Winners and losers from the Wallabies squad to face Ireland

By BM / Roar Rookie

With the Ireland Test series just around the corner, excitement is building.

As the build up to the 2019 World Cup begins, here’s a look at the major winners and losers from Michael Cheika’s squad.

Winners

Ned Hanigan
Hanigan has not played any rugby since a Round 12 knee injury against the Crusaders ruled him out, leading many to think that he would be left out of this squad.

It is well known that Cheika has taken a liking to Hanigan since his early days with the Waratahs, the youngster providing extra cover with his ability to play both lock and Mo.6. It seems this versatility has got him over the line for this series.

The next question for Cheika is whether he trusts Hanigan in the matchday 23, having not played any football for the past month.

Caleb Timu
There was a lot of hype surrounding Caleb Timu coming into this Super Rugby season, after a stellar NRC for Queensland Country, and he has certainly lived up to it.

With 91 carries for 381 metres, along with a very high tackle rate, in an inconsistent Reds side, Timu was a must.

Timu’s early-season form has likely guaranteed involvement in this series and I wouldn’t be surprised to see him fill a starting backrow spot.

Curtis Rona
Starting the year on the wing, Rona struggled to make any real impact and was even relegated to the bench for a few games.

Daryl Gibson then decided to move him to outside centre.

His first few games were uneventful, but the last few weeks Rona’s combination with Kurtley Beale has clicked and his late push was enough to be selected.

While I doubt he will start come June 9, Rona offers a quality reserve utility role and his ability to cover multiple positions could come in handy later in the series.

Photo by Gabriel Rossi/Getty Images

Tom Banks
Definitely the bolter of the squad, Banks has shown all his talents this year for the Brumbies. He presents a danger every time he carries the ball and possesses both pace and footwork.

Banks’ standout game against the Bulls last week, where he played a crucial role, proved enough for him to have his name read out.

While he may struggle to crack the starting side against the Irish, this selection is definitely a positive one for the future.

Losers

Peter Samu
He’s been tearing it up across the ditch this year and Cheika made public his desire to pick him, but the stars did not align.

There is news that Samu could still be selected and, given the light backrow chosen (only five players), Cheika is obviously still hopeful that New Zealand will oblige in a release.

A question that arises from the Samu situation is, how were these players let go in the first place? Guys like Peter Samu and Michael Alaalatoa were deemed not good enough, with Cheika opting for old timers such as Benn Robinson and Stephen Hoiles.

But that is a topic for another day and I hope that Samu can bolster the backrow stocks leading up to the World Cup.

[latest_videos_strip category=”rugby” name=”Rugby”]

Taqele Naiyaravoro
Despite playing his best rugby since bursting on to the scene in 2014, Naiyaravoro has been left out. We can only assume that this is due to his decision to leave the country at the end of the season. And fair enough, in the build up to the World Cup, Cheika has gone for continuity.

Unfortunately, Naiyaravoro will be the latest name to go on the list of one or two Test Wallabies or All Blacks ‘stolen’ from their Pacific homelands.

Jake Gordon and Michael Ruru
I have grouped these two together as I see them as being in the same position.

Unfortunately, the logjam behind Will Genia means they missed out, despite both playing quality matches this year.

Either of these two could slot into the squad without much fuss and were hard done by as are both better than Joe Powell. Playing significantly less game time may have counted against them.

Hamish Stewart
While Bernard Foley has the Wallaby No.10 jersey all sown up, Stewart may have been holding out hope that Cheika would pick him as a backup. This was not the case, with Reece Hodge looking the obvious back-up. It has since been announced that Stewart will join the squad as a training group member, which indicates Cheika is looking at him.

Overall, I wouldn’t be too disappointed if I was Stewart, as the training will provide invaluable experience.

The Crowd Says:

2018-06-05T09:18:43+00:00

Gepetto

Guest


People will want to see the match day team before buying tickets. There are some liabilities in the squad.

2018-06-01T21:33:55+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


Poor comment, even if meant in jest.

2018-06-01T21:29:21+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


Good points, the boot chucker should be outta there!?

2018-06-01T05:36:50+00:00

Pablo

Roar Rookie


Both Hannigan and Robertson are playing better football than last year, (well done Darryl Gibson) Can see why they were selected as both young, though definitely better players out there to start. Phipps, what a poor selection! Gordon is a far better option at international level, and has weekly experience playing and training with Foley, Beale and Folau as well, without Phipps's brain drain and terrible kicking and passing. Oh well hopefully, he has another stags night, and rules himself out!

2018-06-01T03:48:45+00:00

bradm

Guest


I watched I Tonya last night and it got me thinking......how to get someone to take a baton to Mr Slushie (formerly the iceman) for the betterment of Australian Rugby?

2018-06-01T02:00:21+00:00

Neil

Guest


Yes, I also am highly skeptical of this new 'rotation' policy. It sounds to me as though Cheika got in Gibson’s ear and said ‘give Phipps some game time just so I can pick him.’ He is nowhere in the same league as Genia and Gordon has certainly been playing a better game than him all year. I’m a Tah’s supporter, but my patience ran out on Phipps years ago.

2018-06-01T01:54:31+00:00

one way street

Guest


Phipps and an injured Hanigan being selected is bad enough " While Bernard Foley has the Wallaby No.10 jersey all sown up " ^ This is the catalyst as to why Rugby in Australia is down the drain .

2018-05-31T23:44:06+00:00

Puff

Guest


According to a Daily Telegraph NZ article the NZR will reluctantly release Pete Samu for a payment of $50k. It appears players must be released to their respective unions when selected for test service. But as the gent has lived in NZ since 2014 and has dual nationality this regulations does not apply. It appears the ARU are reluctant to pay for Cheika’s request. The Crusaders are a little frustrated as he is still under contract and long hours have been invested improving his on field abilities.

2018-05-31T20:51:10+00:00

Sinclair

Guest


Allowing for the usual few 'captain's picks' the squad seems surprisingly within bounds for Cheika. For mine, Hanigan and Robertson are lucky but have good motors. However, I think both are lacking in core skills for their position. I would prefer to see them head overseas to sides where they will be able to develop those skills. Exeter is full of Oz players and seems to be good at getting the most out of players. Wouldn't mind seeing a link develop there. It is hard to see the up side with Phipps as he has had the same issues (passing, judgement) for a long time. Desperately hoping this squad can develop improvement in some long term problem areas like exiting from deep in own 1/2, awful tactical kicking and poor kick chase, mid-field defence, lack of back row balance and issues with a lack of powerful ball carriers in forwards. There is a bit of overlap between these issues. Potentially, this squad can offer some improvement in most of these but only if some changes to game plan are involved.

2018-05-31T20:00:02+00:00

Shocked

Guest


Cheika has stated that fitness be of utmost importance. Fitness and game time. Yet rules wont apply to Hanigan, who hasnt seen Super Rugby for a month and is struggling with a knee injury. He'll start. Phipps.....geez. The bloke is out for the first half of Super rugby with injury, fails to crack the 9 jersey as Gordon is playing well, suddenly given the 9 jersey due to a 'rotation policy', off field dramas, has leadership role stripped off hin but is than handed a Wallabies spot. If i werr Gordon id be thinking what more do i do to crack a spot? Phipps is everything wrong with the Rugby culture in Australia, but is gifted a national spot. What a joke

2018-05-31T16:56:09+00:00

MH01

Guest


Phipps - winner - should be no where near the squad . I can even see Ned improving over time, though makes no sense persisting with Phipps.

Read more at The Roar