The Roar
The Roar


'Absolute dog move' or 'very smart'? Cricket world reacts to Sixers' controversial final-over ploy

Autoplay in... 6 (Cancel)
Up Next No more videos! Playlist is empty -
26th January, 2022
5585 Reads

The finish to the BBL11 Challenger final between the Sydney Sixers and the Adelaide Strikers was surely the most controversial in the competition’s ten-year history.

With one ball remaining in the game and needing two runs to win, the Sixers would spark Australia-wide debate about the so-called ‘spirit of the game’, when they chose to retire out injured batter Jordan Silk for fully-fit wicketkeeper-batter Jay Lenton, in the hopes of scrambling the winning runs.

How decisive the move was will never be known, with Strikers fielder Jon Wells – perhaps out of haste knowing there was no injured runner to target – fumbling on the boundary to gift the Sixers the winning boundary.

The reaction from the Fox Cricket commentary box was swift and uncomfortable, with Australian great Adam Gilchrist, one of the country’s fairest ever players, unsure about the Sixers’ tactics.

“I don’t know about this, I do not know about this,” Gilchrist said as the move was being made.

“My gut feel says I don’t like it. The Sixers have been pressed, it’s been rammed home to the Sixers in the lead-up to this finals series, we’re sticking by the rules, the rules that we made up two weeks ago, but we’re sticking by them. The Sixers have said, well, there is a rulebook there, we’re going to exploit a rule here.”


Fellow commentator Mark Waugh agreed, saying the move was ‘within the rules, but it’s probably not within the spirit of the game.’

Outside the box, the reaction was more divided, with plenty of scorn heaped on the Sixers and coach Greg Shipperd.

Leading the charge was well-known political and economics journalist and blogger Greg Jericho, who described the retirement as an ‘absolute dog move’.

The Sixers’ ploy was also quickly savaged for being ‘putrid’ and ‘absolutely disgraceful’, amid laments for the spirit of the game.



However, there was plenty of praise for the Sixers as well, with former England international and BBL veteran for the Melbourne Stars, Luke Wright, calling the move ‘very smart’.

Acclaim came in for the two-time reigning champions’ ‘clear thinking under pressure’, while former AFL player Michael Barlow said Lenton, an assistant coach for the Sixers before being thrust into the game due to the COVID-enforced withdrawal of regular wicketkeeper Josh Philippe, played a key role.



Waugh’s critical reaction in the immediate aftermath also received a going-over, with AAP journalist Scott Bailey pointing out that the Test great has long been an advocate for teams retiring out struggling batters in T20 cricket.

Meanwhile, Test captain Pat Cummins steered clear of the controversy, while nicely summing up what we all were thinking.

Notably, Gilchrist and Waugh’s initial opinions of the incident cooled substantially once the match concluded, with the latter saying after the match: “I’m happy with it, I’m fine with it.

“All the things that have happened to the Sixers in this tournament – not being able to play Steve Smith, etc. – they’ve played by the rules tonight, so I’m happy with it.”

“I was questioning it as it played out… I thought, ‘hang on a minute, is this right?’” Gilchrist added.

“But thinking about it, I agree with Junior; it is within the rules and it’s actually fairly quick thinking, nifty thinking, and that’s years and years of experienced cricket heads coming together there.

“I can’t do anything other than to sit back and go, well done, they’ve picked up an opportunity there within the rules.”

Hayden Kerr scores the winning runs.

Hayden Kerr scores the winning runs for the Sydney Sixers during the BBL Challenger final.. (Photo by Steven Markham/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Strikers captain Peter Siddle was also fine with the tactic when asked about it after the game.

“You can retire blokes, at the end of the day,” Siddle told Fox Cricket.

“He can retire, it’s not actually a big issue.

“Obviously I was disappointed at the time. It’s just a retirement, isn’t it… that’s just a part of the game.”

Sports opinion delivered daily 


Strikers coach Jason Gillespie was fine with the move, too, posting on Twitter that he had ‘no issue with it at all’.

Sixers captain Moises Henriques was also staunch in his defence of his team’s actions, describing the move as ‘clearly within the rules of the game’.

“Unfortunately, we had a guy go down with a hamstring, one of the fittest guys in the league [Silk],” Henriques told Fox Cricket after the match.

“Probably something to do with our schedule and our five flights in eight days and so many back-to-back games.

“He normally bats five, so the fact that he’s gone in to bat at eight – I think we’re sacrificing enough as it is.”