How to spice up the Bledisloe dead rubber? Give Quade a run

By Will Knight / Expert

This weekend’s Bledisloe Cup dead rubber is as dead a rubber as a dead rubber can be.

The lead-in this week has been loaded with coaches, players, ex-players and pundits churning out the fluff.

Apparently there is no such thing as a dead rubber. The All Blacks are wary of an improving Wallabies.

The Wallabies can make a huge statement by beating the All Blacks. The Wallabies need to make a fast start again. They can get the monkey off their back.

It could be the start of a new era. It would help erase some of the bitterness from the protracted Super Rugby axing saga that led to the Western Force’s demise.

Snore.

None of that is going to get a pulse back in the Bledisloe body. After winning the two Tests during this year’s Rugby Championship, the clash in Brisbane on Saturday night has all the anticipation of a senate sub-committee inquiry into GST reform.

There’s no narrative to infuse excitement into the contest.

This match needs not only Don King to give it a bit of zing, but Dana White, The Rock, Nick Kyrgios, Shane Warne and Dennis Rodman.

Or an Israel Folau same-sex marriage tweet.

How would I spark up the dead rubber? Who could act as a defibrillator? Quade Cooper.

We all know his history against New Zealand, right? A sneaky shot on Richie McCaw, sledging the Kiwis, getting under their skin. Public enemy No.1 in the Shaky Isles. And he was born in Auckland!

So why not pick him for Saturday night’s clash?

Yeah, I know, it reeks of desperation. It’s a tacky way to promote a Test match.

It cheapens the Wallabies jersey? Well, Michael Cheika has handed Wallabies jerseys out like lollies this year. Injuries never help, but 11 players have won Wallabies debuts in 2017.

Jordan Uelese got the nod on the back of 28 minutes of Super Rugby for the Melbourne Rebels.

Richard Hardwick hardly had a stack of standout Super Rugby games under his belt. Eto Nabuli, Izack Rodda, Marika Koroibete, Lukhan Tui and Curtis Rona were similar.

(AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

It wouldn’t be ridiculous to pick Quade again. It’s not like picking someone randomly off the street – you know, the way Quade’s boxing crew pick his opponents.

He’s still the second-best specialist five-eighth in Australia. If Bernard Foley went down injured, perhaps Cheika would go for Kurtley Beale at No.10. But he’s blitzing it at inside centre.

Quade has got plenty of chances for Australia and muffed quite a few, but there’s not too many jumping over the top of him as Foley’s back-up.

Put Foley on the bench. Give Quade 50-60 minutes to show his manic best and worst. Foley is one of Australia’s top-tier players, so handing him a bit of time off isn’t the worst idea with a European tour on the horizon.

Another way to add some appeal – or more accurately, romance – would be to start the retiring Stephen Moore at hooker. It will be his 125th Test match, but last in front of his home fans in Brissy. He’s a grunt man – not a crowd-puller – but it would give another angle to promote the dead rubber.

There’s room for a bit of showbiz in professional sport, right? Wins bring money. So if you’re not winning – and there’s commercial pressure – shouldn’t the door open to other ways to get the fans engaged?

And these potential selection scenarios pose the question: is there a point in rugby where stability and pragmatism can make way for shameless promotional imperatives and naked commercialism?

Is there room for a coach to be told to not pick his best team, but pick a team that will potentially add thousands more bums on seats and many more sets of eyes on the TV coverage?

Surely a dead rubber is a chance to do that.

Moreso these days, we are told that players are being picked with a view to the next World Cup. Or others are being rested because of the arduous workloads.

So not selecting a best XV is already happening. In the Kiwis’ case, when they made mass changes for their trip to Argentina last month, that wasn’t even a dead rubber. You certainly get a bit of leeway when you’re winning.

Coaches often have to become skillful at selling a message when at a team announcement – one of the most obvious ones pretending to rest a player when in fact they’ve been dropped. The coach has got to be seen to be sticking up for his players publicly.

So perhaps making some selection shocks in the name of blatant promotion – such as picking second-best Wallabies five-eighth and No.1 most-maligned-by-New-Zealanders Quade Cooper for a dead rubber – isn’t as far-fetched as it sounds. It’s just all in the sell.

The Crowd Says:

2017-10-23T17:36:24+00:00

Ad-0

Guest


Exactly.

2017-10-21T12:16:15+00:00

double agent

Guest


Best thing Deans ever did was to get rid of him.

2017-10-21T12:14:48+00:00

double agent

Guest


So how did that go?

2017-10-21T12:13:21+00:00

double agent

Guest


If QC hadn't bunged his knee and still had the running brilliance he had in the SR 2011 then he would be No1. Unfortunately for him and Australian rugby that's not the reality.

2017-10-21T12:10:59+00:00

double agent

Guest


Have you forgotten QC's World Cup Hell?

2017-10-21T12:08:24+00:00

double agent

Guest


That's because there's no one else.

2017-10-21T12:03:35+00:00

double agent

Guest


I'm sure when Thorn is selecting his 10 for QLD his first thought will be 'which of these guys cheap shotted Richie McCaw?'

2017-10-21T11:58:54+00:00

double agent

Guest


That's because when he's not there they play a halfback at 10 or a club player.

2017-10-21T11:56:11+00:00

double agent

Guest


Will, I don't how you can ever say it's dead rubber. That's about the dumbest thing anyone can say regarding Australian Rugby. We are currently behind something like 49-128 in test match wins so any victory that bridges that deficit is like gold. There's nothing dead or unimportant about it.

2017-10-21T05:46:27+00:00

Taylorman

Guest


The same speedball he used to speed his way out of test rugby? ?

2017-10-21T05:19:19+00:00

Redsback

Guest


Why don't we just compare the record of the two? Without looking it up, I'm certain Cooper's record is better. He's abetter player than Foley

2017-10-21T05:17:21+00:00

Redsback

Guest


Especially in wet weather, he should be there. Are we really going to run it from our own 5m line in the wet? For precisely this reason, it made sense to pick Hunt at Fullback for this game and move Folau to the wing at Koroibete's expense. But alas, they are Queenslanders and, despite anything Cheika says, he has a clear and obvious bias against them. That there can be not 1 Reds player starting a game in Brisbane is an abomination. I'm disappointed to have bought my ticket before the team was announced. No Quade was obviously not a surprise, but no Hunt is just a stupid decision.

2017-10-20T22:06:48+00:00

PiratesRugby

Guest


Drongo, QC is far from perfect and needs to put his shoulder into tackles a bit more. But he runs rings around Foley. He is faster, a much better passer, better kicker and when he commits to it, a better defender. Cheika is running a sheltered workshop for underwhelming NSW players. The fact that Suncorp will be half empty is of no concern to him or the ARU. Cheika is the captain of the ship and Australian rugby is the Titanic.

2017-10-20T22:01:57+00:00

PiratesRugby

Guest


You mean he might miss all his kicks or make two intercept passes to the opposition hooker?

2017-10-20T21:41:24+00:00

Farmer

Guest


No he would be the Waratah No. 22 ? Sitting on the pine!!

2017-10-20T20:35:27+00:00

soapit

Guest


sounds blissful!

2017-10-20T14:42:48+00:00

Ad-0

Guest


Sorry to trigger you, fella. Just my humble opinion.

2017-10-20T13:35:38+00:00

Charlie Turner

Guest


Dave and Fionn, no argument from me. Dean's had publicly stated in late 2010 his belief that based on historical evidence RWC's were won on defence, he was half right. Selecting McCabe at 12 with crash ball instructions was poor judgement and shortened Pats career by years. Touring with one specialist open side and three half backs then selecting McCalman at 7 for the injured Pocock in the Pool match against Ireland and Sean O'Brien is another one that still burns.

2017-10-20T13:09:25+00:00

Ad-0

Guest


He's a massive talent, but he crumbles once the pressure gets turned up. His weaknesses are all between the ears I'm afraid.

2017-10-20T11:54:32+00:00

Fionn

Guest


I just went and looked at the player ratings from the Guardian of the match—Quade got a 4, but so did Moore, Elsom, but AAC and Alexander were only given 5s, but Faingaa, Samo, Kepu and Vickerman were given 3s. It was a poor performance all around (and Deans should have owned that), and yet Quade was and is the only one scapegoated "he kicked it out on the full". Well, there were another 79 mins and 59 seconds after that. Yeah, agreed, the backline selections were atrocious, particularly in the centres, which just killed our attack.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar