The Roar
The Roar


Match preview: Sydney Swans vs Hawthorn, Round 8, 2018

The Hawks are sitting pretty once more. (AAP Image/Paul Miller)
Roar Pro
10th May, 2018

The Swans travel to the MCG for the first time this season, taking on their 2017 nemesis, the Hawthorn Hawks.

The rejuvenated Hawks have exceeded expectations early this season, sitting in fourth spot on the ladder with five wins from seven games, and a healthy percentage of 121, while the Swans hang on to eight after losing their third match from four at the SCG this year.

Former Swan midfielder Tom Mitchell has been a star for the Hawks this season, leading the AFL for disposals, is top three for contested possessions and averages the second highest AFL Fantasy Points with 124.

Mitchell is equal first with Nat Fyfe in the AFL Coaches Association’s Champion Player of the Year Award after seven rounds, with 38 votes, while Swans ruckman Callum Sinclair is the best Swan with 20 votes.

The Swans and Hawks have fought out one of the great modern rivalries, with their last three games decided by a goal or less – 5, 6 and 6.

While the Hawks have dominated the recent head-to-head match-ups, winning five from the last six, the Swans have won two of the last three matches at the MCG.

The weather bureau has forecasted dour, cold, windy and rain sodden conditions for their Friday night blockbuster clash, with rain, hail, possible thunderstorms and winds up to 40km/h expected.

It’s likely to be another low-scoring encounter between the teams, with the Hawks’ 12.9 (81) at the SCG last season, the highest score by either team in their last four encounters.

The Swans will be sweating on the fitness of Franklin after midfielder Dan Hannebery was ruled out of the clash earlier in the week.

Lance Franklin Sydney Swans AFL 2017

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

They’ve been forced to play small with significant absences from their forward line, resisting the urge to debut youngsters Darcy Cameron, Joel Amartey or Tom McCartin.

The Swans are unbeaten away from the SCG this season and have lost just two away games since Round 7 last season, once to Hawthorn in Round 19, and once to Geelong in the semi-final.

The Swans will need to find extra avenues to goals to beat the Hawks – while they’ve managed to win away games with, and without Buddy Franklin, they haven’t been ticking the scoreboard over regularly enough.

The difference between the two teams will be which team can generate the more dangerous scoring opportunities, and convert their chances, especially if the weather follows the forecast.

While Hawthorn have displayed more consistent form, they struggled to overcome challenges from St Kilda and Essendon, while conceding 75 first-half points to the Roos in round 5.

Where and when?
MCG, Friday, May 11, 7.50pm AEST

Last five meetings
R19, 2017, Hawthorn 10.12 (72) d Sydney 9.12 (66) at the MCG
R10, 2017, Hawthorn 12.9 (81) d Sydney 11.9 (75) at the SCG
R17, 2016, Hawthorn 11.9 (75) d Sydney 10.10 (70) at the SCG
R9, 2016, Sydney 10.9 (69) d Hawthorn 7.13 (55) at the MCG
R16, 2015, Hawthorn 23.8 (146) d Sydney 7.15 (57) at ANZ Stadium


Key match ups
Nick Smith versus Luke Breust

Luke Breust has returned to goal kicking form with aplomb, currently second on the AFL goal kicking list with 20 and leading the Hawks goal charts. Nick Smith always takes the most dangerous small forward and will go to Luke Breust, with Cyril Rioli and Paul Puopolo missing.

Luke Breust Hawthorn Hawks 2016 AFL Finals

(AAP Image/Julian Smith)

Callum Sinclair versus Ben McEvoy
Callum Sinclair has been the Swans’ revelation this season in the forced absence of Kurt Tippett and Sam Naismith, taking on sole ruck duties and flourishing, producing career best form and numbers. McEvoy has often been critical to giving the Hawks midfield first use and has been one of their best players this season.

James Sicily versus Gary Rohan
Hawthorn’s hothead James Sicily has been one of the Hawks’ players of the year, providing plenty of thrust and run out of their backline. Swans speedster Gary Rohan will need to hit him where it hurts the most – the scoreboard – if he’s to come out on top.

Six points
1: The Hawks dominate the recent head-to-heads between the teams, winning four of the last five and nine of the last twelve since the Swans’ 2012 premiership. The Swans’ largest winning margin in that time has been 19-points, while the Hawks have won by 83, 63 and 54 points.

2: Swans former midfielder Tom Mitchell has dominated the midfield for the Hawks this year with 67 clearances (1st), 253 disposals (1st) and 120 contested disposals (3rd). Swans midfield bull Kennedy trails someway back with 26 less contested disposals (7th), 15 less clearances (4th), and six less centre clearances (4th).

3: Until Round 5, Swans superstar forward Lance Franklin was leading the Swans’ and AFL’s goal kicking charts. Luke Breust is the top ranked Hawk and second in the AFL for goals this season with 20.

4: The Swans midfield slightly edge out the Hawks with contested possessions, averaging 147.4 (8th) to 145.7 (9th), while the Hawks hold sway with uncontested possessions, leading 224.3 (10th) to the Swans’ 214.6 (14th).


5: The Swans are the number one clearance team in the AFL, with 286 in the first seven rounds, while the Hawks – who have the number one clearance player in the league – are ranked seventh with 263.

6: The Swans’ defence will have to dig deep for the Swans to win, averaging 41.6 (6th) rebound 50’s to the Hawks 36.6 (18th) per game, while the Hawks have recorded ten more marks inside 50 this season.

It’s a big week for…
In Lance Franklin’s forced absence, Will Hayward has been superb for the Swans over the last two rounds, providing a genuine inside 50 target and kicking 6.2, moving to equal 26th on the leagues goal kicking chart with 11 for the season. Burton, Frawley, Stratton and Sicily will likely match up on him at different times during the match, if he can impact the scoreboard.

Sydney Swans by 9