Opinion
Well, it’s fair to say that the baby is out with the bathwater, and then some. The idea of flying under the radar and creeping up the ladder was great… while it lasted.
Big thanks to Errol Gulden for his near best afield efforts the last two weeks, five goals from Logan McDonald, Chad Warner playing like nothing else matters and Sam Reid finding his mojo again. Didn’t you guys get the memo?
I swear there was a pre-season memo sent to the players.
Dear [insert player name here],
The media, the pundits, every predictor and his dog, and even blind freddy haven’t given us a hope in hell of doing much this year. Even the kiss of death doesn’t want to tip us.
Heck, even some of them had us pegged for bottom four again this year. One even had us fighting for the spoon.
Therefore, let’s subvert expectations, set the bar so low that when we succeed, they’ll be shocked to the core.
Kind regards,
Swans coaching department.
All I wanted from this season was the watch the Swans younger players make a solid, if not unspectacular start to AFL life, prove that they can play the level and watch the elder statesman transition into mentoring and coaching roles. I can imagine that a lot of people had similar expectations. Dreams of good performances, close losses to decent teams, and maybe challenging in that 10-12 ladder position range.
The pre-season wasn’t anything special, losing both games to the Giants. Heck, we weren’t good in the second game in the first half, but a third quarter explosion put us in position for a win. As always, pre-season performances are not a true indicator of future performance.
The one thing that’s been remarkably consistent from the pre-season to the first two rounds is that we’re a leaky sieve in the opening and closing 10 minutes of a match. We’ve conceded 13 goals in the that time (five in the opening stanza, eight in the last) so far this season, while we’ve scored just three goals. The turnarounds, as phenomenal as they’ve been, have been crushing the opponents through the second and third quarters, outscoring them 26 goals to ten.
We’ve turned 50-point leads into 30-point wins. A win is a win, and I’m more than happy to see the four points on the board, but it is something that the team needs to work on.
There’s aspects to that drop off, be it conditioning or concentration. Whatever it is, I hope it’s addressed before too long, because a tight game against a team like St Kilda or Melbourne could go down to the line, and if we’re still conceding goals late in the game, we’ll never be confident or comfortable that we can run out winners.
Besides the late fades and sluggish starts, the performances of the lesser lights, new recruits and inexperienced players has been something I’ve never seen. I don’t recall three debutants ever making such an impact on a side in their first two games, while Jordan Dawson, Tom McCartin and Chad Warner have been bloody good. The old dour Swans are long gone, this crop of players is an exciting group to watch.
The signs of a team in transition have been there since late 2018. One of John Longmire’s biggest criticisms was his inflexibility, his dedication to a style of play that was clearly falling behind the times. Who would have thought that the most recent rule changes would have benefitted the Swans the most? I certainly didn’t. I thought it would work in our favour, I just didn’t expect this.
I suspect the recruitment of Don Pyke has more to do with the way that we’re playing, than the man on the mark rule change.
Last year was a very good season for a team finishing in the bottom four. We competed well in the majority of matches, almost beat Geelong in the final round – a win that would have pushed them out of the top four and meant that Richmond would have likely played Brisbane in the grand final. I expected more of the same this year, some good performances, players growing in confidence, more from Dylan Stephens and finally Will Gould getting a run.
Instead, Stephens can’t even get close, Justin McInerney’s picked right up where he left off, Chad Warner has just exploded out of the blocks, while Isaac Heeney looks like a bona fide forward 50 star. We’re banging in goals from all over the place, scored 120 points in consecutive weeks for the first time since 2017, and are registering ridiculous inside 50 stats.
For so long, Tom Papley was our focal point in attack, but now I can barely remember a time the players even kicked it to him inside forward 50. He’s still contributing strongly in other areas of the field, but he no longer has to do it all himself. Gulden is having an stonking start to his career. He’s set the bar so bloody high that it can only go down from here.
I didn’t expect much, but I honestly fear a win on the weekend against Richmond, because every man and his dog will be picking Swans to finish top four. Yada yada Fox Sports blah blah, something about a team from the eight always making the top four every season for the last 15 years. If it’s us, great, but I fear the pressure and expectations that will come with it.
I’m chuffed either way, the way the boys are playing is far beyond my wildest imagination and for the first time in the last two years, I’m not just cheering the Swans because they did something okay on the field, I’m up and about and screaming my head off at the TV and going purple in the face.
Damn it feels good again!
Who’s in your ultimate team? Pick the best team and compete with other fans for daily prizes on Draftstars. For the best odds on the game try out Aussie bookmaker PlayUp. Think. Is this a bet you really want to place? Set a deposit limit.
The AFL Players' Association has come out swinging against the league for their decision to hand Port Adelaide forward a three-match suspension for using…
Overreacting to a single loss is one of the most overplayed scenarios in sport, but it’s important for the Swans to still believe that…
It’s high stakes with five teams having lost their first three games of season 2024, and in desperate need of a win.
It could be a weekend for contenders to emerge, teams to hopefully break droughts, o and overall footy to have a party.
We’ve already seen what Jack Ginnivan is capable of at Collingwood with his ability to grasp big moments - how will he go against his former teammates?
Sydney forward Sam Wicks will not feature at AFL or VFL level for the Swans this weekend, after a dispute with a teammate threatened…
