompson.

    De Belin has added another bow to his game, showing he possesses some decent ball-playing skills in the long term absence of Gareth Widdop. He should at least be in the conversation for Origin selection but will in all probability miss out.

    Ray suspects the removal of the man-bun has been key to his exceptional form on 2017. I believe it’s the yards the props and back three have improved on in 2017 which has given the back-row the luxury needed to show how good they really are.

    With Russell Packer moving to the Tigers in 2018, don’t be surprised to see the Dragons make a play for a similar type of front row forward for next season and beyond.

    The timing of Packer’s departure is not ideal, but they did gain a gem from the Raiders in Paul Vaughan and a similar pick-up could be on the cards if they stay patient. Clubs will look to shed players to stay under the yet to be determined 2018 salary cap.

    Over to you readers. Add any players you feel deserved to make the over-hyped list. Ray originally nominated Mitchell Moses, which I felt was unfair to Parramatta Eels fans.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (21)

    • May 19th 2017 @ 8:43am
      kk said | May 19th 2017 @ 8:43am | ! Report

      Hi Ron,

      An exceptional read and typical Swanson…balanced, humorous, factual.

      The over-hyped list. Dylan Napa. Apart from a win over Sam Burgess I rate him
      as a good club player. He does not shown sustained efforts to warrant Origin
      selection yet the Q coaching crew keep talking him up because he was a star
      in Q U20’s

      • Roar Guru

        May 19th 2017 @ 9:46am
        Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 9:46am | ! Report

        Geez Max that’s a controversial call, young Napa. I do enjoy watching him iron out players in defence, not many players currently who hit the way he can. Will be interesting to see if Coen Hess turns into another gun back rower or maybe goes the way of a Tariq Sims (there’s one I left off the list)/ Learoyd-Lahrs type.

        In my opinion Napa’s front row partner JWH is not all that flash playing on the International stage. I’ll give the young blood nut the benefit of the doubt until we see him in Origin. Aaron Woods has his critics too. Most over rated outside back ever, Beau Ryan…

      • May 19th 2017 @ 10:29am
        The eye said | May 19th 2017 @ 10:29am | ! Report

        Max,re:Napa..just basically said the same thing only a tad harsher over on the Wayne Bennett being a supporter though have punched harder..

        You cant just punish Lei and let Pana off scot free,Ron,one quiet both quiet..but gee,their hooker didnt help last week..

        • Roar Guru

          May 19th 2017 @ 12:33pm
          Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 12:33pm | ! Report

          Not sure I agree The eye, Rapana still making some very strong runs out of their own end and eating up metres, if his inside struggles pretty sure it has a massive effect on his influence on games too.

          Actually you make a good point around Hodgson. Judging from the Raiders from 2015, Austin, break out season 2015, contained better 2016, drop in form, Hodgson on fire 2016, less influence 2017, ditto the Leipana combo.

          Are Sticky’s tactics too predictable perhaps?

          • May 19th 2017 @ 12:38pm
            Alex L said | May 19th 2017 @ 12:38pm | ! Report

            Rapana has dropped the ball an awful lot this year; averaging two drops per game — mostly coming out of yardage too, it’s really dragging the team down.

            • Roar Guru

              May 19th 2017 @ 2:05pm
              Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 2:05pm | ! Report

              BJ seems disinterested though this season. Rapana was outstanding in a lost cause in the Anzac test, he does make a few error’s but he makes up for them with his tackle busts and metres gained.

              • May 19th 2017 @ 3:17pm
                Alex L said | May 19th 2017 @ 3:17pm | ! Report

                I think you can really only do so much in terms of making up for giving the opposition attacking sets through basic errors — do it enough and there’s no making up for it.

    • Roar Guru

      May 19th 2017 @ 9:12am
      Con Scortis said | May 19th 2017 @ 9:12am | ! Report

      Hi Ron

      I still love Talkin’ Sport. Whilst I have no idea what Robbo is going on about half the time, and Peter’s lame jokes can grate a bit, occasionally they do great interviews and their callers can amuse. Best of all, Graeme is as smooth as Simon the Likeable.

    • Roar Guru

      May 19th 2017 @ 9:41am
      Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 9:41am | ! Report

      Agree Con but they sometimes shoot from the lip with bugger all substance. Having said that I love some of the callers, the half cut Kiwi Bill always entertaining and reeling back the years great segment.

      The league tipping expert, name escapes me, is the biggest fraud on the planet. How many times throughout the regular season will he A) Back against the favourite or B) In a 50/50 game take the away side?

      I tune out when he comes on as well as Sue banging on about the Dragons.

      • Roar Guru

        May 19th 2017 @ 10:53am
        Con Scortis said | May 19th 2017 @ 10:53am | ! Report

        Kiwi Bill is a legend, but their most infamous caller is Adrian, who is a prize dropkick who calls all the stations. I’ve heard Adrian call Triple M and tell Wendell Sailor that he was a pretender as a winger and one time he left the blokes on ABC Grandstand completely dumbfounded. You could write an entire article on Adrian.

        Truth be told, I normally switch between Talkin’ Sport and Triple M, depending on who is on and whether I’m being irritated. Re’ Triple M, I like Dan Ginnane and Gurds but I can only tolerate small doses of Wendell’s jibber jabber. Michael Ennis was great last season.

        • May 19th 2017 @ 1:11pm
          kk said | May 19th 2017 @ 1:11pm | ! Report

          Hi Con and Ron, Off topic odd bods.
          Don’t miss FARGO3 Viceland Ch 142 Tues 23 May 9:20 – 11:30pm

          • Roar Guru

            May 19th 2017 @ 1:57pm
            Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 1:57pm | ! Report

            Haven’t finished or started season 2 yet Max. The movie was awesome series just as good. Totally off topic BTW Gunderson!

            • May 19th 2017 @ 2:40pm
              kk said | May 19th 2017 @ 2:40pm | ! Report

              Season 2 takes film making beyond the impossible.
              It is so good I forgot about Rugby League for an hour or so.

          • May 19th 2017 @ 2:12pm
            Albo said | May 19th 2017 @ 2:12pm | ! Report

            Aw, heck Max !
            Ewan McGregor nails it big time in this series ! Gotta love the Coen brothers unique sense of humour ! “Minnesota Nice” is hilarious !

            • May 19th 2017 @ 2:36pm
              kk said | May 19th 2017 @ 2:36pm | ! Report

              Agreed Albo,

              The casting is a lesson on recruitment… perfection on parade.

              • Roar Guru

                May 19th 2017 @ 3:39pm
                Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 3:39pm | ! Report

                Can you pass the casting directors details onto Jimmy Doyle Max…ASAP!

        • May 19th 2017 @ 4:44pm
          Big Daddy said | May 19th 2017 @ 4:44pm | ! Report

          You couldn’t have got that more correct.
          Adrian is the biggest dropkick ever allowed across the airwaves.

          • Roar Guru

            May 24th 2017 @ 7:44am
            Ron Swanson said | May 24th 2017 @ 7:44am | ! Report

            In all fairness to Adrian, always entertaining…unlike some who make you almost fall asleep

    • Roar Guru

      May 19th 2017 @ 12:37pm
      Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 12:37pm | ! Report

      Adrian, you even hear the bloke attack that old douche John Laws on his promo…heard him on the BSB as well getting Terry Kennedy all riled up. I’ve always wondered if he was the same person as the infamous Ronald M who used to stir the pot on zero tackle.

      What odds Adrian hasn’t left the house in 20 years. I picture him like the character from Bad Boy Bubby. Dan Ginnane would be a good replacement for Rabs, if it’s Ray Hadley I’ll never watch a free to air game of rugby league ever again!

    • Roar Guru

      May 19th 2017 @ 1:20pm
      Jason Hosken said | May 19th 2017 @ 1:20pm | ! Report

      Gday Swanners, I’ve been tuning into Over the Black Dot on a Wednesday night on NITV. You can’t go wrong with a three-man panel including Owen Craigie and George Rose. It’s a refreshing look at footy and comes with a decent bag of gags.

      Tell you what else – just like Things of Stone and Wood, Ikin has run his race.

    • Roar Guru

      May 19th 2017 @ 2:04pm
      Ron Swanson said | May 19th 2017 @ 2:04pm | ! Report

      I’ll have to look out for that show Hosko. I’m not a fan of Paul Kent either, a frustrated lower grade Bears player too for those unaware.

      I think the Roar should start a web based NRL and possibly AFL show, go with the old Moose’s title, Controversy Corner. Sure they could wrangle at the very least a NSW Cup player each week to challenge a member of the panel on the pass the ball through the elephants trunk challenge and hand pass for the men in tights version!

      How good what that be?? You had to throw in the old TSW reference to ruin my Friday arvo which had on high rotation Fleetwood Macs “Tusk” the old SOO theme from back in the day with gone but never forgotten Gibson’s, Mike and Jack and DJ Shadow/Run The Jewels – Nobody Speak.

      Damn Helen has taken over my headwaves!!!

    , , , ,