The High Five: Super Rugby Round 14

By Digby / Roar Guru

Eight matches from Round 14 of Super Rugby have been completed with just the Lions and Kings still to be completed early Monday morning in the antipodes – a match which will have little effect on the makeup of the playoffs this season with only three rounds remaining.

The Chiefs stumble in Auckland
It was not an inspiring match in Auckland as the conditions deteriorated throughout but it was played with plenty of endeavour as the ‘Bombay’ rivals fought out a 16-all draw at Eden Park.

The Chiefs outscored the Blues in terms of tries but ill-discipline proved costly as the Blues slotted a number of penalties to keep themselves slightly ahead for the majority of the match.

Both sides had their opportunities to take the lead outright, a sideline conversion attempt from Aaron Cruden missed after a Chiefs try leaving the score locked up while Piers Francis failed to slot a relatively simple penalty attempt within the last 10 to leave the Blues in particular disappointed that a golden chance to score their first win over a fellow New Zealand side for quite some time.

While it was simply pride on the line for the Blues, the result for the Chiefs sees them fall off the pace within the New Zealand conference to be now sitting fourth, equal points with the Highlanders but behind on points differential.

It should be remembered they have a game in hand over their southern rivals.

Highlanders put themselves back in the mix, Hurricanes keep the pressure on
The Highlanders have bought themselves back into the mix for a better playoff position, capitalising on the Chiefs result to draw level on points after a comfortable, if somewhat controversial win over the Waratahs in Dunedin, winning 44 points to 28, scoring some fine tries in the process and showing signs they are not to be discounted from this year’s title race.

The welcome sight of Ben Smith back at fullback for the home side, back from injury was instantly felt for the Highlanders, in both attack and defence as they picked the Waratahs apart through sheer pace and width.

But, it was not all one way traffic, as the Waratahs scored a few themselves, Israel Folau perhaps playing his best match this year, looking lethal with ball in hand and would be encouraging for Waratah and Wallaby fans alike.

Meanwhile, the Hurricanes managed a bonus point win in Pretoria over the Bulls to keep the pressure on the Crusaders though they themselves secured five points in Melbourne over the Rebels, the achievement notable for both sides as many regulars sat out the match, the Hurricanes also having to battle through with injuries to Ardie Savea and Mark Abbott most notably during the match.

With Beauden Barrett a late scratching due to precautions over headaches leading up to the match, the Hurricanes will be nervous about their roster heading into an important couple of matches in the coming weeks while the Highlanders gear up for an important clash against the Crusaders in Christchurch.

A win for the Highlanders could see them in a prime position to obtain the highest wildcard spot for the playoffs while a Crusader victory will ensure they cannot be overtaken for the New Zealand conference title.

[latest_videos_strip category=”rugby” name=”Rugby”]

The Sharks fire off a warning shot
In difficult conditions in Durban, the Sharks confronted the Stormers in a battle of attrition in a willing and bruising encounter, eventually prevailing over their local rivals by 22 points to 10, shutting down the Stormers with an impressive defensive effort, repelling the Stormers time and time again.

They will be an incredibly tough prospect for whoever draws them come the playoffs with a wildcard spot assured, and all achieved with arguably their third-choice first five, with Pat Lambie and Curwin Bosch currently unavailable.

Admittedly this result was achieved at home and this will be a luxury they will have to do without come the playoffs, but they will be a sticky prospect to overcome and if results fall their way, they could force themselves further up the pecking order on points and into a better position come the playoffs.

The Brumbies all but lock in the Australian conference title
With the advantage of being drawn to play last this round, the Brumbies would have seen their closest rivals within the Australian conference lose their individual matches.

The Reds were well beaten by the Force in Brisbane in a cohesive and disciplined performance while the Waratahs’ loss in Dunedin left the Brumbies with the gate open and they stormed through it, securing a bonus point win over the hapless Jaguares in Argentina by 39 points to 15 in a six tries to two thumping.

The Brumbies scored some delightful tries in what will be a pleasing attacking performance for many of the faithful, after numerous struggles to find the try line.

The conference is not quite locked up yet but with a game against the struggling Rebels in Canberra next round and the Reds, Waratahs and Force all lining up against New Zealand opposition the Australian conference could well be safe for the Brumbies after next weekend. It is certainly theirs to lose from here.

Neutrals please
There is no doubt the Highlanders benefited from some marginal decisions in their match against the Waratahs in Dunedin and while I stop short of suggesting the match would have returned a different result otherwise, I continue to be flabbergasted by the competition’s organisers inability to ensure neutral officials for every inter conference match, a New Zealand crew looking after that match last night for example.

The competition is under fire, declining audiences, a format that’s not working, threats of legal action over the proposed dropping of teams for next year, the list is piling up but one thing that can be controlled is the perception of neutrality at least in terms of the officiating yet SANZAAR continues to give its detractors further ammunition for an issue that is so simple to resolve.

Test matches always have neutral officials so why not Super Rugby? It is an International regional tournament after all and while I am all for the best man for the job, so on and so forth, it is a simple perception which can be easily addressed, not to mention the inconsistency of the appointments.

I can recall two matches for the Hurricanes, against the Highlanders and Crusaders where the main referees were Angus Gardner and Jaco Peyper respectively!

Sort it out SANZAAR, stop shooting yourselves in the foot.

So there are my five major talking points from this round of Super Rugby as we start to look forward to the next few rounds as we all start to get distracted with the international break to come.

In my moment of the week, and because front rowers are the coolest, check out the Highlanders Siua Halanukonuka 20 odd meter dash, to agonisingly be pulled up short, but unselfishly placing the ball back for his fellow front rower Dan Lienert-Brown to take the glory, fantastic stuff, showing a full range of skills after his smiling goose stepping from last weekend.

Until next week then!

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2017-05-29T02:42:19+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Well, we don't play for charity now do we pinetree? ;) Regardless, who knows how any of us will look after the Lions series, there will be some tired boys after that I would have thought!

AUTHOR

2017-05-29T02:39:39+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Thanks for that Brett, very interesting. That must be a really big spreadsheet!

AUTHOR

2017-05-29T02:39:04+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


It was a great kick. Have decided, I am a steamroom guy.

AUTHOR

2017-05-29T02:38:15+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


There is a fair bit of water to pass under the bridge yet and of course one big unknown will be how the teams shape up after the internationals.

AUTHOR

2017-05-29T02:36:45+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Me too Fionn, but for other reasons to yours ;)

2017-05-28T19:40:00+00:00

soapit

Guest


brett has there been a difference in results towards the home team between home town refs and neutrals?

2017-05-28T19:38:17+00:00

soapit

Guest


plus we are not the euro champions league who dont really have to worry about money. conferences facilitate additional derbies which supposedly bring in more cash while keeping travel costs down (as well as the wear and tear on the player from the travel). like IF i would be fine if they went back but i can understand the logic of where we're at and i dont really find it impact on my enjoyment of the comp significantly (mind you that could be because the oz teams are nowhere near the top to be worth checking against the others anyway)

2017-05-28T14:02:45+00:00

Hanne

Guest


Thr Blie Bull fans are only interested in winning, not interested in how win or the quality of rugby played and they are not winning at this moment.... The fans will come back when they start to win again. Very different from the Force and to a lessor extend Lions fans that stick with their team no matter what.

2017-05-28T12:33:48+00:00

Pinetree

Guest


I should add that the Chiefs have the Tahs and Brumbies which would also throw another spanner in the works for the Sharks reaching 5th/6th as the Chiefs are also on 45 pts.

2017-05-28T12:20:01+00:00

Katipo

Guest


@The Neutral. Yes, it should be designed to fit the calendar. But keep it simple. I think the Super Rugby playoffs and Champions League are one and the same tournament - Super Rugby. You could play a 16 team knock out tournament in 4 weeks. That's really easy to accommodate. You could knock out from 32 teams in 5 weeks. Sanzaar could invite any union on the planet to enter teams, and it needn't be the same nations every year. If you structure the Champions tournament Cup, Bowl, Plate (like the Sevens), every team plays a few games. An option is to play the tournament in one country each year, ad rotate hosting rights through the Sanzaar members. With the Lions in NZ this year, would be great to host Champion-of-Champions in Australia, South Africa or Japan, say.

2017-05-28T12:17:17+00:00

Internal Fixation

Guest


Hi Cuw and Soapit, I completely understand the frustration with the conference system. I loved Super rugby when it was essentially a round robin tournament but I have always viewed it as a "champions" league of sorts. I can therefore understand why the organisers went to the conference system. I also recognise they have got it very wrong in the current format but as Soap correctly points out the timezones are a real challenge for broadcasters and unfortunately modern quality professional sport is a slave to TV rights. So CUW I would argue that the highest earning yearly competitions in the world in terms of team value, prizemoney and TV rights are all effectively conference systems. These include Champions League, NBA, NFL, MLB and NHL as well as Henieken Cup and EuroBasket. Therefore it is no surprise SANZAAR tried this - but failed.

2017-05-28T12:15:21+00:00

Pinetree

Guest


Yes Rhino, after second thought I realized that very real possibility. If the Sharks get into 5th or 6th place, then it is mathematically impossible for the Sharks to end on less or equal points than the Stormers. Highlanders already 6th on 45 points and the Stormers can only get 45 points if they won all 3 games with a bonus point. Sharks should beat the Bulls in Durban to climb to 46/47 points. The Sharks will most likely have to beat the Lions to get 5th/6th (is a home game for the sharks). Highlanders still have the Reds and the Canes the Force, which if they win will push them out of reach if the Sharks do not beat the Lions (as a Crusaders fan i will be cheering the Sharks on!). However, if the Sharks do beat the Lions, then the NZ derbies could come into favor for you.

2017-05-28T12:10:31+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


Champions League in Football (Europe and Asia), Basketball, Handball, Volleyball (all Europe) to name a few soapit. Four hour time difference between London and Moscow. Would the idea be to have national conferences only playing each others until the playoffs, but a European Style Champions League style group face an playoff merged into the season? Would be three trophies to chase: National conference champions (round robin) Super Rugby playoffs "Champions League a.k.a. Sanzaar Cup. Could teams outside the established nations be invited for the Sanzaar Cup? Can it be designed to fit the calendar?

2017-05-28T12:06:40+00:00

AndyS

Guest


To be honest, I am less worried about neutrality than the assumption of superiority. IMO, far more common than someone thinking "They are from the same country as me, so I'll ignore that" would be the thought "They are the better team, so I don't need to keep an eye on them/close enough/it won't matter anyway/etc". Losing sight that it becomes a self-fulfilling bias.

2017-05-28T11:07:34+00:00

Charging Rhino

Roar Guru


I was gonna say mate.... Very possible for it to be Stormers vs Sharks. If that's the case then Sharks fans will be peeved that the game has to be played in Cape Town as the Sharks will most likely finish with more log points and wins.

2017-05-28T11:03:52+00:00

soapit

Guest


cuw can you name any competitions that are played across large distances and multiple timezones that arent in the us/canada or super rugby? i cant think of any off the top of my head but they would be your prime candidates for similar systems (assuming for the sake of argument we arent including champions leagues)

2017-05-28T11:00:06+00:00

soapit

Guest


kia thats basically just adding an extra final, its just a question of where you draw the line, getting to play that match at all could be seen to be unfair.

2017-05-28T10:57:49+00:00

soapit

Guest


not to mention you can be guranteed consistent equipment. however not sure theyd be able to guarantee/dictate the angle be available from every ground like nrl is able to

2017-05-28T10:22:20+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Digger, I'm sure I've told you about my bloody big spreadsheet that I keep each season: results, tryscorers, cards, etc. Well one of the things I've tracked this year is the whole neutral refs thing, and the breakdown over the 111 games over 14 rounds is thus: 33 neutral refs in cross-conference games 14 neutral refs in local derbies 8 away refs in cross-conference games (eg, an Aust ref in an NZ-Aust game) 29 home refs in cross-conference games (eg, an NZ ref in an NZ-Aust game) 27 home refs in local derbies (includes J.Peyper in tonight's game) Now this is the first time I've tallied these up, and I'm pleasantly surprised to see that there have actually been more neutral refs in cross-conference games than home refs. That's a good thing. But in terms of perception, the number of home refs in cross-conference games does SANZAAR no favours..

2017-05-28T10:10:23+00:00

One Eye

Roar Rookie


I have to say, I thought Jackson was extremely lenient on the Waratahs, especially at the tackle/ruck both on attack and defence he let them hold on far too long.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar