Cahill leaves City: Why, how, and what next?

Evan Morgan Grahame Columnist

By Evan Morgan Grahame, Evan Morgan Grahame is a Roar Expert

 , , ,

45 Have your say

    Well, less than a month after he made a televised demand for more playing time, Tim Cahill now finds himself unemployed.

    A mutual termination of his contract, agreed to by Cahill and Melbourne City, has left the Australian football-loving public wondering what will come next for their greatest ever player. Although the news yesterday prompted a sharp intake of breath, we were forewarned; the post-victory grandstanding after Australia secured their World Cup berth was enough, but the hallmarks of Cahill’s late-career have not been stability and permanence.

    He has played for four different clubs since 2012, and his departure from City – having been their main marketing stud – shows just how shallowly Cahill’s roots dug down in Melbourne. 

    So, how are we to view this? What kind of light is thrown onto the silhouette of Cahill rambling off over the horizon? Clearly, the credulous view to take – not entirely unreasonably – is that Cahill is in earnest pursuit of more playing time, just like he said. The club – rather than allowing a discontented star to sour the dressing room – have given him a running start.

    That would be a remarkably generous position for City to take; when was the last time a football club bent so altruistically – and immediately – to the demands of a player, to the point of foregoing the remainder of his playing obligations, as well as all the commercial benefits retaining him offers? It’s doubtful City have simply freed Cahill up to search for greener pastures out of the goodness of their heart. 

    It bears remembering too that Cahill’s contract with City was reportedly quite heavily front-loaded, meaning his earnings there were set to taper down. Furthermore, the contract was arranged to lead Cahill into a coaching role, a conduit into his post-playing career; has Cahill now suddenly deemed this arrangement too hasty?

    If he entered into this three-year-plan knowingly last year, aware that this was the final club he’d lace up the boots and take to the field for, did he expect to start every game, play the bulk of the minutes on offer, all the way up until retirement? Perhaps he did. 

    Warren Joyce, though, evidently does not subscribe to that view. Cahill is a player that can’t really just be inserted willy-nilly into the starting XI, with minimal disruption to the general coherence of the team. Joyce has deemed it too problematic to try and shoe-horn Cahill in alongside Ross McCormack, while keeping room for the two wingers. This problem will only be complicated further when Bruno Fornaroli returns.

    Joyce is cooking City up into a team to his tastes, and Cahill is not an ingredient in that recipe. City conceded in the first half against Newcastle last weekend, and came back to win. They still have, in spite of their recent ho-hum run of results, the second best defence in the league.

    There is a new, stolid side to City, that was not there last season, or the season before that. The club have let the most marketable player in the league walk away; it’s hard to think of a more emphatic way to assert their level of faith in Joyce’s vision. 

    So is Cahill’s decision purely fuelled by the wholly understandable and supportable desire for more minutes? He will need to play regularly – though not necessarily more regularly than he was at City – if he’s to make a fourth World Cup.

    In all, 29 players have actually made playing appearances in four or more World Cups, and that list is indicative of searing talent as much as it is longevity: Pele, Maradona, Cafu, Gigi Buffon, Lothar Matthaus, and Paolo Maldini, this is the group that Cahill will join if he kicks a ball in anger in Russia next year.

    There’s a huge diamond, cut and polished, ready to be set into Cahill’s professional legacy, and he needs to be in the best position to reach out and take it. 

    Will it be another A-League club that satiates Cahill’s desire for playing time? Without even broaching the subject of Cahill’s wage demands, how many clubs even need a 38-year-old starting striker? Sydney FC and the Victory both have established starters that they would be unwise to demote.

    Newcastle and Perth also have leading imports in that part of the pitch. Brisbane have spent a marquee slot on Massimo Maccarone, as have the Wanderers on Oriel Riera. The only teams left, then, are Central Coast, Adelaide and the Phoenix.

    Would Cahill play in Wellington, and could they afford him? Adelaide have been mooted as a possible destination, and it could be viable depending on how much salary cap space Karim Matmour’s departure has freed up.

    Central Coast look as though they could use Cahill; the activity Paul Okon’s system promotes occurs out on the wings, with Daniel de Silva, Andrew Hoole and Connor Pain at their best charging at defence from wider positions. Right full-back Jake McGing, dispatcher of a number of venomous crosses against Perth on Sunday, would also appreciate having Cahill – still one of the best headers in world football – to aim at too.

    Whether Cahill would slot comfortably into Okon’s young team, who are rallying impressively behind their manager’s philosophy, is another question, as is – in all cases – the question of the salary. 

    Roy O'Donovan of the Mariners (left) is confronted by Tim Cahill of City

    (AAP Image/David Crosling)

    Keeping in mind the marketing money Cahill carries around with him, no one is arguing Cahill should short-change himself, and take a pittance salary at his next club. But really, it would undermine Cahill’s entire reasoning to see him price A-League clubs out of the bidding, and sign with a cashed-up Asian team in Korea, Japan or the Middle East.

    Whether he’d be more regularly utilised there is questionable, and he’d certainly be less visible. Of course, the foundation that supports Cahill’s argument is already crumbly. What happens if the next Socceroos manager – to be decided on by a committee of ex-Socceroos, as well as a consultancy service – decides that, no matter how many minutes he’s getting, Cahill isn’t part of his World Cup plans?

    He’s still probably our second-best striker, and on all recent evidence is still out best big-game – see: World Cup – player. But he is old, and the attribute he’s most known for – namely applying forehead to leather – isn’t one that modern managers really game-plan around.

    What if the new man heads in a different direction, so to speak? Then all this agitation will have backfired, and Cahill will have succeeded only in highlighting his decision to put personal ambition ahead of team success, and his capricious regard for a position as figurehead of one of the league’s newest, most ambitious clubs. 

    Stepping back and surveying the scene in cool terms, this seems an almighty gamble for Cahill to take. He is banking on a team, that needs him and can afford him, picking him up soon. This team needs to be fine with the fact that Cahill is clearly prepared to call out the manager publicly if his minutes drop too sharply, and that he’s focused primarily on the World Cup, and not necessarily the immediate ambitions of the club.

    They also need to be playing in a league good enough and near enough to catch the attention of whoever next fills the position of Socceroos manager. Does such a team exist?

    Evan Morgan Grahame
    Evan Morgan Grahame

    Evan Morgan Grahame is a Melbourne-based journalist. Gleaning what he could from his brief career as a painter, the canvas of the football pitch is now his subject of contemplation, with the beautiful game sketching new, intriguing compositions every week. He has been one of The Roar's Expert columnists since 2016. Follow him on Twitter @Evan_M_G.

    This video is trending right now! Submit your videos for the chance to win a share of $10,000!

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (45)

    • Roar Rookie

      December 7th 2017 @ 6:16am
      Stevo said | December 7th 2017 @ 6:16am | ! Report

      You’ve summarised it well.

      “Stepping back and surveying the scene in cool terms, this seems an almighty gamble for Cahill to take. He is banking on a team, that needs him and can afford him, picking him up soon. This team needs to be fine with the fact that Cahill is clearly prepared to call out the manager publicly if his minutes drop too sharply, and that he’s focused primarily on the World Cup, and not necessarily the immediate ambitions of the club.

      Clearly Joyce and Marwood were not going to entertain Timmy calling the shots.

      • December 7th 2017 @ 6:42am
        RBBAnonymous said | December 7th 2017 @ 6:42am | ! Report

        That’s the problem when the FFA does the recruitment.

        • December 7th 2017 @ 10:00am
          pete4 said | December 7th 2017 @ 10:00am | ! Report

          Expensive but probably a punt FFA thought worth taking at the time

          Melbourne certainly has the capacity to support the 2 clubs easily

      • December 7th 2017 @ 12:41pm
        Mark said | December 7th 2017 @ 12:41pm | ! Report

        After he started complaining, i’m amazed it took this long for him to depart. The lack of any real reaction from City fans speaks volumes.

    • December 7th 2017 @ 6:55am
      Buddy said | December 7th 2017 @ 6:55am | ! Report

      Maybe TC had a chat with Mile Jedinak during the WC play offs and realized that the English League championship makes a great home for players winding down their careers that still want strong competition and hard graft every week. Fighting to get out of this division and into EPL is no easy task and one of the most successful formulas down the years is to mix the squad up with a blend of older wiser battle hardened troops as well as the more youthful players that are looking for their big break and the chance to play in one of the highest profiled competitions in the world. Villa have a squad littered with experience in defence and midfield; less so up front but there are plenty of clubs vying for a promotion place that could certainly make use of the talent and experience TC would bring.
      I can’t see him playing A League again, it doesn’t seem to be the right stage for him. I would have thought that there has been some careful planning on Mr Cahill’s part and that will come to light in a few weeks when the January transfer window opens.

      • December 7th 2017 @ 12:40pm
        Mark said | December 7th 2017 @ 12:40pm | ! Report

        Unless Millwall are feeling sentimental, who else will take him? He hasn’t played at a level equal to the Championship since he left Everton. If he’s not up to being a regular starter in the A-League, he’s not going to be one in the Championship.

        He’s taking a big gamble. I think he’ll end up in the Middle East where the pace of the game is slower, but he’ll just have to hope the new coach won’t write him off immediately for playing there.

    • December 7th 2017 @ 9:18am
      Birdman said | December 7th 2017 @ 9:18am | ! Report

      maybe TC should have looked at joining a lower profile A-League team when he signed on at MC if the World Cup was in his sights.

      Championship or Asian football await but at 38, he needs to find the onion bag regularly to get the minutes…..

      • December 7th 2017 @ 9:55am
        pete4 said | December 7th 2017 @ 9:55am | ! Report

        Adelaide or Sydney are still possible destinations they reckon

        UAE league season finishing end of Feb so unlikely Cahill will go there

        • December 7th 2017 @ 11:27am
          Fadida said | December 7th 2017 @ 11:27am | ! Report

          Where are Sydney going to hide his salary? They must be over by a million!
          Adelaide makes plenty of sense

          • December 7th 2017 @ 11:37am
            punter said | December 7th 2017 @ 11:37am | ! Report

            We will take the hit for the sake of the Socceroos.

            • December 7th 2017 @ 1:51pm
              Fadida said | December 7th 2017 @ 1:51pm | ! Report


    • December 7th 2017 @ 9:37am
      spruce moose said | December 7th 2017 @ 9:37am | ! Report

      I think wage demands are now moot for Cahill.

      No club would be prepared to pay much for a 38 year old that is seeking game time.

      He holds few cards here.

      If the world cup is really his goal, then remuneration should be largely immaterial – it’s not like he needs the money anyway.

    • December 7th 2017 @ 9:57am
      Nemesis said | December 7th 2017 @ 9:57am | ! Report

      It’s no doubt Tim is full committed to playing at WC2018 and that’s why he’s left City. If AUS had failed to qualify, TC would probably have retired from the professional game.

      As an Aussie fan, I’d love to see TC sitting on the bench in Russia. To do this he needs to play regularly for a club in a competition that is valued by a future coach of our National Team & he needs to shine regularly.

      The perfect opportunity awaits Tim only 30 minutes flight from Tullamarine. AUFC would be the perfect club for him. The coach has a system that is begging for a bloke with Cahill’s attributes.

      Can they afford him? Well, AUFC has just had an international player leave the club. If Tim really wants to compete at a 4th consecutive World Cup, he’d tell AUFC “I’ll play for the minimum wage”.

      • Roar Rookie

        December 7th 2017 @ 10:56am
        At work said | December 7th 2017 @ 10:56am | ! Report

        A move to Adelaide would be ideal, also I’d hate to see TC leave our shores.
        I have no issue with what he has trying to do, I actually commend him for leaving a guaranteed contract and possible future coaching to leave and find more playing time.
        Good luck to him, no Australians should hold a grudge to Cahill for what he has done for the Socceroos over the years.

    • December 7th 2017 @ 10:10am
      bobbym said | December 7th 2017 @ 10:10am | ! Report

      Thanks for everything but..Tim Over the Cahill . Time to move on – time for someone else to step up and take the mantle. Retire with dignity.

      • December 7th 2017 @ 11:26am
        shirtpants said | December 7th 2017 @ 11:26am | ! Report

        Not a chance. He’s done more than enough these last 12 months to be worthy of a place in the side if he can find regular minutes. He’ll be a bench player but I’m more confident in him than just about any of our other forwards.

      • Roar Rookie

        December 7th 2017 @ 11:49am
        Sam Bunn said | December 7th 2017 @ 11:49am | ! Report

        Cahill is a proven match-winner on the biggest of occasions, his experience is invaluable and the confidence he must instil in his teammates would almost be enough in itself to justify his spot

        • Roar Rookie

          December 7th 2017 @ 11:49am
          Sam Bunn said | December 7th 2017 @ 11:49am | ! Report

          Not to mention he’s the undisputed GOAT

        • December 7th 2017 @ 12:09pm
          Nemesis said | December 7th 2017 @ 12:09pm | ! Report

          There’s no doubt Tim has stepped up on numerous occasions when AUS needs him. But, the Myth of Cahill sometimes clouds the reality.

          Jedinak stepped up against Honduras in the 2nd leg.
          Kruse stepped up in the 1st Away Leg against Syria.

          Cahill failed to step up against Thailand at AAMI Park when goals were desperately required to avoid the Play-offs. In fact, he missed a sitter in the 1st half.

          Cahill failed to step up in the Away Match against Japan. He failed to step up numerous times in the Group Matches. He only scored 1 goal in the Group Stage from 7 Group matches. He played in 3 drawn matches. If he’d stepped up & scored just once, AUS would’ve avoided the play-offs.

          So, yes. Cahill has been good scoring goals for AUS – that’s his job. Maty Ryan’s job is stopping goals. Both do their job well. As do all the other players at various times.

    , , ,