The Roar
The Roar

AFL
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Opinion

One question mark for each finalist ahead of Week 1

Autoplay in... 6 (Cancel)
Up Next No more videos! Playlist is empty -
Replay
Cancel
Next
Editor
28th September, 2020
43
1583 Reads

We’ve had 18 gruelling rounds of home-and-away action. We’ve had a totally pointless bye week. Now it’s time for finals to finally get underway.

With a wide-open top four and some teams in the lower bracket who fancy themselves, we’ve got a finals series to salivate over.

I know I can’t pick a winner just yet, but I can come up with something for each top-eight side to worry about beforehand.

Port Adelaide

What did those heavy losses to the big guns mean?

Port Adelaide made a dramatic return to the finals as minor premiers in a year many thought Ken Hinkley would be struggling to retain his job.

They sat in first place at the end of each and every home-and-away round and finished with a very healthy percentage of 136.4, so they’re clearly up there with the best.

However, two of their three losses were self-described “uppercuts” – a 37-point trouncing at the hands of Brisbane a 60-point shocker against Geelong, who were on a very short break.

They’ve got a woeful recent record against the Cats – two wins from their last 17 meetings – to go with three straight losses against the Lions, although they’ve held their own against the Tigers of late.

Advertisement
Advertisement

With the least recent finals experience of any of this year’s top four, the Power could’ve finished 17-0 and still had something to prove. But their meek showings against some fellow top four sides, especially the Cats, is of particular concern.

Power coach Ken Hinkley looks on

Can the Power bounce back from a demolition by Geelong earlier this year? (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Brisbane Lions

Can we crack the Richmond hoodoo?

It’s the longest current losing streak one side has to another in the AFL. The last time Brisbane defeated Richmond, Terry Wallace was coaching the Tigers.

The time before that, Leigh Matthews was at Brisbane’s helm.

Richmond are 15-0 over the Lions since Damien Hardwick took over and, for the most part, it hasn’t been close. The 47-point margin in last year’s qualifying final flattered the Tigers a bit, but the home side were found wanting when it counted.

Poor kicking doomed Brisbane in their 41-point loss earlier this year too, and you have to wonder whether the biggest advantage Richmond have over their opponents is between the ears.

Advertisement
Advertisement

There’s little separating the midfield of the two clubs, while you’d imagine a back six led by Harris Andrews is of one of the better equipped against the tall duo of Tom Lynch of Jack Riewoldt, but the forwards just can’t seem to get it done.

Dayne Zorko and his Lions team mates look dejected after losing

The Lions have had little to smile about against the Tigers of late. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Richmond

Will we get our team balance right?

Richmond have precious little to worry about coming into the finals. They come into October with a six-game winning streak, including convincing wins over West Coast and Geelong.

But with the injury list shrinking, Damien Hardwick has an enviable selection headache to deal with.

Shai Bolton and Dion Prestia come back, but who drops out at their expense? Did Josh Caddy do enough to hold his spot in a burgeoning small forward line? Does Jack Higgins have a spot if he recovers from his calf injury in time? What happens when Tom Lynch comes back – are they too tall if they persist with Mabior Chol as a second ruckman?

The Tigers are firming nicely and have probably done enough to slip into favouritism over the last few weeks, but they’ll need to get the 22 just right as they look to claim a third flag in four seasons.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Damien Hardwick

Damien Hardwick has some tough calls to make at the selection table. (Photo by Graham Denholm/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Geelong Cats

Is our last fortnight cause for concern?

I had the Cats as premiership favourites coming into the final stretch of the home-and-away season, but they didn’t exactly impress over their last five matches.

They made Essendon look like a VFL team, but their other matches saw them do just enough to see off the Crows, turn up 20 minutes late against the Bulldogs, get outclassed by Richmond and need a Patrick Dangerfield special in the last quarter to see off a dogged challenge from Sydney.

They’ve had the week off to reset and refresh, but given their finals record is already maligned, their wobbly finish to the home-and-away season is very much a cause for concern.

Joel Selwood of the Cats leads his team out onto the field

The Cats come into October on the back of shaky form. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

West Coast Eagles

Advertisement
Advertisement

Has no top-four finish cost us again?

Last year’s shock loss to Hawthorn in the final home-and-away round saw the high-flying Eagles dumped from top four and, as we all know, the move to the lower bracket doomed them to a disappoint semi-finals exit.

This year that costly upset appears to be Round 2’s all-timer against Gold Coast, a match Adam Simpson blasted his side for, according to GPS data, running softer than a training match they’d held midweek.

They’ll start hot favourites against Collingwood in their elimination final, just as they did against Essendon in 2019, but it’s the week after I’d be worried about if I were an Eagles fan.

They’ve had famous wins against the Power in Adelaide over the journey, but their last two meetings have seen them decisively towelled up. They defeated Geelong by nine points at home this season but haven’t tasted success against the Cats away from Perth since way back in 2006.

West Coast may have put their reputation as tragic travellers to bed over the last month, but they’ll be up against it should they progress to Week 2 and will be left to ponder what might have been if they’re tripped up again.

Luke Shuey of West Coast Eagles looks dejected

The Eagles may rue another top four berth gone begging. (Photo by Matt Roberts/AFL Photos/via Getty Images)

St Kilda

Advertisement
Advertisement

Are we just making up the numbers?

Saints fans should be ecstatic with a return to finals after a nine-year absence and the assertion by a certain AFL.com.au columnist whose name rhymes with ‘cranium carrot’ that a first-week exit would mean 2020 is a failure is complete nonsense.

But despite their sixth-place finish, you have to wonder whether St Kilda are the easy pick to bow out this weekend. They did knock off the Power in Adelaide, but they got towelled up by both Geelong and Collingwood and also dropped matches against Brisbane and West Coast.

You’d also have to say they caught the Bulldogs and Tigers at a good time when they claimed their scalps at the start of the season.

I’m all for fresh sides making a splash in finals, so I hope I’m wrong, but an iffy record against the top eight and wobbly form coming into October (three wins from seven matches) makes them the logical choice for being one-and-done.

Jack Steele of the Saints celebrates kicking a goal

Jack Steele and the Saints have an uphill battle to do damage in the finals. (Photo by Matt Roberts/AFL Photos/via Getty Images)

Western Bulldogs

Which Bulldogs side will turn up?

Advertisement
Advertisement

It’s the same story as 2019 for the Bulldogs: their best is clearly good enough to trouble the very best of sides but their worst is bad enough to give the Frankston Dolphins a sniff.

This is a side that put Greater Western Sydney and an in-form Melbourne to the sword before snatching a win off West Coast while also copping a 52-point hammering at the hands of Carlton.

They’ve pushed Port Adelaide all the way and been pushed all the way by the Suns. They wiped the floor with the Cats for one quarter and slowly watched that lead disappear.

Last season they came storming into September with three huge wins over finals sides or finals hopefuls before getting obliterated by the Giants in the first week.

For now I’m backing them to get past the Saints, but a second straight elimination final loss would be a huge disappointment for a side that was clearly recruiting to improve last year.

Marcus Bontempelli of the Bulldogs looks dejected after a loss

The Bulldogs could win or lose by 60 points this week. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Collingwood

Can our forward line get it done?

Advertisement
Advertisement

Collingwood’s scoring prowess has never been their coup de grace, but it’s fallen to worrying levels in 2020.

It’s little wonder just about every trade rumour involving a key forward links them with the Magpies.

Coming into finals they’re ranked 13th in the AFL for scoring, below the likes of Gold Coast, Hawthorn and Carlton. The other seven finalists are the competition’s seven best scoring teams.

Essendon came into last year’s finals series ranked 13th for scoring and got blown off the park by West Coast, while the year before saw Sydney finish sixth despite being 12th for scoring and they got embarrassed by the Giants.

The simple version is Collingwood need to score a lot more points if they want to make anything of this finals campaign. On paper, with Brody Mihocek, Jordan de Goey and Jaidyn Stephenson, they should be doing better than they are; the big question will be whether they actually do.

Brody Mihocek and Jordan De Goey of the Magpies celebrate a goal

Collingwood need to put more points on the board. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)