Five talking points from the Japanese Grand Prix

By Ben Waterworth / Roar Guru

Four races remain in the 2019 Formula One season.

We have one of our championships confirmed and a whole lot of interesting things to look at after another round draws to close.

Stewards, timing and typhoons
What a crazy weekend in Japan. From the threat of a typhoon, the rescheduling of qualifying, right through to a pretty action-packed race. The 2019 Japanese Grand Prix seemingly had it all.

However, one thing it didn’t seem to have was an idea when the race was meant to finish. Was it lap 52? Lap 53? Ask Lance Stroll and I’m sure he’d tell you lap 53, however a computer glitch which sent the chequered flag signal out a lap early had the race finish on lap 52, meaning Stroll’s Racing Point teammate Sergio Perez took home points instead of the Canadian.

Considering how strong Stroll had driven this weekend, he’d no doubt be leaving Japan feeling pretty gutted. At least we can’t blame a model this time around.

There was also the little issue of the stewarding across the race. The first corner incident between Max Verstappen and Charles Leclerc was initially deemed a racing incident with no further action needed. However, a classic Verstappen radio whinge (which in fairness to the Dutchman hadn’t happened in a while) soon changed the fortunes of that investigation, and Leclerc was promptly investigated and punished 15 seconds both for the accident and driving in an unsafe condition after the race.

Another contentious issue revolved around Sebastian Vettel and his movement off the line before the race start. Cameras appeared to show the German making a false start, moving forward slightly on the fifth light before stopping and then ultimately starting again on the race start proper. There were calls of inconsistency given Kimi Raikkonen received a penalty last round in Russia for a similar incident, however the stewards explained that Vettel wasn’t moving when the lights went out, while Raikkonen was deemed to have been moving when the lights went out in Sochi.

(GEPA Pictures/Red Bull Content Pool).

Six in a row for Mercedes
Remember the early 2000s when people bemoaned how boring the sport was when Ferrari and Michael Schumacher won time and time again? Or when the sport was in dire need for change in 2013 because Sebastian Vettel and Red Bull were just too good?

Those were actually pretty good days compared to now it seems, because we live in a world where Mercedes have collected their sixth double-double in a row. This is a history making moment for the team, as they have become the first to do so in the history of Formula One.

But for fans who like to see a bit of variety? It hasn’t exactly been the greatest period in the sport.

Mercedes secured their sixth consecutive Constructors’ Championship at Suzuka thanks to Valtteri Bottas claiming the win and Lewis Hamilton finishing third and securing a point for the fastest lap. They also assured that one of the two of them will win the drivers’ championship at the end of the year.

And while neutral fans may find this period of domination tedious, credit must of course be given to the team for their consistency over the last six seasons to maintain such a dominant foothold at the top of the sport. Many doubted they would replicate the success they once achieved in the 1950s when they took over Brawn at the end of 2009, but a decade later Mercedes have proved that they are one of the greatest teams in the history of the sport.

Alex Albon looks good for Red Bull in 2020
Fourth place for Albon at Suzuka is his best ever result in Formula One. The Thai driver drove superbly all weekend in Japan, setting the same time as Max Verstappen in Q3 and bouncing back from a bad start in the race to achieve 12 points and surely give himself a firm stranglehold on retaining his seat at Red Bull in 2020.

(Dan Istitene/Getty Images)

His challengers, Pierre Gasly and Daniil Kvyat, didn’t quite give the Milton Keys team too much cause for notice across the weekend. Gasly was solid enough to finish in 8th, while Kvyat didn’t even crack the top ten all weekend and struggled home in 12th.

Expect an announcement soon that the impressive rookie will get to continue to showcase just exactly what he is capable of by securing his seat for another season.

Will the real Renault please stand up
Where did that race pace come from Renault? After seemingly languishing at the back of the grid with a variety of issues all weekend, the French outfit put in a bolter during the race to come home 6th and 10th.

Daniel Ricciardo was criminally overlooked in the ‘driver of the day’ conversation with a storming drive from 16th to sixth, while Nico Hulkenberg drove a quiet but solid race to claim a double points finish for the team.

What made it more interesting for the team is the fact that McLaren only had one car in the points, after another superb drive by the ‘smooth operator’ himself, Carlos Sainz. The battle for fourth in the Constructors is definitely on in the remaining four races, with Renault hoping they can get on top of their pre-race pace to get up higher on the grid and really take the challenge to McLaren for the rest of the season.

Stop getting too excited over ‘Super Sunday’
The big takeaway for most people from the weekend was how amazing it was to have qualifying and the race on Sunday. This so called ‘super Sunday’ excited so many people that they are getting a little too ahead of themselves by saying it is the final nail in the coffin to introduce a sprint race next season as part of qualifying, and perhaps shake up the schedule over a weekend to include more action on a Sunday.

(AP Photo/Luca Bruno)

While in theory this is a good idea, people seemingly have a short memory when it comes to this idea. In 2004, we had our first instance of qualifying moving to a Sunday at the Japanese Grand Prix due to Typhoon Ma-on, and everyone was quick to jump on the hype train and implement a split qualifying in 2005 to enable qualifying on a Saturday and a Sunday.

That created a disastrous aggregate system that was hated by pretty much everyone and was scrapped after only six races.

If there is a call for more action on a Sunday, why not bring back the Sunday warm-up session that used to take place for an hour in the morning on race day? This was always a great opportunity for teams to get out on the track, test the conditions and get their cars race-ready and fully know how the track would most likely handle for the race that afternoon.

This would ultimately mean that parc fermé regulations would need to be relaxed after qualifying, but if there was a workaround it would mean more on-track action for fans at the circuit and more track time for drivers. This is something many drivers complain about and long for, so it could be a win-win situation.

With all that in mind, it’s now time to focus on Mexico in two weeks to see if Lewis Hamilton can secure his sixth drivers’ championship. Considering how he has fared at the Autódromo Hermanos Rodríguez in the past, you certainly wouldn’t put it past him.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2019-10-17T21:41:49+00:00

Ben Waterworth

Roar Guru


You should try watching F1 in this part of the world haha! Sunday evening races for the majority of the season, then we get 4am starts for Canada, US and Mexico, around the same for Brazil and then a midnight one for Abu Dhabi. The only good ones for us are obviously Australia, China and Japan being late Sunday afternoon. Singapore is decent too. But since living in New Zealand it's even worse as it's 2 hours later for every race! 1am starts basically for every European round...ugh. Definitely remember Australia and Bahrain 2016. I was at the Australian race and everyone in the crowd was confused as to what was going on. It was good in theory, but in practice? Terrible. I actually was a fan of the one lap shoot out. I don't see them bringing it back as this format generally works, but I'd like to see them scrap Q3 rules and let them have quali specific engines and tyres to let them go flat out like the good old pre-2003 days. Those sessions could be tedious, but they were still fascinating viewing and had a driver on the absolute edge of their capabilities for a hot lap. Really sorted the good drivers from the really great drivers. I actually never attended a GP when there was a Sunday warm-up. My first ever race was 2003 in Australia when I was 16, and I remember there being the 2 hour test session on the Friday which was actually quite entertaining for a first taste of F1. But they somehow made it work back in the day so I'm not sure how they would do it today. Australia has a PACKED support race category. You don't go more than at least 15 minutes without there being some form of action on the track. And I know they've added another category next year so yeah, it would be tricky. But I know having been to some other races around the world where there are barely any support categories, it would make it a bit easier. I remember attending my first Malaysian GP and there being like 2 support races and just hours of nothing. It was odd. And thanks for the welcome! I've been floating around for a bit and finally decided to start writing and I'm definitely enjoying it and reading everything you guys have to write!

2019-10-17T17:22:00+00:00

Joshua Kerr

Roar Guru


1. I found the stewarding a bit weird too this weekend. No penalty for Leclerc then a 15 second time penalty a few hours after the race. What are they playing at?! Vettel didn't move out of the starting box and so didn't get detected by the sensor and so didn't get a penalty. Simple. He didn't benefit at all because he was immediately overtaken by Bottas so he sort of penalised himself. 2. Bravo Mercedes. It looks easy to dominate the sport like they have but it definitely isn't and a lot of credit should be paid to the people we don't see working hard at the factory in Brackley. As usual, I'm torn. Yes, it's great that they've won six successful driver-constructor championship doubles but we've had some excrutiatingly boring races over that period. Success and domination comes at a price, viewing figures tumble due to the predictability and I get ridiculed for saving 21 weekends, 22 from next year, for F1 armchair watching (and writing). 3. Albon's great. I love his driving style. He's been rather fortunate to be given grid penalties that relegate him to the back of the grid as he has proven that he can move through the field well when required. 4th place in Japan was helped out by his teammate retiring and Leclerc's self-inflicted damage after contact with Verstappen at the start (plus post-race penalty). Still, compared with Gasly's performance in the same seat in the first half of the season, I think Albon's a shoe-in for the 2020 seat. 4. Renault did pull it out of the bag in the race. However, I think it's only more impressive because they had to come through the field. They are still second-best to McLaren but don't let this detract from a decent race from them. 5. So-called 'Super Sunday' was a nightmare for me here in the UK. Qualifying at 2am? No thanks! It's bad enough that the race started at 6.10am. I think the idea of qualifying sprint races should be played with but the current qualifying format has been going strong for 14 seasons and shouldn't be tampered with. Remember Australia and Bahrain 2016? I'd rather not. While I like your idea of the warm-up session, it's not plausible for all grands prix, especially the European rounds. I fear that a warm-up session could come at the expense of support races, with them perhaps being moved to an earlier slot to accommodate the new session. I'm too young to remember when warm-ups actually existed and so cannot comment too much on the sessions themselves but I'd hate to see the support races get dealt a harsher deal than the mediocre one they have already. (What does the support race schedule at the Australian GP look like, Ben, and where would you put a warm-up session if you had the powers to do so? While you are lucky enough to have wall-to-wall coverage on Channel Ten, Sky Sports F1 refuses to show anything but the F1, although BT Sport sometimes decides to show the Supercars from Melbourne.) P.S. Lovely to have you join the motorsport team. With Michael, Jawad, you and I, we've got a great mix of opinions suitable for such an opinionated sport!

Read more at The Roar