Rugby News: Banks' $2.8m mega offer threatens RWC place, ABs legend mauls 'horrific' SRP tactic

By The Roar / Editor

Wallabies fullback Tom Banks has received offers to play in Japan worth a reported $1.4 million a season for two years, leaving the Brumbies and Rugby Australia frantically scrambling to keep him on board for next year’s Rugby World Cup.

The Brumbies chief executive Phil Thomson confirmed Banks was sought after by Japanese clubs, telling the Sydney Morning Herald the No.15 was the target of a “very attractive and lucrative offer from Japan”.

“It’s tough, for all parties,” Thomson said.

“It is a tough decision for Tom and it’s a tough market to compete with, here in Australia. At the moment we are still in discussions, there is no final decision. We will try and work closely with Rugby Australia to make sure the best offer is on the table.

“It’s really hard. You can sign a deal like that and set yourself up for a long time, so that’s in the mind of people. Anything can happen in your career over a three-year period so you can have injuries or loss of form or whatever.

“Is it better to take the bird in the hand, or back yourself to play more Test matches and experience World Cups – and then you’ll still be a commodity sought after at a later time? It is a tough one.”

Thomson said RA and the Brumbies were working to structure a counter offer that was similar to the deal where Michael Hooper was able to cash in a season playing in Japan.

“That’s certainly on the table and open for discussion too, so we can look at all those ways we can structure a deal with him to give him the opportunity to continue to play for Australia but also have the opportunity to go to Japan and experience that lifestyle and earn some additional money,” Thomson said.

“With someone like Tom, he has played Test match rugby for Australia but he is still establishing himself as the genuine number one fullback in Australia, leading into a World Cup year in 2023. That’s something we can chat with him about, making himself the premium No.15 here in Australia and experiencing a World Cup.”

The recent changes to the Giteau Law allows coach Dave Rennie to choose three overseas based players at any one time but would leave him with a significant headache. Fullback has also been a problem spot for the Wallabies, although Jordan Petaia, Jock Campbell and Kurtley Beale shape as realistic options.

The Herald said Banks would drop approximately $1 million if he ignored the offers and stayed with the Brumbies. The paper said two clubs linked to Banks were Honda and Canon and that Banks had “made up his mind” about his next steps.

Join experts Brett McKay and Harry Jones along with special guest Jonathan Kaplan on the latest edition of The Roar Rugby Podcast.

Force to sign Fainga’a

Fresh from unveiling Simon Cron as their incoming coach, the Western Force are close to signing Wallabies hooker Folau Fainga’a from the Brumbies.

Fox Sports says the Brumbies No.2 will join on a one year deal. He had been offered a deal tomplay with Lyon in France.

Marshall trips into rolling mauls

All Blacks legend Justin Marshall has described rolling mauls as a try-scoring tactic “a horrific thing to watch” as the Highlanders used the ploy to devastating effect to beat Moana Pasifika on the weekend.

“It’s really predictable rugby, “Marshall said on SENZ radio.

“When it gets down to that zone, it’s frustrating to watch a team like Moana Pasifika, who are really competitive right across the board but the opposition score four tries (against them) from rolling mauls, and that’s the game.

“That’s not really playing rugby is it. It’s a horrific thing to watch, because there’s nothing dynamic, nothing entertaining about it.”

Marshall said it also led to an unusual statistic.

“Hookers are the leading try scorers at the moment, more than outside backs,” he said.

“It’s not just against Moana Pasifika. Every single team seems to be going into that zone knowing that the laws of the game or whatever it might be restricts the opposition, if you get really well set, from shutting down a driving maul.

“… No one seems to be sacking the lineouts any more, so I wonder whether or not they can’t get access to the jumper to sack it because of the laws and the way they’re protected and blocked.

“But whatever it is, to be honest, it’s pissing me off.”

ALB faces injury battle

All Blacks centre Anton Lienert-Brown could be out for an extended period after suffering another shoulder injury in the Chiefs’ dispiriting loss to the Blues.

The 56-Test star partially dislocated his right shoulder in November’s loss to Ireland. On Saturday he appeared to suffer a dislocation to the same shoulder.

“Not great,” coach Clayton McMillan said of Lienert-Brown. “He’s putting on a brave face but initial reports are that it’s not looking good. His arm is in a sling.”

All Blacks captain Sam Cane said he felt for his team-mate.

“He’s a massive part of our team and must be closing in on 100 games,” Cane said. “I’m not going to feel too sorry for him yet. I’ll cross my fingers and hope it’s not as bad as initially thought but my gut feel is he may be in a bit of strife.”

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-15T20:48:53+00:00

Rugbytrylover

Roar Rookie


You never rated him? A Wallaby, Brumby..... not rated.... thank god you’re not a coach.

2022-04-15T20:46:45+00:00

Rugbytrylover

Roar Rookie


Horan....great player... dud commentator ...

2022-04-15T20:32:20+00:00

Rugbytrylover

Roar Rookie


Came off again last night against the Rebels.... he seems very injury prone?

2022-04-13T01:53:16+00:00

AndyS

Guest


If they are getting offers for their SR teams and refusing them, then RA really are the architect of their own situation. The reality is they aren't, because what well heeled support they have is quite happy for them to spend other people's money. It has always been that way, heaven forfend they should ever feel the need to get their own wallet out. Even when there is an exception, Forrest wouldn't be spending any extra money specifically because he knows what would happen the moment the other teams felt like they were being disadvantaged. Or even didn't have the advantage of a player list paid a couple of million more than his.

2022-04-13T00:51:47+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


Pretty right there James, as I've been there seen it, even though I was only on a voluntary basis. The attitude of ' look after one's self' still remains amongst them from what I'm still hearing from a reliable source. Very much like the overall politicians we have ATM.

2022-04-13T00:46:53+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


Yeh Jacko, & ' Mountain Oysters' as well, I imagine!! Lol :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

2022-04-13T00:43:51+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


Yeh Doc possibly Paisami would be better returning to Aotearoa, but the big thing is, where would they fit him in?

2022-04-13T00:41:05+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


Yep DA Otepoti, has a great cultural history, going back before European settlement as well.

2022-04-13T00:38:46+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


With Marshall's comments, one would think he would know better being a Southlander, as back in the day, the South of Aotearoa, was known for the good old ' true' style of rucking, that was imbedded into us very early in learning the game. Even the coaches, back then, instructed us the ' RIGHT' way to do the procedure. It's a pity, that the IRB ( back then ) pulled the plug on that particular way, as it was by far quicker than what is in place now. Geeeez with today's technology, & enforcing more responsibility back onto the coaching, it would be the far better option. ' BRING BACK RUCKING' , as it was, back then, & with the technology we have NOW.

2022-04-12T17:05:26+00:00

TJ-Go Force!

Roar Rookie


The money overseas is just crazy. The exodus will only continue. Not sure how we will sustainably have 5 pro teams if this trend continues. Frost, Banks, FLW, LSL, etc. all departing. Man we better get some good academy programs in place!

2022-04-12T10:54:26+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


Take it Tom. Do it for your family. Forever know you should have been a 50+ cap wallaby but the previous coach picked everyone except you for every reason except the right one. The reality is you’re now not an automatic selection and you may not get another offer like this.

2022-04-12T10:21:00+00:00

PK

Guest


I'm sad to say it as a Brumbies and Wallaby fan, but Banks should probably take the money. And good for him - it's a great opportunity. Despite what some keyboard warriors on here are saying, it will be a loss for Aussie rugby. Banks is a quality player, clearly the best Aussie fullback in Super Rugby over the last few years. He hasn't set the international scene on fire, but then very few do. (If your criteria for national selection is setting the international scene on fire, you won't be fielding a national team.) He's played well and belongs at test level, and with his pace and skill and smarts is fully capable of doing something special now and then. 1.4 million is a lot, but maybe not crazy for exciting international fullback who could thrive in the league, esp. if he has a good attitude and work ethic and is someone you can see adding value to a team in lots of different ways.

2022-04-12T08:26:37+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


Then I am going against the grain… :thumbup:

2022-04-12T08:21:34+00:00

Glenn

Guest


I can, and do. but consistency is not expected from a Mad...Kiwi. :silly:

2022-04-12T07:54:00+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


I agree about this being an over the top amount, this would be an amount more for proven World Class players, it will be interesting to see how this works out… :thumbup:

2022-04-12T07:34:22+00:00

JC

Roar Rookie


Not at all — I just meant that we don’t have that model of ‘cashed-up’ private ownership because the Super clubs here belong to the state unions. Even Twiggy, as great as he’s been, isn’t throwing stupid money around.

2022-04-12T07:28:10+00:00

Wigeye

Guest


Think marshy said saders would win by 30 if I heard it right, way off, Grant nesbit hes really good at pronouncing all the names he's obviously worked on it over the Years

2022-04-12T07:11:31+00:00

AussieBob

Roar Rookie


So how are JC and JP proven at test level? Couple of holes in your logic champ.

2022-04-12T07:09:14+00:00

AussieBob

Roar Rookie


He has stepped up plenty so called experts think Hodge is the sh$t completely baffling and what has JP done so far, few good touches plenty of poor ones.

2022-04-12T07:08:11+00:00

JC

Roar Rookie


True and there’s obviously a global market for rugby players. But I just can’t work out where the value is in $1.4m pa for Banks, as good as he is. Obviously I’m missing something.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar