The Roar
The Roar



When the Kangaroos met the Demons: Combining Melbourne and North Melbourne

Autoplay in... 6 (Cancel)
Up Next No more videos! Playlist is empty -
Roar Guru
8th November, 2019

A Melbourne merger of the Kangaroos and Demons is an interesting prospect. This would be the best combined list of this speculative scenario in 2020.

To be eligible to be chosen for this team a player must have played a minimum of five games in 2019. I’ve chosen to combine North Melbourne and Melbourne with a total of 11 North Melbourne players and 11 Melbourne players. The players I’ve selected must be on their team’s respective list for the upcoming 2020 season.

Combined Melbourne-North Melbourne list

Coach: Rhyce Shaw
Co-captains: Todd Goldstein, Ben Cunnington
B: Oscar McDonald (Melbourne), Jake Lever (Melbourne), Neville Jetta (Melbourne)
HB: Michael Hibberd (Melbourne), Robbie Tarrant (North Melbourne), Jamie Macmillan (North Melbourne)
C: Ed Langdon (Melbourne), Ben Cunnington (North Melbourne), Trent Dumont (North Melbourne)
HF: Shaun Higgins (North Melbourne), Nick Larkey (North Melbourne), Jayden Hunt (Melbourne)
F: Kayne Turner (North Melbourne), Ben Brown (North Melbourne), Jack Ziebell (North Melbourne)
Foll: Todd Goldstein (North Melbourne), James Harmes (Melbourne), Clayton Oliver (Melbourne)
Int: Adam Tomlinson (Melbourne), Jed Anderson (North Melbourne), Angus Brayshaw (Melbourne), Jack Viney (Melbourne)

Jake Lever

(Daniel Pockett/AFL Media/Getty Images)


I chose Rhyce Shaw as coach as he did a good job during his tenure in 2019.


I chose Todd Goldstein as one of the two co-captains as he’s a good character and a good role model for the other players to look up to. Ben Cunnington, on the other hand, leads by example, through his unwavering attack on the footy and the quality player he is, and deserves to be a co-captain.



Oscar McDonald is an underrated defender who is an important part of the Melbourne team. Jake Lever would be an important part of this combined team in the full back position. Neville Jetta can prove he is one of the top small defenders in the competition. Michael Hibberd can provide plenty of run off the half back flank. Robbie Tarrant is clearly North Melbourne’s best tall defender and is most suited to the centre half back role. Jamie Macmillan would flourish playing on a half back flank.

Sports opinion delivered daily 




The midfielders were relatively easy to pick as Ed Langdon is a quality player who’s most suited to playing on a wing and Ben Cunnington is one of the most underrated midfielders in the competition. Trent Dumont finished fourth in the North Melbourne best and fairest in 2019.


Shaun Higgins could prove hard to curtail playing on a half forward flank. Nick Larkey is a quality centre half forward who will start to get recognition as he has a lot of ability. Jayden Hunt had a reasonable 2019, but I expect him to improve in 2020 after finishing tenth in this year’s Melbourne best and fairest. Kayne Turner needs to kick more goals and will do so in 2020. He also has the ability to push up the ground, as he averaged 18.6 possessions per game in 2019. Ben Brown is an automatic selection at full forward. Jack Ziebell should play up forward as he is a hard match up if he plays in the forward pocket.


Todd Goldstein is a good ruckman and a great leader, therefore he’s is a walk-up start. James Harmes averaged 24.5 disposals a game, playing every game in 2019, and I expect him to relish more midfield time in 2020. Clayton Oliver finished equal first in the Melbourne best and fairest for a reason. He averaged 30 disposals and is probably going to improve even more in 2020.



Adam Tomlinson has the capability to play wherever he is needed for the team at any given time. Jed Anderson has the ability to play every game next season as he doesn’t need a lot of the ball to make an impact. Angus Brayshaw didn’t have his best season in 2019 but still managed to finish eighth in the best and fairest. Jack Viney should be an impact player as he needs to have more of an influence on the game. Reducing Viney’s game time would help him do that.