1. The ball is kicked out from the centre.
2. Collingwood’s Brayden Sier attacks it. Fremantle’s Tobe Watson holds onto him and drags him by one arm during the whole contest.
3. Sier gathers the ball with his free hand
4. Immediately, David Mundy and a Fremantle teammate close on Sier and tackle him front on.
5. Watson tackles Sier from behind.
6. The three Fremantle players are locked around Sier and tumble to the ground.
7. Sier is penalised for holding the ball.
What the hell?
AFL umpire Shane McInerney (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)
Surely “holding the ball” is only applicable in the following circumstances:
• If a player physically can dispose of the ball, but chooses not to;
• Or disposes of the ball illegally, e.g. by dropping it or throwing it;
• Or holds onto the ball a long time without attempting to dispose of it.
Not one of these criteria apply to Sier. Even if Watson wasn’t already holding him, the two Fremantle players close on him from front-on, making any disposal, or attempt at a disposal, impossible.
Sadly, we’re now seeing a lot of decisions like this now being paid. However well-intentioned, the rule is being bastardised into an absolute that is patently unfair, and definitely not in the spirit of the game.
This has already happened before with another rule – penalising players for diving on the ball, dragging it in, and not making a genuine attempt to get it out.
Okay. That’s fair enough.
But there are occasions a player will have opposition piled on him. Physically, it’s impossible for him to:
a. clear the ball;
b. make a physical attempt to try to clear it, and;
What’s expected of the player then? To defy physics, lift three hundred kilograms of weight piled on top of him, and palm the ball clear?
In attempting to go harder on rules, we simplify them until they’re lobotomised.
Look at ‘deliberate’ as another example.
From Sunday’s game Jamie Elliott tried to soccer the ball clear while slipping backward. The ball went about 20 metres forward and rolled out.
Was Elliott’s intention to find the boundary line? Doubtful.
Was Elliott’s intention to clear the ball from congestion and drive the contest further afield? Likely.
After last week delisting 11 players within less than 24 hours of their final match of the season, North Melbourne have in recent days taken yet more steps in what looks set to be a radical playing list shakeup, placing a trio of established players in Shaun Higgins, Jared Polec and Ben Brown on the […]